Menu
‹ Chapter 74 of 201 ›

On the necessity of Paradox

8 min read · Chapter 74 of 201

THIS is an unpalatable doctrine, which especially demands impartial openness to conviction. When we meet with an opinion that is opposite to our own preconceived notions, our natural tendency is to resist it as an unwelcome intruder, and the weapon readiest to hand is a charge of paradox. The real meaning, as intended in the title, of this much-wronged word is, a statement at variance with received opinion [παρά δόξαν]; one which Sir Oracle would pronounce contrary to common sense. We may at once admit that luxuriant growths of paradox have frequently sprung up, with not a grain of truth in the whole crop; such may be dismissed as unworthy of consideration. It will suffice to notice two classes of paradoxes, both of necessary occurrence in the progress of knowledge; one in which the received opinion is false, when the contradiction is real, marks a province reclaimed from the wastes of ignorance, and is utterly uncongenial to those born blind; the other class includes those cases in which the former notion is true, when the paradox is two-sided, each side embodying a truthful view of the subject, and the contrariety being only apparent.

Apart from experience we might infer the necessary existence of paradox a priori. Our knowledge being progressive, the process of discovery must give rise to paradoxes of the first-class from time to time. We are told of an African potentate who considered it contrary to all sense and experience that water should become solid. To our forefathers it would have appeared sheer trifling to assert the existence of inhabited antipodes, involving the absurd hypothesis of people walking about head downward, like flies on a ceiling; while to maintain that the earth revolved in its orbit round a fixed sun, when men daily saw with their own eyes the sun travel from east to west, was to promulgate a heretical paradox amenable to the Inquisition and condign penalty. But in this day of fuller light we give free audience to fair argument; bigotry is an exploded mistake against which it is waste of time to inveigh. Be it so, reader, in your particular case; and yet do you not know many among your Christian friends who might be the better for taking warning from these conservative inquisitors of old?

But our object is more especially to consider the other class of paradoxes, those having two apparently contradictory sides, both founded on truth. As a specimen take the sur-rebutting self-contradiction of Paul: "I am crucified with Christ; nevertheless I live; yet not I, but Christ liveth in me." The necessary existence of these paradoxes also is deducible from reason. When minds of limited capacity endeavour to comprehend infinite truth, the effect can only be the comprehension of a part. Different minds will naturally select for acquisition different parts; and the same mind, if it have breadth enough, may comprehend two or more of these different parts, which in such mental conjunction constitute a paradox of the kind now under discussion. Even our natural instincts and mutual affections are higher than reason; how much more likely is it then that in our intuitive aspirations after the only sufficient object of our souls we should find the golden bowl too shallow! Laboriously we

231

climb the Rock of Ages, and apply ourselves each to clasp a portion of it in our arms, but when, panting and with spent strength, we look around for results, we find our chosen mainstay is not that which our brother has grasped, still less is it the inaccessible, heaven-piercing summit.

Let us endeavour to estimate the intrinsic value of an imputation of paradox. Suppose one recommends the prayerful study of the Bible to a worldly person, the latter is wont self-complacently to reply, "Your religion is paradoxical; I believe my reason was intended for my use, and I intend to use it." Again, suppose a liberal-minded Christian vindicates a falsely stigmatised Arminian from the strictures of an Ultra-Calvinist. A proper method may be to show that God's decreed will and His command to believe do not run counter to one another; but the censor satisfies himself with the plausible argument "I wish to be consistent, and cannot quit my faith for a tissue of paradoxes." Yet in the various departments of nature, in the world of our own eyes, there are paradoxes to confront the inquirer at every step; and much more in the regions of spiritual knowledge is the narrow, inscrutable path of truth, fenced in by innumerable obstacles. To substantiate this statement a few instances are appended of paradoxes both natural and spiritual.

How marvellous is a ray of sunlight, composed of every colour, yet perfectly colourless. Take another example from optics; we know that two lights have more illuminating power than one, nevertheless an optician could show us two strong lights so arranged as to neutralise the luminous waves of each other and produce darkness. But we have no need to search outside ourselves for paradoxes; they occur at the very outset of our metaphysical philosophy. Each individual comprises within himself a miraculous combination of mind and matter, two essences at the very opposite poles of creation, yet interacting and depending one upon the other in a manner inexplicable except by supposing some mysterious infusion into one homogeneous being. And proceeding in this chaotic region of psychology along a logically faultless chain of argument, philosophers* have been landed at their bourne in the phantasmal theory that we have no ground for believing in the existence of either matter or mind abstractedly from our individual perceptions of them, since these perceptions are the only entities that man's consciousness can be cognizant of. Again, in the vexed question of personal identity is involved the paradox that I am the same person I was ten years ago, although of the present constituents of my body and mind not a single atom is identical with those which entered into my composition at the former period. Mathematicians certainly claim infallibility for their science within its own straight limits, howbeit the cabalistic x of algebra can set up a specious pretension to equality with itself doubled, and on the other hand the circle, the geometrician's own familiar creature, obstinately baffles its master's highest skill by refusing to be equalled to its fellow, the square.

Still more demonstrable is the inconsistency of those who, while prepared to stand by or fall with the truth of God's revelation, at the same time insist on determining their walk by the light of reason. What ingenuity can escape from the dilemma arising out of the origin of evil, and incontrovertibly derogating from either the goodness or omnipotence of the Judge of all the earth? This, however, is but one of countless instances. Ralph Venning, with characteristic Puritan perseverance, amassed and published a collection of over 500 orthodox paradoxes, or cases in which a believer clears truth by seeming contradictions, and so thoroughly has he done his work that no apology is necessary for the following extracts from his magazine:—

He (the believer) believes

"That the Father is not the Son, nor the Son the Father, yet that the Father and the Son are one."

"That the Father is greater than the Son, yet the Father and the Son are equal."

* Berkeley and Hume.

"That God can do all things; yet there is that done in the world which God cannot do."

"That he cannot be justified by the law, and yet that the law cannot but justify him."

"That there is more in Christ that he needs; yet less than all will not content him, nor serve his turn."

"That no man ever yet hated his own flesh; and yet that many hate nothing more than their own flesh."

"That as soon as he begins to live, he begins to die, and that the more his life increaseth, the more it decreaseth, that his birth is the beginning of his death, and yet that as soon as he dies his life begins."

"That a Christian is not to spend all his time in prayer, and yet he is to pray always."

"That all a man's days are numbered, and yet that a man may die before his time."

"That nothing can be done against the will of God (for, who hath resisted His will); and yet that every sin is committed against the will of God."

"That a believer should not seek great things for himself; and yet that believers seek the greatest things for themselves without offending; yea, he believes they should offend if they did not do it."

"That God willeth all men to be saved, and yet that God wille not the salvation of all men."

"That justification is by faith alone, and yet that faith which is alone doth not justify."

"That a saint should not be secure though he be safe, yet that he should not be afraid though he be in danger."

"That reason is not equal in all men, nor perfect in any men, but so weak, fickle, and inconstant in the most of men, that there is no reason why any man should lean to his own understanding, and that there is none or little why any man should impose on another, he being so seldom and so little while consistent with himself, who was as confident, and upon thought-reason, as confident of the opinion wherein he was, as he is of the opinion wherein he is."

Thus from reason and experience alike we may infer the necessary existence of paradox. The fact is humiliating, may it be an instrument for implanting the scarce exotic grace of humility into our hearts! We are commanded each to esteem others better than himself; how this injunction is observed let our innumerable sects, with their exclusiveness and intolerance, testify. They who have gained an insight into the manysidedness of truth should open their hearts to investigate the tenets of those who differ from them. Among the numerous creeds there can scarcely be any which does not exhibit some one truth at least in an eminent degree of excellence. If we are large-hearted enough to discover this excellence, we cannot but be edified thereby, and may moreover be prevented from opposing some whom the day of judgment may reveal as fellow labourers—more diligent servants than we, is it possible?—in the kingdom of heaven. Fallible and paradoxical as we all are, is there not a merciful fitness in that the precept runs, not to judge one another according to appearance, but to love one another with a pure heart fervently.

The wisdom of the many has found expression in the apophthegm that a thing may be too strange not to be true. In contrast with our hard-headed sceptical generation I find a loveable credulity in the ancient whose mind had been expanded to the thought, Credo quia impossibile. When He affirms, who charges with folly the profoundest wisdom of philosophers, ought we not humbly to answer, I believe, though it be incredible. And not only humbly, but cheerfully; for in His sight all things are naked and open; with Him is no shadow of turning; and all Christians are heirs of God, joint-heirs with Christ. Then looking forward to the general assembly and church of the first-born made perfect, let us not repine at present imperfections, but dutifully gather the fragmentary scintillations of our allotted knowledge, therewith to form a truer conception

233

of the unsearchable depths of Omniscience. The composers of our sublimest music, when they would stimulate our feelings to the highest pitch of intensity, sprinkle discordant notes throughout their most moving themes, from the poignancy of such chords constructing an enchantment of undefinable pathos and unimaginable mystery, yet finally resolving the complex, impassioned strains into a cadence of sweet harmony. Much more shall God, the author of all noble inspirations, out of the many seemingly jangled sounds and painful dissonances of our present sphere, create for Himself a transcendent symphony of infinite and eternal concord.

B. SMITH.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate