Menu
‹ Chapter 85 of 258 ›

Hospital Reform — The Abuses Of The Present System

4 min read · Chapter 85 of 258

AN old divine has told us that they are the worst of cheats who defraud the public; but surely they are of a still lower grade who rob a hospital. The hospitals of London are the property of the poor, and the sons and daughters of indigence, according to common supposition, have long enjoyed their own without cavil or hindrance. Venerable on account of their age and capacity for alleviating human suffering, monuments of royal or private beneficence, like Guy's or St. Bartholomew's, have been deservedly regarded as models of order and impartial administration. The exception now taken to their management imputes no blame to those who manage them. Their fault lies in trying to do too much. The deceptions and meannesses practised by individuals are sins for which the hospital authorities can hardly be held responsible, and no slur will be cast on them by the following remarks.

The all important subject of the hospitals and the poor is well wrought out by Elizabeth Thomas, in the story of "Great St. Benedict's," published some little time ago by Messrs. J. F. Shaw and Co. With the story itself we shall not concern ourselves further than is necessary for the illustration of the subject. If our readers look into the book for themselves they are not likely to be disappointed. We have asked ourselves in surprise—Can these things be so? Even now we would fain hope that there must be some mistake.

Arthur Shirley, the hero of the narrative, is a noble-minded young doctor, in the east of London, who lives to benefit the poor, and after labouring night and day among the crowded lurking-places of disease, falls a martyr to his one consuming idea of hospital reform. He surrenders a lucrative appointment at St. Benedict's because he will not follow the fashion of pretending to do impossibilities, and on this account he is disappointed in marriage, his betrothed not caring to ally herself with a man of uncertain prospects. The state of things in the wards and consulting-rooms is well described. "At St. Benedict's a medical staff of ten physicians and surgeons is provided for the treatment of 5,000 in-patients a year, while a staff of the same number is considered sufficient for the treatment of 85,000 out-patients." This excess of work engenders the unsatisfactory system known among medical students as "knocking them off"; and a young surgeon on the establishment, whose conscience condemns this smart practice, may readily fall into trouble. "Knocking off" is understood by gentlemen high in the profession, for when once they become associated with hospitals there is only this one way of tiding over their difficulties. Thus Dr. —, of St. Benedict's, "has had to see and prescribe for 125 men, or for 164 women and 62 children in a morning's work. He has had, in addition, a considerable number of old cases. One day, he says, he saw and dismissed in an hour and ten minutes 120 patients, or at the rate of thirty-five seconds each. . . By this abuse the in-patients, for whom the hospitals were alone built and intended, suffer also, . . the in-patients cannot be kept long enough to cure their diseases, and the greater part go away simply relieved." The argument

177

is that out-door relief would be more effectively administered by local dispensaries, for under the present system "the wards are poisoned by the breath of thousands of out-patients, suffering from infectious diseases." The reform party, which, by the way, does not number all the medical profession, are able to put their case in a strong light, and it is hardly likely that the customs of a past generation can be maintained for an indefinite time.

These things affect the hospitals and their governors; other abuses touch the honour of the well-to-do classes, and for these exposure should prove a cure. The facts, as stated by our author, are humiliating to the great English people, and we give them in her own words, lest we should be charged with misrepresentation. One doctor is made to tell another doctor as an undoubted fact "that the poor are being gradually turned out of the consulting-rooms by well-to-do persons. He knows of persons with incomes of £1,000 a-year who come to the hospitals as out-patients; and the wives and daughters of men almost as wealthy actually borrow their servants' clothes in order to apply as out-patients. This cruel state of affairs not only robs the public charity and the poor, but has caused starvation and misery to many a young doctor, as the out-patients who should rightfully call him in and pay a moderate fee for his services now go to the hospitals and get attended for nothing."

It appears that many who obtrude into the consulting-rooms seek to hide their meanness by giving false names and sham addresses. The confession of a lady, casually encountered among the waiting company affords a yet deeper insight into this scandalous abuse:—"I have always tipped the porter, perhaps rather well, and have never been treated except by one of the cleverest physicians or surgeons. . . My husband became a governor for ten pounds a year, so of course he can give letters and orders to any amount." Where among human-kind shall we look for honour if not in the governor of a hospital? We hope that the case is a fiction.

The abuses exposed and deplored are entailing misery on the poor, and they are occasionally the direct cause of death. In the forced hurry of "knocking off," many mistakes are necessarily made—fatal blunders so far as the unfortunate subjects are concerned. A disorder, which might have been cured if properly treated in time, by the patient being taken into the house, is only aggravated by a student's slight examination of thirty seconds, the application of a liniment, and the drinking of a bottle-full of common-place medicine. The fate of poor little Jack of Miss Thompson's narrative, whose complaint—"caries of the cervical vertebra"—was mistaken for swelling of the glands, and who died in a week after being refused admission at Great St. Benedict's, where his life might have been saved, is sadly typical of what occurs in real life. The subject is a painful one, and the cry for reform comes from those who are not strong enough to help themselves. Why should abuses, which, with our rapidly increasing population, are becoming simply intolerable, be allowed to remain for an hour? On a subject so vital the Government should take prompt action. Certain hospitals in the Borough of Southwark will be all the better for a commission of investigation of the most searching kind.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate