Menu
‹ Chapter 159 of 255 ›

A Free Sauce with the Free Church

7 min read · Chapter 159 of 255
A Free Sauce with the Free Church

IS the high reputation that the Free Church of Scotland has hitherto held among the evangelical churches of Christendom on the wane? Not yet have forty years transpired since the "Disruption." A young branch of the old Kirk, she took root as soon as she was severed from the parent tree, and gave immediate signs of vitality and vigour that drew admiring eyes. In numerical strength her numbers exceeded the community she quitted. Her ministers were renowned for their purity and their piety, for their courage and their consecration. They seemed to have inherited the faith and fearlessness of John Knox, the mettle and chivalry of Richard Cameron and the Covenanters. Maintaining "the headship of Christ," and doing homage to him as her only Lord, the enterprise she displayed and the prosperity she realized at home and abroad while she continued true to the standards was, perhaps, without a modern parallel. So has "the Free Church" sowed good seed and reaped the devout gratitude both of continental and colonial churches, whom she greatly aided. We sincerely hope that the sad story of Israel is not about to be repeated in her chronicles. When Joshua and the elders who outlived Joshua were gathered to their fathers there arose another generation which knew not the Lord nor the works he had done for Israel. The sounds that reach us from the Presbyterian camp raise suspicions of decadence from which we recoil with horror. Can it be that "of their own selves men have arisen, speaking perverse things, and drawing disciples after them"? Our attention has been drawn to a curious problem raised by Dr. Bruce, who is favourably known beyond his own denomination by his previous works as an able and orthodox exponent of Christian doctrine. To his "Cunningham Lectures on the Humiliation of Christ" we invited attention in a recent number of this magazine. In the lectures that supply the basis of his book on "The Chief End of Revelation" he has wandered into another field of religious literature. We use the word "wandered" advisedly, for he appears to lose his way soon after starting, to take a rather circuitous route, and then to lie down in a wilderness of doubt, there to indulge in a dream of long ages to come. The task he proposed to himself was a contribution to "Christian Apologetics;" but missing the track of the old pioneers he has rambled about in the region of "metaphysics." In a brief preface he tells us that "two convictions have been ruling motives in this study. One is, that in many respects the old lines of apologetic argument no longer suffice either to express the thoughts of faith, or to meet successfully the assaults of unbelief. The other is, that the church is not likely again to wield the influence which of right belongs to her as custodian of the precious treasure of Christian truth, unless she show herself possessed of vitality sufficient to originate a new development in all directions, and among others in doctrine, refusing to accept as her final position either the agnosticism of modern culture, or blind adherence to traditional dogmatism."

Now, what are we to understand by Christian apologetics? This is

* The Chief End of Revelation. By Alexander Balmain Bruce, D.D., Professor of Apologetics, &c., Glasgow. London: Hodder and Stoughton, 27, Paternoster Row. 1881.

427

an important question to open with. The answer to it may afford some clue to the strange bewilderment of the worthy Doctor. "Apology" in the classics stands for a defence of the truth, or of the faith, if you prefer to express it so. And yet this word "apology" has dwindled down in modern conversation to mean an excuse for acknowledged error. In Origen's famous "apology" he flung down the glove and waged an encounter with the Pagan (Celsus). And in Jewell's "apology" he in like manner did battle with the Papist. We have fallen on softer times and sweeter courtesies. Our redoubtable champion takes off his hat to the Sadducee of the nineteenth century. Literary men have a curious liking for each other. So the author of "The Humiliation of Christ" and the author of "Literature and Dogma," Alexander Bruce and Matthew Arnold, retire from the ring and talk matters over as "friends in council." This is the new departure in "Christian Apologetics."

"The apologist's task in these days is a delicate one," says Dr. Bruce. So we should think if this is a specimen of the style in which it is conducted. Only imagine a lecturer on physical science at the London Institution or the South Kensington Museum publishing a tractate on "The Chief End of Creation," in which he denounces all study of astronomy or geology, of botany or chemistry, and the argument he plays with is the advantage of "a simple creed." What need we care about the sun so long as it shines brightly enough to give us light and warmth? Why bother yourself about the moon or stars if they serve "the chief end" of cheering your dark nights? As for the earth, be content with ploughing the fields and reaping the fruits; sink no mines nor search for hidden treasures beneath its surface. Are not field flowers gay enough in all conscience without troubling yourselves to cultivate an endless variety of ferns and exotics? Draw the line, at any rate, between gardens and conservatories. Like doctrine and dogma in religion, one is tolerable and the other execrable. Then fancy you are listening to some such peroration as this -"In all probability the world has many long ages before it; and we may devoutly dream of the glory of that day when all men will be like little birds who in their little nests agree, because they have no lessons to learn." This is pure fiction on our part; but the book before us on "The Chief End of Revelation" is, we regret to say, a serious fact.

Let it be understood that there is "a chair" in the Free Church College, Glasgow, for "Apologetics and New Testament Exegesis," and the author of this volume is the Professor who occupies it. Having an engagement to deliver a course of lectures to the students of the Presbyterian College, London, he takes occasion to assail the rudiments of that study which they were placed in this institution to learn, and he was selected to teach. This surely is startling enough. We should have thought that, from a high sense of honour, he would have resigned his appointment before he repudiated the department of Christian education from which he draws his emoluments.

After sowing the seeds of suspicion and distrust in the class-room among students for the ministry he then proceeds to address a wider audience through the press. Presumably he appeals to the Senatus of the Free Church of Scotland, and counsels considerable retrenchment in her confessions of faith and her catechisms for the instruction of the

young. Thus he lays down the proposition—"The more catholic the communion the less comprehensive the creed." To promote unity he would concede every position to the gainsayers whom he had heretofore failed to convert. And who are they? They profess to be men of culture, though they prove themselves to be merely charlatans, wise in their own conceit. While they offer fulsome compliments to the purity of Jesus of Nazareth, they dislike his doctrines, and decline to be his disciples. They prefer Plato's dialogues to Paul's epistles. They espouse the philosophy of Aristotle rather than the faith of Abraham. Many of them esteem the rationalism of Hegel as manly, but the practical commentary of Matthew Henry they all scout as childish in the extreme. What has happened? Has any fresh discovery been made? Does a new seer challenge our attention; another Daniel whose oracles unfold brighter visions of immortality than had ever dawned on us before? Oh, no; nothing of that sort. Poor Dr. Bruce is to be pitied. From first to last his treatise shows that he is distracted with fear. His timidity is far more remarkable than his temerity. He beats a retreat along the whole line; not certainly as one who is beaten by an advancing army of faithful and sincere exponents of Revelation, but as one who is exquisitely sensitive of the sneers of an undisciplined crowd of sceptics. He flies before their face, scared by what he calls "flippant caricature." He will not defend "miracles" lest he should be given "the fool's cap;" and he disclaims "prophecy" so far as it pretends to foretell anything positive, to obviate his "being held up to ridicule." If ever extraordinary caution might be pleaded in mitigation of excessive censure we really think that Dr. Bruce is entitled to the clemency of his judges. His propositions are, perhaps, more hesitant than heretical. At least, we would fain hope that his aberrations of mind are not indications of apostasy. If he really has any strong convictions he would surely have more courage in asserting them. He sues for pardon in his preface because he knows that his views will please no theological party. "I do not deprecate criticism, but I ask the critics to remember that the apologist's task in these days is a delicate one." Then, by way of postscript, after ruthlessly denouncing the creeds and catechisms, he disavows any serious opposition to them. "In making these observations I am not to be understood as hinting that immediate attempts at reconstruction of creeds and recasting of catechisms are either likely or desirable." The chief end of Revelation, according to Dr. Bruce, is, after all, extinction; and the dénouement of his treatise, as we have already stated, is a devout dream of that future when mankind will have heard the last of anything that disturbs their own reasoning. In those halcyon days "doubt, division, and dogma" will disappear; and "certainty, concord, and a simplified creed" will complete the combat of centuries of strife.

Alas, alas for the pulpits of the immediate future if this is the kind of logic your students are to learn while in training for pastors! We look back no further than to the times of Chalmers and Candlish, whose careers have so lately closed. We think we hear their prayers for your Presbyteries. Oh that God would hear and answer them.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate