Notices of Books
We do not often insert replies to our reviews, but the following is written in such a good spirit, and we have really trodden on the writer's toes so heavily, that we feel bound to insert it:—
("To the Editor of The Sword and the Trowel.)
"Feb. 15, 1876.
"Dear Sir,—I suppose that in free England everybody is at perfect liberty to call everybody else with whom he or she does not agree, 'a great stupid,' if only it be done in good humour. I do not wish to restrict that liberty in my own case, although the new designation is certainly a rather startling contrast by the side of the 'reverend' title we ministers have hitherto borne. Your good humour in the present instance I thoroughly appreciate; and you have so genially balanced matters by complimenting me on 'out and out church-mauship,' (for which I do not always get credit), 'and my equally thorough 'evangelicalism' (which is infinitely more important), that it would ill become me to utter any personal complaint. But as the question to which you refer was a matter of public discussion and interest, I think it would be only fair to insert in The Sword and the Trowel the following remark, made by the editor of The Christian World, at the time of our difference:—'It is a remarkable fact, that only two out of the extraordinary number of letters received are in vindication of Mr. Spurgeon's view of the subject.' It thus appears that 'the great stupids' were a rather numerous body.
"Allow me to add the assurance of my Catholic regard and esteem for one whom the Master has so highly honoured.
"I am, dear sir, yours faithfully,
"CHARLES BULLOCK."
[Our esteem for Mr. Bullock led us to review his books, and he is quite right in supposing that we called him "a great stupid" in perfect good humour. His good-natured letter leads us to withdraw the epithet, for he must be a sensible man to take it so pleasantly. After looking again into his arguments, we do not think one atom better of
them than we did when we called him "a great stupid," but we will alter the criticism, and suppose that we must be very stupid ourselves not to see the force of his reasoning. As to the fewness of those who were on our side, we have no doubt about that, but we do not count heads when we feel sure we are right.]
The Metropolitan Tabernacle and its Institutions. By C. H. SPURGEON. Price, in paper cover, 1s. Passmore and Alabaster.
HERE the reader will find a deeply interesting history of the church worshipping in the Tabernacle. It is full of illustrations, and costs only a shilling. Get a copy at once before the plates are worn. Bound in cloth the price is two shillings.
William Brock, D.D., First Pastor of Bloomsbury Chapel. By G. W. M'CREE. James Clarke and Co.
A good shilling's worth. Mr. M'Cree calls his memoir "a humble cairn," but we greatly question whether the stately monument, which we understand is in preparation, will one half so well commemorate William Brock. Mr. M'Cree's tribute is so full of hearty affection and intense admiration, that we have not the heart to indicate its weaknesses, and even if we had, they are not so serious as to prevent our heartily commending the effort, and recommending every lover of our noble old friend to read what his personal friend and helper has to say about him. We have been called to account for being one-sided and partial in our "Personal Recollections" of Dr. Brock, and certainly Mr. M'Cree is chargeable with the same crime; but he, no doubt, thought as we do, that it was for us to speak of him as we had found him, and leave others to do the same. No one said that Dr. Brock was perfect; but his frailties, whatever they may have been, were not such as abide upon our memory with sufficient vividness to be recorded; as for the good great man himself, we have him photographed on our heart, and the image is clearer every day.
The Religion of our Literature. Essays upon Thomas Carlyle, Robert Browning, Alfred Tennyson, &c., including Criticisms upon the Theology of George Eliot, George Macdonald, and Robertson of Brighton. By GEORGE M'CREE. Hodder and Stoughton.
EVEN those who are opposed to evangelical views will read these important essays with interest; while to those of us who are of the old Calvinistic school they will afford real pleasure, and at the same time arouse emotions of deep sadness. It was time that someone took in hand the mystic, pretentious scepticism of the period, a fashionable vanity whose day has been too long already. Our author appreciates poetry and deep thought, but he deprecates their alliance with error. Few could so well have distinguished between talent and its perversion, genius and its aberrations; for lack of this discernment, some in reprobating heresy have denied the ability of its defender, and, on the other hand, in admiration of originality, many have winked at the deadly error which it propagated. Our author admits the beauty of the cup, but all the more vehemently warns us against the poisonous draught which it conveys to us.
We agree with his preference of Longfellow to Tennyson, and, indeed, there are few things in his book which we could not heartily endorse. The Christain church is under great obligation to Mr. M'Cree for this work, though he will be well abused for it by the latitudinarian party.
Christ in the Tabernacle: with some Remarks on the Offerings. By FRANK H. WHITE. Third Edition. Partridge and Co.
SINCE the time when we praised our friend's writing, but smiled at his illustrations, each edition has improved, so that now this work is got up in a manner worthy of the author. It is really a very charming book in appearance, and it is full of gracious, edifying matter. Those who know our beloved Frank White will expect to meet with deeply spiritual and simply evangelical thought, and they will not be disappointed.
How to Answer Objections to Revealed Religion. By Miss E. J. WHATELEY. Religious Tract Society.
TOUCHES upon some difficulties which are often raised, and answers them exceedingly well. We did not know that there were two Miss Whateleys of literary note; we are led to hope that there may be more. They have admirably kept up the honour of the name.
Up to Fifteen. A Tale for Boys. By the Author of "Only Me: an Autobiography." Religious Tract Society.
WE read this tale when our head ached, and were much pleased with it. It will make a pretty present for a boy who is just beginning to earn his own living.
Angelic Beings: their Nature and Ministry. By the Rev. CHARLES D. BELL, Rector of Cheltenham. Religious Tract Society.
EXCEEDINGLY elementary. Instructive to children, but we trust that our readers are most of them so well acquainted with their Bibles that all which is here said about angels they already know. It is a fine theme, and Mr. Bell is a safe guide, but we confess we should have been glad of something beyond the commonest of commonplaces.
"To Whom Shall We Go?" A review of Dr. Pusey's sermon, entitled, "God and human Independence," preached before the University of Oxford, on Sexagesima Sunday, 1876. By JOHN PYER BARNETT, Minister of New Road Chapel, Oxford. Elliot Stock.
MR. BARNETT gives Dr. Pusey credit for the great ability and the strong religious tone which mark his discourse, and then proceeds in the best possible spirit to demolish his Babel tower of priesthood. The Oxford friends are happy in having a minister who can handle a matter wisely. The sermon is to be had for fourpence. As for Dr. Pusey, he remains to us one of the greatest of puzzles,—an eminently devout, humble, Christian man, supporting a claim to priesthood which is in itself unholy, arrogant, and antichristian! Lord, what is man!
185
The Gates of Praise, and other original Hymns, Poems, and Fragments of Verse. By Dr. MACDUFF. Nisbet and Co.
WE felt sure from his books, that Dr. Macduff was mildly poetical; but we had no idea that he would actually perpetrate verse. This is a weakness of many noble minds, and of a few ignoble ones also. Our soul is burdened with the poor try which is daily sent to us. We are therefore the more pleased when, amid the mountains of rubbish, we now and then find a jewel. When we light upon one good poem among ten thousand, we are charmed indeed; this has been the case while we have had "The Gates of Praise" before us. Dr. Macduff is a pleasing versifier, and though he is by no means a great poet, he puts the grandest of truths into striking words, and frequently lets fall an expression worthy to live, and to be quoted on all sides. We have selected a specimen of his poems; it is entitled—
SINS CAST INTO THE DEPTHS OF THE SEA.
DEEP sea! in whose unfathomed caves
Our sins are cast and found no more;
No tempest rage, no surging waves,
Can beat them back upon the shore.
Low in unsounded depths they lie,
Like Egypt's submerged chivalry.
Like the army and horse, the shield, bow and quiver,
That slumbered deep down on the coral-paved floor:
So our legion transgressions are buried for ever:
In judgment they rise to condemn us no more;
Buried for ever!
Evermore!
"Thou wilt cast all their sins in the depths of the sea":—
How gracious the tidings for you and for me!
Deep sea! the load from sight is lost;
But where the mighty burden fell,
Though many a gallant ship has crossed,
There is no milestone left to tell.
Unsounded caverns low and deep
For ever will the secret keep.
Oh yes! the great burden is sunk in no river,
Which the drought of the summer to sight might restore;
It is plunged in the ocean-depths,—buried for ever,
In judgment to rise and condemn us no more;
Buried for ever!
Evermore!
"Thou wilt cast all their sins in the depths of the sea":—
Thrice blessed the tidings for you and for me!
Heart Healing. By the Rev. W. BOYD CARPENTER, M.A., Holloway. Hatchards, Piccadilly.
WE have before introduced to our readers others of Mr. Carpenter's chaste and thoughtful little books, and we can say of this book, as of its predecessors, it is full of the quiet poetry of holy thought.
