Menu
‹ Chapter 6 of 220 ›

The New Reformation, or the Old Catholics — By Pastor W. P. Cope, Of Maze Pond Chapel

16 min read · Chapter 6 of 220

UNDER our first title the writer of a recent volume invites attention to an important religious movement on the Continent. The originators of it call themselves "The Old Catholics." They complain, and not without some show of reason, that the origin and aim of their movement have been but little understood by the great bulk of evangelical Christians in this country; and that Nonconformists have shown the least appreciation of its significance, and the least sympathy with its struggles. The charge is not to be denied, but extenuating circumstances may be pleaded. When the movement commenced the end proposed was not so clearly defined as now; at that time, too, public attention was largely absorbed by the Franco-Prussian war; and more lately, the loudly professed friendship with the "Old Catholics" shown by some of the foremost men of the sacerdotal section of the Established Church at home has tended to beget the suspicion, rather than the confidence, of those identified with the free churches of England. If we have looked upon the struggles of the early leaders with seeming indifference, it has not been from want of charity, so much as lack of knowledge. The complicated conditions of church life upon the Continent are hardly understood by us at home. Many of the lesser questions perplexing continental nations we fought our way through two centuries ago. As long as men were simply paddling upon the sands that border the sea of religious liberty, it was not to be expected that their movements could attract much attention: when the swimmers lay aside their garments, and boldly plunge into the surf that interposes between the shore and the broad calm waters beyond, shining like a "sea of glass mingled with fire," we watch their movements with fixed attention, and follow their efforts with a hearty "God speed." Any attempt to throw off the shackles imposed by the Romish church cannot fail to secure the approval and admiration of all who deem the principles embodied in Protestantism the spiritual and logical outcome of Christianity. There may be a more excellent way of gaining this freedom than the "Old Catholics" have adopted; there may be a more perfect freedom to be attained than seems to have satisfied them at the first; but we who have been born free cannot withhold our hearty sympathy from those who are purchasing this inestimable privilege at a great price. In some instances the price paid has been social as well as ecclesiastical excommunication.

The old Reformation may be said to date from October 31, 1517. The new Reformation may be dated from July 18, 1870. On the earlier of these dates Martin Luther nailed his famous Theses against "Indulgences" upon the doors of the church at Wittenburg. He had no

11

thought of fighting against Pope or church. He simply stood up for what he deemed to be the interests of truth. But God was meanwhile preparing him for the successful accomplishment of a work from which the boldest heart might have shrunk. On the later of these dates the Pope—Pius IX.—proclaimed the dogma of Papal Infallibility as a doctrine of the Papal Church. It was a notable day. It awoke dull and gloomy. Before the day closed a terrible storm broke over Rome. Amid lightning and thunder, and by the feeble light of flickering tapers, the Pope read aloud the decree of his own infallibility. The faithful saw in these things a good omen: the storm reminded them of the divine sanction amid which Moses received the law on Mount Sinai. The faithless read in these signs a very different meaning. The political atmosphere seemed to be equally overcharged with electricity, for on that same day war between France and Prussia was declared. This was more than a coincidence; Jesuit influences had long predominated at the Vatican and the Tuileries.

The declaration of Papal Infallibility as a dogma of the Popish Church was the crowning work of Jesuit intrigue. "Ultramontane" is the term now in more popular use. With this end in view, that powerful faction of the church had steadily laboured for many years, and in its attainment there can be no doubt that the Pope himself has been but a tool in Jesuit hands. For this end, though under the disguise of other objects, an Ecumenical Council, as it was called, was summoned, to meet in Rome on the day of the Immaculate Conception, December 8th, 1869.

It would take more space than the limits of this article allow to trace the events by which such a dogma became a possibility. This much must be understood by all who would appreciate the position of the "Old Catholics." The Romish church, from the first, has been divided between two distinct and opposite theories of the authority and prerogative of its Pope. One theory may be called the papal theory; the other the episcopal theory. The former claims for the Pope complete submission as God's vice-regent upon earth. It holds him responsible to God alone for the exercise of his supreme power; and regards him as possessed of attributes, differing both in degree and kind from those conferred upon any other person upon earth. He is the sole depository and channel of the unerring judgment supposed to be promised to the church in all ages. It will be easy to see how a bold and ambitious party in the church could use these principles as a scaffolding, by the aid of which the imposing fabric of papal infallibility could be raised. The episcopal theory opposes the papal system as involving a spiritual despotism of the most tyrannical kind. It regards the Pope as executive head only of the church. He has no legislative power: his primacy is acknowledged, simply, as the personal representative of the church's collective authority, and the organ of her utterance. The two theories are consistent with a belief in infallibility, but each with very different circumstances. The papal system assumes that Peter's chair confers infallibility upon its occupant. He may have gained the post by poisoning his predecessor, as did John XXIII., at one time a pirate; and even after he was made pope the employer of brigands. Or he may have secured it by diplomacy, as did Pius II.; or have been thrust into it

by imperial power, as was Leo IX. He may have been as vicious as Benedict IX., who was elevated to the papacy when a mere boy twelve years old. Or like Urban VI. and Clement VII., rival occupiers of the papal throne, elected by rival factions, more busy in anathema-tising each other than in correcting errors in the doctrines or immorali-ties in the practice of the clergy. On the other hand, the episcopal system claims infallibility for the church, but denies it to its head. It is asserted that it resides in "her collective and unanimous voice," and that "the guardianship of the Christian faith from the influences of corrupt teaching, is the function, not of an individual, but of a council, which should represent the wisdom of an undivided Christendom." These two theories are naturally antagonistic. It has ever been the aim of ultramontanism to crush the liberal spirit struggling for power among the adherents of the episcopal theory. Step by step it has gained the citadel; when strong enough it has threatened its opponents; when too weak to threaten it has sought to bribe them; when it could do neither it has boldly excommunicated the sturdy protestors against papal ascendancy. Rather than yield the slightest of her prerogatives Rome will rule over a narrower domain.

This contest for the supremacy—for that is the practical meaning of the word infallibility—between the church and the Pope has been carried on for over eight centuries; ever since the time when the Eastern church separated from the Western, as the only way of pro-testing against Romish ascendancy. The favourable hour at length arrived for striking the last blow. With Jesuitical skill the Vatican nursed the elements of quarrel between Germany and France, doubt-less hoping by political disturbance to divert attention from the true nature of the blow Rome was about to strike at the personal liberty of her children. There was, probably, too, the ultimate hope that France would triumph, and be prepared to further the papal in-terests. There was one person in the Emperor's court always to be relied on as an ally of the Vatican. The devotion of imperial advisers sometimes failed the church; the Emperor himself could not always resist political considerations in ecclesiastical questions; the Empress never wavered in her obedience to papal dictates. If she ruled the fashions for the women of the world, she was herself ruled by the "woman clothed in scarlet." Her devotion cost her husband a throne, and her son an imperial heritage, such as few children are born to in this world. Had France triumphed it would have placed the liberal Catholics in a helpless, if not a hopeless position. With that prospect before him it seemed a most appropriate time for the Pope to summon the Council.

The council that declared the Pope infallible was not summoned avowedly for this purpose. Such an open declaration of war against civil and religious liberty would have aroused the indignation of Rome's long-suffering, overburdened children everywhere. Suspicions were entertained, and even uttered, that some such object was in view, but not until the members of the council had assembled did its real aim transpire. Its announcement caused great consternation, it was like asking a monarch to sign his abdication. The history of general councils had been one protest against the domination of the Pope: this one was invited to reverse the solemn and oft-repeated decision of

13

the past fourteen or fifteen centuries. It was foreseen "that once fixed as an article of faith, infallibility would become a principle of unlimited significance whether viewed retrospectively or prospectively. It would become a principle embracing all individual and social life, for there would then no longer be any question of the Pope going beyond his proper sphere. Infallibility must define its own limits." The struggle of many of the prelates against the galling yoke of bondage they were invited to put on their own necks; the manœuvres and methods of the Ultramontanist party; the illness of many of the antagonistic prelates, chiefly foreigners, through their enforced residence in Rome during the unhealthy season, which the Italian prelates, more than one-third in number of the whole assembly, were well able to stand; and the uproarious scenes in the course of the discussions, when the ablest speakers of the opposition were hooted down—it is reported that a bishop of the United States said afterwards, with a pardonable sense of patriotic pride, that he now knew of one assembly still rougher than the congress of his own country:—these are matters belonging to the history of the Council. Its history must be studied by all who would understand the secret of papal rule: a popular account of it has yet to be written.

The voting upon the question disappointed the expectations of the Ultramontanists. Eighty-eight voted against the dogma. Sixty-one gave a conditional vote in favour of it. Ninety-one abstained from voting. Four hundred voted in favour of the doctrine. This powerful minority, when scattered each to his own sphere, and subject to the influences the Vatican so well knows how to use, dwindled down to nothing. Some of the bishops who had been most distinguished by the bold stand they had taken in Rome, showed a most abject submission, and even exhibited an uncalled-for severity in dealing with such of their clergy as felt the same difficulty themselves had experienced in accepting the new doctrine. Thus the year 1870 witnessed the consummation of a work which had taken nearly a thousand years to accomplish. The last rivet was driven into the shackles that hitherto had galled, but were now to bind in helpless bondage, civil, intellectual, moral, and spiritual, every adherent of the Romish church. The paragraph which defines the Pope's infallibility closes with an anathema upon any who shall presume to contradict it.

Such a decree, as will be seen, struck a fatal blow at the episcopal theory, and reduced the bishops to a state of abject submission to the Pope. They remain, but only as "papal commissaries, possessed of so much power as the Pope finds good to leave them, and exercising only such authority as he does not directly exercise himself." It constituted, in fact, a new foundation for the church. A protest was soon raised against this overbearing policy: fourteen Roman Catholic professors at Nuremberg rejected alike the authority and the decree of the council. Three of them were at once suspended by the bishop of the diocese for the publication of their protest. The key-note of the movement was struck at Munich, in a manifesto which excited great public attention: in it the protestors affirm, "We do not accept the decrees illegally established at Rome on July 18th; we remain true to our ancient Catholic faith, in which our fathers lived and died, and shall therefore

offer an active and passive resistance to every attempt to force on us a new doctrine, or to drive us out of the church." This was the beginning of the movement. Like the great Lutheran Reformation three-and-a-half centuries before, it began with a protest. For some months the only attitude assumed by the Old Catholic party was that of earnest and dignified protest. Attention was still further drawn to the movement by a very spirited appeal addressed to the French Catholic bishops, who had betrayed the cause they had originally espoused, by Father Hyacinthe, in France; and in Switzerland by the spirited refusal of Egli, of Lucerne, to read the dogma when required by his bishop. Although at a later date he withdrew from active co-operation with the Old Catholic movement, Father Hyacinthe rendered it very efficient service in its early stages. It is said that in personal appearance, as well as in the character of his genius, he resembles Mr. Spurgeon. When taunted that he had left the church of his fathers, he replied, "that he still belonged to the church of his baptism—a church greater than those who govern it, greater than those who defend it." At the head of the movement stands pre-eminently Dr. Dollinger, Professor of Theology at Munich. Born in the year 1799, he was over seventy, an age at which most men like to retire from active service, when he threw down the gauntlet of defiance at the "infallible" Pope. At all times a diligent student, his published works have given him a world-wide reputation among ecclesiastical readers. For some years he represented the University in the Bavarian Chamber, and was regarded as a leader of the Ultramontane party. Without swerving from the fidelity his religious convictions required, he was disheartened and disgusted by the unscrupulous efforts of that party, to bring into subjection to the papal control every department of human study. He accordingly became identified with the liberal Catholics. True to his early ideal of a united Christendom, and perceiving the dangers that threatened the temporal power of the Pope, so late as 1861 his "Church and the Churches" was published, in advocacy of these two principles. With all his devotion to the Romish church, he was too true a man to become a party to the conspiracy for subordinating human freedom to the dictates of the occupant of St. Peter's chair. At one time the hope of the Ultramontanists, he became by a series of steps, perfectly consistent with all we know of him before, their most determined foe. Foremost of the theological faculty summoned by the archbishop soon after his return from the council, he was the first to demur to the demand for unhesitating submission. "Roma locuta est," said the archbishop, and, turning to Dollinger, asked, "Ought we not to be ready to begin to labour afresh in the cause of the Holy Church?" "Yes," was the reply, in his peculiarly decisive manner, "for the Old Church." That answer contains the germ of the whole movement.

Further action was precipitated by the Archbishop demanding by a certain date the formal submission of Dollinger and his colleagues to the Vatican decree, under the penalty of ecclesiastical punishment. In March, 1871, his reply was published. Appealing to Scripture and history, he declared "as a Christian, a theologian, an historical student, and a citizen, I cannot receive the doctrine." So spirited an utterance stirred popular enthusiasm. The archbishop delayed to put in force the

15

punishment he had threatened. It was only delayed. Under papal pressure the mandate was at length issued, and Dr. Döllinger and his colleague, Professor Friedrich, were declared excommunicated; the sentence being read from every pulpit in the city.

We have not space to trace the growth of the movement; how other men followed the example so worthily set; how a petition signed by twelve thousand Catholics, pointing out the political bearing of the dogma, was presented to the king; how Pope Pius went out of his way to denounce the leaders of the movement as men more to be dreaded than the Communists, "those fiends let loose from hell"; how some who had signed an address of sympathy to the excommunicated professors were denied the rites always administered by the church to the dying, unless they first retracted the opinions such a signature seemed to imply. Rome lacked not the will but the power to persecute.

Towards the close of September attempts were made to organise and consolidate the movement. A congress, attended by five hundred delegates from almost every European country, assembled at Munich. A scheme was drawn up to provide, as far as possible, for the pressing wants of those who were denied the rites of the church, and for the guidance of others anxious to form Old Catholic congregations. Resolutions were also passed indicating the theological views of the community. It is not to be supposed that we, with deep seated and historic objection to an episcopal hierarchy, should sympathise very warmly with their declarations on this point. But we cannot withhold our admiration for their spirited appeal to Scripture, and their readiness to allow the laity a share in church polity. Before the year closed, twenty-three "Vereins" or congregations were in existence, notwithstanding the irritation and opposition of the Ultramontanists.

We pass over the political bearings of the movement, and the sympathy it at length gained both from the Bavarian and Prussian governments, and the aggressive efforts made through the agency of Reinkens, formerly a professor of church history at Breslau. The point to be noted is that every step taken in the direction of organisation was a step further in distance from Rome. The pressure of circumstances admitted of no delay: they must organise or submit to defeat. Hence, at the congress held at Cologne, 1872, it was resolved to give further extension to the "resolutions passed at Munich, by authorising the establishment of parochial cures, and all the necessary arrangements for separate services and sacramental ordinances." One difficulty had been but partially solved. As long as that difficulty remained the whole movement was open to the charge of imperfect ecclesiastical organisation. No bishop had, as yet, identified himself with the Old Catholics. Without a bishop the children could not be confirmed, nor the clergy lawfully consecrated. We may smile at the gravity of the position: to them it was a grave question. Nursed as they had been in the very bosom of Episcopacy; separated from an ancient church by their preference for the episcopal over the papal theory, the want of a bishop would assume an importance we are not able to understand. They could not always be dependent upon the archbishop of Utrecht, as in the previous year, for the work of confirmation. The change in the political atmosphere made it desirable that the infant community should

have some recognised head. The papal encyclical of December, 1872, and the passing of the Falk laws in Prussia, seemed like so much outward pressure, tending to the decision already foreshadowed in the appointment of a committee, composed of clerics and lay, empowered to take measures for the election of a bishop. The choice fell upon Reinkens. If not unanimous it was nearly so. Before accepting the office he made it a condition that the vow should be one of love and reverence, not that of obedience, which Rome has forged into so crushing an instrument of tyranny: The bishop, on his part, bound himself by a like vow to his flock. These are new features in Episcopacy. Protestants cannot rail against Romanists in the matter of bishops: in both cases they are forced upon the community by political or ecclesiastical considerations. Here is a return to primitive times. The staunchest Nonconformist could hardly object to a bishop when elected by the almost unanimous choice of laymen and clergy. This was the remarkable position Reinkens was called to fill.

It is computed that, up to this time, the adherents of the movement number in Germany 50,000. The numbers, probably, would have been much greater but for the difficulty of finding a sufficient number of well educated priests, for such their ministers are still called. Switzerland shows a much larger number. There its success has been so marked as to draw from the Pope a most serious warning against them in his encyclical of March, 1875. He denounces them as "a deplorable sect," which "draws from the arsenal of old heresies so many errors about the leading principles of the Catholic faith." The faithful are exhorted to avoid their writings and all contact with them. "Let them have no relation whatever with the apostate priests, who have been thrust among them, and who dare to exercise the functions of the ecclesiastical ministry, but who are absolutely destitute of all consideration and of all legitimate missionary authority; let them hold them in abhorrence as strangers from without, and as robbers who come in only to plunder, destroy, and murder."

We have endeavoured to sketch the rise and progress of this remarkable movement. Our space will admit of no more. Already some of the corrupt practices and doctrines with which they started have been corrected. Some of the gross superstitions of Rome have been abandoned. It is true much more remains to be done. Surely we may augur the best from men who have done so well. Even the blind man when touched by Christ's own hand did not all at once see clearly; it needed another touch from the divine hand and a stedfast gaze before he could distinguish between men and trees. Brought up in the purblind state of popery, we cannot expect these people all at once to see things in the same clear light in which we have been looking at them for several centuries. If the ideal of a united Christendom, the pet hobby of Dr. Döllinger, do not tempt them from the stern, hard path of church reformation and church reorganisation, we shall see still greater things. It would be easy to criticise some of the blemishes and weaknesses of the movement. Time and the hard discipline of facts will be the better remedy. With all sympathy, and a hearty God-speed, we urge the leaders not to rest, as though they "had already attained, either were already perfect," but to press forward.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate