Menu
‹ Chapter 73 of 220 ›

Charles G. Finney, the American Evangelist

14 min read · Chapter 73 of 220

OF all the American revivalists, Mr. C. G. Finney is held by many to occupy the foremost place; and, as his labours are but little known to the present generation, the members of his family have been advised to give his life-story to the world. It does not appear that he intended his autobiography for publication during his lifetime, although it bears unmistakable evidence that he intended such to be its ultimate destination. As a general rule, an autobiography is a failure, for no man is competent to express a just estimate of his own life-work; either, on the one hand, vanity will tempt him to say too much, or, on the other, modesty will compel a reserve which leaves a part of the truth untold. If facts are modified by expansion, or toned by repression, an impartial verdict is impossible.

The demand for personal pronouns largely determines the character of a biography. In a single page of the work before us, taken at random, there are twenty-seven personal pronouns in thirty-six lines.

It must have been a task of some difficulty for the author, at the age of seventy-five, to write the story of his life, especially as he is stated not to have kept a diary. The memory does not always treasure a strictly accurate record of the past, and this accounts for some of the statistical errors which are apparent to the English reader; as, for instance, when he says the Old Tabernacle in Moorfields "would hold several hundreds more than the great Exeter Hall." It is natural for old men to think kindly of the past, and if they have been at all prominent, to appraise themselves at their fullest value. When we have listened to the stories of the bronzed old pensioners at Greenwich or Chelsea we might have concluded that the victories of Trafalgar and Waterloo mainly depended upon their individual heroism; but we knew a few other facts, and therefore did not accept all the history with which they would have endowed us. The same remark applies to Mr. Finney's narrative.

Without claiming for the book before us any great literary excellence, we think it worthy of perusal, but we hope our readers will discriminate between the accidents and the essentials of Mr. Finney's success. The methods of one man are not, necessarily, the models for another: we hope that in this case none will attempt to make them so.

Charles Finney was born at Warren, in Connecticut in the year 1792, and, when two years of age, he removed with his parents to Oneida County, New York, which was then little better than a wilderness. The following quotation describes the disadvantages under which he laboured as a child. "My parents," he says, "were neither of them professors of religion, and, I believe, among our neighbours there were very few religious people. I seldom heard a sermon, unless it was an occasional one from some travelling minister, or some miserable holding forth of an ignorant preacher who would sometimes be found in that country." No future application can wholly remedy the evil effects of the example of ignorant and ungodly parents on the sensitive nature of a child, and yet young Finney managed somehow or other to qualify himself for a

* London: Hodder and Stoughton, 27, Paternoster Row.

teacher by the time he was twenty years of age. He says, "I taught and studied as best I could, and twice returned to New England and attended a high school for a season." By the advice of his preceptor, he abandoned the intention of going to Yale College, and devoted himself to the study of Latin, Greek, and Hebrew. The difficulties which presented themselves not only tested his mettle, but fired his heroism, and great credit is due to him for his perseverance and the success which he achieved.

In 1818 he entered as a student in a law office at Adams, in New York county, a sphere in which any young man of ordinary ability would be sure to have his wits quickened and acquire a knowledge of men and manners which no other position in life could give. The time he spent in business was not lost, for no one can qualify himself for the delicate and difficult task of managing a church except by acquiring the wisdom which comes from experience. Too many young men enter the ministry altogether unfit to lead others, because they have never learned to rule by first learning to obey.

Mr. Finney gives a sad picture of the preaching to which he listened in New Jersey, but we suppose it would not have been difficult to find any number of parallel cases in our own English pulpits of that day. The sermons were soul-less essays, with nothing to arouse the conscience or instruct the anxious mind. We are not surprised, therefore, that he says of himself, "When I went to Adams to study law, I was almost as ignorant of religion as a heathen." His legal studies, in which reference was made to the Mosaic institutes, led him to purchase the first Bible he ever possessed, which he read with interest and profit. As the minister was in the habit of calling at the lawyer's office, he began to manifest an interest in the young student, and they frequently discussed the subject of the Sunday's sermons. Light now began to dawn upon young Finney's mind, and he became uneasy about his spiritual condition, which led him to attend the weekly prayer meeting. "When I was in one of the prayer meetings," he says, "I was asked if I did not desire that they should pray for me. I told them no, because I did not see that God answered their prayers. I said, I suppose I need to be prayed for, for I am conscious that I am a sinner, but I do not see that it will do any good for you to pray for me, for you are continually asking, but you do not receive. You have prayed enough since I have been at these meetings to have prayed the devil out of Adams, if there's any virtue in your prayers. But here you are praying on and complaining still." This severe criticism must have shocked the good people, and it was not altogether just: only a young enthusiast could imagine that the devil was to be disposed of in this way.

The anxiety he now felt betrayed itself in spite of the most laborious efforts to conceal it. When he retired to pray he stopped the keyhole of the door lest he should be overheard, and hid his Bible in the desk when any one entered his room. The story of his conversion is one of thrilling interest, how he was arrested in the street by an inward voice which pressed upon him the necessity for immediate decision; how he retired to a wood near the village to pray; how he resolved, "If ever I am converted I will preach the gospel;" how he at length made a full surrender of his will; and then how the baptism of the Spirit

215

succeeded. The rationalism of the present day may regard his experience as the illusion of an excited brain when under the influence of an absorbing passion, but we see no reason to discredit the essential truth of the narrative. He says, "The Holy Spirit descended upon me in a manner that seemed to go through me body and soul. I could feel the impression, like a wave of electricity, going through and through me. Indeed, it seemed to come in waves and waves of liquid love; for I could not express it in any other way." Conversion to Mr. Finney was something more than the adoption of an orthodox creed, or the resolution to be more strictly moral and religious; it was a new birth, a change so radical that he became "a new creature in Christ Jesus."

To many, his decision to abandon his vocation may appear too precipitous; but who is competent to determine the wisdom or folly of any course of action to which a man feels himself impelled by the resistless inspiration of the Spirit of God? He justified his refusal to contest a case for which he had been retained as attorney by the plea, "I have a retainer from the Lord Jesus Christ to plead his cause, and I cannot plead yours." He says, "I had the impression that God wanted me to preach the gospel, and that I must begin immediately."

The spirit of self-satisfaction with which he records his first triumphs is not altogether commendable. He came to the rescue of a shoemaker, who was being worsted in an argument with Universalists, and the vanquished sceptic went off to the woods and returned a bright convert. In being called upon to ask a blessing at the evening meal, in a friend's house, he burst into weeping, and a godless young man present "moved back from the table and fled to his room and locked himself in, and was not seen again till the next morning, when he came out expressing a blessed hope in Christ." When he made his first prayer in public, he says, "We had a wonderful meeting that evening, and from that day we had a meeting every evening for a long time. The work spread among all classes, and extended itself, not only through the village, but out of the village in every direction." He went on a visit to his parents, and they were both converted; and the lawyer, in whose office he was employed, was the next to yield. The rapidity with which these cases of conversion succeeded each other excites our wonder, and were we not assured of the omnipotence of divine grace, we should hesitate before accepting the record as a simple narrative of facts. As it is, we cannot dispossess our minds of the suspicion that a less sanguine man would have merely expressed a hope, where Mr. Finney makes an absolute assertion.

Elated by such immediate success, we are not surprised that Mr. Finney resolved not to enter either of the theological seminaries to study for the ministry, remarking, "Men cannot learn to preach by study without practice." Whatever may have been the practice in the American colleges at that time, it is now a general custom with all our colleges to encourage the students to preach during their academic career. The only exception to this rule is in the case of the students at our universities, who must be ordained before they are admitted to the pulpits of our national church.

Mr. Finney's methods of sermonizing are not to be regarded as a rule for others. He says, "For some twelve years of my earliest

ministry I wrote not a word, and was most commonly obliged to preach without any preparation whatever, except what I got in prayer. Oftentimes I went into the pulpit without knowing upon what text I should speak, or a word that I should say. I depended on the occasion and the Holy Spirit to suggest the text, and to open up the whole subject to my mind; and certainly in no part of my ministry have I preached with greater success or power. If I did not preach from inspiration, I don't know how I did preach. It was a common experience with me, and has been during all my ministerial life, that the subject would open up to my mind in a manner that was surprising to myself. It seemed that I could see with intuitive clearness just what I ought to say; and whole platoons of thoughts, words, and illustrations came to me as fast as I could deliver them." And then he adds, "Let no man think that these sermons which have been called so powerful were productions of my own brain, or of my own heart, unassisted by the Holy Ghost. They were not mine, but from the Holy Spirit in me." We have yet to learn that the promised aid of the Spirit justifies any minister's appearance before an audience, excepting under very special circumstances, without the most careful preparation. The man who claims absolute inspiration for every utterance absolves himself from the responsibility of any error into which he may unwittingly fall, and demands a divine sanction for any nonsense he may utter. We dare not limit the power and sovereignty of the Holy Spirit, as we feel we dare not prescribe the methods and the limits of his divine operation, but we confess to a feeling, induced by the language of Mr. Finney, almost amounting to conviction, that he must have been mistaken as to the degree in which he preached under the Spirit's influence. In recording the instances connected with one of the early revivals, we do not question the sincerity of his belief, although we feel at liberty to indulge a little silent scepticism. He says, "The Spirit of God came upon me with such power that it was like opening a battery upon them. For more than an hour, and perhaps for an hour and a half, the word of God came through me to them in a manner that I could see was carrying all before it. It was a fire and a hammer breaking the rock, and as the sword that was piercing to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit. I saw that a general conviction was spreading over the whole congregation. Many of them could not hold up their heads." We can scarcely see how Mr. Finney could make the following sentence dovetail into what we have quoted above: "In New England I have found a high degree of general education, but a timidity, a stiffness, a formality, and a stereotyped way of doing things, that has rendered it impossible for the Holy Spirit to work with freedom and power." It is surprising that one who claimed to be severely logical should invent such an hypothesis to account for his temporary non-success. A considerable tax is imposed upon the credulity of the reader when he is asked to believe that the proprieties of the New Englanders "rendered it impossible for the Holy Spirit to work with freedom and power."

On one occasion Mr. Finney said to his people, "The work of conversion is suspended, and we do not know that a conversion has occurred now for six weeks; and you know the reason." It appears that the Baptist minister wanted to baptize some of the converts whose

217

parents belonged to his church, but, as a Presbyterian, Mr. Finney opposed this; and extorted a promise that the question should be waived "until the revival was over." "The minister," he says, "sent off immediately, and secured the help of one of the most proselyting Baptist ministers that I ever knew. He came in and began to preach and lecture on baptism. They traversed the town for converts in every direction; and whenever they could find anyone to join they would get up a procession, and march and sing and make a great parade in going to the water and baptising them. This so grieved the Presbyterian church, as to destroy their spirit of prayer and faith, and the work came to a dead stand. For six weeks there was not a single conversion." Having summoned a meeting to which he stated his own views, he adds, "The question was intelligently settled, and soon the people ceased to talk about it. In the course of a few days the spirit of prayer returned, and the revival was revived and went on again with great power." We hesitate to accept this narrative as an indisputable record of facts, although we do not question the sincerity of the writer's belief. Revivals so easily checked must be poor things.

It would occupy too much of the space at our command to give an account of the various revivals which Mr. Finney claims to have been instrumental in promoting. Suffice it to say that, as a general rule, his arrival was always the signal for an extraordinary manifestation of the Spirit. Converts are reckoned by hundreds of thousands, but we fail to discover any record of their admission to the evangelical churches, and vague generalities must be taken for what they are worth. We set it down to an over-sanguine temperament that Mr. Finney reckons every trembling Felix as a true convert; perhaps, also, we may regard it as one of several methods by which he asserts his nationality.

In the year 1849 Mr. Finney visited England, at the request of Mr. Potto Brown, of Houghton. He visited several towns in England and Scotland, and records similar results to his labour as in America. We remember to have heard him on the occasion of his second visit in 1858, but at this date the impression is very indistinct. The text was, "His commandments are not grievous," and, as far as we remember, the great argument for inducing men to become Christians was the mildness of the Saviour's rule. This appears to have been a prominent feature in his ministry, and grew out of his views of the atonement. Again and again, in the course of his narrative, does he heap ridicule upon the doctrine of substitution, as taught by Calvinistic theology. Speaking of his intercourse with Mr. Gilbert, of Wilmington, he says, "I endeavoured to show that if man were helpless, as their views represented him to be, he was not to blame for his sins. If he had lost in Adam all power of obedience, so that obedience had become impossible to him, and that not by his own act or consent, but by the act of Adam, it was mere nonsense to say that he could be blamed for what he could not help. I had endeavoured also to show that, in that case, the atonement was no grace, but really a debt due to mankind on the part of God for having placed them in a condition so deplorable and so unfortunate." The doctrine of "imputation" he denounces as a "wonderful theological fiction." "Instead of telling sinners to use the means of grace and

pray for a new heart," he says, "we called on them to make themselves a new heart and a new spirit, and pressed the duty of instant surrender to God. We taught them that if they would at once yield to their own convictions of duty, they would be Christians." It would need a lengthy paper to combat the Pelagian heresy which is so conspicuous in these quotations, and we must content ourselves with proposing the following queries:—(1) If men are not involved in the consequences of Adam's sin, how can we account for the universality of human depravity? (2) Are the laws of a nation unjust because the children of a notorious offender suffer in consequence of his delinquency? (3) If men have not lost the necessary power to obey the commandments of a righteous God how can we account for the continuance of the race in disobedience when all sin entails suffering now and leads to remote consequences fearful beyond all conception? (4) If it be an act of divine grace to save those who are only responsible for their own acts of sin, and who have the power to obey when they so will, is it less an act of grace to save those who are more deeply involved, and whose inherited taint of nature has deprived them of the moral power to offer a perfect obedience to the will of God? (5) Is God unjust for permitting the propagation of the race because every one is "born in sin and shapen in iniquity"?

At the risk of being charged with blasphemy for daring to question the orthodoxy of a man who claimed divine inspiration for his views, fidelity to our convictions of what we believe the Bible teaches inspires the necessary courage, and we gravely question whether the supposed benefit of Mr. Finney's labours has not been greatly overestimated. Discount, very large discount, must be made, ere the truth is reached. Spots where great revivals are reported were, to our knowledge, full of witnesses to the evanescent character of a large proportion of the conversions. We do not believe that the grievous errors which marred his testimony could have led up to conversions of the right kind, though they were evidently adapted to produce presumptuous confidence, and transitory excitement. No doubt good was done by the portion of truth which survived the error, but when the fire has tried the Babel building, we fear the mass of it will go as mere wood, hay, and stubble.

We are not surprised that, holding the views he did, Mr. Finney should write his life story with so little reference to the person and work of the Lord Jesus Christ; and that love to a personal Saviour as the constraining motive of Christian obedience should be so conspicuous by its absence.

In common justice we feel bound to add, in conclusion, that the instances of conversion, with which the book abounds, are of the utmost interest, and that the perusal of the Life of Finney will afford instruction to those who are established in Christian experience, and who are fortified by a definite creed.

V. J. CHARLESWORTH.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate