Norman Macleod
WHEN a biographer has to deal with a vast mass of material, and is anxious to convey to the outside world his own impressions of his hero, he is in danger of defeating the object he has in view by attempting too much. Every literary scrap is deemed as sacred as the relics of a patron saint, and what to a multitude of readers must be regarded as the merest trifle is invested with an importance bearing no proportion to its intrinsic value. In this age of express trains and condensed telegraphy, when the daily news is summarised in a column, when scientific treatises are compressed into a single article, when sermons addressed to royalty are limited to sixteen minutes, and when the essence of literature is prepared like "Liebig's Extract," we question the wisdom of extending a biography into two octavo volumes of 800 pages. We should like to know how many subscribers to Mudie it will take to cut all the leaves, and the average number of pages they will each read. By those who can command the time, however, the life of Norman Macleod will be read with interest and profit. The author has, perhaps, done well to give the material from which future biographers will cull and condense when the time comes to present the
* Norman Macleod. London: Daldy, Isbister and Co., 56, Ludgate-hill.
life-story in a briefer form. He has certainly attempted no unimportant task in vindicating his brother's character against the attacks of those whose prejudices or principles he had assailed. Having provoked the rebukes of Sabbatarians, the abuse of Teetotallers, and the anathemas of the Evangelicals, Norman was not only regarded with suspicion and distrust, but was even hissed in the street. We are not sure of the success of his attempt to justify Norman's State-church prejudices, for which he contended as though they were the indisputable axioms of the New Testament. To espouse a theory of church government, which from its very nature, treats dissentients as schismatics, and, at the same time, to profess a catholicity which embraces the whole brotherhood of man, is an anomaly difficult to defend, if, indeed, it does not involve an inconsistency impossible to justify. When a man lays down the postulate that an Established Church is the necessary exponent of national religion, he is sure to be confronted with problems impossible of solution, or to arrive at conclusions which involve the most palpable absurdities. We honour the good doctor for singing—
"Trust no party, sect, or faction,
Trust no leaders in the fight,
But in every word and action,
Trust in God and do the right;"
but, when "right" is interpreted by a mind influenced with foregone conclusions, we must regard it as only another way of writing "policy." We would not pronounce a harsh censure on any man for defending the traditions in which he was cradled; but when he betrays a doubt which indicates that his inherited convictions are not in strict accordance with the sober judgment of his maturer years, we begrudge him even his claim to conservatism as a solace for his qualms of conscience. We feel bound to say this much; but, at the same time, we frankly admit that Norman Macleod was a man of sympathies as true as they were broad—that he was faithful to his convictions, though these were toned by the most transparent prejudices, and that he was honestly impelled, in all he undertook, by a laudable desire to benefit his fellow-men, and to add the music of his deeds to swell the harmonies by which the name of the Lord is glorified.
In giving the salient features in his life-story, we shall show that he was a good man—simple, trustful, devout, earnest—and that his character has won him a lasting monument.
He came of a hardy stock, and was born June 3, 1812, at Campbeltown, of which parish his father was minister. As a boy he was very talkative, and had a keen sense of the ludicrous. "Once, when he was unwell and about six years old, it became necessary to apply leeches. These he named after the various characters of the town—the sheriff, the provost, &c., &c.; and while they were on his chest, he kept up an unceasing dialogue with them, scolding one or praising the other, as each did its curative work well or ill, and all in the exact voice and manner of the various persons they were meant to represent." At the age of twelve he was sent to Morven, where his grandfather had ministered for many years, and was lodged with the village schoolmaster, that he might learn Gaelic, with the view of becoming a Highland minister.
177
"The long evenings in the snug cottage, when the spinning-wheel was humming, the women teasing and carding wool, the boys dressing flies for fishing, or shaping boats, were also enlivened by wondrous stories of old times. Norman had here an insight into the best side of the Highland character, and into many Highland customs now long passed away." In his charming reminiscences of a Highland parish, he recalled those happy days of boyhood, and urged an appeal to all who have to do with children,—"Make the days of boyhood happy; for other days of labour and sorrow must come, when the blessing of those dear eyes and clasping hands and sweet caressings will, next to the love of God, from whom they flow, save the man from losing faith in the human heart, help to deliver him from the curse of selfishness, and be an Eden in the memory when he is driven forth into the wilderness of life." The way in which tens of thousands of children are brought up is inexpressibly sad. No loving smile ever flings its light upon the dark clouds of their little world; no tender word breaks in upon the dull monotony of the harsh restraints by which they are held in check; no fond caress reveals to them the beating of a human heart. We have heard of a boy who, when a ray of sunlight fell across the dreary room in which his whole life had been lived, ran to get a hammer and a nail to secure the welcome visitor. Juvenile delinquency is a terrible fact of our modern civilization, but its development is not wholly due to human depravity; parental neglect must bear its share of the responsibility.
On his father's removal to Campsie, young Norman left the home of his Gaelic tutor and entered the parish school, where he enjoyed the advantages of the instruction of a competent scholar: afterwards he went to Glasgow, thence to Edinburgh. It was at Campsie he formed a friendship with old Bell, a kind of Gaelic Johnson, who talked freely upon subjects literary, political, and theological. This quaint old man "used to utter aloud in church his dissent to any doctrine he disliked, or sometimes his impatience expressed itself by his long black stick being twirled gradually up through his fingers till it reached well over his head. On one occasion, a young preacher having chosen as his text, 'There shall be no more sea,' proceeded to show the advantages of such a condition of things. Higher and higher rose Bell's stick as his favourite principles of geography were being assailed under every head, till, at last, it came down with a dash on the pavement, accompanied by a loud 'Bah! the fule!'" We sympathise with old Bell under the affliction of having to listen to an assault on some pet dogma from the pulpit, but we cannot justify the rudeness of his protestations.
Norman Macleod was a student at Edinburgh when Dr. Chalmers occupied the professor's chair, and they appear to have cherished feelings of admiration for each other, which were not destroyed when they afterwards took opposite sides in the Disruption Controversy. His studies were rather desultory than deep, and the diligent application of after years never remedied the defects in his college education. There is a touch of sadness in the following entry in his journal towards the close of his life: "Intellectually I am weak; in scholarship, nothing; in a thousand things, a baby. He knows this, and so he has led me and greatly blessed me, who am nobody, to be of some use to my church and fellow men. How kind, how good, how compassionate art thou, O
12
God!" This honest self-depreciation must not, however, be unduly pressed into an absolute verdict. Every great man is led to form an estimate of himself which no one else can endorse, while little men exaggerate their virtues only to have their veracity called into question by the sober judgment of others.
The death of his brother James, to whom he was passionately attached, marked the turning point in Norman's career, and "formed an epoch from which he ever afterwards dated the commencement of earnest Christian life." It is impossible to read the extracts from his journal, which relate to his experience, without a deep conviction that whatever else he was, there was no doubt about the reality of his Christian character. In 1834 he writes:—"Oh thou who hast brought me to this. Thou who didst make me what I am when I had no strength of my own, to thy loving and merciful hands I commend myself, wholly trusting that I may, through the aid of thy Holy Spirit, be every day more sanctified in my affections, and ever constant in the performance of my duty." Again: "By the grace of God, I have been enabled to wait upon him more than I was wont. It is an awful mistake to think that when we conquer a sin it is beaten for ever. It is indeed invincible—we can only keep it from conquering us, and so overcome it." At another time: "In the name of God the Father, Son, and Spirit, my God, I begin the year! I am thine by creation and redemption, and by choice on my part, I am thine for ever, and I desire to consecrate every power and faculty of body and soul to thy service, knowing thee, the ever blessed One, whose service is unutterable joy." On entering his 43rd year, he wrote: "O my God, I have not hidden my daily shortcomings from thee. Thou hast forgiven me in Christ. My Father, never let me be without the indwelling of thy Spirit for an hour, for it would be an hour of dreadful horror. Let my life be every day more unconscious of my own presence, and more conscious of thine. Make me an instrument in thy hands for advancing thy kingdom, reviving the church of Scotland, and for uniting all Christians in this land."
"The passages from his journals, referring to his spiritual life," says his biographer, "are thoroughly just representations of the self-scrutiny to which he subjected himself during his whole life. Those who knew him only in society, buoyant, and witty, overflowing with animal spirits, the very soul of laughter and enjoyment, may feel surprised at the almost morbid self-condemnation and excessive tenderness of conscience which these journals display; still more at the tone of sadness which so frequently pervades them." But we ask, why should they feel the least surprise? If his moods were as varied as the ocean, his peace of soul may have been as serene as its solemn depths, even in the wildest storm. Every human faculty is sanctified and ennobled by genuine piety, which demands that a man shall be true to himself in the varied spheres in which his lot may be cast. Christianity is not a synonym for asceticism. Norman Macleod could not restrain his humour in congenial society any more than the blackbird can withhold his song when the sun has kissed the spring flowers into beauty; on the other hand, he could not repress the grateful emotions of his soul when, in his hours of solitude, he traced the blessings and the hopes of his life to the loving heart of God.
179
After acting as tutor to the son of a Yorkshire gentleman, an appointment for which he was indebted to Dr. Chalmers, and enjoying the advantages of foreign travel, he was installed as the minister of the Scotch Church at Loudoun. His toryism provoked the opposition of the Chartists, and the prestige of patronage, by which he was inducted to the living, aroused the suspicions of the Covenanters. An old pauper woman, who was looked upon as a great light among the Covenanters, resolved to put him to a severe test before she would recognise his credentials. Putting her tin trumpet to her ear she said to him, "Gang over the fundamentals," and not until he had proved his orthodoxy to her satisfaction would she condescend to give him a welcome as an ambassador for Christ. The success of the early years of his ministry at Loudoun was disappointing, although he commanded large congregations, and was justly held in high esteem by his parishioners. His great heart yearned for the amelioration of the condition of the poor, and he perfected the usual parochial machinery, which he worked with great vigour. He seemed impatient, however, of the slow results of preaching, and cast about for expedients to gain the end desired. There was an evangelical ring in his sermons, but the influence of the broad church theology betrayed itself, and weakened his power as a soul winner.
The moral culture of the unregenerate is good so far as it goes, but casuistry is a sorry substitute for conversion. Human virtues, in their highest possible development, are like the drapery of a marble statue—they lend the semblance of life to the reality of death. When Christianity is reduced to a code of morals its chief glory is eclipsed, and "the cross of Christ is made of none effect." To urge the doctrine of the universal Fatherhood of God is to ignore the universal experience of men, and to discredit the inspired testimony that we are "by nature the children of wrath," because we are "the children of disobedience," and "the children of the wicked one." When the Saviour urged the necessity of the new birth, he laid down the primal law of the new creation, and any theory which suggests an interpretation to weaken its force, or restrict its application, must be dismissed as another gospel which will prove, in the end, a delusion and a snare. Neither mental discipline nor moral culture can induce the filial spirit by which we utter the responsive "Abba Father," and "If any man have not the Spirit of Christ he is none of his." We confess to a conscious thrill of horror when we contemplate vast masses of men to whom the Lord Jesus is only an historical personage, and the Bible a specimen of ancient literature, but we dare not indulge "a larger hope" respecting their destiny than the word of God warrants. An ambassador for Christ must be guided by the express terms of his commission, and, when confronted with problems difficult of solution, he can always fall back upon the axiomatic question, "Shall not the Judge of all the earth do right?"
In 1843 Norman Macleod was transferred to Dalkeith, where he soon established several preaching stations that he might reach the lowest classes of the community. His devotion to his work was most commendable. In a letter to his mother he says:—"After working very hard during the week, I rose to-day at half-past six, studied till nine, taught my school till eleven, preached forenoon and afternoon long
sermons, had baptisms, slept an hour, preached for an hour to fifty outcasts in the Wynd, was my own preecutor and clerk, and hero I am as fresh as a lark—a pulse going like a chronometer, and a head calm, and clear, and cool as a mountain spring." He was greatly interested in the subject of missions, and assisted in the formation of thirty Missionary Associations for the support of Female Education in India. He went as a deputation to British North America, and afterwards to India; his impressions of these countries were given in the pages of Good Words. Having grown weary of ecclesiastical strife, into which he was drawn with some reluctance, he entered heartily into the movement for forming "The Evangelical Alliance," which was designed to promote Christian union, and to afford opportunities for fraternal intercourse, but, like many good men, he was ultimately compelled to sever his connection, when fellowship was only to be purchased by the suppression or surrender of convictions.
In writing to his brother, on the choice of a profession, he expressed his own exalted view of the Christian ministry, and, as these pages may be read by young men whose future is not yet definitely shaped to their mind, we give the following passage:—
"I would not exchange my profession for any on earth. All I have seen in courts and camps, at home and abroad, in Europe and America, all, all makes me cling to it and love it the more. My love to it is daily increasing. I bless and praise God that he has called me to it. Would only I were worthier of the glory and dignity which belong to it! I find in it work most congenial to my whole being. It at once nourishes and gives full scope to my spirit. It affords hourly opportunities for the gratification of my keenest sympathies and warmest affections. It engages my intellect with the loftiest investigations which can demand its exercise. It presents a field for constant activity in circumstances which are ever varying, yet always interesting, and never too burdensome to be borne. It enables me to bring to bear all I know, all I acquire, all I love, upon the temporal and eternal well-being of my fellow-men, and to influence their peace and good for over. Kings and princes may veil their faces before such a profession!"
His position as minister of the Barony Church, Glasgow, brought him into the prominence for which his natural abilities and experience had fitted him. His vigorous preaching attracted large congregations, and he set himself to organise methods of usefulness, in which he enlisted his communicants. He hit upon the novel plan of gathering none but working people on Sunday evenings in their every-day clothes to hear the gospel, and so popular were these services that his elders had to guard the doors, in order to keep out all persons who could boast a Sunday suit. As moderator of the General Assembly, and as a representative of the Scotch Church in a deputation to India to confer with the missionaries, he may be said to have reached the highest points of honour in the church to which he belonged.
It was as editor of Good Words, however, that he achieved his greatest popularity. His professed aim in this venture was usefulness, and his contributors numbered some of the ablest representatives of every class of literature. To keep up the freshness of novelty, and to admit nothing antagonistic to the truths and spirit of Christianity, and to
181
avoid offending the prejudices of all sections of the church, was a task demanding the exercise of extraordinary powers and discretion. The magazine attained an unprecedented circulation, and he may be said to have inaugurated a new era in periodical literature, but we question whether he derived, in the retrospect, as much real satisfaction from his editorial labours as he must have done from his mission work among the Glasgow wynds. The extraneous work with which he burdened himself, though honestly undertaken for the good of his fellow-men, may really be found to have restricted his usefulness. Power for good lies rather in concentration than diffusion, and when we consider his sincere and ardent piety, the versatility of his genius, his broad human sympathies, and his grand physical powers, we confess to a feeling of regret that his energies were not wholly given to the work of the Christian ministry. His attempts to raise the morals of the people by the lever of popular literature, and his efforts to build up an established church as the bulwark of Protestantism and the exponent of national religion, must be regarded as the visionary schemes of an honest, though misguided enthusiast.
Norman Macleod was a great favourite with all the members of the Royal family, and, with very considerable delicacy, the author has given a few glimpses of the private life of the Queen. He appears to have discharged his duties as chaplain without any sacrifice of fidelity or compromise of conscience. "I saw the Queen on Sunday night," he writes, "and had a long and very confidential talk with her. I feel she wishes me to utter, as I do, anything which in my soul I feel to be true and according to God's will. She has a reasoning, searching mind, anxious to get at the root and the reality of things, and abhors all shams, whether in word or deed." To one of the young princes he said, "It is only as a pastor that I am permitted to address you. But as I wish you to thank me when we meet before God, so would I address you now." On hearing of his death the Queen wrote a letter to the bereaved family in which the following sentence occurs:—"To herself personally, the loss of dear Dr. Macleod is a very great one; he was so kind, and on all occasions showed her such warm sympathy, and in the early days of her sorrow gave the Queen so much comfort whenever she saw him that she always looked forward eagerly to those occasions when she saw him here." There is no affectation either on one side or the other. Norman Macleod saw in Her Majesty a good and true woman, and Her Majesty recognised in her Highland chaplain a good and true man.
His daughter was one of the last to see him, and she thus writes of the interview:—"He took my hands in both of his and said, 'I am an old man, and have passed through many experiences, but now all is perfect peace and perfect calm. I have glimpses of heaven that no tongue, or pen, or words can describe.'" And so the good man passed away to the eternal home of the redeemed, where service is not embittered by the strifes of party factions, and where all worship, freed from the legislative restraints imposed by ecclesiastical or parliamentary councils, is the perfect expression of pure gratitude, and "God is all in all."
V. J. C.
