Menu
‹ Chapter 235 of 264 ›

Joseph Barker

13 min read · Chapter 235 of 264

THE story of Joseph Barker's life is one of remarkable interest. Unfortunately many still remember him best as Joe Barker, the infidel, though thousands rejoice that he was delivered from his unbelief, and died hoping in the Lord. The memoir from which we fashion our paper is for the most part autobiographical, and some portions appear to have been written while he was still a wanderer in the labyrinth of doubt. His nephew, in his editorial capacity, has not used a wise discretion in dealing with the material at his command, and has left several important links in the story to be supplied by the reader.

From faith to doubt and back again is the burden of the book, and the story is a sad one. While admitting the probability of a sceptical reader being influenced for good, we cannot lose sight of the possibility of damage accruing to the mind of young men who are not established in the verities of the gospel. Those who have broken loose from the moorings of faith may attempt to justify their scepticism by the infidelity of Barker, and discredit the reality of his change when he re-entered the fellowship of the Christian church. The re-espousal of the belief of his earlier years may be regarded by them as a mental aberration superinduced by the trial and disappointment of years, and not as affording any evidence of the truth of Christianity. We trust, however, the book may accomplish the end for which it is intended, and prove, in God's hands, the means of convincing many that infidelity is wholly irrational, and that only in the religion of the Lord Jesus Christ can we find the basis of a sound morality, the bond of a true character, and the inspiration of a genuine benevolence.

There is nothing very remarkable in the history of Barker's early days, if we except the shifts and struggles of the family and his own waywardness. His parents were simple-minded Methodists, and "knew nothing of theology, nothing of controversy. Their simple creed was one God, one Christ, one hope, one religion, one heaven. To love God and all mankind, to shun evil and do good, to go through life with clean hands and pure hearts, rejoicing in hope of everlasting blessedness was all they cared about." And enough, too, one might well exclaim!

Under the influence of such a creed young Barker became religious without having, we fear, been really converted, and was introduced to the class meeting before he became a Christian in any vital sense. His description of this cherished institution of Methodism is surely a burlesque; its defects are exaggerated, and its advantages discredited. He says, "There is a great and constant temptation to people to profess what they do not feel; to say they enjoy that which they do not enjoy; to say they have a confidence or an assurance which they have not; and multitudes are overcome by this temptation. They wish to be believed to be something, or they are carried away by the force of example and prevailing custom, and use words which they do not understand, or profess enjoyments they never felt." The most ardent Methodist cannot deny this possibility; the most candid will admit that many yield to the temptation. On the

other hand it must be admitted that the class meeting is to many a means of grace, and is justified by Scripture precedent and precept. We are even prepared to admit that the restraint of confession as to the Lord's dealings is an element of weakness in some of our churches, and a decided loss to the tempted and sorrowful. It was in the exercise of his sacred ministry that David exclaimed, "Come and hear, all ye that fear God, and I will declare what he hath done for my soul." Barker's objections to the class meeting apply with equal force to all our services, and especially to singing, for without doubt many sing language expressive of an experience to which they are total strangers.

Before he had become established in grace he commenced a course of reading which would have proved helpful, but, unfortunately, he fell in with some works which assailed the truths of Christianity, and he gave up the use of all theological terms which were not found in the Bible. When he threw away the "words" he stood in danger of discrediting the doctrines which had been thus formulated by the pious wisdom of ages. "Natural depravity," "The Trinity," and "Substitution" are not Scripture terms, but they express doctrines which are clearly revealed; and until the doctrines can be more aptly expressed their retention is forced upon us as a necessity. "The form of sound words" must be "held fast," for truth is best apprehended and retained by the verbal signs which fix it, and by which it is clearly expressed.

That Barker should have been suspected of heresy is not surprising, for in rejecting the husk it was feared he had despised the kernel which it held. Such was not the case, however, at this time, for he not only read assiduously Adam Clarke's Commentary, but also began the study of Greek and Latin to aid him in the quest of truth. He kept up his attendance at the class meeting, and preached on the Lord's-day. By intellectual assent he was a Christian, but he seems to have been utterly devoid of a joyous experience of divine things. He made himself familiar with the external architecture of the house without entering as a child at home to enjoy its shelter and repose. This is not so rare an experience as some may imagine. When subscription to the articles of a creed is accredited as sufficient evidence of the new birth, the essential elements of joy and stability are lacking.

His father's circumstances having improved, he was taken from the mill where he had been employed, and sent to a Methodist school at Leeds. Here he made himself familiar with the works of standard authors, and soon emerged as a regular local preacher. His orthodoxy was, however, suspected by some, for he was still hampered by his efforts to preach without using theological terms, if, indeed, he did not advance views which were actually erroneous. He claimed a degree of liberty for himself which was fatal to good discipline, and his teaching not conforming with the Methodist standard of faith his connection with that body was terminated.

At this juncture the Methodist New Connexion was started, and he joined that fellowship, believing that he "should have perfect liberty of judgment, of speech, and of action." But, as might have been expected, he did not find everything to accord with his views. The Separatist carried with them the traditions of the Old Connexion, and copied the bigotry with which they charged their former leaders.

565

Barker was not long before he felt the pressure of new rules, and discovered that the freedom from restraint he had long coveted was a will-o'-the-wisp he could not overtake. Had the leaders yielded the concessions he claimed, and sanctioned the eccentricity he demanded, he would have placed himself at the head of a schismatic party with an influence which would have wrought incalculable mischief. Writing of this period he says, "I have seen since, that a man may have too much liberty as well as too little; too little restraint as well as too much; and that a church without authority and discipline must inevitably lose itself in confusion and ruin. We are none of us fit for unlimited liberty." It is to be regretted that he failed to form this judgment earlier in life; it might have saved him from the humiliation of revolt from an accepted standard of orthodoxy, and secured to him, had he been sincere, years of usefulness in the ministry of the gospel.

Joining with other turbulent secessionists, who asserted their legal right to a chapel at Newcastle-on-Tyne, he became their minister, but the liberty conceded to the members soon degenerated into license, and a fresh secession only increased the mischief. "Several entered on a career of scepticism, and stopped not till they had reached its darkest extremes." His own resolution is thus stated: "I now resolved," he writes, "I would think aloud. I would search to the bottom of all things, and make known the results without reserve. I would throw off all restraints of prevailing creeds and customs, and enter on a career of wholesale and untrammelled investigation and discussion."

About this time he was busy in issuing pamphlets from his own pen, and set up a press to print them. Difficulties thickened, however, and his family was often brought into sore straits. To circulate his views more freely and fully he established a paper, called The Christian, the character of which justified another name. He says of his writings at this time, "in all these are passages which, in one's calmer and more candid mood, one is obliged to condemn." His confession of want of candour in the views he advocated lets in a little light upon the conduct of other Freethinkers. When honesty is sacrificed to polemics, the theories advanced must be discounted at their true worth.

Writing of a ten nights' debate with William Cooke in the Lecture-room, Newcastle, he says, "Neither party was in a state of mind to learn of the other. War, whether it be a war of words or a war of deadlier weapons, tends generally to widen the differences of the combatants. And so it was here. And one party certainly went further and travelled faster in the way of error after this exciting contest than he had done before." Men are not made Christians merely by being convinced of the historic truth of Christianity, for the agency of the divine Spirit is essential, and the heart rather than the intellect is the sphere of his operation. This was a lesson Barker came to learn at length, though he sadly missed it in his earlier years.

He now drifted into the fellowship of the Unitarians, published some of their books, and preached in their pulpits; but he found, on acquaintance, that they lacked the unity which comes from an assured belief. He says, "There was a gradual incline from the almost Christian doctrine of Carpenter and Channing, down to the principles of Paine and Voltaire. Down this incline I gradually slid, till I reached at last

the land of doubt and unbelief." It is impossible to read this confession without a shudder. Like a frail bark he was launched on the waste of waters, to drift without chart or pilot towards the dreary shore of the shadow of death.

Ill at ease with himself, and at war with the Christian faith, he only increased his restlessness by dabbling in politics. He would abolish the throne, and sweep away institutions the growth of centuries, and set up a model republic based upon universal suffrage; but his agitation landed him in Manchester jail, and he had to undergo a trial at the assizes on a charge of sedition and conspiracy. After a lengthy delay the Attorney-general withdrew from the charge, and he was set free.

He now renounced the very semblance of religion, and his so-called search after truth ended in his doubting whether there was any truth at all. His biographer says, "He was always adopting new opinions, always advocating something fresh, always shifting his ground, so that his followers never knew what to believe or what to reject. The fact was he could make the people believe anything, however absurd, and did make them believe everything he advocated, until they arrived at the same goal as himself, and believed nothing." It is no matter for surprise that his influence and popularity, vast as they undoubtedly were, began to wane when the people he had taught to doubt regarded him with distrust. Many found their way back into the Christian communions they had been foolish enough to leave, while others plunged deeper into the mire of disbelief. "In 1851," writes his nephew, "he sailed for America, and the country had rest."

One object he had in view in leaving England was to obtain a little quiet for calm reflection in the course he had been pursuing, for he was not satisfied with the changes which had taken place in his own views and ways of life. How could he be satisfied, one may well ask, with the dreary negations he had substituted for a positive faith, and with a moral character which had fearfully deteriorated! "I sought for comfort," he writes, "in a godless and Christless philosophy; but sought in vain. I tried to extort from nature some word of consolation, but not a whisper could I obtain. I tried to forge some theory of my own that might lessen the gloom in which I was wrapt; but my efforts were fruitless. I had 'forsaken the fountain of living waters,' and nothing remained but broken cisterns that could hold no water. I WAS WRETCHED!"

In central Ohio, where he made his home, he does not appear to have realized his desire, nor to have carried out his resolutions. He migrated beyond the limits of the States, to the unpeopled territory of Nebraska, and here he writes, "The difficulties, the perplexities, on the side of unbelief, were more distressing and embarrassing than those I had encountered on the side of Christianity. The further I wandered the blacker the clouds became, and the thicker the darkness."

If Christianity were false, surely it were better to enjoy the hope of the Christian than to endure the despair of the infidel. "Godliness hath the promise of the life that now is," and faith's rich harvesting ennobles character, and enriches the soul with blessedness and joy. From his dark experience the conviction was at length born, "that religion, whether founded in truth or not, was necessary to the

567

virtue and happiness of mankind." When he began to cherish this conviction, the feelings it engendered grew stronger every day, but strange to say, he was allured into undertaking a lecturing tour, a course which, for the time being, was fatal to his peace.

Accepting the post of lecturer to a freethinking congregation in Philadelphia for a period, he withdrew from the compact before the term expired. He says, "I had come to the conclusion that war with Christianity was not the way to promote the virtue and happiness of mankind, and I told my congregation so. And I also advised them, now they were about to be left without a lecturer, to go to some place of worship." This was a decided step in advance of any position he had hitherto reached, and it marked an important crisis in his history. The slave of the bad habit of faulty reasoning, he had a stern battle to fight with himself before he could weigh, with an impartial mind, the evidences of Christianity. It is a severe conflict, when the gospel struggles with the opposition of the heart; it is more than doubly severe when it has to force the citadel of the mind, the windows of which have been barred and barricaded by doubts. Such was his condition when, in 1860, he took ship at Boston to return to England that he might be "perfectly free to pursue whatever course a regard to truth and duty might require." His wife and sons appear to have held fast to their integrity during his mad wanderings, and when he stepped on board the vessel a letter was handed to him from his youngest son, in which this sentence occurs: "Father, dear, when you get to England don't dream that by any breath of yours, or by any paper balls that you can fire, you can ever shatter or shake the eternal granite foundations on which Christianity rests." These words had a powerful effect upon his mind, which was deepened by the experiences of the voyage.

On arriving in England he fell in with the Secularists again, and became joint editor of their publication, The National Reformer, but not being an out-an-out advocate of their views the arrangement soon terminated, and he commenced a paper of his own, and set himself the task of "writing on the Christian side as he had written on the sceptical." The study of the Bible with a new motive made it appear to him a different book, and he experienced emotions to which he had long been a stranger. "Father is coming right" was the joyous exclamation of the members of his family, who had rejoined him: but the process was very slow. He was led away again by his love of self-display and championed the cause of infidelity in a debate in the City Hall, Glasgow, with Colonel Shaw, and afterwards settled down as lecturer to a party of unbelievers at Burnley. He writes, "All the time I was at Burnley, my heart first and then my head were coming nearer to Christ and Christianity." At the grave of an atheist he offered the first prayer which he had breathed for many years and, shortly after when he had preached a funeral sermon on the occasion of the death of a former friend, who had lived and died in the faith and hope of the gospel, he declared himself a Christian. By this act he finally separated himself from the fellowship of the infidel party, and joined the Primitive Methodists, amongst whom he became a preacher; and laboured to the last, both in England and America, to repair, if possible, the mischief he had done by his opposition to the gospel. This, of course, was

impossible; he could only uproot here and there some of the noxious weeds he had sown; he could not destroy the seed-germs of the errors he had scattered broadcast on two continents; he could not recall the years he had wasted, although he honestly endeavoured to redeem the time which remained. Writing from America to Dr. Cooke, within six weeks of his end, he says—"I do, indeed, still cling to Christ. He is, in God, my all, my Teacher, Guide, Example, Saviour, and unfailing Comforter: and I live and labour, and spend all my time for him; and if I had my old strength and millions of money, all, I believe, would be his. When not tortured by bodily pain I am, as a rule, unspeakably happy in his love; when racked and tortured, patience and resignation are all I can boast." Sad, indeed, as his career was, he enjoyed blessedness and peace at the last, but his joy was chastened by the bitterness of regret.

The story of such a life has a voice for to-day, when the cherished truths of ages are rudely assailed by a reckless criticism and the rash conjectures of modern thought call in question the verities of the gospel. The confessions of Joseph Barker as to his decline, his fall, his experience, and his recovery should make our young men pause before they embark upon the stormy sea of doubt, and risk their happiness, their usefulness, and their eternal salvation. The book will have served a useful purpose if only one should rise from the perusal of its pages with the quickened resolution of the poet:—

"Should all the forms which men devise

Assault my faith with treacherous art,

I'd call them vanity and lies,

And bind the gospel to my heart."

VERNON J. CHARLESWORTH.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate