Is it True?
IN his work entitled, "Disestablishment, from a Church Point of View," Mr.
Gilbert calls attention, as an attached member of the Church of England,
to some abuses which must shock the sense of propriety of every section of the
community, and must, we think, cause the most earnest Episcopalian to resolve
to remove the blot by every means in his power.
Among other grave matters, in dealing with the Temperance question,
Mr. Gilbert prefers charges of complicity with the drink traffic against the
Church in its corporate capacity, which must mantle the checks of its devoted
adherents with the blush of shame. This is what he says:—
"But to return to the connection between the Church of England Temperance
movement and the State clergy at large. Does it not appear an absurdity that
our archbishops and bishops should give temperance lectures and address
public meetings on the sin and misery caused by intemperance, teaching their
hearers to avoid the public-house, as leading them into temptation, while in
their corporate capacity, as members of the Ecclesiastical Commission, they
are perhaps the largest owners of public-house property in the country,
certainly they own more than any brewer's firm in the kingdom. Indeed, so
well is this fact known among the working classes, that frequently in the
Western Road from Hyde Park Corner, through Knightsbridge, they are in
the habit of pointing, as typical of the Establishment, to a Church of England
on the right-hand side of the way, near Albert Gate, having a gin-palace on
each side of it, built up side by side in a row, the place of worship and the
gin-shops being all Church property. It is stated—and I believe it would be
found to be a fact—that the Bishop of London, when he leaves his house in
St. James's Square, and rides to his palace at Fulham, passes on his road more
than 100 public-houses built on land belonging to the Church.
"Of the expense at which some of these public-houses are maintained by
their customers may be estimated from the returns of two respectably conducted
establishments of the kind—one, the Royal Oak at Notting Hill, on the land
of the Bishop of London; the other, the Hero of Waterloo, near the terminus
of the South Western Railway, on the estate of the Archbishop of Canterbury.
It is stated that the returns of the Royal Oak will not be less than £10,000
141
a-year, or more than the maintenance of all the places of worship of every denomination, schools, and the police-force of the district within a diameter of a mile; while the returns of the Hero of Waterloo are equal to a similar expenditure, on the Surrey side of the water. Nay more, it is asserted—and I believe will hardly be disputed—that when the lease of a public-house in possession of the Church Commissioners falls in, it is valued by a professional gentleman employed on property of the kind to know if its rental can be increased. The Church will also grant ground-leases for the erection of public-houses, as may be seen on the Paddington estate. Nay more, when one of the leases of their public-houses is for sale, and it be thought a bargain, the Commissioners will become the purchasers. Nor is this evil confined solely to London. Some time since I measured a square of 300 paces each way in the centre of Salisbury, and found on it no less than 18 public-houses and gin-shops, all on Church lands; and other localities may be mentioned where they are equally numerous.
"I may now be told that I am doing the bishops an injustice by making this accusation against them; that a special commission has been appointed for the management of the estates of the Church, in which they have nothing to do. But it must be remembered that the Estates' Commission is simply a branch of the Ecclesiastical Commission; and if any legal quibble should be forthcoming (and I have shown in many ways that legal quibbles are admitted by our law authorities with astonishing facility when used in the service of the Established Church), the bishops have seats in it. But I submit that if their hands are tied their voices are at liberty, and they have had full power of using them. Possibly the cry of 'confiscation' may be raised against any attempt to deprive the Establishment of its gin-shops. And I admit the cry of 'confiscation' has frequently had tremendous effect on the minds of the public, occasionally scarcely less so than that of 'the Church in danger'—and with as little reason. But let us first see whether there really is any confiscation in the matter, and if so, in what it consists. The Church, as represented by the Ecclesiastical Commissioners, has indisputably the right to refuse the renewal of a public-house lease when it falls into their possession. Say they refuse to renew the lease—what then? The house still remains, and is applicable to any other trade, consequently there is no confiscation of any property. The sole thing confiscated is the spirit and beer license. If the spirit license is admitted as a portion of the foundation for the support of our Ecclesiastical system, let it be stated honestly and candidly, and the public will then have in their possession another plea to urge them to exertion in the separation of Church and State."
Is it true? We ask without casting any doubt on Mr. Gilbert's veracity; but fearing the possibility that he has been led into error as to the true state of affairs. His book is before the world, and challenges reply. Meanwhile we urge every temperance man, whether he be Churchman or Nonconformist, to be urgent and incessant in the demand that this abuse be brought to a speedy end. Fancy what an outcry there would be if the Tabernacle derived its income even in a small degree from owning gin-palaces. We say no more. Let the members of the Episcopalian body see to this evil, of which the most of them have never heard before. Now that they have heard of it, let them accept no quibbles by way of justification; but let them demand a clean sweep of the whole concern. There are plenty of uses for lands and houses without consecrating them to Bacchus, in order to bring in a larger revenue for Christ.
10
