Notices of Books
Palestine Repeopled; or, Scattered Israel's Gathering. A Sign of the Times. By the Rev. JAMES NEIL, B.A. James Nisbet and Co.
IT is more and more marvellous to us that some persons should be able to manufacture vast theories out of such slender materials of fact. "Palestine Repeopled" is a phrase supported by the assertion that there are now 30,000 Jews in Palestine. We are also informed that the number of the Jewish race is somewhere between five and ten millions and therefore taking the medium of seven millions, it appears that three Jews out of seven hundred are in Palestine, or less than half a Jew per cent. We believe that many times in history there have been more Jews in the Holy Land than there are now, even though facilities for travel were entirely absent. We look for the salvation of Israel and her restoration to her own land, but we see no sign of either at
present, and are not disposed to be lenient to those who exaggerate every little fact into a great wonder. It may be pleasant to inspire hope, but the consequences of disappointment are too serious for us to allow the expectations of Christians to be excited by mere trifles.
The Opium Question. A Review of the Opium Policy of Great Britain, and its Results to India and China. By the Rev. ARTHUR S. MOULE. Seely, Jackson, and Halliday.
ALAS for the day in which our country fell into the great sin of the Opium Traffic, for it is so hard to make her retrace her steps. We are glad to see the multiplication of earnest pamphlets on the subject: perhaps in due time the public conscience will be aroused, and then with a voice of thunder England will demand that she should no longer be forced to be the wholesale poisoner of China's millions.
Texts misquoted and misapplied. By R. C. L. B. With Preface by Canon RYLE. Hatchards, Piccadilly.
CONTAINS some very sensible remarks, and exposes some very common blunders. We do not accept all this author's criticisms, and we have a very low opinion of some of his authorities, such as Geddes; but still we could wish that all our ministers could receive the hints with which this little volume is so plentifully stored. Only a day or two ago we received the text recorded in Gen. xxxi. 49 as a parting word, and we tried to show the sender that it was a very inappropriate sentence, for there was no heap of stones between us, and we could trust each other without having a watchman to keep us from harming one another. We are all the more glad to find the following remarks so well sustaining our opinion.
"The Lord watch between me and thee when we are absent one from another." Gen xxxi. 49.
This is an exception to the popular texts under discussion, inasmuch as it is not one quoted by preachers; but it is sometimes used by Christian friends on the occasion of their parting one from the other, in the sense of invoking the watchful care of the Lord over each other during their separation. Whereas, it is evident, in looking at the context, that the speaker, Laban, is here expressing the greatest distrust of Jacob, and is calling upon God to be a witness between them that he (Jacob) should be true to the covenant respecting his daughters. 'And Laban said, This heap is a witness between me and thee this day: therefore was the name of it called Galeed (a heap of witness) and Mispah (a watch-tower); for he said, The Lord watch between me and thee, when we are absent one from another,' etc. Nothing could be more inappropriate to friends parting in mutual confidence and affection.
Readings in Rhyme, from the Drama of Drink. By Harriet A. Glazebrook. John Kempster and Co.
WILL be appreciated by Templars and Prohibition men. The rhymes are all alive, and we hope no Templar will be angry when we add that they are full of spirit.
Jennett Cragg the Quakeress. A Story of the Plague. By MARIA WRIGHT. S. W. Partridge and Co.
A prettily quaint story of a godly Quakeress, her venturesome journey to London while the Plague was raging, and her returning in safety with two orphaned babes in her horse's panniers. Jennett Cragg was a real character, and her journey was a well recorded fact, but imagination has filled in the details.
Principles of New Testament Quotations. By the Rev. JAMES SCOTT, M.A., B.D. T. and T. Clark, 38, George Street, Edinburgh.
THE quotations made in one part of the Scriptures from another are a valuable guide to the authenticity of the sacred writings, and to the preservation of them in their original purity. The quotations from the Old in the New Testament writings are precisely such, both in their variety and degree, as might naturally be expected when referring to authorities with which those to whom they were addressed were familiar and which were reverenced by them. The quotations of the early Christian Fathers from their Scriptures are also of great use, as evidences of the books that were considered by them to be canonical. The whole subject is so thoroughly investigated that it may be said to be exhausted in the volume before us. That no pains have been spared to make it complete, the following statement will show: "Not more than 25 of the 39 books of the Old Testament can be said to be formally cited in the New. The passages once quoted are 220, but the whole number of repeated citations amounts to 290. Seventeen only of the 27 books of the New Testament contain quotations from the Old. The single citations may be estimated at 226, and their whole number by repetition at 284." The references to other passages without any formal quotation are, of course, still more numerous. An index is given of nearly four hundred partial or entire quotations of the New Testament from the Old. The value of this book to Biblical students from these few observations must be obvious to all.
231
Sermons to the Natural Man. By WILLIAM G. T. SHEDD, D.D. T. and T. Clark, 38, George Street, Edinburgh.
A MORE searching, faithful, and thorough warning against limited views of human guilt has not appeared for many years. It is a complete vindication of the terrors of the divine law from reason, from conscience, and from revelation. Its trumpet-tones need to be sounded on both sides of the Atlantic, to rouse from their fatal dreams those who "speak smooth things, and prophesy deceits." The following words bespeak the character of the whole book. "Sinful man shapes his creed in accordance with his wishes, and not in accordance with the unbiased decisions of his reason and conscience. He does not like to think of a holy God, and therefore he denies that God is holy. He does not like to think of the eternal punishment of sin, and therefore he denies that punishment is eternal. He does not like to be pardoned through the substituted sufferings of the Son of God, and therefore he denies the doctrine of atonement. He does not like the truth that man is so totally alienated from God that he needs to be renewed in the spirit of his mind by the Holy Ghost, and therefore he denies the doctrines of depravity and regeneration. . . . A hundred systems of philosophy, falsely so called, have come and gone, but the one old religion of the patriarchs, and the prophets, and the apostles, holds on its way through the centuries, conquering and to conquer." No one can do justice to the theology of the present age without including this antidote to its errors.
Messianic Prophecy. By Dr. EDWARD RICH. Translated from the German. T. and T. Clark, Edinburgh.
THIS book is not very readable, and we are glad of it. Its subject is inviting in appearance only, and its composition is hard, dry, and cold. Whoever wishes to see the prophetic and priestly offices of Christ in both Testaments absorbed in his priestly office may here see it to perfection. We regret to see so much learned labour devoted to such a purpose.
Kindness to Animals. By CHARLOTTE ELIZABETH. S. W. Partridge & Co.
WE wish well to all writers who try to teach children to be kind to dumb animals. Matters are somewhat better than they were, but there is still a great deal of wanton cruelty in the world among those who ought to know better. This little book may prevent the boys from growing up like their fathers, and therefore let it be widely distributed. Destroying birds and their nests, lashing horses, beating donkeys, torturing insects, and tormenting poor ministers with needless letters, are cruelties from which we hope the world will soon be free.
A Bible Dictionary; being a Comprehensive Digest of the History and Antiquities of the Hebrews and Neighbouring Nations. By the Rev. JAMES AUSTIN BASTOW. Hodder and Stoughton.
A VERY good Bible Dictionary for the money—namely, half-a-guinea. We have tested it upon several words, and have found it sound in doctrine, compact in style, and both useful and discretionary in its information. We advise young ministers to purchase Smith or Kitto before they enter upon marriage and its expenses, but to a poor married student Bastow will be very useful.
Bible Evidences Summarized. By HENRY WASH. Church Education Society, 11, Adam Street, Adelphi, W.C.
JUST what it professes to be, and we know not of any other equally clear and complete summary of the same kind. All the historic, rationalistic, and scientific arguments of modern times against the credibility of Scripture testimony are faithfully stated and ably refuted in few words. The work is not wholly controversial, but gives a brief enumeration of the contents of the whole Bible.
God's Training School. Edinburgh: William Oliphant and Co.
THIS is an exposition of Jacob's prophecy concerning his son Joseph as a fruitful bough. It is good of its kind, and abounds in appropriate Scripture references.
A Chronological and Geographical Introduction to the Life of Christ. By C. H. E. D. CASPAIN. Translated by MAURICE J. EVANS, B.A. T. and T. Clark, 38, George Street, Edinburgh.
THIS is a book of immense research. Every page contains as much copious and well-digested matter as is often found in a whole volume. Its object is to ascertain from the most reliable sources, as far as Biblical criticism and personal observations have yet proceeded, the place and time in which the several incidents connected with the earth actually occurred. These incidents are specified and tabulated with a precision unknown before, as there is no other record of a similar amount of patient and scholastic toil having been expended upon that particular subject. To verify each quotation, and to proceed step by step through every train of reasoning, would require an amount of mental toil which few will be disposed, and fewer still will be able, to bestow. Some few deviations from generally received opinions may be discovered, but happily for the most part the usual notions in reference to Biblical chronology and topography are confirmed. The common opinion upon the day of the crucifixion is elaborately defended, but not to our entire satisfaction; especially as, upon that assumption, Thursday is acknowledged to be unaccounted for in the Passion Week, and there is no attempt to explain how, even in the Jewish mode of reckoning, one day and two nights of burial can be three days and three nights. We offer these suggestions, not to teach, but as still willing to be taught. As a book of reference this volume will be unusually helpful to Biblical students.
Sermons by the late Rev. David Laxton, of Sheffield. Hodder and Stoughton, 27, Paternoster-row.
THESE sermons are of mixed merit, and yet all above the common level. The three entitled "The Inexpiable Nature of Human Guilt," "The glorious Gospel of Christ," and "The Peace of God," are worth all the rest; and the first of these, for its adaptation to the present age, is worth the other two. Listen to its tones: "The most fatal and damnable delusion which any man can enter-
tain is the belief that he can make expiation for his own sins, either by his future obedience or his future suffering either in this world or the next. It is a delusion which silences the voice of conscience on the one hand, and prevents the sinner from coming under the saving influence of God's mercy on the other. It is a delusion which is calculated to raise man to that height of blasphemous presumption in which he sets God at defiance, and in effect says to him, 'You cannot, you dare not punish me eternally.'" These are weighty sentiments, in comparison of which all that has been written on behalf of annihilation, or universal restoration, is lighter than "the chaff of the summer threshing-floors."
The Holy Childhood. James Nisbet and Co., 21, Berners Street.
THE sentiments are good, but the imaginary form of dialogue might, we fear, produce a taste for a class of reading which is more associated with evil than with good.
Nestleton Magna: a Story of Yorkshire Methodism. By QUINTUS QUARLES. Elliot Stock, 61, Paternoster Row, London.
IN other words, a religious novel, which, though the best of its kind, is not better than the best. It is founded upon truth, we are told, then why not upon truth only? why mingle the silver, and gold, and precious stones, with wood, hay, and stubble? Methodism, too, above all things decorating itself in the feathers of romance! Surely facts might be gathered from the fifteen millions of adherents of which it boasts sufficiently illustrative of its principles without resorting to fiction. Of course, what its best friends wish it to be is always better than what it is; but then it is for what it is they have really to be thankful, and to hold it up for the imitation of others. Methodism, especially in Yorkshire, and remarkably so in bygone days, abounds with real narratives which need no colouring to enhance their interest and instruction. With the sentiments of this book we are in full sympathy, but not with their borrowed dress.
233
The Faith once Delivered to the Saints; or, Doctrinal, Experimental, and Practical Godliness Vindicated and Enforced, and the Errors of the Times Exposed. By the Late JOHN FOX. Elliot Stock.
THE late John Fox must have had a very odd notion of what is meant by cordiality, for he says of his little book,—
"To the people, and to the ministry or servants of the various sectarianisms of the present day, this work and labour of love is cordially dedicated by the author." Grim cordiality this, which begins by describing the churches as "the various sectarianisms." Equal cordiality towards Baptists and Calvinists will be found all through the book; but the revisers of the work, who knew the author personally, assure us that "any acerbities of expression found in this book were not written in a spirit of bitterness or vindictiveness." We quite believe it, for it often happens that persons who write fiercely are among the meekest of men when the pen is out of their hands. We hope that the miniature portraits taken by the late excellent John Fox were more successful as works of art than this volume as a piece of theology. The good man's portrait of a Calvinist is so far from the truth that we are glad that we never sat to him, for he would probably have depicted us with horns and hoofs. It is among the ironies of history that this book is printed by a firm of sound Calvinistic Baptists, so that it is probable that all the good which will ever come from the production of the miniature portrait painter's book will fall to the share of one of the men whom he most vehemently denounces. Peace to his ashes! Calvinists can bear such assaults as his with unruffled serenity.
Central Truths. By the Rev. CHARLES STANFORD. Hodder and Stoughton; and Power in Weakness, by the same author and publishers.
THE issue of these volumes in plain stiff covers at two shillings and eighteen pence will, we trust, bring them within the reach of many poor men who have hitherto been unable to procure them. The books themselves are too well
known to need our commendation. Their chaste style and mellow tone have long ago placed them among the Christian classics.
Winds of Doctrine. By CHARLES ELAM, M.D. Smith, Elder, and Co., 15, Waterloo-place.
THE most absurd theories will have their admirers if they come from men of great scientific attainments. Their speculations will be taken upon the credit of their actual discoveries. But as real wealth often leads to ruinous speculations, so real scientific knowledge often leads to more than ordinary folly. Those to whom we should look for real acquisitions and clear reasonings in natural science are the first to overleap its boundaries and to substitute their own reveries for established facts. They may reason themselves into the descendants of apes and lobsters and material molecules, but have no right, we think, to do so for others. As from nothing man gradually came—so we are required to believe—to nothing he gradually returns. "If this doctrine," says the book before us, "as now held by a large and powerful section of the scientific world, does indeed, as it professes, afford the only plausible solution of the various problems of ontology, then it follows naturally and of necessity that matter is all-sufficient, and that man is an automaton without spirit or spontaneity. Then is our immortality a dream; volition, choice, and responsibility are mere delusions; virtue, vice, right, and wrong are sounds without possible meaning; and education, government, rewards, and punishments, are illogical and mischievous absurdities. Let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we shall be carbonic acid, water, and ammonia." We are thankful for the author's scientific refutation of such errors, and are yet more thankful that our own common sense upon these subjects still remains.
After Work. A Magazine for Home Reading. WILLIAM POOLE, 124, Paternoster Row.
A WELL-MEANING magazine, advocating temperance and virtue. It may be useful among working people, but it does not exhibit any very remarkable ability.
The Holy War by John Bunyan versified.
By E. J. James Nisbet and Co.,
Berners Street.
It has often occurred to us that Bunyan's "Holy War" has received far less attention than it deserves. In metaphysics it is not surpassed by other works upon mental philosophy; nor in experience by other writers upon experi-
mental Christianity. It might have even taken the place of "Pilgrim's Progress" if it had come out before it. Both allegories are powerfully descriptive of a type of true godliness from which, it is to be feared, the church is fast receding. This poetic version will serve, we hope, to direct fresh attention to the "Holy War."
