Silencing the Critic
MANY volumes of the lives of early Methodist worthies have been issued from the Wesleyan press, and they are all so interesting that they deserve to be perused not alone by Methodists, but by members of all Christian communities. As, however, the purchase of these volumes must necessarily be beyond the power of large numbers of readers, it is well that selections of pithy anecdotes should be occasionally offered to the public to gratify and stimulate their appetite. The following capital story we cull from a little book entitled, "Recollections of Methodist Worthies," published at No. 2, Castle-street, City-road:—
"The economy of Methodism provides that all the members of the Society should contribute towards the support of their ministers; and hence the inconvenience, to which very many clergymen in other denominations are exposed, who are dependent upon the liberality of a few of their flock—sometimes, indeed, upon the bounty of a single individual—is avoided.
"Nothing, however, can protect Methodist preachers, nor any other preachers, from the offensive interference, or overbearing, or opposition of certain self-sufficient men, who not only make themselves of more importance than their neighbours, but imagine that they have a right, above all other people, to review, and approve or condemn, all that is done in their respective localities, and all that they hear from the pulpit, or on the platform. Men of this class are to be found in all churches, and are intolerable pests of the societies to which they belong. Like all bullies, whose discernment, as a rule, is very quick, they know by instinct whether their presence is dreaded by others; and they take a malicious delight in plaguing and persecuting the modest and unassuming, the thoughtful and quiet. To deal with them effectually requires the manifestation of contempt, as well as the exercise of courage; and sometimes even both of these fail.
"Many years ago there lived a man of this class in one of the Midland counties, who was, at the same time, the terror and the support of the circuit to which he belonged. He was possessed of ample means, and was not unwilling to help the cause when money was needed: but he made everybody feel what he was doing, and constantly took occasion to abuse, in the roundest terms, stewards, trustees, superintendents, and others, who applied to him for help, for their mismanagement, denouncing them as blunderers or extravagant persons, who deserved no help unless they did what he recommended, and threatening to withdraw his
63
favours if they did not reform. He was especially offensive to his ministers, declaring his opinion that they were a degenerate race, and very inferior to their forefathers: if they were thoroughly in earnest, and were attentive to the wants of the people, the cause would be much more flourishing and prosperous. It was his invariable practice to quarrel with their preaching; and he made a point of remaining in his pew after each Sunday morning service, that he might give them suitable lectures on their ignorance, or their indiscretion, or want of power. He seldom meddled with their theology, for here he felt his weakness; and he knew that on this point they were generally correct; but if he had been reading a book which they had not had the good fortune to see, they were not abreast of the times: if one of them shouted more than was necessary, or spoke of hell and the lost, he ought to remember that there were many persons in the congregation who could only listen to such remarks with pain: and if he was quiet in his bearing and delivery, it was hardly to be wondered at, that the people should be dull and apathetic under such discourses. In short, there was no pleasing this very fastidious hearer.
"An excellent man, who was much beloved in the circuit as a superintendent minister, and whose preaching was universally liked, was—to use his own expression, 'worried to death' by this constant fault finding, and determined that he would leave at the end of his second year. He did so. At the following Conference another preacher was appointed to succeed him, who was a man of great ability, but considered rather rough. He had the misfortune also to be somewhat lame, and because of his halting style in walking was humorously called by his brethren, 'Brother Dot-and-go-one.' Finding that his predecessor in the circuit was leaving at the end of two years, and ascertaining that he was at the Conference, he went up to him and said:
"'What sort of a circuit is this you are leaving?'
"'Oh, a very nice circuit indeed.'
"'Is it hard?'
"'Not at all: the farmers are very kind, and lend us their gigs; we seldom have to walk any distance.'
"'But you are leaving at the end of the second year. What's that for?'
"'Oh, I thought it better to come away.'
"'But why? Were you not comfortable?'
"'Oh yes, very comfortable, thank you: except with one man.'
"'Ah! who was that? Was it one of the circuit stewards?'
"'No; he wasn't circuit steward while I was there.'
"'Then how did he trouble you?'
"'Why, the fact is, he was always quarrelling with my sermons. I could never please him: according to his judgment, whenever I preached I made some mistake; I ought not to have said this thing, or I ought to have said some other thing; I had misunderstood the meaning of my text; or I didn't know much of what was going on in the church or the world, and ought to be better informed—until at last I made up my mind that I wouldn't stand it any longer; and so I have come away at the end of my second year.'
"'And that was the only reason for your leaving? Were the people kind, and willing to hear the Word?'
"'Oh, quite so. I never met with any people more so.'
"'Thank you,' said 'Brother Dot-and-go-one,' as he limped away.
"On the first Sunday after his arrival in his new circuit, he had to preach in the chapel where this criticising hearer worshipped. He preached with great energy, and with marvellous effect. The congregation were much excited, and all were congratulating themselves upon the advent into their circuit of one who knew how to handle the Word of God so well. Even our friend, the critic, was conscious of most pleasurable emotions; for he had listened with profound interest and delight to the entire discourse. But he must be true to himself, or he would lose his importance in the circuit. He therefore remained in his pew as usual, until 'Dot-and-go-one' descended the pulpit stairs, and came down his aisle. Then rising, and shaking hands with his new minister in the most cordial manner, he said:
"'Thank you, Sir; thank you, Sir, for your most excellent sermon: you have given us a most admirable discourse.'
"'Yes, I have,' said 'Dot-and-go-one.'
"'You have indeed, Sir. We seldom get such preaching here. It will throw new life into this place.'
"'So it will;' said 'Dot-and-go-one.'
"'It will indeed, Sir. I could have wished, however, and, I am sure you will excuse my saying so—that you had been a little shorter. You see, our people here are a very poor and plain people, and they are apt to get wearied, if they sit too long in a place of worship. The wise man himself says, that 'much study is a weariness of the flesh.'
"'So he does;' said 'Dot-and-go-one,' nodding his head, as he assented to the correctness of the quotation.
"'Just so,' replied the critic. 'And though I do not speak on my own account—for it is always a great treat to me to listen to an intellectual discourse, like the one you have just given us—yet, I am sure, you must agree with me that it is better, far better, not to weary people in a place of worship. Now, I think that you might, with great advantage, have omitted the third part of your discourse; which, to tell you the truth, was a little above the comprehension of our people, and might, perhaps, give them the impression that you were rather trying to show them how much you knew, than to edify them. Less argument in the body of your sermon, and more force in its application, would have made it much more effective. You will excuse my plain speaking. I always think it better to let a man know my mind, even though it should sometimes not be very pleasant to speak. But you will not be offended with me for saying what I have said, will you?'
"'Offended with you, my dear!' said 'Dot-and-go-one.' 'Offended with you! No; I pity you, my dear! I know you have got a soft place here'—touching the fault-finder on his forehead—'and I pity you from the bottom of my heart;' saying which, he limped away.
"The critic was silenced, and gave no more trouble."
