II.—THE DOCTRINE OF HUMAN DEPRAVITY
1. This doctrine as it is supposed to affect man in his human relationships. It is a fact that somehow man at a very early stage of his career shows sad and sorrowful signs of a weak moral nature; that it requires constant and severe training to put him right, and to keep him right, and that he needs but little training to go wrong, to show temper, self-will, vindictiveness, even when only a few months old, and his whole career is a source of care and anxiety to all who are related to him. His moral nature seems poisoned at its springs, no part of it is untainted; and this is true of mankind everywhere and always.
This moral problem, however, has nothing to do with Calvinism; we may take the pessimist or the optimist view of man's moral nature. The child may be as unselfish and generous as some imagine; the boy may be truthful and obedient; the man may be upright and pure in all his earthly relationships; father, son, merchant, citizen, ruler. He may be held in the highest esteem by all who know him. The world has left a record not only of wrong, and crime, and cruelty, it has also chronicled deeds of nobility and moral grandeur, showing the sublime possibilities of our nature, though it is mournful to confess that as a matter of fact the record of evil is unspeakably more voluminous than the tales of heroism, love, and goodness.
This question affects the moral philosophers, philanthropists, and civil authorities, and the several religious bodies have their varied opinions concerning it; but Calvinism makes no authoritative affirmation on the subject; and to say that we allege that man is in every sense depraved and vile, is simply to either misunderstand or to misrepresent us.
2. This doctrine as it really affects man in his Godward relationships. If there were no God, and no future life, no Calvinist would affirm the total depravity of man. Man would not then be totally depraved; he would still be imperfect and wayward, but a noble being, with glorious possibilities of expansion within his reach. But as there is a God, and man persists in being in a state of alienation from him, treats him as if he were not, and had no claims on man's love and service; breaks his laws, and tramples carelessly on his precepts, lives as if this were the only life, and feels annoyed when brought face to face with eternity through the appeals and arguments of the thoughtful and earnest preacher. He is surely "dead in sins." "Sold under sin." He is "carnally minded, which is death." He has a mind "which is enmity against God."
Godward the heart of man is frozen, is in a state of winter, darkness, death. In this, the higher side of his relationships, he is totally depraved; he is a wreck, a ruin, a failure. This he will remain for ever unless he is changed through the grace of God.
This state of enmity, alienation, darkness, death, can be described as total depravity, and Calvinists do not hesitate so to describe it.
Arminians come near to this very view of man's state before God, and his attitude towards God. We do not shrink from telling man the worst of it, and appeal to him to have repentance towards God; for God alone can turn our winter into summer, our darkness to light, our death to life.
