Menu
‹ Chapter 145 of 258 ›

Thomas Carlyle — By C. A. Davis, Bradford

17 min read · Chapter 145 of 258

THE grand, wayward genius, hard as granite, tender and plaintive as a mother's love, whose marvellous writings—graphic, lurid, and pathetic beyond any of this or almost any other century—have wielded an influence on the world of literature scarcely paralleled, and whose rugged moral teachings, unflinching hostility to sham, invincible maintenance of what is real, have been the most efficient back-bone producing agent in the realm of character in this otherwise soft age,—this glorious Lion-Man is gone from among us. But the momentum of his life will be long ere it is exhausted. He was a great Force: he imparted an intellectual and moral impetus to thousands: he made his mark on his country, and has left behind him an influence, on the whole, noble and godly, for which we may bless the Giver of every good gift.

We have just risen from the perusal of Mr. Wylie's intensely interesting and wonderfully adequate book. It is not a formal, dry biography; rather a friend that undertakes to introduce you to Carlyle, talking about him on the way, pointing out the scenes through which he moved from childhood to old age, showing you the genesis of his books, telling of his friends, and making you often the companion of Carlyle himself; yet falling into no hero-worship, but with just discrimination dividing between truth and error in the great master's teachings. It shows you his griefs—ah! what griefs were they—his sympathy with sorrowing friends, his solemn reverence towards God; and brings you at last to the old man's grave—a grave at which the thoughts of a nation stood hushed.

The age has been blessed by the career of such a man, and it does one good to trace his life and work in such a book. Mr. Wilson's is a much smaller, yet creditable, work.

The great Scottish peasant—for, learned and cultured as he was, he retained to the last the rough exterior, even when presented to the Queen or visited by an Empress in his Chelsea home—was born, as everyone now knows, December 4th, 1795, at Ecclefechan, in the southwestern district of the Scottish Lowlands. His father, one of five brothers, "pithy, bitter speaking bodies, and awfu' fechters," was a stonemason, who did his work well, strongminded, original, strict, who went to church as to parade duty, "for which he, in the other world, expected pay with arrears, as I trust he has received." His mother was equally remarkable, uniting to strength of brain a most winsome tenderness of heart, and teaching her son, who almost worshipped her, "less by word than by act and daily reverent look and habitude, her own simple version of the Christian faith." Thomas was the eldest of nine children. That most remarkable of all autobiographies, "Sartor Resartus," veiled though it be, gives us beautiful pictures of his childhood. A deep, pondering mind there was in the little being whose eyes were so wide

* Thomas Carlyle: the Man and His Books. By William Howie Wylie. London: Marshall, Japp, and Co. 1881.

Thomas Carlyle: the Iconoclast of Modern Shams. By Rev. John Wilson, M.A. Paisley: Alexander Gardner. 1881.

337

opened on the village world around him. Behold him, for instance, at supper on the orchard wall, whither he was wont to carry forth his porringer of bread and milk. "There," he says, "many a sunset have I, looking at the distant Western Mountains, consumed, not without relish, my evening meal. Those hues of gold and azure, that hush of World's expectation as Day dies, was still a Hebrew speech for me; nevertheless I was looking at the fair, illuminated letters, and had an eye for their gilding." He was about eight years old when it first struck him that the stage coach "could be other than some terrestrial moon, rising and setting by mere law of nature like the heavenly one; that it came on made highways, from far cities towards far cities; weaving them like a monstrous shuttle into closer and closer union." With amazement he began to discover that Ecclefechan "stood in the middle of a Country, of a World; that there was such a thing as History, as Biography; to which I also, one day, by hand or tongue, might contribute." "Thus at that tender age," says Mr. Wylie, "the vindicator of Cromwell and the most brilliant historian of the French Revolution got the first glimpse of the work that had been given him to do."

From the village school he was sent to the Grammar School at Annan—the "Hinterschlag Gymnasium" of Sartor—where education was conducted by brute force. Adam Hope was the master's inappropriate name: he knew syntax enough, "and of the human soul thus much—that it had a faculty called memory, and could be acted on through the muscular integument by appliance of birch rods." Our poor little bookworm needed no such incitement to learning, rather the reverse, for he had already been secretly studying his Latin rudiments with great industry. The bullies of the school, moreover, were cruel to the child, taking advantage of "his small personal stature"; and he wept so often under their tyranny "that he was nicknamed the Tearful, which epithet till towards his thirteenth year was not quite unmerited." At rare intervals, however, "the young soul burst forth into fire-eyed rage, and, with a stormfulness under which the boldest quailed," he asserted his rights.

The most fruitful circumstance of this Annan life was the meeting with Edward Irving, and the forming of the friendship which lasted till the great preacher's death. "But for Irving I had never known what the communion of man with man meant." Irving was sixteen, and Carlyle two years younger when they first met, and Carlyle was soon after transferred to Edinburgh, and in company with his friend began there his college life.

This Edinburgh college course does not appear to have given him great satisfaction; but he availed himself, more than perhaps any other human being ever did or will do, of the resources of the library; and before he was nineteen had read more books probably than all the Edinburgh professors put together. His parents had destined him for the ministry, but he found himself thrust back from that course by the mental conflicts that raged within him. "The voice came to me, saying, Arise, and settle the problem of thy life! I had been destined by my father and my father's minister to be myself a minister. But now that I had gained man's estate, I was not sure that I believed the doctrines of my father's kirk, and it was needful I should now settle it. And so I entered into my chamber and closed the door, and around me

there came a trooping throng of phantasms dire from the abysmal depths of nethermost perdition. Doubt, fear, mockery, and scorn were there; and I arose and wrestled with them in travail and agony of spirit. Whether I ate I know not, whether I slept I know not; I only know that when I came forth again it was with the direful persuasion that I was the miserable owner of a diabolical arrangement called a stomach; and I have never been free from that knowledge from that hour to this, and I suppose that I never shall be until I am laid away in my grave."

A four years' experience of school-mastering followed his leaving college; but it gradually became clear to him that literature was his true vocation: and his first notable efforts were directed to the opening up to English readers the treasures of German literature. A review of Goethe's "Faust," a "Life of Schiller," the translation of Goethe's "Wilhelm Meister's Apprenticeship," followed rapidly upon one another, and created wide interest in England and Germany.

The ship of his life-career being now fairly launched, we have to see him joined by a worthy companion. His wife was, by all accounts, of the very best. "It would be difficult," says Mr. Wylie, "to name any other man of letters, in any land, who was so perfectly happy in his marriage." Mrs. Carlyle was richly gifted both in heart and intellect; her varied culture and refinement of nature caused her to be regarded as one of the most remarkable women of her day. Her father was Dr. John Welsh, a medical man of Haddington, in Dumfriesshire, and she was a descendant of that John Welsh, the Scotch Reformer, who married the daughter of Knox. Edward Irving, who was her tutor, used to speak of her intellect as the most powerful he had ever seen in a woman.

She brought her husband the little property of Craigenputtoch, a farm lying in a wild solitude on the shore of Loch Urr, among the granite hills of Nithsdale. There is a good story of a shepherd on one of these Galloway hills who told an English tourist he would see "sax kingdoms"; and pointed out in succession Cumberland, in England; the Isle of Man, once a sovereignty in the families of Derby and Athole; the coast of Ireland; and the ground on which they were standing, part of Scotland. "Yes, that makes four," said the Englishman, "but you have two more to show me." "That's true, sir, but don't be in a hurry. Just look up aboon yer head, and that is by far the best of a' the kingdoms—that, sir, aboon is heeven. That's five; and the saath kingdom is below yer feet, and to it I hope ye'll never gang; but that's a point on which I canna speak wi' ony certainty."

In this mountain home Carlyle spent the next seven years of his life, writing the "Essays," which constitute much of his finest work, and "Sartor Resartus," which immortal book, however, "the most creative effort of his genius," could not get into print till 1833-4, when it had to take itself to pieces and appear bit by bit in Fraser's Magazine. America was readier than England to recognize the genius of the book; and great was Carlyle's amazement and delight when there came to him in 1836 a copy of his great work from Boston, in book form, with a handsome cheque in payment of the right to publish "Sartor" in America. It may be added, that the first money he received for the

339

"French Revolution" came from America. He had got as much as £130 from that source when the work had "brought him no penny" in England.

Carlyle was now contemplating work that could not be done in solitude. The writing of the history of the "French Revolution," determined him to remove to London, that he might have the best libraries within easy reach. He took up his residence in Cheyne-row, Chelsea, the house which was his home for forty-seven years, and in which he was to die. In London he delivered four courses of lectures, of which that on "Heroes and Hero-worship" has been preserved in permanent form. One of the greatest conversationalists of his day, he was a born orator. "His talk," said one, "is an amazement and a splendour scarcely to be faced with steady eyes." The audiences which listened to these lectures were composed of the élite of the intellectual world of London.

In 1837 appeared "The French Revolution: a History:" a marvel; written with a pen of flame; sublime, weird, awful, of deep pathos; the most vivid piece of history writing ever done. It straightway sent Carlyle's name sounding through every corner of Great Britain. Sir William Hamilton got hold of the book at three in the afternoon and never laid it aside till he had finished the three volumes at four the next morning. Dickens used to read it through twice a year. John Stuart Mill said, "No work of greater genius, either historical or poetical, had been produced in this country for many years." Mr. Mill might well read it with painful as well as delighted interest, for Carlyle had lent him the first part in manuscript. He passed it on to Mrs. Taylor, the lady to whom he was afterwards married; whose servant, finding it lying about in the study, the next morning kindled the fire with it; and as Carlyle said, "up the chimney with a sparkle and a roar went the 'French Revolution;' thus ending in smoke and soot, as the great transaction itself did more than half a century ago." Mill was horrified; but Carlyle, though burdened and dejected with the double task, manfully set to work to rewrite it, "and in course of time the 'French Revolution,'" as he said, "got finished, as all things must sooner or later."

Of his other books we have not spree in this article to speak particularly. There followed some political pamphlets; then his magnificent "Oliver Cromwell's Letters and Speeches; with Elucidations," a work which had been suggested to him many years before by his mother, who believed Cromwell to be grossly misrepresented. The vast, herculean labours which the production of this book entailed can hardly be known. He was a martyr to the "Museum Headache." He toiled through continents of State papers, contemporary pamphlets, and authorities of all kinds. He personally explored Cromwell's battle-fields. The result of the work was "to restore the image of Cromwell, freed from dust and defilement, to the admiring gaze of the English people." He raised the "Uncrowned King of England" out of his grave to be again the promoter of righteousness and freedom; and Carlyle became, through his biography of Oliver, one of the mightiest progressive forces of his age.

His "Life of John Sterling" followed next, an exquisite biography,

but disappointing to those who had rejoiced over the Calvinism of "Cromwell," because it appeared to treat lightly the highest truths of religion as "immeasurable dust whirlwinds."

"The History of Frederick the Great," which in bulk is his greatest book, and cost him incredible labour for fourteen years, is a masterly performance; but one cannot help wishing that the intense application and splendid genius displayed in it had been employed on a better subject. If instead of glorifying one of the worst characters in history, the royal highwayman who stole Silesia, and plunged Europe into that devil's dance known as the Seven Years' War, he had devoted one-third of the time and toil to a work he had contemplated, but never achieved—a Life of John Knox—the magnificent fabric reared by his literary skill and industry would have been worthily and consistently crowned. England and Scotland are the poorer for the possession of "Frederick," and the want of such a life of the Scottish Reformer as our literary giant had given of the great Puritan statesman and soldier. The "History of Frederick" was greeted in Germany with enthusiasm; but its effect in England was to weaken its author's moral influence.

It will be best here to chronicle some opinions of his which we can view only with regret, and so clear them out of the way, that we may afterwards close our brief paper with that in the magnificent old man which is only beautiful. Would it have been credited that Carlyle was a friend to slavery? Listen to him! "An engagement for life" (his euphemism for slavery) "is better than one from day to day." Let the negroes be consulted as to that. "I never thought," said Carlyle, "the rights of negroes worth much discussing in any form." "The man who is seventy-nine years of age" (his age at the time) "has not seventeen minutes to spare for the entire negro race." "Our beautiful black darlings are, at least, happy, with little labour except to the teeth, which surely in those excellent horse jaws of theirs will not fail." Bitter, scornful words. Quite consistently he espoused the cause of the South in the American civil war; and with all his might defended brutal Governor Eyre, returned red-handed from slaughter and outrage in a British colony; where, to suppress some negro discontent, he had slain four hundred and fifty innocent negro peasants, in cold blood, in batches of ten or twenty; had stripped naked and flogged with a new instrument of torture made of piano wire six hundred other inhabitants of Jamaica, from the matron of seventy to the boy of twelve; had caused a thousand homes to be burned and robbed by the soldiery, and had hanged without trial that noble Christian, Gordon. And what said Carlyle? This—"Penalty and clamour are not the things this governor merits from any of us, but honour and thanks, and wise imitation (I will further say) should similar emergencies rise, on the great scale or on the small, in whatever wo are governing." We may account for this sorrowful moral twist by Carlyle's worship of Force: such work as was cut out for him by the "History of Frederick" could not bless his nature.

Very joyfully subscribe we, however, to his Titanic outburst against gin. "Be it with reason or unreason," he wrote of a certain class of Glasgow operatives, "too surely they do in verity find the time all out of joint; this world for them no home, but a dingy prison-house of reckless unthrift, rebellion, rancour, indignation against themselves and

341

against all men. Is it a green flowery world, with everlasting azure sky stretched over it, the work and government of a God; or a murky, simmering Tophet, of copperas-fumes, cotton-fuz, gin-riot, wrath and toil, created by a demon, governed by a demon? The sum of their wretchedness, merited or unmerited, welters, huge, dark and baleful, like a Dantean hell, visible there in the statistics of gin; gin, justly named the most authentic incarnation of the Infernal Principle in our times, too indisputably an incarnation; gin, the black throat into which wretchedness of every sort, communicating itself by calling on Delirium to help it, whirls down; abdication of the power to think or resolve, as too painful now, on the part of men whose lot of all others would require thought and resolution; liquid Madness sold at tenpence the quartern, all the products of which are and must be, like its origin, mad, miserable, ruinous, and that only!" Would that the working men who need it would weigh Carlyle's appeal—"No man oppresses thee, O free and independent franchiser; but does not this stupid pewter-pot oppress thee? No son of Adam can bid thee come or go; but this absurd pot of heavy-wet, this can and does! Thou art the thrall, not of Cedric the Saxon, but of thy own brutal appetites and this scoured dish of liquor; and thou pratest of thy liberty? Thou entire blockhead!"

And what thinks the reader of this on Darwinism? "Alluding to the development hypothesis, waxing warm, and at the same time bringing his hand down on the table with a thump like the sledge-hammer of Thor, he emphatically added, 'I have no patience whatever with these gorilla damnifications of humanity!'"

But we draw near to his great sorrow and his end. It was while he was absent in Edinburgh, delivering the address as Lord Rector of the University, that his wife was suddenly snatched from him. She, riding in her brougham in Hyde Park, saw her little favourite dog run over by a carriage. She lifted it into the carriage, and the coachman drove on. Not receiving any direction from his mistress he stopped the carriage and discovered her, as he thought, in a fit. He drove to St. George's Hospital, where it was found she was dead. We intrude not into the sacred privacy of the old man's grief. The blissful union of forty years was dissolved: henceforth he is left alone. Annually he made his lonely visit to the burial ground at Haddington, where the loved remains were laid; and (as the grave-digger has seen) knelt long in silence upon the grave; even kissed the soil. Read the simple, heart-moving inscription placed by him on the tombstone: "Here likewise now rests Jane Welsh Carlyle, spouse of Thomas Carlyle, Chelsea, London. She was born at Haddington, 14th July, 1801; only child of the above John Welsh and of Grace Welsh, Caplegill, Dumfriesshire, his wife. In her bright existence she had more sorrows than are common, but also a soft invincibility, a capacity of discernment, and a noble loyalty of heart which are rare. For forty years she was the true and loving helpmate of her husband, and by act and word unweariedly forwarded him, as none else could, in all of worthy that he did or attempted. She died at London, 21st April, 1866, suddenly snatched away from him, and the light of his life as if gone out."

Three years afterwards he wrote these solemn, pathetic, comforting words to his friend Erskine, of Linlathen: "So be it with us all, till we

quit this dim sojourn, now grown so lonely to us, and our change come! 'Our Father which art in heaven, hallowed be thy name, thy will be done';—what else can we say? The other night, in my sleepless tossings about, which were growing more and more miserable, these words, that brief and grand prayer, came strangely into my mind, with an altogether new emphasis; as if written, and shining for me in mild, pure splendour, on the black bosom of the night there; when I, as it were, read them word by word, with a sudden check to my imperfect wanderings, with a sudden softness of composure which was much unexpected. Not for perhaps thirty or forty years had I once formally repeated that prayer; nay, I never felt before how intensely the voice of man's soul it is; the inmost aspiration of all that is high and pious in poor human nature; right worthy to be recommended with an 'After this manner pray ye.'

He had a bright eye for "affairs" almost to the end. His last letter on public matters was that to The Times, remembered by us all, assailing the policy on the Eastern question of "our miraculous Premier," and denouncing "the unspeakable Turk." That little letter performed effective service out of all proportion to its length.

His activity was now giving way. Last summer the people of Chelsea noticed that his morning riverside walk was becoming infrequent; that when he did appear his form was more bowed; his step feebler. Yet he survived through the rigorous winter that followed; till on the morning of Saturday, February 5th, 1881, he breathed his last. "Next day in Westminster Abbey Dean Stanley told his congregation of one tender expression—one plaintive yet manful thought—written but three or four years ago. 'Three nights ago, stepping out after midnight and looking up at the stars, which were clear and numerous, it struck me with a strange new kind of feeling'—'In a little while I shall have seen you also for the last time. God Almighty's own Theatre of Immensity, the Infinite made palpable and visible to me. That also will be closed, flung to in my face, and I shall never behold it any more. The thought of this eternal deprivation, even of this, though this is such a nothing in comparison, was sad and painful to me. And then a second feeling rose in me: What if Omnipotence, that has developed in me those pieties, those reverences, and infinite affections, should actually have said, 'Yes, poor mortals, such of you as have gone so far shall be permitted to go further. Hope; despair not. God's will, God's will, not ours, be done.'"

It was a noble life. Would that it had been irradiated with a brighter faith in the Redeemer!* With some few exceptions, which have been noted, its influence was as wholesome as it was mighty. Blameless and beautiful in his domestic life, he blazed before the world with a splendour of genius which was equalled by his dogged, invincible capacity for work. You travel through his books as through the finest scenery of his native land; where rugged sublimity and mountain grandeur give

* How heartily we unite in this sentiment. Alas, the influence of Carlyle upon many minds has been very questionable. No doubt we must attribute their vagaries rather to their own weakness than to any teaching of their master; but had he been more assuredly a believer in Jesus his marvellous power would have more effectually wrought for righteousness, and his errors would have been avoided. C. H. S.

343

place ever and anon to startlingly sudden glimpses of the utmost loveliness in glen and heaven-reflecting loch lying at your feet. He is homely, grotesque, sublime, and delicately tender almost in a breath; and he is one of the strongest thinkers of this age. But his most impressive characteristic is his sense of infinitude and eternity. His thought took a solemnly wide sweep. You hear ever the strong waft of its wing beyond the bounds of visibility and time. The thunder of eternity was ever audible to him, and he made it audible to this age. Scotland has produced many noble men; perhaps none greater than this last great Scot—Thomas Carlyle.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate