Is it true?

IN our March number we quoted from Mr. Gilberts book, "Disestablishment from a church point of view," a statement to the effect that many public-houses had been erected upon church lands. An instance was given in the city of Salisbury. This instance has been questioned, and Chancellor Swayne has declared that "neither the Bishop, nor the Chapter, nor either of the City incumbents, possess one single building here devoted to the sale of strong drink in any form." This statement we accept, and fully exonerate those for whom the Chancellor speaks; and so far as this is an answer to Mr. Gilbert's statement that he counted eighteen public-houses erected upon church lands, we desire to withdraw from any supposed participation in the charge. We only took it from Mr. Gilbert's book, and headed our extract, "Is it true?" and if the Chancellor has proved that it is not true we are glad of it. Mr. Gilbert is a gentleman upon whose veracity and accuracy we place implicit reliance, and he begs us distinctly to say that he personally refuses to admit that he has been in error. We fear that the Chancellor's statement does not meet the charge in all its length and breadth, but concerning this we are at present unable to say more.
Our sole intent in inserting the article was to throw light upon the action of religious and charitable corporations which encourage the liquor-traffic. These bodies cannot help having licensed houses with old leases, which were granted when the public conscience was not aroused; but they can refuse to allow new licenses to be taken out, and as the old ones fall in they can destroy them. We do not so much denounce the past as demand improvement for the future.
