Menu
‹ Chapter 250 of 255 ›

Notices of Books

16 min read · Chapter 250 of 255

A Commentary on St. Paul's Epistles to the Corinthians. By JOSEPH AGAR BEET. Hodder and Stoughton.

MR. BEET has at once taken up a foremost place among expositors. He is to the manner born. All those elements of character which are needful to an interpreter, one of a thousand, are apparent in him. We cannot say that we have read through this bulky half-guinea's worth of Commentary, but we are rejoiced to declare that wherever we have picked upon a selected passage we have found our author full, painstaking, and suggestive. Few can beat Mr. Beet. We sincerely hope that he will live to accomplish the ambitious programme which he has sketched for himself, and give us all the epistles after the manner in which he has now annotated the Romans and Corinthians.

Memoir of Israel Atkinson. By R. HODDY. W. Willman, 34, Bouverie-street.

MR. ISRAEL ATKINSON was the honoured pastor of a Baptist church in Brighton, of the Strict Communion order. His holy character and consistency won for him high esteem, both in the church of

God and from those who are without. Many of those who sat at his feet in Brighton became pastors of Baptist churches, and this alone proves how edifying and stimulating his ministry must have been. The good man never departed from beaten paths, and greatly deprecated new methods of attracting congregations: his mode of addressing the sinner was not that which is now common in our churches, and his whole theology was of the high Calvinistic order; but he was a man full of grace and faith, and a lover of souls. By divine help he forced his way from the poverty and ignorance of his childhood to scholarship and usefulness, so that he became foremost among the leaders of a section of our Israel. The earlier part of his memoir is more interesting than the latter portion, because it contains more striking incidents. For the rest, the run of a prosperous minister's life is like the history of a nation which dwells at peace, more pleasant to experience than to read about. Mr. Atkinson's friends will value this biography, which is most creditably put together by the author of the Gospel Herald.

Infant Baptism Demonstrated to be Reasonable, Historical, and Scriptural. By JAMES MALCOLM. London: Houlston and Sons.

WHAT a singular man is Mr. Malcolm! He tells us that the more he has discussed the question of baptism with Baptist ministers and laymen, and the more he has read our works (though we must say that his own book shows that he has read little beyond two pamphlets, one of which was published at one penny), the more he has been convinced that we are in error. This is a most unusual experience, but Mr. Malcolm is clearly an unusual man; for unlike most other Pedobaptists he has found out that our arguments are but "assumptions" and a "hollow sound." He thinks he has succeeded in revealing their "barrenness" and "naked deformity." He has failed to elicit even a "shadow of proof" from any of our authorities, and no wonder, for all the candid admissions made by standard Pedobaptist authors he disposes of by a wave of his mighty hand! Each admission is but a gratis dictum. All that they assert in favour of Pedobaptism, Mr. Malcolm regards as utterly "shattering our position," and in this way Mr. Malcolm keeps his conscience easy. Awkward questions are silenced by the oracular dictum, "a child might see that there is not an atom of argument in this question;" an able exposition is but "a shallow caricature"—"a parasite foisted upon it (the text) from a biassed judgment." One of our arguments is but "fitted to catch ignorant or shallow individuals," such as the great Pedobaptists who have joined our ranks and the great scholars who one and all admit the strength of our position, though they do not join our communion. Altogether Mr. Malcolm finds that ours is but "surface work." All this quite prepares us for the statement, "I do not recollect one either minister or private person but has in little more than a quarter of an hour entirely given up the argument." Mr. Malcolm has surely met with some ill-informed Baptists, or else he has an estimate of his own achievements which few will endorse. He thinks, however, that he has not only been successful, but he can teach the "trick" to the youngest, and then woe betide the Baptists. "Any person has

it in his power to quiet him (the Baptist) almost in an instant." If the Pedobaptists share Mr. Malcolm's opinion of the strength of his arguments, there will be a greater demand for his book than we could otherwise dare to expect. He has written the book, so he tells us, "to aid them (the Baptists) in coming to our position," and he assures us that "I have thus made a sufficient exposure of the Baptists' erroneous statements."

After all these heroic achievements we need not be surprised to find that Mr. Malcolm designates his book a "demonstration." What less could it be? What more can anyone ask? No weaker word than "demonstration," such as satisfied and perhaps more than satisfied the really great and able champions of Pedobaptism on this side of the Tweed, will do for this Scottish missionary. He must have words powerful as his own prejudice, and hence he has chosen terms which strangely and even ludicrously contrast with the feebleness of the arguments they embody.

What is Mr. Malcolm's demonstration? The weaker brother need not fear to hear it. Mr. Malcolm actually brings before us as a demonstration two arguments which have been long slain and buried out of sight in England, though now and again we have met with a sort of fossil controversialists who like Rip Van Winkle have slept a long sleep and know not that many things have happened since they first dozed off. The first part of Mr. Malcolm's demonstration is? that in as much as we Baptists permit females to sit at the Lord's table, and yet we have no express command to do so, we have forsaken our main position. Mr. Malcolm forgets that we do not sit at the Lord's table as either males or females, but as disciples of Jesus Christ. In Christ there is neither male or female—all are one.

Mr. Malcolm, however, mainly relies on the argument from the ancient rite of circumcision. He even admits that "apart from circumcision there would be no sufficient proof for infant baptism," and yet the world-renowned Biblical scholar, Dr. William Lindsay Alexander, says, "If baptism is to be regarded as having come in the place of circumcision the argument from the

635

Abrahamic covenant lies altogether with the Baptists." The doctor actually makes this remark in his life of the celebrated Dr. Wardlaw whose Pedobaptist sheet-anchor was this argument which Dr. Alexander firmly and resolutely throws away. The same argument was hopelessly shattered on this side of the Tweed also by the ablest champion of Padobaptism, the erudite Dr. Halley. He has given the circumcision argument its quietus for ever, though some smaller men still amuse us by urging it.

The Pedobaptists, we fear, will hardly thank Mr. Malcolm for really demonstrating that their cause is indefensible, and that our position is simply impregnable. The more the subject is agitated the better for us.

The book abounds in inconsistencies and loose expositions, but these we do not stay to notice—perhaps we have already given the book more notice than it deserves. If Mr. Malcolm would "suffer a word of exhortation," we would urge him to leave controversy to those who are called and qualified to exercise their powers in that direction, and would persuade him to continue in his useful labours and visit the widow and the fatherless in their affliction.

From Sin to Salvation. By THOMAS GRIFFITH, A.M. London: Hodder and Stoughton, 27, Paternoster-row.

In a kind of philosophic treatise on the seventh chapter of the epistle to the Romans, the worthy author attempts to exhibit what he terms "the Pauline picture of the Redemptive Process." "The Apostle Paul," says he, "paints the convert first as lying in a state of insensibility to sin; next, as waking up into a state of conflict with sin; and finally, as landed in a state of triumph over sin. In the first stage the animal life is predominant, in the second, the intellectual life. Not till the third stage is there begotten that spiritual life which works out righteousness, and this spiritual life is derived entirely from Christ—from our participation in his death, his resurrection, his Spirit, and our thus being made citizens of that higher world in which he lives and reigns," p. 125. Mr. Griffith's part is, we presume, to show that pure faith is

consistent with sound philosophy. Some four centuries separate Plato and Paul in our chronicles. But we occasionally meet with men of culture who seem to be equally charmed with the dialogues of the one and the epistles of the other. At least, they like by a freak of fancy to bridge the distance of their time and training, and imagine a grove or a cloister in which these twain, the academician and the apostle, might come together in social converse, and discover with glad surprise that, in the school of nature and the school of grace, they had learnt the same lessons, though they had not used the same books. Our author happily steers clear of any such conceit. He sees that the philosophy of facts is at variance with the Rationalism of the age. Thus, by way of sample, the recognition of "birth-sin." Are we born like sheets of pure white paper, to be written on by the hand of our schoolmasters? or are we ushered into the world like palimpsests, scored and confused by cross superscriptions? We are survivals defiled by the deposits of ancestral savages, animals, and molluscs. Brain development, which is a matter of heredity, determines our character. So true is the apostle's assertion that in us, that is, in our flesh (derived from our forefathers) "dwelleth no good thing."

Has Man a Future? Materialism and Christianity Contrasted. By J. TYLER. W. Poole, 12A, Paternoster-row.

A PAMPHLET of one hundred and thirty-six pages. In fourteen sections, "The Materialist" states his case first, and "The Christian" states his case afterwards, upon the various topics suggested. There is no attempt at dialogue. The plan may be well conceived, but we do not think that it is as well carried out. "Materialist" is rather racy, and "Christian" is very prosy. It is a great pity that it should ever be so.

The Dying Martyr's Testament to the Town and University of Cambridge. Written in prison in 1555. By JOHN BRADFORD.

THIS earnest epistle should interest our Cambridge friends. It is to be bought for a penny of Mr. Coe, 69, Eden Street.

The Cyclopædia of Practical Quotations, English and Latin: with an Appendix of Proverbs. &c., &c., and Copious Indexes. By J. K. HOTT and ANNA L. WARD. R. D. Dickinson.

PRINTED from the American plates. A very useful book for a literary man, to whom the copious indices will be a great boon. Its production has cost much labour, and it will, in consequence, greatly save labour to those who use it. It is deservedly called "practical," since it is not for show, but for real work. In this respect it excels all other quotation books which have hitherto come under our notice. Mr. Dickinson ought to have his edition cleared out speedily.

The Infant's Magazine. The Children's Friend. The Friendly Visitor. Volumes for 1882. Seeley, Jackson, and Halliday.

THE two magazines for the little ones stand in a high position in juvenile literature, and The Friendly Visitor is as good as good can be. The yearly volumes make splendid Christmas presents: they are gorgeously arrayed, and worthy of their fine raiment.

Until the Day-break: Birthday Mottoes for the Homeward Way. By G. M. and E. St. B. HOLLAND. Sketches of Christmas. Light and Love. Living Water. Royal Gifts. Christmas Greetings for the Children. 1s. and 1s. 6d. per packet. Deaconess House, Mildmay Park.

EXQUISITE taste is apparent in this album and in these Christmas cards. Moreover, there is an originality and freshness about them which we greatly prize. It was time that there should be some little variety in birthday albums, and here we have it. The cards are all that the daintiest lady ought to desire, and the texts upon them are wisely selected. Mildmay Park may have great joy in the issue of such thoroughly excellent things.

The Band of Hope Review. The British Workman. The Family Friend. The Band of Mercy Advocate. Volumes for 1882. Partridge and Co.

WE can only repeat our praises of these incomparable serials. We believe them to be the means of vast good. They are

thoroughly well executed in all respects, and their large sale proves that the working people like good things, and do not care to buy the cheap and nasty prints upon which an unwise philanthropy spends its energies. Anything which is intended for the elevation of the masses should be of the very best in teaching, in taste, and in workmanship. This Mr. Smithies has always recognised, and hence his success.

Lectures on Disestablishment delivered in Queen Street Hall, Edinburgh, in February and March, 1882. Edinburgh: Andrew Elliot, 17, Princes Street, and also the Liberation Society, Serjeants' Inn, Fleet Street.

THE first lecture in this pamphlet is on "The sufficiency of the voluntary principle," by the Rev. Principal Cairns, D.D. The second is on "Church and State," by James Carmet, Esq., LL.D., S.S.C. The third is on "National Religion, its true conception, and the best means of realizing it," by the Rev. Alex. Oliver, B.A., and the fourth is on "The ecclesiastical endowments of Scotland," by Thomas Shaw, Esq., M.A., LL.B., advocate.

These lectures are of the very highest order of merit. They are clear and concise, calm and convincing. Principal Cairns' vindication of the voluntary principle leaves nothing to be desired, and his arguments are as suitable for this side of the Tweed as the other. The lectures were given under the auspices of the Edinburgh United Presbyterian Presbytery, and are well worthy of the projectors of the movement. Scotland gets her best sons to advocate the separation of religion from state patronage and control, and the result is a literature of which any country may be proud.

The presbytery promises us another course of lectures this winter, "in which the Scriptural and other important aspect of the question will be treated with greater fulness." This volume we will look forward to with a lively interest, for the Scotch divines know how to handle this subject with fulness and force. The work before us ought to be read by all who desire to understand the great question discussed. We hope the land will be well salted with it.

637

WE have received such a quantity of books from the Religious Tract Society that we cannot do more than briefly mention a selection of them at this time. At a later date we may notice the others. The following list will be a guide to those who are choosing presents for the season.

Katie Brightside, and how She made the Best of Everything. By RUTH LAMB. LARGE type, fine engravings, splendid binding, and all for half-a-crown. Just the book for Miss Nellie and her sister, aged ten and eight.

Hid in the Cevennes; or, the Mountain Refuge. 3s. A fine book for reading during winter evenings.

The Old Worcester Jug; or, John Griffin's Little Maid. By EGLANTON THORNE. 1s. 6d. Capital. If we must have tales let them be of this order.

Jacob Witherby; or, Need of Patience." By AGNES GIBBENE. 1s. 6d. Gracious and taking.

Across the Water. By Mrs. PAYNE. A story working out life in America to excellent purpose. An elegant book for 2s. 6d.

Under the Old Roof. By HESBA STRETTON, author of "Jessica's First Prayer." This authoress needs no introduction. Her little shilling book is, no doubt, excellent, but we cannot afford to cry just now. The weather is quite damp enough without our tears, so we shall not read it, but leave our young readers to do so.

The Parallel New Testament; also The Parallel New Testament, Greek and English, with space for Manuscript Notes. Oxford Editions. H. Frowde, Oxford University Press Warehouse, 7, Paternoster-row.

AN exceedingly practical use to which to put the Revised New Version: it is printed in parallel columns with the authorized text, and so, at a glance, the alterations are apparent. He who spends eighteenpence on this arrangement will be a poor creature if he does not get far more than his money's worth in a few days of careful reading. Nicely bound editions in morocco can be had for 5s. and 7s. The student is still better served by an edition in good type containing the two versions, the

original Greek, and the Readings displaced by the Revisers. This in cloth boards is 12s. 6d. It is an essential part of the apparatus of a student of the New Testament, and it is as useful as it is indispensable.

The Scripture Pocket-book for 1883. Religious Tract Society.

A POCKET-BOOK which we have much pleasure in recommending. It contains much general information, and is well arranged as a book for short memoranda, such as most persons find the need of.

Critical and Exegetical Handbook to the Epistle to the Hebrews. By Dr. GOTTLIEB LUNEMANN. The General Epistles of James and John. By J. E. HUTHER, Ph.D. Edinburgh: T. and T. Clark.

Dr. MEYER's commentaries are supplemented and completed by Thessalonians and Hebrews by Dr. Lunemann, and Timothy and Titus, and Peter and Jude, and James and John, by Dr. Huther. They are said to be invaluable for accurate scholarship. Dr. Schaff styles Meyer "the ablest grammatical exegete of the age." No learned library can be perfect without Meyer's Commentaries, which are complete in twenty vols. for £5 5s. To the mass of our readers Meyer will be unintelligible, but to students of the Greek tongue, who want to know definitely the precise text, he will be an indispensable guide. When such a man as Ellicott confesses his obligations to an author we may be sure that he is the first in his class. All educated ministers are grateful to the Messrs. Clark for putting such learned work within their reach.

Little Dot and her Friends. Sixty-four coloured Plates and Vignettes. Religious Tract Society.

A GRAND Christmas book for little Dot, containing "Little Dot's Daisies," "The Story of Jack and Nell," "The Story of Little Pippin," and "The Little Lamb."

The whole are bound in a gorgeous cover, and constitute a volume which may well make the eyes of many little ones to twinkle. "The Little Lamb" is, to our taste, the story of the whole; every child ought to read it. The coloured pictures are something to look upon with delight again and again.

41

Seven Reasons for Believers' Baptism.

By the Rev. F. B. MEYER, B.A.

Grattan and Co., 3, Amen Corner.

THIS is an excellent little pamphlet of

twelve pages, and is published at one

halfpenny, or 3s. 6d. per hundred. Send

for a hundred, and enclose a copy in all

your letters to your friends, it will do

them all good. We shall be pleased to

hear from Mr. Meyer again on this

subject, which he handles so clearly and

kindly.

The Church Standard. One penny

weekly. Forty Winks. "The Fire-

side" Christmas number (6d.) A

Christmas Wedding. "Home Words"

for Christmas. (1d.) "Home Words"

Office, 1 Paternoster Buildings.

MR. BULLOCK is a genius at magazine-

making, and a man for whom to thank

God every day. In his Church Standard

we note his bold words as to the Chris-

tian World: we are deeply sorry that

there should be need for them. In

another article upon Disestablishment

we are pleased to note the fairness and

candour of the Editor, though we do

not for a moment endorse his opinions.

The two Christmas numbers are really

about Christmas, and are as good as

good can be in their own line.

Christian Ethics. First Division:

Individual Ethics. Second Division:

Social Ethics. By Dr. H. MARTEN-

SEN, Bishop of Seeland. Edinburgh:

T. and T. Clark.

CERTAINLY a very able work upon

morals; but altogether Lutheran in

religion, and continental in tone. We

are continually differing from the au-

thor; now upon his fancied intermediate

state and the rightfulness of prayers

for the dead, anon upon the duty of the

state to the church, and then again upon

the character of the theatre. The work

is a masterpiece of learning, but whe-

ther the objectionable parts of it are not

likely to do as much harm as the rest of

it can do good, we cannot say. He who

reads this author should exercise clear

discernment, and then he will find

thought suggested and knowledge in-

creased. Our respect for the author's

reasoning is not great when he can

justify prayer for the departed by Paul's

exhortation that prayers be made for all

men, and even by the petition in the

Lord's prayer—"Thy kingdom come."

There are throughout the work abun-

dant proofs that learned men are capa-

ble of far greater folly than more ordi-

nary people. Upon baptism our author

is a sacramentarian. This importation

does not give us a very high idea of the

orthodoxy or spirituality of the Danish

Church; but we are glad to find our

author sound on the Sabbath and vivi-

section questions. Much good dashed

with much error.

The Truth about Opium-smoking. With

Illustrations of the Manufacture of

Opium, etc. Hodder and Stoughton.

DOUTERS as to the guilt of the opium

traffic, read this! Warriors for right,

who contend against this terrible evil,

here is a storehouse of arguments for

you! The work is trenchant, and were

not men's consciences asleep, it would

cause them to banish the enormity from

the face of the earth. Alas, that our

country should sin against the light,

and gain a revenue for India out of the

blood of Chinamen!

The Elder and his friends: Christian

friendship delineated in the private

letters of John. By ALEXANDER

MACLEOD SYMINGTON, D.D. Nisbet.

WE are always glad to meet with a book

from Dr. Symington's pen, for he is a

man after our own heart. He here

discourses upon John's private epistles

most soundly and sweetly. Placing

this little but weighty work among our

expositors, we breathe a prayer that

thousands may read it to their lasting

profit, for it deals most faithfully with

men's souls, and does not shrink from

the unpopular side of divine truth.

A Commentary on the Revised Version

of the New Testament. By W. G.

HUMPHREY, B.D. Cassell and Co.

NOTES upon the passages altered in the

revision. It is a good idea, but ought

to be carried out in a fuller style. We

do not set much store by this work:

better will be sure to follow. The short

history of the English Bible which is

placed in the introduction, is remarkably

well condensed. The author is one of

the Revisers, and therefore well quali-

fied to tell why alterations were made

by the New Testament company; this

alone is interesting.

639

The Interpreter's House, and What I learnt there; or, New Lessons from an Old School. By the Rev. JAMES E. ARNOLD. Religious Tract Society.

If this is meant for an imitation of Bunyan's manner, it is an utter failure. Our author has not got the Saxon tone and idiom, although he uses many Saxon words. Moreover, there are too many Latinized words to allow us to think of honest John except by contrast. Bunyan

would never have talked of "subsisting in concord," nor of "scenes that have been for the most part those of life and action." These are not in the old tongue; the last quoted is Saxon in letter, but foreign in spirit, and so are many of our author's expressions. Apart from this, the book is excellent. Forgetting Bunyan, we have no fault to find, but much praise to bestow. Arnold is good alone; but after Bunyan he is nowhere.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate