Menu
‹ Chapter 82 of 201 ›

Popish Persecutions — A Brief Glance At The Inquisition — By Rev. W. P. Cope, Of Maze Pond Chapel

16 min read · Chapter 82 of 201
Popish Persecutions — A Brief Glance At The Inquisition — By Rev. W. P. Cope, Of Maze Pond Chapel

THE history of the Inquisition, which has been written at great length by Dr. W. H. Rule, in two volumes, illustrates in a very remarkable manner the spirit and aim of the Papal Church. Like a cloud about the size of a man's hand was the first appearance of this remarkable institution: and like the cloud seen by the prophet's servant it has grown in size till its dark shadow has been flung on almost every land where the Pope has been recognised as a spiritual superior. But unlike the cloud seen from Carmel's height, laden with blessing to a thirsty impoverished land, this cloud has made the fruitful places barren; it has turned the garden of the Lord into a wilderness, and its progress has been marked by floods of blood. Great attention has been drawn of late to the action of the papal church. She has challenged

257

it by her blasphemous pretensions to infallibility. The more her claims are examined; the more the light of modern inquiry is let into her secret history of the past; the more we question how she has used the power that once was hers; the more earnestly shall we protest against her assumption of supremacy over the human race, and be prepared, if needs be, to endorse our protest with resolute action. The story of the Inquisition is no ordinary story of religious persecution; for persecution has been unhappily a leading feature in almost every system of religion. In proportion as it has been destitute of the spirit of him who "came not to destroy men's lives but to save them," religion has used the sword of the magistrate or the weapon of the soldier for the extermination of heresy, or the spread of its own system. The papal church, however, has gained the unenviable distinction of establishing a secret ecclesiastical court with tonsured judges, independent of civil law and control, for the extirpation of heresy by means of torture and death.

In forming a right estimate of the principles and practices of Inquisition it must be borne in mind that it flourished in an age of gross cruelty. Human life was then held less sacred than now. Offences deemed light in the present day—those against property or social order—were visited with the extreme penalty of the law. Savagery was stronger than sentiment. The sword of justice was always whetted, and, wielded by an arm always in practice, it dealt very wide and sweeping blows. But when the most has been said that can be said in explanation of the circumstances amid which the Inquisition rose to its greatest power we cannot but feel that a dark blot remains upon the page of Romish church history. The church that could perpetrate such outrages upon humanity must still be very narrowly watched. The machinery is unchanged; the principles remain unaltered. Should the opportunity again occur for setting them in motion everything is ready. What might be done can only be imagined when we understand what has been done. For six hundred years—one third of the Christian era—"The Holy Office," as the Inquisition is sometimes called, exercised its fell authority: the number of its victims it is impossible to tell. A very moderate estimate for Spain alone puts them at more than 350,000. It is worthy of notice, as more than a singular coincidence, that in 1869, during one of the revolutionary struggles of that unhappy country, most remarkable evidence was brought to light of the horrible proceedings of the Holy Office. The question of liberty of worship was under discussion in the Spanish Cortes—the Spanish Parliament. In the height of the excitement some workmen digging out a foundation in the Plaza Mayor of Madrid uncovered two black streaks of ashes. They were not parts of the regular geological formation. In them were found fragments of human bones, an iron collar, and other matters. They were mute witnesses to popish cruelty in the ages past come to plead for liberty of conscience and of worship. For the want of these they had sealed their faith with their blood two hundred years before.

This institution, which has left its brand mark upon France, Spain, Portugal, Italy, India, Venice, and in a slighter degree upon Germany—wherever the papal supremacy trimmbed—owes its origin to a Spanish

monk, Domingo de Guzman by name, better known in the Romish church as St. Dominic, the founder of the Dominican order of Friars. It is said that his mother was troubled by a dream some time before his birth. She imagined she was delivered of a dog, who came to light, carrying a burning brand in his mouth, to set the world on fire. The boy's career in a strange manner fulfilled the mother's dream. From the first he identified himself with the persecuting party of the church. During a visit to France, soon after he had been made a priest, it is said that he distinguished himself by controversy with the heretics. Some of them he converted by showing the superiority of his arguments over theirs in standing the fire. His arguments written upon paper, chemically prepared of course, were thrice thrown into the fire without being burned. It was a strange method. Beginning by throwing his own arguments into the fire he ended by putting his opponents there. It is easily understood how in those rough, rude times, when argument failed to convince the obstinate heretic, harsher measures should be adopted. Restless, ambitious men were not wanting to take the initiative. A bold, daring leader would then as now find many followers. What they lacked in originality they could at least make up in devotion. This was St. Dominic's position. Animated by the success he had already achieved against heretics, he conceived the design of forming a new order of preachers against heresy. It is a curious fact that in opening an Inquisition, in any place, a sermon forms an important part of the ceremony. Texts were not difficult to find; for it would not be the first time the devil quoted Scripture to suit his purpose. When the canonical Scriptures failed them was there not the Apocrypha? One of the preachers of the new order of Dominicans opened the Inquisition at Toulouse in 1234 by a sermon upon a text in Ecclesiasticus xlviii. 1.—"Then stood up Elias the prophet as fire, and his word burned like a lamp." The notes of that sermon are not preserved. We have the records of some others. At Saragossa, in 1671, the Inquisition was opened by a sermon on Luke xi. 14—28, "And he was casting out a devil, and it was dumb." After stating that "Aaron was an inquisitor of the law, and that he was that day represented by the inquisitors at Saragossa," the preacher divides his sermon into two heads. First, "The obligation to delate," i.e., to betray, or lay information against others; second, "The holiness of the office of Judge-Inquisitor." Under the first head it is remarked that "Religion is a warfare; every soldier should give notice to his chief if he knows there are enemies. If he does not give notice he deserves to be punished as a traitor. The Christian is a soldier, and if he does not denounce the heretics he is a traitor; justly will the Inquisition punish him" . . . . "Jacob separated himself from the house of Laban, his father-in-law, without saying 'good bye.'" Why did he not pay respect to his father-in-law? Because Laban was an idolator, and in matters of faith religion must be above all human consideration; therefore the son ought to delate the heretic to the Inquisition, although that heretic be his own father. Moses was inquisitor against Pharaoh, his foster-grandfather, plunging him into the sea because he was an idolator; and against his brother Aaron, reproving him for having consented to the golden calf. Therefore in offences of inquisition you

259

must not stop to think whether the delinquent be your father or your brother. Joshua was inquisitor against Achan, commanding them to burn him, because he had stolen property confiscated under the curse of Jericho, which ought to have been burnt in the fire: therefore it is just for heretics to be burnt. Achan was a prince of the tribe of Judah, and yet they delated him: therefore every heretic ought to be delated, though he were a prince of the blood royal." We will not reproduce the argument of the second head; enough to say that in it the Inquisition is compared to the Book of Revelation, which was sealed with seven seals. It signified that the process of the Inquisition is so secret that it seemed to be sealed with seven thousand seals. "Only a lion opens it, and then the lion is changed into a lamb. What clearer figure of an Inquisitor can there be? For making inquisition into crimes he is a lion that terrifies: after having sought them out he is a lamb that treats all the guilty written in that book with gentleness, kindness, and compassion." The unhappy heretic delivered over to the tender mercies of these lamb-like inquisitors would have found the treatment of the savage lion preferable. Many in the dungeon and on the rack would be reminded of the words of David, "Let me now fall into the hands of the Lord, for his mercies are great; and let me not fall into the hands of men."

From preaching to persecution was an easy step. Heresy must be stopped, for it was undermining the authority of the church. If heretics refused to recant and confess their sin, they must be prevented from spreading the evil with which they were tainted. The leper in times of old was removed out of the camp. Heresy was a worse disease than leprosy, and it must be "stamped out." St. Dominic set himself to organise a system that should secure this desirable end. The Dominican fraternity had already been established. He tried to form another order, one of women. They proved fractious and uneasy, and had soon to be dispersed. Nothing daunted, he tried a third time, and formed a band called "the Militia of Christ," to fight as crusaders against heretics. They were chiefly married men—all of them gentlemen. Their wives were also sworn to help them in this holy warfare, but chiefly in the discovery of heretics. Attached to the "family" of the Dominicans, yet not subject to the rules of that order, they were known as familiars, a title afterwards appropriated by certain officers of the Inquisition. Several years were required to consolidate this machinery. From time to time the authority of the Pope had to be secured in sanction of the successive steps that were taken. It was not to be expected that Dominic would rest long without wishing to put to the test the method he had devised for the extirpation of heresy. We find the Inquisitors busy at work in France, in Italy, and Germany at the close of the first quarter of the thirteenth century. For reasons of state policy, too tedious now to explain, the reigning monarch in each case not only consented to the proceedings, but directed that all possible aid should be given by the civil officers of the state. It must not, however, be supposed that these heretic-hunting monks always received a hearty welcome from the people. Sometimes the inhabitants of a town would rise up against the officers of the Inquisition, and, by their threats, drive them from the place. But Rome, wily and patient, could

always wait. Sometimes it waited with settled purposes of revenge that time only intensified. It could wield weapons more terrible than fire and sword. In one case the whole town was put under ban. The usual deplorable consequences followed: the ministers of religion were withdrawn, trade was suspended; a blight, worse than the gloom that settled upon Egypt in the days of the plagues, was upon the place. The people were soon reduced to submission. Very piteously did they pray that the curse might be removed. Very seriously did they vow on their own part and that of their successors, perpetual obedience to the holy Inquisitors, who for the future should do as they please. Any penalties that might be inflicted they would rigorously perform. Then the Holy Fathers returned, and, as a warning to other towns and future generations, exacted judgment—judgment without mercy.

The Romish church found it a great advantage to have a body of men specially devoted to the work of preserving the saints in their faith; and catching "the foxes, the little foxes that spoiled the vine." Pope Innocent III., who deserves to be canonised as the Patron Saint of the Inquisition, in very tender language expressed his concern for the "Lord's vineyard," exposed to the ravages of these foxes—"their faces diverse, and their tails tied together with a band of vanity." From such, as the apostles taught, the faithful were to turn away. Against them let the priests sound their silver trumpets loud and clear, and call out the people. Let the ark of the Lord go forward. Let the walls of Jericho be overthrown. Let them be crushed under a perpetual curse. Attempts were made on several occasions to secure the conviction of some who sympathised with the heretics; but these attempts made in a civil court, were ineffectual. The bishops were not always so active in their provinces as Rome desired. Perhaps the bishop was aged, and desired to spend his last days on earth in the peaceful relations he had cultivated for many years. Sometimes he was of a mild and loving disposition; watchful over the spiritual devotion of his children; tender in his dealings towards those who differed from him, grieved with their departures from the faith, yet hoping to win them by love and patience. Sometimes he was intimately acquainted with the friends of the suspected heretic: they were persons of influence in the social circle in which he moved. He could not set in motion any law that aimed at the life or even the liberty of their friend without seeming to betray the trust they reposed in him. In vain were papal briefs exhorting them "to take the foxes" addressed to such bishops as these. It needed men who had devoted themselves to the work of heresy-hunting; men whose hearts were well hardened by a long apprenticeship to the bloody task; men far removed from all other influences save supreme devotion to the Holy See. Let them loose like some raging ravenous lion in the midst of a helpless multitude. What if some perish innocently? Theirs the surer and earlier glory. In any case, should heretic or penitent perish, the inquisitors of every country were exempted from the guilt of murder by the special grace of Benedict XI. If bishop or priest try to shelter or screen the suspected heretic, let him also be suspected; or if he show laxity in supporting these zealous defenders of the faith, perhaps it is because he secretly sympathises with the suspected, and is at heart one of them. In self-defence,

261

then, priest or bishop, whatever might be his own natural feeling, was bound to support the "Inquisition" whenever it was opened.

In later times the proceedings of the Inquisition came to be called an "auto-da-fe," or "Act of Faith." In its early days it was known as a "general sermon of faith." The proceedings were in all cases opened by a sermon. There have been preserved the records of the proceedings of two Inquisitors, specially appointed for France. They commenced their work at Toulouse, and carried it on at intervals from 1308 to 1322. As a preliminary step, a seneschal, a judge, a sergeant-at-arms, and a civil governor, as representing the Sovereign, swore on the gospels "faith to the Lord Jesus Christ and to the Roman church, promising to defend Christ and the church with all their might; to pursue and take all heretics in their belief, with their aiders and abettors, and accuse and present them to the church and the Inquisitors. They swore engagement not to give office of any kind to the aforesaid pestilential persons, nor to any reputed to be such, and not to admit the like into their family, their friendship, or their service." After administering similar oaths to other officials, the Inquisitors pronounced sentence of excommunication against all that had in any way hindered or opposed them, and their subordinates, either openly or secretly. Having thus prepared the way for further proceedings, the unhappy victims of suspicion were brought out of their cells, or to use the expressive language of the original record, "brought out of the wall." They were literally immured. In many places cells have been discovered in which the condemned were built in, a space being left at the top in which food was thrust. Among other sentences passed by these two Inquisitors is this, "sitting at this tribunal and having counsel of good men, learned in civil and canon law, we condemn you by sentence in this writing to perpetual prison of the wall, there to perform healthful penance with bread of grief and water of affliction." In these records there appear, in the first entry, the names of fifty-seven persons with designations which show that whole families had been captured by the officers of the Inquisition, their sole offence being that they had embraced the gospel in opposition to the doctrines taught by the Romish church. In a second entry appear the names of eighty-seven persons sentenced to penance for the "damned crime of heresy." Among them, three men, one of them aged, and three women, two of them widows, are sentenced as follows: "And because you have offended more largely and more gravely, and therefore deserve weightier punishment, we determine that you shall be perpetually shut up in closer wall and straiter place in fetters and chains." In their zeal against these heretics they pursued them to the grave. Among the list of sentences recorded is found the following: "We command, in sign of perdition, that the bones of the said persons, if they can be distinguished from the bones of the faithful, be exterminated or exhumed from the sacred cemeteries, thrown out hence, and be burned." The beginnings of the Inquisition promised fairly for its future growth. From walling up living heretics and exhuming and burning the bones of the dead, we are prepared for any barbarity the holy office may be guilty of as it grows in years and power.

It took years to grow. Those years were marked by the grossest

corruption and licentiousness in the world; and of hollow prating, pharisaic righteousness on the part of the church. The solemn decrees, the bulls and statutes of this period, are full of expressions that imply the greatest zeal for the purity of the faith. If freedom of thought be suppressed, it is said to be done in the interest of religion; if one departed from the appointed standard of faith, and suffered for it, the penalty is made to appear as much for his soul's sake as for the good of the church. Yet if we read the history of the church in its true light, it was intriguing for temporal power. Heresy hunting and heresy burning were often only expedients for masking its true designs. Morality was at a discount. Sensualities of the grossest kind were indulged in. All classes of society, all situations of domestic life, both with the clergy and laity, in the homes of the people, and under consecrated roofs, were alike infected. While the severest sentences were passed upon the honest heretic who dared to think for himself and differently from the priest, crimes of the vilest character were overlooked; or if condemned, immediately condoned. If penance was inflicted, no one thought seriously of performing it. While Inquisitors are charged not "to spare any on account of age or sex," the priest is advised "that because the frailty of our time cannot abide censure of so great rigour, let it be attempered with prayers, alms, and other satisfactions, as far as they know how, or as they may consider to be expedient." To the female sex they were to be especially tender. Women who should confess were to have "the oil of mercy added to the wine of the canon." So that a dissolute woman, whom Christianity would now place in a reformatory, was simply dismissed with a trifling penance; or, if wealthy, sent to a nunnery "to serve God;" while a matron of unspotted life who would not go to confession, or who was known to ask a blessing on her food in a form unauthorised by the priest, would be immured in a dungeon; and if she did not repent would eventually be burned at the stake. It was, in fact, better to be a criminal than a heretic: for a reasonable consideration the clergy were willing to spare transgressors the pains of penance and the pangs of purgatory, but any upon whom the breath of a suspicion of heresy had fallen they relentlessly hunted to the death. No matter how pure and unblemished the life and reputation of one suspected, the murderer was better treated than the heretic. If the priests could not interpose between the criminal and the law, they at least could make sure of his admission to heaven. Cast out of this world, they induced Peter to open for him the gate of the next. As for the heretic who died under the ban of the church, there was neither compassion for him here, nor hope for him in the world to come. The dungeon, the stake or the scaffold, and hell, these were his well-merited fate. The sufferings they bore here were only a typical tithe of what they would endure hereafter. So that if the priests were believed, the friends of the heretic had the agony of knowing that their loved ones were lost for ever. No masses could avail them: in their case the fires of purgatory would never cease to burn.

What a network of spiritual despotism was being gradually woven around the people we can hardly understand! No one would dare to proclaim his own thoughts if they differed from the teachings of the

263

priests. If he expressed any sympathy with the sufferings of those handed over to the inquisitor, he was suspected of sympathy with his heresy as well. To be thus suspected was to be in danger of similar sufferings. Stunted and warped in his spiritual growth and mental freedom, the Papist was allowed all manner of bodily excess and riot. Stealthily and successfully the papal church was emasculating the manhood of that age. It strove for the supremacy, and suffered nothing to stand in its way. Even its most zealous adherents, upon the first symptoms of wavering, became its victims. Frederick II., crowned emperor by the Roman Pontiff, and one of the first to recognise the authority of the Inquisitors, whom by a constitution published at Padua, he took under "his special protection," was soon declared an infidel, denounced as an enemy of the church, and as such was pursued to the day of his death. It is equally remarkable that his chancellor, who had framed the constitution of Padua, which gave the inquisitors such power in the empire, came to a miserable end through the intrigues of the priests. They determined to be masters of the situation, and were equally determined that neither chancellor nor emperor should stand in their way.

These were only the beginnings of the Inquisition. "If they do these things in a green tree what shall be done in the dry?"

(To be continued.)

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate