Menu
‹ Chapter 137 of 222 ›

Introduction to the Song of Songs — By Dr. Franz Delitzsch

9 min read · Chapter 137 of 222
Introduction to the Song of Songs — By Dr. Franz Delitzsch
Introduction to the Song of Songs — By Dr. Franz Delitzsch

THE SONG is the most obscure book of the Old Testament. Whatever principle of interpretation one may adopt, there always remains a number of inexplicable passages, and just such as, if we understood them, would help to solve the mystery. And yet the interpretation of the book presupposes from the beginning that the interpreter has mastered the idea of the whole. It has thus become an ungrateful task; for however successful the interpreter may be in the separate parts, yet he will be thanked for his work only when the conception as a whole which he has decided upon is approved of.

It is a love-poem. But why such a manne-song† in the canon? This question gave rise in the first century, in the Jewish schools, to doubts as to the canonicity of the book. Yet they firmly maintained it; for they presupposed that it was a spiritual, and not a secular love-poem. They interpreted it allegorically. The Targum paraphrases it as a picture of the history of Israel from the Exodus to the coming of the Messiah. The bride is the congregation of Israel; and her breasts, to quote an example, are interpreted of the Messiah in his lowliness and the Messiah in his glory. But "Solomon" is an anthropomorphic representation of Jehovah himself, and all the instances of the occurrence of the name, with one exception, are therefore regarded as an indirect allegorical designation of the God of peace. Because of its apparently erotic, but in truth mysterious, contents, it was a Jewish saying, as Origen and Jerome mention, that the Song should not be studied by anyone till he was thirty years of age. Because, according to the traditional Targum interpretation, it begins with the departure out of Egypt, it forms part of the liturgy for the eighth day of the Passover. The five Megilloths are arranged in the calendar according to their liturgical use.

In the church this synagogal allegorizing received a new turn. They saw represented in the Song the mutual love of Christ and his church, and it thus became a mine of sacred mysticism in which men have dug to the present day. Thus Origen explains it in twelve volumes. Bernhard of Clairvaux died (1153) after he had delivered eighty-six sermons on it, and had only reached the end of the second chapter, and his disciple Gilbert Porretanus carried forward the interpretation in forty-eight sermons only to verse ten, when he died. Perluigi de Palestrina gained by his twenty-nine motettoes on the Song (1584) the honoured name of Principe della Musica. In modern times this allegorico-mystical interpretation is represented in the department of exegesis (Hengstenberg), sermon (F. W. Krummacher), and poetry (Gustav Jahn) as well as of music (Neukomm's duet: Er und sie), and even of painting (Ludw. von Maydell).

If the Song is to be understood allegorically, then Shulamith is the personification of the congregation of Israel, and mediately of the church. All other interpretations fall below this. Hug (1813) under-

* See Reviews. We insert this, not because we quite agree with it, but because it is a far better theory than many others which have been advocated. That which is called "the seduction theory" is loathsome to us. † Love-song.

stands by the "beloved" the kingdom of the ten tribes longing after a reunion with the house of David; and Heinr. Aug. Hahn (1852) the Japhetic heathendom. Ludw. Noack (1869) has even changed and modified the readings of the Hebrew text, that he might find there the ballads of a Tirhāka romance, i.e., a series of pictures of the events occurring between Samaria and her Æthiopian lover Tirhāka, of the years (B.C.) 702, 691, and 690. These are the aberrations of individuals. Only one other interpretation recommends itself. Solomon's charisma and aim was the Chokma. The Peshito places over the Song the superscription חכמת חוכמת. Is Shulamith, then, the personification of wisdom, like Dante's Beatrice? Rosenmuller (1830) is the most recent representative of this view; and we ought, then, to have in Dante's Convulo the key to the allegorical interpretation. He there sings sweet songs of love of his mistress, Philosophy. But there is nothing in the description here to show that Shulamith is Wisdom. The one expression, "Thou shalt teach me" (viii. 2), warns us against attempting to put Wisdom in the place of the church, as a reversal of the facts of the case.

But if one understands the church to be meant, there yet remains much that is inexplicable. Who are the sixty queens and the eighty concubines (vi. 8)? And why are the heroes just sixty (iii. 7)? The synagogal and church interpretation, in spite of two thousand years' labour, has yet brought to light no sure results, but only numberless absurdities, especially where the Song describes the lovers according to their members from head to foot, and from foot to head. But notwithstanding all this, it is certain that the "great mystery" (Eph. v. 32) mirrors itself in the Song. In this respect it resembles the love of Joseph and Zuleikha, often sung by the Arabian poets, which is regarded by the mystics as a figure of the love of God toward the soul longing for union with him. Shulamith is a historic personage, not the daughter of Pharaoh, as has been often maintained since the days of Theodore of Mopsuestia (died 429) and Abulfaraj (died 1286), but a country maiden of humble rank, who, by her beauty and by the purity of her soul, filled Solomon with a love for her, which drew him away from the wantonness of polygamy, and made for him the primitive idea of marriage, as it is described in Gen. ii. 23, 25, a self-experienced reality. This experience he here sings, idealizing it after the manner of a poet; i.e., removing the husk of that which is accidental, he goes back to its kernel and its essential nature. We have before us six dramatic figures, each in two divisions, which represent from within the growth of this delightful relation to its conclusion. This sunny glimpse of paradisaical love which Solomon experienced again became darkened by the insatiableness of passion, but the Song of Songs has perpetuated it, and whilst all other songs of Solomon have disappeared, the providence of God has preserved this one, the crown of them all. It is a protest against polygamy, although only in the measure one might expect from the Mosaic standpoint. For the law recognizes, indeed, in its primitive history, monogamy as the original form (Matt. xix. 4-6); but in its legislation, giving up the attempt to abolish polygamy, it is satisfied with its limitation (Deut. xvii. 17).

The Song celebrates paradisaical, but yet only natural, love. It stands, however, in the canon of the church, because Solomon is a

361

type of him of whom it can be said, "a greater than Solomon is here" (Matt. xii. 12). Referred to him the antitype, the earthly contents receive a heavenly import and glorification. We see therein the mystery of the love of Christ and his church shadowed forth, not, however, allegorically, but typically. The allegory has to coincide throughout with that which is represented; but the type is always only a type subtractis subtrahendis, and is exceedingly surpassed by the antitype. In this sense Jul. Sturm (1854) has paraphrased the Song under the title of "Zwei Rosen" (Two Roses) (the typical and the antitypical). When my monograph on the Song appeared (1851), a notice of it in Colani's "Revue de Theologie" (1852) began with the frivolous remark, "Ce n'est pas la première rêverie de ce genre sur le livre en question; plus à Dieu que ce fût la dernière"; * and Hitzig (1855) judged that "such a work might properly have remained unprinted; it represents nothing but a perverse, inconsiderable literature, which has no conception of scientific judgment and industry." But this work (long since out of print and now rare) was the fruit of many years' study. The commentary here given is based upon it, but does not put it out of date. It broke with the allegorizing interpretation, the untenableness of which appears against his will in Hengstenberg's commentary (1853); it broke also with the theory which regards the poem as a history of Solomon's unsuccessful seductive efforts to gain the Shulamite's affections, a theory which Hitzig (1855) tries to exempt from the necessity of doing violence to the text by arbitrarily increasing the number of speakers and actors in the plot. I certainly succeeded in finding the right key to the interpretation of this work. Zockler has recognised my book as presenting "the only correct interpretation of its design and contents." Kingsbury, author of the notes on the Song in "The Speaker's Commentary," has expressed the same judgment. Poets such as Stadelmann (Das Hohelied, ein dramatisches Gedicht—The Song of Songs: a dramatic poem, 1770) and J. Koch, late pastor of St. Mary's in Parchim (died 1873), have recognised in their beautiful German paraphrases my interpretation as natural and in conformity with the text; and for twenty years I have constantly more and more seen that the solution suggested by me is the right and only satisfactory one.

Shulamith is not Pharaoh's daughter. The range of her thoughts is not that of a king's daughter, but of a rustic maiden. She is a stranger among the daughters of Jerusalem, not because she comes from a foreign land, but because she is from the country. She is dark-complexioned, not from the sun of her more southern home, but from the open sunshine to which she has been exposed as the keeper of a vineyard. In body and soul she is born to be a princess, but in reality she is but the daughter of a humble family in a remote part of Galilee. Hence the childlike simplicity and the rural character of her thoughts, her joy in the open fields, and her longing after the quiet life of her village home. Solomon appears here in loving fellowship with a woman such as he had not found among a thousand (Eccles. vii. 28); and although in social rank far beneath him, he raises her to an equality with himself. That which attached him to her is not her personal

* This is not the first idle fancy of the kind upon the book in question; God grant it may be the last.

beauty alone, but her beauty animated and heightened by nobility of soul. She is a pattern of simple devotedness, naive simplicity, unaffected modesty, moral purity, and frank prudence—a lily of the field, more beautifully adorned than he could claim to be in all his glory. We cannot understand the Song of Songs unless we perceive that it presents before us not only Shulamith's external attractions, but also all the virtues which make her the ideal of all that is gentlest and noblest in woman. Her words and her silence, her doing and suffering, her enjoyment and self-denial, her conduct as betrothed, as a bride, and as a wife; her behaviour towards her mother, her younger sister, and her brothers—all this gives the impression of a beautiful soul in a body formed, as it were, from the dust of flowers. Solomon raises this child to the rank of queen, and becomes beside this queen as a child. The simple one teaches the wise man simplicity; the humble draws the king down to her level; the pure accustoms the impetuous to self-restraint. Following her, he willingly exchanges the bustle and the outward splendour of court life for rural simplicity; wanders over mountain and meadow if he has only her; with her he is content to live in a lowly cottage. The erotic external side of the poem has thus an ethical background. We have here no "song of loves" (Ezek. xxxiii. 32) having reference to sensual gratification. The rabbinical proverb is right when it utters its threat against him who would treat this Song, or even a single verse of it, as a piece of secular literature. The Song transfigures natural but holy love. Whatever in the sphere of the divinely-ordered marriage relation makes love the happiest, firmest bond uniting two souls together, is presented to us here in living pictures. "The Song," says Herder, "is written as if in Paradise. Adam's song—Thou art my second self! thou art mine own!—echoes in it, in speech and interchanging song, from end to end." The place of the book in the canon does not need any further justification. That its reception was favoured also by the supposition that it represented the intercourse between Jehovah and the congregation of Israel may be conjectured indeed, but is not established. The supposition, however, would have been false; for the book is not an allegory, and Solomon is by no means an Allegoromenon of God. But the congregation is truly a bride (Jer. ii. 2; Isai. lxii. 5), and Solomon a type of the Prince of Peace (Isai. ix. 5; Luke xi. 31), and marriage a mystery—viz., as a pattern of the loving relation of God and his Christ to the church (Eph. v. 32). The Song has consequently not only a historico-ethical, but also a typico-mystical meaning. But one must be on his guard against introducing again the allegorical interpretation, as Soltz (1850) has done, under the misleading title of the typical interpretation. The typical interpretation proceeds on the idea that the type and the antitype do not exactly coincide; the mystical, that the heavenly stamps itself on the earthly, but is yet at the same time immeasurably different from it. Besides, the historico-ethical interpretation is to be regarded as the proper business of the interpreter. But because Solomon is a type (vaticinium reale) of the spiritual David in his glory, and earthly love a shadow of the heavenly, and the Song a part of sacred history and of canonical Scripture, we will not omit here and there to indicate that the love subsisting between Christ and his church shadows itself forth in it.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate