Notices of Books
Sacramental Confession. By Dean Howson. W. Isbister and Co., 56, Ludgate Hill.
This is a calm and conscientious protest against the introduction of the confessional into the Church of England. It endeavours to vindicate the practice, so far as it is sanctioned by the Book of Common Prayer, and reduces it, therefore, to a question, not of principle, but of degree. Officially, confession has no place in the Christianity of the New Testament. It is a thing not to be pruned, but uprooted. It is one of the strongholds of Popery against which the universal cry should be, "Raze it, raze it even to the foundations thereof." We have only to dig through the wall to see the abominations that are concealed under this sacred name. The Dean occupies no enviable position, for while alarmed at the use that has been
made, and may yet be made, of such a pious fraud, he is compelled in some degree to vindicate it.
Sonnets of the Sacred Year. By the Rev. S. J. Stone, M.A. Religious Tract Society.
Thirty pages of disquisition by way of introduction on what a sonnet is and may be. This is the best part of the book to our mind. After "Keble's Christian Year" he must be a bold man who tries to follow in his track. The author confines himself to one metre of fourteen lines, but does not, we think, escape comparison by so doing, and certainly hampers himself not a little. We fear we are not enough initiated into the mysteries of a ritual to appreciate as we ought to do the adaptation of a sonnet to Quinquagesima Sunday or Maundy Thursday. Perhaps Mr. Disraeli could do so.
41
Alone with God; or, Life Lessons Learned in Solitude. By A. S. ORMSBY. Yapp and Hawkins.
EXCEEDINGLY good and spiritual, and both in doctrine and tone most praiseworthy, but somehow or other we cannot keep awake while reading it. There is a pleasant smoothness in it like the flow of oil, and a prettiness of diction like the tinkling of distant sheep bells, or the cooing of doves, and we feel a vapour from the land of Nod stealing over us or ever we are aware. The author belongs to a class of writers who are so good as to be at the same time faultless and powerless, they never say anything amiss nor anything striking, they do not arouse your criticism, because they say nothing but what every good man knows and believes. This volume is one against which nothing could be said, except that after reading fifty such, very few of us would have had a single fresh thought suggested to us, unless it came to us in a dream, occasioned by the sweet and soothing melodies of such literature.
Health and Home. By a Quiet Woman. James Clarke and Co.
OUR admiration for all quiet women is unbounded. We know a whole circle of them who deserve that description, and are models of all the virtues in consequence. If we are not mistaken, we also know one or two of the female persuasion who will never deserve that title till they are dead. "The Quiet Woman" who produced this eighteen-penny book is a very good writer when she lets religion alone. On girl's allowances, window gardening, maids, and meats, she is fully up to the mark, but upon theology she had better be quiet. Why her peculiar views upon future punishment needed to be introduced among her cookery and dress-making perhaps she knows, but we do not. We shall have heresy next in crotchet patterns, and false doctrine in our mince pies. Nobody, of course, will take any notice of the dear soul, any more than they would pay attention to our editorial selves if we went off just now into a dissertation upon hasty pudding, or an exposition of the ingredients of boiled custard; but still it is noteworthy that believers in certain
theories must bring them to the front, whether the opportunity is fitting or no, and therefore it is well to be ready with the antidote at all times. We have seen it announced that a certain minister had gone over to annihilationist views, and upon inquiry we have received a plain denial, with the remark that the cause is so weak that its advocates are glad to enrol a recruit, even if half a word is said. They count other people's chickens among their fowls. However, on almost all subjects but theology we agree with this "Quiet Woman," and especially upon the matter of fresh air in places of worship. She must be a person of sound sense, considerable reading, and keen observation. Her book, all exceptions being allowed for, is likely to be of much practical service. We subjoin a part of her chapter on "a religious grievance," which we commend to the immediate attention of all sextons, churchwardens, managers, deacons, trustees, chapelkeepers, elders, preachers, pastors, pew-openers, hearers, nodders, sleepers, etc., etc.
"There is one form of suffering, and that, too, connected with the exercise of their religion, to which even the keenest of sectarian malcontents submit with the most absolute indifference; a tax on public worship, which none are found vigorously to denounce; an adulteration of one of the prime necessaries of life which is allowed without resistance or complaint. Ventilation of all religious or ecclesiastical questions as affected by the law we have in abundance. Even our tithes of mint, anise, or cummin we will not pay or forego, as the case may be, except under compulsion; but ventilation of our religious buildings, our churches and chapels, wherein Sunday after Sunday we shut ourselves up in crowds for longer or shorter periods—that is a thing which we never concern ourselves about. The air we breathe during the time of public worship may be adulterated to the last degree, yet we inhale the poison without complaint; we choke our lungs and stupefy our brains with the noxious compound, and seldom so much as dream of inquiring whether it be a matter of necessity that the spiritual sustenance which our souls require
should be dispensed to us in an 'atmosphere so foul that, in nine cases out of ten, it is positively unfit, at the end of an hour, for respiration.
"Surely it is an anomaly that in the very places where the Word of God, the written law, is expounded and enforced, the great unwritten law should be systematically violated; and that the conditions on which an all-wise Creator has made the health and well-being of the human frame to depend should be set at naught precisely in the temples dedicated to his service.
"The very idea of purity seems to be linked as by natural association with the worship of him who is purity itself; and to inculcate obedience to his behests, or to acknowledge the duty of observing them in an atmosphere tainted by the pent-up exhalations from some hundreds or even thousands of close packed human bodies, is, to say the least, a wilful inconsistency.
"It is to be feared, however, that if an inconsistency, it is a very common one. Not a few of my readers, probably, have borne witness by their own experience of suffering or discomfort, to the truth of my remarks. The fact is that, as a rule, the ventilation of our churches and chapels is a thing either wholly unprovided for or practically neglected; and although to this rule there are exceptions, many places of public worship being efficiently and carefully ventilated during both the heat of summer and the chills and frosts of winter, still such places are comparatively rare, and in the majority of cases, every individual in the congregation assembled within the walls of the sacred edifice is compelled, during the time of Divine service, to breathe an atmosphere laden with impurity, and unfitted for the purposes of healthy life. I have been in large, handsome churches where, on a hot summer's morning, not a window was opened throughout the building, except, perhaps, a tiny fanlight here and there in the roof; where, in fact, the windows were not made to open, nor any means of ventilation provided as a substitute, and where even the slight stream of fresh air that might have entered from the open door was carefully blocked out by a glazed or curtained screen! Of course, the air under
the galleries was offensive in the extreme, and even in the open centre space was stagnant and stifling to a distressing degree. And these are but samples of thousands of churches where everything is good, clean, and well cared for—except the air which the worshippers are compelled to breathe.
"Every one knows that we must breathe in order to live; but every one is not equally aware what amount of fresh air is necessary for the requirements of health, or how wofully this needed supply is curtailed in most crowded places of assembly. From 700 to 1,200 cubic feet of space for each adult is the amount assigned by modern science as the minimum which the conditions of health require. In a crowded church, with windows and doors all shut, sometimes with fifty or a hundred gaslights burning, in addition—and each gaslight it must be remembered, consumes as much oxygen as three or four adults—the cubic space for each individual may be reckoned at about 150 feet! How is it possible for a wholesome atmosphere to be maintained under such conditions?
"It is true that this foul, exhausted atmosphere is breathed for a comparatively short space of time. Two hours at most will cover the duration of any average service, and the fresh outer air into which the people then emerge happily undoes, to a large extent, the evil produced by the fetid exhalations within. Many, however, who little expect it, must and do suffer permanently from their effects. Young children, delicate women, and those enfeebled by disease or age, cannot submit themselves with impunity to the consequences of breathing, for even a couple of hours, the atmosphere thus laden with impurity, and deprived to an enormous extent of the elements that fit it to sustain life. Surely, in the interests of humanity and common sense it would be worth while to inquire whether such a state of things shall be allowed in so many cases to continue. Is there no one in such congregations who will resolve neither to be stifled periodically at church on Sundays, nor to stay away?—no one who will see to it that some efficient means of ventilation shall be provided, and some person be appointed whose duty
43
it shall be to see that those means are used?
"One frequent reason of the deficient supply of fresh air in places of public worship is, that although doors and windows may be made to open, they are kept permanently closed, especially in new and highly decorated churches, because, forsooth, it saves trouble by keeping out the dust! I have known churches which for that very reason never had a current of fresh air through them from one week's end to another, save that which came in for an hour or two each Sunday by the open door. So soon as the congregation had dispersed, the doors were shut, and the unwholesome miasma and exhalations from the lungs and bodies of a thousand human beings were shut in too, ready to be rebreathed at the next time of service by the hapless worshippers. No wonder that on hot Sundays or gas-lit evenings faintings are common in such places, or that dulness and drowsiness afflict the hearers during the preaching of the sermon. No wonder that the morning congregations doze away their afternoons, too stupefied to use their exhausted brains in any other way, or that the evening hearers wake next morning with a headache for which they strive in vain to account. These are the visible and slighter effects produced by this mode of violating Nature's laws in the house of Nature's God. The direr results, if less palpable and direct, are still not far to seek. Every wise physician knows how fertile a source of disease is the breathing of impure and deteriorated air.
"Surely it is possible, if not altogether to eliminate, at least very largely to mitigate the sanitary evils which so often attend the assembling of ourselves together for the purposes of public worship. It is not absolutely necessary that we should impair our physical well-being by breathing, over and over again, the impure exhausted air which already has passed through our own or our neighbours' lungs. It may be that where every available foot of space in a building is packed with a crowded congregation, sometimes two or even three tiers deep, an adequate supply of fresh air for each individual can hardly be secured. But for mercy's sake let us
have what we can! Let the windows be made to open, let ventilators in abundance be fixed in the walls and roof, let the church or chapel be thoroughly aired between each service, so that at least the atmosphere be fresh and pure to begin with.
"If these things cost money, let us pay it. Better spend our means on a supply of pure air than on carved work and on mural decorations, embroidered altar cloths or crimson cushions. These may please the eye, or gratify ecclesiastical pride. We may even fancy that we do God honour by thus worshiping him in the beauty of art and upholstery as well as in the beauty of holiness. But let us not forget that there is a beauty of obedience to the natural as well as to the moral law, and that one of the first of these commandments is, Thou shalt not breathe foul air, even in the house of God."
The Twin Records of Creation, or Geology and Genesis. By GEORGE W. VICTOR LE VAUX. Lockwood and Co., 7, Stationers' Hall Court.
We have little sympathy with long and elaborate attempts to reconcile the discoveries of geology with the Mosaic narrative of the creation. The first verse of revelation, which informs us that in the beginning God created the heavens and the earth, without saying when that beginning was, concedes to the geologist all that he can reasonably demand. Creation is revealed in the Scriptures so far as the race of man is concerned, and in harmony with its one great design. The attempt to discover six periods of some millions of years in geological records, answering to the six days of the Mosaic creation, supposes an intention in Scripture to teach geology. This supposition is absurd, and has so far failed that it may be safely affirmed that the theory of six definite periods could not have been suggested by the facts themselves. We protest too against an allegorical interpretation of what is narrated as literally true, as calculated to mystify our views, and weaken our faith at the commencement of our Bibles in all that is to follow. Scripture does not profess to use the language of science, but that which is common to man. The common-sense meaning of the Scriptures
to those to whom it was addressed is the Scriptures. It may be with good intention that scientific men put forth their hands to steady the ark of God, but it needs not their help. "Then were they in great fear where no fear was."
Delivery and Development of Christian Doctrine. By ROBERT RAINY, D.D. T. and T. Clark, Edinburgh.
WE have lectures here about Christian doctrines rather than upon Christian doctrines themselves. These are very properly affirmed to be contained in a perfect system, gradually developed in the Old Testament, and speedily completed in the New. Beyond this, there is a development, we are told, of Christian doctrine by the church itself, to be gathered from church history, and from the discoveries of modern times. The church, we are informed by our author, has a corporate teaching capacity. We know no such corporate church, and consequently no such capacity. Assistance may be gained from others in interpreting the doctrines of the Scriptures, but no addition to the doctrines themselves. The development of Christian doctrine in the Scriptures is one thing, and the development of those doctrines after the completion of the Scriptures is another. It is of great importance in the present day that these two things should not be confounded. With this caution, these lectures may be read with much profit.
St. John the Author of the Fourth Gospel. By CHRISTOPH ERNST LUTHARDT. Translated by CASPAR KENE GREGORY, Leipzig. T. and T. Clark, Edinburgh.
THERE is no part of the sacred volume which has not at some time or other been vigorously assailed, and which, by exciting equal and often greater powers in its defence, has been left it more confirmed than before. Much learning and research have been employed, and many ingenious and plausible arguments have been adduced, to prove that the fourth gospel could not, as has been generally supposed, have been written by the apostle John. The whole subject has been here submitted to the most tho-
rough investigation, and the authenticity of that gospel history established beyond any reasonable doubt. Nor let such a result be deemed unworthy of the immense labour by which it has been attained. All Biblical students owe a lasting debt of gratitude to such defenders of the faith. An attack upon the outworks of inspiration is aimed in reality at the citadel itself; we should contend, therefore, for the one with the same zeal as for the other. The fourth gospel was evidently written by an eye-witness, and both the manifest personal participation in what he records, and the way in which he speaks of himself, without mentioning his name, are peculiarly characteristic of the apostle John. We may confidently continue, therefore, to quote it in connection with his name.
Christ and the Scriptures. By Rev. ADOLPH SAPHIR, B.A. Morgan and Scott, 12, Paternoster Buildings.
MR. SAPHIR'S works may always be read with safety and with profit. They lead us into green pastures, and are within the ancient landmarks. They are, moreover, elegant in diction and rich in illustration. They are always Scriptural; but the one before us is in commendation of the Scriptures themselves, and of Christ as their principal theme. The Bible is among books what Christ was among men; the one divine, the other human. The Bible is Christ among men. There standeth one among you whom you know not. It is the study of the Bible more exclusively for which Mr. Saphir contends, and for which he pleads the example of Christ himself and his apostles. The Old Testament, he maintains, is the right point of view from which to approach the New. The New supposes the Old. Christ was planted in a Jewish, and not in a Gentile soil, and is not less intelligible to the Gentiles on that account, but more so. It removes him from their own associations to such as were specially provided for him. This is a valuable testimony against the growing tendency in the present day to transfer the interpretation of the New Testament from Jewish to Gentile ideas. Mr. Saphir's whole volume is faithful to its title—"Christ and the Scriptures."
45
Faith in the Blessed God. By Rev. WILLIAM TAIT, A.M. Whitaker and Co., Ave Maria Lane.
A VERY readable book, and far above the average pulpit productions of clergymen. We agree with the author that it is blood-shedding unto death that makes atonement. We hold Canon Liddon to be utterly wrong if he seeks to maintain that "one sigh from the Redeemer's heart, one lash on his sacred person, would have redeemed a world." It is the dignity of the person, not the amount of the suffering, which is most to be regarded; yet the victim must die, or no sacrifice able to remove the demerit of sin has been offered, and no atonement such as the violated law of God requires.
Yanim; or, the Bible Wine Question: Testimony of Scripture, of the Rabbis, and of Bible Lands against recent Sacramentarian Innovations. By Professors WATTS, WALLACE, and MURPHY, Belfast; and Rev. WILLIAM WRIGHT, B.A., Damascus. Edited by Professor WATTS. Belfast: William Mullan. 6d.
THOSE ministers whose churches are tormented by the unfermented wine question will here find much help in keeping to the old paths. The document signed by Dr. Thomson of "The Land and the Book," and by others of the more eminent missionaries in Syria and the Holy Land, ought to settle the question for ever. They bear witness that they have never met with unfermented wine in the East, nor are there any records, or traditions, that such wine was ever known there. The fact is—there is not, and there never was, and never can be such a thing as unfermented wine, though it suits some men to call their messes by that name. At the same time it should be observed that much which is called wine in this country is not worthy of the name, and it is a shame to remember our Lord's death by drinking such vile decoctions. Let it be really wine, as pure and good as can be had, and no communicant has then any Scriptural right to object. As the slightest word on this subject generally brings a flood of angry letters, we beg to intimate that our columns are not
open to discussion, and that our own mind is made up. We are at one with those temperate temperance friends who forbear to divide churches, and mar the unity of the saints upon this point: to them we wish God speed, and we hope ever to co-operate with them. They have their own sphere of action, and a very important one it is; and when pursued in subservience to the gospel, for the noble object of preventing and curing the great and crying sin of drunkenness, their work is philanthropic in the highest degree; nay, more, it is Christlike, and tends to benefit the souls as well as the bodies of men. To make men sober is one thing, to make them quarrelsome is another: we are content with the former.
Jesus in the Midst. By GEORGE CROSS. Thomas D. Morrison, Glasgow.
THE incident of the nameless and silent woman who washed our Lord's feet with her tears is here dealt with, and we have greatly enjoyed the perusal of the meditations thereon. The author needs to condense his words, which dilute as well as express his thought; but the book is one we prize, as dealing with a touching and instructive event in a fresh, thoughtful, and attractive manner.
An Old Story. By S. C. HALL. Virtue, Spalding, and Co., 26, Ivy Lane.
A TEMPERANCE tale in verse, and very well told, the illustrations are above the average, and the matter (if exaggerated) is still, alas, too true. We heartily bid our temperance friends God speed. If we cannot agree with all they say, we see so much room for work amidst abounding drunkenness that we hail with joy all efforts which come to our help in seeking to remove this curse.
The Book of Praise for Children. H. K. Lewis, 136, Gower Street, London.
A VERY good collection of children's hymns. Most of our old friends are here, and a few new ones. The rank popery of a cross printed on the brow of the baby in baptism sadly disfigures the book. The only certain effect of such a superstitious piece of foolery is to make the temper of the child cross. If that is what is meant, we see force in it.
Thoughts for Heart and Life. By THEODORE L. CUYLER, D.D. Hodder and Houghton.
LIVELY little sketches, which all aim at doing good. There is nothing very deep or excessively striking, but the tales are prettily told and the pious observations neatly put. A half hour might be every now and again very happily whiled away with these "thoughts," and profit would be sure to come of it as well as amusement. The story of Old Johnson is too good to leave unquoted.
"Johnson was a Virginia negro, who died in Michigan at the almost incredible age of one hundred and twenty! He never would have lasted so long if he had not—like Father Cleveland, of Boston—carried about him that cheerful heart that doeth good like medicine. One day, when he was at work in his garden, singing and shouting, his pastor looked over the fence, and said: 'Uncle, you seem very happy to-day.' 'Yes, massa, I'se just tinking.' 'What are you thinking about?' 'Oh! I'se just tinking' (and the tears rolled down his black face)—'I'se tinking dat if de crumbs of joy dat fall from de Massa's table in dis world is so good, what will de great loaf in glory be! I tells ye, sir, dar will be enuf and to spare up dar.'
Once Mr. F—said to him, 'Uncle
Johnson, why don't you get into our meetings once in a while?' He answered: 'Massa, I wants to be dere, but I can't have myself.' 'You can't behave!' 'Well, massa, ob late years de flesh is gettin' weak; and when dey gwin to talk and sing about Jesus, I 'gins to fill up, and putty soon I has to holler, and den some one 'll say "Carry dat man out the door, he 'sturbs de meetin."' 'But you should hold in till you get home.' 'O massa! I can't hold in. I bust if I don't holler.' (Would it not be a blessed thing for some prayer-meetings that are now dying of dignity if they could have such a 'holler' to wake them out of their slumber?) This jubilant old negro lived in literal dependence on God. When a gift was made to him, he received it as if sent to him by Elijah's ravens. 'When I wants anything, I jes asks de Lord, and He is sure to send it; sometimes afore I'se done askin', and den sometimes He holds back, jus' to see if I trust Him.' One of the last things remembered of him was the message he gave to a minister who called to see him, when he was 'waitin' for the chariot ob de Lord.' 'O massa!' said he, 'if you gets home afore I do, tell 'em to keep de table standin,' for old Johnson is holdin' on his way. I'se bound to be dere.'"
