Temper in Ministers — A Paper Read At The Soiree Of The College Conference — By Pastor A. Rax, Of Battersea
IT is almost appalling to reflect how exceedingly little can be done by an individual life, however earnest in its purpose, towards diminishing the amount of misery and sin that exists in the world. We are not considering now a good man's work as it is in combination with Christian work the wide world over, but we are thinking of individual effort. There, on the one hand, is sin in all its hideous proportions—against it are arrayed the best powers of a single life, and it is, I say, almost appalling to think how little one can accomplish in view of what remains to be effected.
This being so, it should be the care of every godly man that the little influence he has for good may not be counteracted by any personal quality. At best it is all too little, and must not suffer further loss. If he perceives, therefore, that anything in himself defeats or thwarts him in his purposes of mercy he should be intolerant towards it, and use all means for its removal. There are few things more painful to witness than a life of self-frustration, a man energetically destroying with one hand work which he is vigorously prosecuting with the other. Such lives are worse than useless, because they not only fail to do good, but by the evil of their example they do positive harm.
The statement requires no proof that a malicious, revengeful, or wrathful nature will go far to defeat any efforts of an individual to bless and save his fellows. It will disqualify him in spirit, it will estrange the sympathies of those whom he seeks to save; above all, it will grieve the Holy Spirit so that he will cease to work by such a one. If this be so, perhaps a subject of greater importance could scarcely be brought before the attention of a company of Christian ministers than that which aims to show the influence and effect of a minister's disposition upon his work, and how much his success or non-success may be attributable to it.
Now, it must be conceded that the peculiarities of a minister's position are such as to try to the utmost the qualities of his natural disposition.
1. There are physical trials that must not be quite overlooked.
279
Studious and sedentary habits have a whole train of diseases as their consequence. Impaired digestion and derangement of the liver often result from close and laborious application, and who can be saintly under such circumstances! These, with the continual labour of the brain, are likely to produce a mental irritation which is to be more pitied than blamed.
2. Then there are trials arising out of the moral infirmities of those over whom the pastor is called to preside. A perfect church would go a long way toward the securement of a perfect pastor. How often might the minister justly turn upon some unruly member of his church as Elijah did upon Ahab and say, "I have not troubled Israel, but thou and thy father's house." If the members of a church have to complain of the irritability of their pastor it would at least be worth their while to try the experiment whether he might not be reformed by an effectual reformation of themselves. We say it might be worth a trial, we do not venture to affirm what the result would be. Perhaps there are some pastors so intrinsically bad that nothing would alter them, still nothing would be lost by putting it to the test. Let the little old woman who is fond of tea and gossip alter her tactics, and talk of the people the pastor has visited, and the good he has done them, instead of those whom he has not seen, perhaps for the best of reasons, though unknown to her. Let the brother who has the dubious gift of detecting heresy, and can scent its faintest breath miles off, give up his favourite pastime a little while and turn his attention to a more novel and profitable employment, the discovery of what is sound and orthodox in the sermons,—suppose the sisters let the pastor's wife alone for a week or two, or, if they do anything, try and smooth out the deep line of care on the forehead, and soothe the great ache in the heart by utilising their extraordinary gifts of speech in an agitation for an increase in their pastor's stipend. Let the deacons now and then, instead of being as mute as fishes on the subject, tell their pastor in the vestry how much good they have got out of his sermon, and how sure they are that God will bless it. We say let a few of these expedients be tried, and while we won't pledge ourselves as to the results—we should not wonder, stranger things have happened—it is not beyond the bounds of probability that it might result in a complete transformation of their minister.
Probably the people are as often blameworthy as their pastor for any sudden outburst of anger on his part. He may come down to a church-meeting in the most pacific of moods, full of high and holy purposes, but he would be a bold man who would venture to predict what he might meet with before the meeting closed. The great majority will be Christian people amenable to reason, and willing to support their pastor when his cause is just, but in almost every community there are one or two who are—well—not EMINENT for grace, nor wisdom, nor considerateness of feeling. These persons, doubtless, subserve some important end in the church militant, though what it may be remains inscrutable to most of us. Perhaps they are permitted by a wise and gracious providence, as a means of grace to the pastor. Lest he should be exalted above measure, there are given to him thorns in the flesh, messengers of Satan sent to buffet him. He has to confront obtuse and
stupid people, who are remarkable only for their inability to understand the plainest and simplest statement; pugnacious people who seem to regard a row as a means of grace and to be mightily refreshed thereby; weak and simple people who generally become tools in the hands of designing and treacherous persons too cautious to appear themselves. These are a few of the types of character which a pastor may meet. Thank God they are not numerous, and often not influential in the church, but they can do much toward embittering his life and tempting him to words and actions which in cooler moments he would not defend, nay, which he would heartily deprecate.
3. A danger may also arise from the pastor's recognized position as a ruler in the church. He should not be merely a mouthpiece to give effect to the church's decisions, but he should, by his counsel and influence guide it in the formation of those decisions. "Remember them which have the rule over you," or "are your guides." This may have a tendency (especially with men of particular temperaments) to make them intolerant and tyrannical. A sincere and friendly suggestion proffered in all good faith perhaps appears like an impertinent intrusion into his office, and an attempt at dictation which he feels that his dignity requires him to resent!
4. Then there is a temptation to yield to anger, especially in weak men, in order to assert authority. These persons are continually putting their foot down, and they do it so frequently and upon such insignificant occasions, and with such apparently harmless results, that presently the deacons and people come to feel that they do not care a straw whether the foot be down or up; if it is up they know it will soon come down, and if it is down they know it won't hurt anyone. Now far be it from us to say there may not arise occasions when a minister does well to be angry. He should show a hearty and unaffected contempt for all that is false and mean, base and impure. While he should be merciful toward the contrite he should never give the shadow of a wrong his patronage, or let it find a sanctuary in him. I can think of (as a Christlike spectacle) a minister in righteous indignation, so overwhelming the hardened liar, seducer, or blasphemer, with withering reproaches, as to make him sink with fear, and tremble as though before the judgment throne; but these occasions are peculiar and rare, and even then people should see he has a restraint upon himself, that he has a reserve of power which he has not displayed. A minister should never be seen with all his stops out. People should only be left to surmise vaguely what might possibly happen if they had the temerity to rouse the virtuous indignation of their pastor. Whether it would result in an earthquake, or their immediate and total annihilation, or the final displacement of all things, they should be left only darkly to guess; and probably they would feel that at least it would not be judicious nor desirable to clear away the obscurity in which the question is enveloped by personally inducing experiments in that direction. Now, we have indicated these sources of danger, not for a minute to excuse or palliate the lamentable failures in temper, which are, alas, all too common, and the fruitful source of mischief to the Christian church; but we have mentioned them that they may induce a greater watchfulness and prayerfulness on our part.
281
II. We go on secondly to notice The influence and effects of the minister's disposition on his work.
Probably our success or non-success in our work depends in a greater degree upon our personal character than some of us have ever imagined. It will be profitable, therefore, to spend a few minutes in considering the effect of the one upon the other.
1. Now, we need only remind you of the fact, that ungodly men are all too ready to make religion responsible for the failures of its professed advocates. The method of reasoning, of course, is clearly illogical. The Christian system should be judged by its own direct and natural tendencies. The question open for discussion is, "What kind of a spirit did its Founder seek to inculcate and foster?" And if it could be proved that it was a fiery and revengeful spirit, then perhaps they might be justified in pointing to such traits in the characters of its professors as the natural result and outcome of such teaching. But to make it responsible for all that is alien to its spirit simply because it appears in the life of one who has taken upon himself to advocate its claims is manifestly unjust. Grant us the liberty of such a mode of reasoning, and we have no hesitation in declaring that we could succeed in casting discredit upon any cause. If we can discover a temperance advocate given to habits of drunkenness, would it be fair to infer that total abstinence sanctioned and induced intoxication? The smallest child can see that the man is drunk, not through encouragement derived from the principles he had championed, but through disregard, and in spite of them. But thus men reason about religion. Albeit its mission is to produce peace, and to inculcate meekness, long suffering, forgiveness, guided more by the enmity of their hearts than by an impartial judgment of what is just and right, they make religion answerable for all the follies and sins of those who profess adherence to it. How often, alas, have we seen the worldly point to the inconsistencies of the professor, and say, "This is your religion, This is your religion," when they would have been more just and logical had they turned upon the offender and rebuked him for manifesting a spirit so much at variance with the faith he professes.
Now, this being the frame and temper of men toward religion, it is easy to see what a damaging blow can be dealt it by a fiery and wrathful minister. How ready will they be to point to his temper, and then turn upon the religion he has professed and brand it as a foul hypocrisy, how ready to seize upon any unseemly act as a pretext for disregarding its authority and resisting its claims. Seeing, then, brethren, that men will persist in looking for an exposition of the principles of religion to the lives of its professors rather than to its own written code, shall we, not even while we protest on behalf of religion against its unfairness, seek to present a spirit so much in harmony with its teaching that we shall extort even from these an unwilling tribute to its beauty.
2. We remark, in the next place, That a minister's disposition will in an important degree determine the kind of reception his message will meet. Men will pay regard, not merely to the words that are spoken but to the character of the person by whom they are spoken, so that practically their value is enhanced or diminished by the disposition of the speaker. We are not defending this, we are simply stating a fact.
18
We know that the worth of a statement must depend on its own intrinsic excellence, and that this cannot be affected by the character of its exponent. Truth is as true when uttered by the devil as when spoken by an angel, but there is little doubt that people would be more disposed to receive it from the latter than the former. Let a minister, through a long course of years, manifest a benevolent and affectionate nature, weeping with those that weep, rejoicing with those that rejoice, endearing himself so much to his flock that whether there is joy in the house or sorrow they will send for him, because his presence brightens the one and makes the other easier to bear; let the tender and beautiful associations of a hundred homes gather round him, so that as time rolls on he will in some way be mixed up with all their pleasant and solemn memories—the wondrous carols of Christmas-tide, the home coming of the boys, the birth of the baby, the marriage of the daughter, and with the dark hour of bereavement too—and when such a man comes forth on the Sabbath-day it will be to minister to a very partial people. Listening to a dear and honoured friend, they are prepared to receive his words and think them good, however simple those words may be. The pastor reads his text: "Pure religion and undefiled before God and the Father is this, To visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction and to keep himself unspotted from the world." The stranger critically examining the sermon may find fault because of its shortcomings; it lacked argument, pathos, illustration, but to that gentlewoman there in widow's weeds it is a very different thing. With the memory of those repeated and tender visits in the hour of her great life-sorrow, the earnest prayers offered in the sick room, the projects to make her life less desolate and dreary, the ready counsel, and the willing help—all these cluster about the sermon and make it great. Though the remarks may have been ordinary and commonplace, she, putting the good man's life beside the good man's words, finds all lack supplied. There was the most touching pathos, the most powerful argument, the most thrilling illustration in the unwritten part of the homily—the preacher's Christian life. On the other hand let a minister, out of the pulpit, show himself hard, ungenial, inconsiderate, and he may preach sermons of real merit, but prejudice will affect his people's judgment, or, if his talent be of such a remarkable order that it cannot be denied, and his matter so sound that it cannot be gainsaid, it will nevertheless be uninfluential. They will feel there is fault somewhere, and whether it is in the life of the preacher, or the doctrine he preaches, they do not stay to consider, and so repudiate both.
8. Another evil resulting from a fiery and irrefut nature in the minister will be his inability to rebuke successfully the same vice in others. The themes of a minister's discourse should be as varied as the word of God. He should leave no precept unenforced, no sin unrebuked. But how can a pastor, notorious for a hot and hasty temper preach upon the duty of patience and longsuffering? The consciousness of his own failings will seal his lips. He feels he cannot honestly declaim against that in others, which he allows in himself. Conscience says, "Thou that judgest wrath and uncharitableness, art thou wrathful or uncharitable? Thou that preachest against temper, hast thou temper?" Hence he shuns such a topic altogether. Or if in disregard of the
283
incongruity of the case he ventures on such a subject, it is only to render himself ridiculous and a laughing-stock to all his hearers. The young folk will shake with merriment as they hear their pastor gravely expatiating on the beauty of Christian meekness and forbearance, and remember the scene at the last church meeting, where one and all were apprehensive that a fit of apoplexy would bring his labours to an abrupt and immediate end. Such a sight would only find a parallel in a thief preaching against dishonesty, a drunkard against intemperance, or the devil against sin.
4. I refer but to one other point. The power of the minister to reproduce his disposition in others.
It is instructive to watch the career of some brethren in their fruitless search for a peaceable and united church. They long and pray for one, but they never get one. Other brethren seem to settle comfortably, but they never do. They watch the cloud and follow it very, very often, but it invariably leads them to a nest of hornets or a den of thieves. It is an annual occurrence to find under the head of Baptist Intelligence some such notice as this: "On Thursday last the church and congregation at Beulah Chapel met to take a farewell of their pastor, the Rev. Timothy Bland, and present him with a purse of gold on his retirement, he having accepted the very hearty and unanimous invitation of the church at Little Dumbledon." An unsuspecting public does not read between the lines, does not know that the purse of gold is by no means an offering of affection, but rather a bribe to secure the pastor's retirement, does not know that it was subscribed joyfully and freely as opening a way whereby the church might be saved from further discord, and perhaps extinction. The church at Little Dumbledon, to which a local paper recording the event has been despatched by their new pastor, does not know this, and pleases itself by thinking how deeply he must be in the love of the people there.
Ah well, Little Dumbledon! "As your day your strength will be." So far as your new pastor is concerned, "Beloved, think it not strange concerning the fiery trial which is to try you as though some strange thing happened unto you." It has happened in each place where he has previously settled. Now men of the stamp of the Rev. Timothy Bland are given to talking about the unequal ways of Providence: in social hours, with a look of unutterable wisdom they will propound as one of its very deepest mysteries the question how it comes to pass that some ministers always go where they find kind and peace-loving people, while other devoted servants of the Lord (and here they allude to themselves) are invariably called to traverse the thorny paths of persecution, and dwell with a godless and froward flock. But men of the Timothy Bland order are not given to depreciate their own powers, as they are not given truthfully to read their own hearts, so they come to the conclusion that the Lord knows that such people as those with whom they have to deal need one to preside over them who has a sound judgment, a judicious mind, a kind but resolute will, and withal such a measure of faithfulness as not to shrink from telling them of their faults and failings in the plainest possible manner. But friends who wish the Rev. Timothy Bland well, would tell him something else. They would tell him of the existence of a very homely proverb which says, "Like
priest like people." That while it is difficult to make them copy his transcendent virtues, it is easy to lead them to imitate his vices. They would tell him that it is as useless for him to move from place to place with the hope of a peaceable spot, until he has reformed himself, as for a man burning with fever to toss to and fro upon his bed with the expectation of finding a place permanently cool. They would tell him that, before he can expect people to be more considerate of him he must learn to be more considerate of them.
And oh, Rev. Timothy Bland, if you would only condescend to hearken to this advice, you might have fewer testimonials, fewer opportunities of studying church life from fresh standpoints, but you would gain immeasurably in the usefulness of your life and the peacefulness of your mind, and of the churches it might be said again as it was in old time, when another desperate persecutor became converted, "Then had the churches rest."
My brethren, how great is the evil of which we speak. How many ministers there are to-day of great intellectual power and ripe and varied learning, calculated to be eminently useful in Christian service, were it not for a sour or ungovernable temper which just paralyses them and leaves them helpless in the work of God?
Now all we have said may be met with the remark, No doubt the evils you mention do arise from a morose or querulous spirit in the minister, but then how can it be helped if we are naturally constituted thus? We can choose the colour of our gloves, or the quality of our literature, but our dispositions are not left to our own selection. It is no more within our power to decide what temperaments we shall be born with than it is to choose what colour our hair shall be, whether red or black; or the shape of our nose, whether aquiline or pug. Now there is a measure of truth in all this. No doubt some are naturally more amiable than others. It is not nearly such a hard fight with some to conquer their passions. But the question is whether Jesus is not greater than our hearts, whether his grace is not sufficient, whether he is not able to keep us from falling? How can we confidently tell the sinner Sabbath after Sabbath that Jesus is able to make him a new creature, that he can empower him to overcome old lusts and old besetments if we do not believe this? As a matter of mere resolve and human effort, it is as hopeless to expect relief as for a man in a low-lying valley to drive away the mist which envelopes him, but as he may be free from it by ascending some mountain height where the pure, fresh breezes blow, so by quitting mere human struggle and ascending to the height of the Saviour's proffered grace we may triumph through him. "The conies are but a feeble folk, yet make they their houses in the rocks." Let us learn well this truth. We are nothing but weakness, but he is strength; abide in him.
