Some thoughts on Matthew xvi. 39 — By George Waterman
"Let this cup pass from me."
THE usual exposition of this passage assumes that the agony of the Saviour in the Garden of Gethsemane, when he sweat as it were great drops of blood, was occasioned mainly—if not exclusively—by the outpouring upon him, as the sin-bearer, of the wrath of God. That he was then making expiation for the sins of the world. That then the sword of divine justice was unsheathed and thrust into the very soul of him who was taking the sinner's place. And that the tremendous load he was bearing forced from his holy—yet human—nature the bitter prayer, "Let this cup pass from me."
In a late number of "The Metropolitan Tabernacle Pulpit," a different exposition is proposed. The honoured and greatly-beloved author of that sermon suggests that the agony in the garden may have been the result of a conflict between the Saviour and his "alter ego;" that the Saviour was, as it were, contending with himself; balancing the reasons for and against his undergoing the fearful suffering which he must experience in making an expiation for human guilt; and in which his determination to proceed to the bitter end triumphed over every other suggestion.
Where so little is revealed, we are bound to enquire with great reverence and caution. But it may at once be stated, that neither of these views seems entirely satisfactory. Both of them seem inconsistent with the avidity—if such a word may be here employed—with which the Saviour anticipated his great sufferings. In view of these sufferings his language is, "I have a baptism with which to be baptised, and how am I straitened until it be accomplished." "What shall I say? Father, save me from this hour? But for this cause came I unto this hour."
May there not be some other exposition of the passage which will relieve it of the possible appearance of weakness and vacillation on the part of the Saviour; and yet be perfectly consistent with those views of his sufferings, as the expiation of human guilt, which the orthodox church has held in all ages?
In order to a possible answer to this question, it will be necessary to remember that the inspired apostle to the Gentiles distinctly draws a parallel between Adam and Christ, as the first and second Adam. The first Adam fell before the power of the tempter. But if Christ is to take fully the place of the first Adam, he must stand, where the other fell. He must honour the law by a perfect obedience, even under the most trying temptation, where the first Adam dishonoured it by disobedience. And when he had gained a complete victory over temptation, and stood firm and steadfast in his obedience, then the first part of his work would have been accomplished. It will then remain for him to expiate the guilt of the first Adam, and of his posterity, by bearing the wrath of God poured out without mixture.
Now, had this first part of the necessary work of the Saviour been
223
fully accomplished? Some may point to his temptations in the wilderness as the complete vanquishing of Satan. But is it so? Are we not expressly told at the termination of that conflict, "then the devil leaveth him for a season?" Can we regard that encounter in the desert, at the very beginning of the Saviour's public ministry, as having exhausted all the powers of the tempter?
Does not the Saviour distinctly tell his disciples, only a little while before this scene in Gethsemane begins, that "the prince of this world cometh, and hath nothing in me?"
If, then, it may be supposed that a final struggle would take place between the tempter and the tempted, we may be assured that Satan would do his best to retrieve his former defeat. It is hell's last opportunity. The three years of our Lord's public ministry have satisfied Satan, if he may be supposed to have had any doubts about it before, when he said, "if thou be the Son of God," that this was truly that seed of the woman which was to bruise his head. Hence we may conceive of him as bringing all his power and hellish malice to bear upon the Saviour's mind. Horrible blasphemies fill the ear of the pure and holy Son of God. Wicked suggestions come in swarms. His soul is filled with them. He turns from them with intensest loathing; and prays that this cup—unknown until tasted—may pass from him. But the prayer is not answered. His soul, yearning for kindred sympathy in these most trying circumstances, seeks it at the hands of his chosen disciples. But they are sleeping; and thus incapable of ministering the needed sympathy. Satan intensifies his assault. With a deeper anguish the Saviour a second time prays that he may be spared a further infliction of this cup; but again adds, "Not as I will, but as thou wilt." A second time he is impelled to seek some fellowship from his again sleeping disciples. An angel appears strengthening him, in answer to the prayers which he had offered up with strong crying and tears; fearing, it may be, that his bodily powers might sink under the accumulated load that he was bearing. But the final onset is as unsuccessful as either of the preceding. Satan is completely vanquished by the Saviour, not for himself only, but for man. Hell has summoned all its powers for the last testing engagement; and has been ignominiously defeated by the Saviour, single-handed and alone! Our Jesus has triumphed over the combined powers of the realm of darkness! The agony is over. The victory is won. And the Saviour returns to his disciples, calm and composed, to meet the approaching band of the traitor.
In support of this view of the probable cause of the Saviour's agony in the garden, it may not be out of place to notice the language of his prayer. It is "let this cup pass from me"—(Tōuro seems here to be emphatic). But when, a little afterwards, he is seized by the armed band under Judas, he says to Peter, "the cup which my father hath given me to drink, shall I not drink it?" He here evidently makes a distinction between the cup his father had given him to drink, and the cup which was pressed to his lips in Gethsemane, and concerning which he prayed that it might pass from him.
If, on the other hand, he had been drinking in the garden of the cup which his father had given him to drink, on what psychological principles
can we account for the sudden change in his spirits and conduct? When he comes to his disciples the last time; when he meets those who had come out to apprehend him, he appears perfectly calm and self-possessed. But if he has just been engaged with, and has finally and for ever vanquished his and man's great foe, we may more easily understand his calmness and serenity, as he goes forward to meet the new form of trial which awaits him. Having met and vanquished Satan, he says to his human enemies, "this is your hour and the power of darkness."
Then, too, when he comes to the three disciples and found them sleeping, he mournfully says to them, "What, could ye not watch with me one hour? Watch and pray, that ye enter not into temptation." How peculiarly appropriate that word "temptation," if he himself were then truly in conflict with the tempter.
If the Saviour were drinking of the bitter cup of divine wrath, in the garden, we can scarcely think of an angel being sent to strengthen him. He is not forsaken of his Father in the garden. On the contrary, he prays to him to "let this cup" pass from him. There comes a time in his sufferings when the father hides his face, and then the Saviour cries. "Eli, Eli, lama sabachthani." Then his heart breaks with grief, and he gives up the ghost.
If the foregoing suggestions be founded in truth, the final sufferings of the Saviour consisted of three parts, each distinct and separable from one another.
First:—The purely spiritual conflict with Satan; in which all the powers of darkness were defeated. This assault may have been somewhat similar in character, although infinitely more intense, to that which his people are sometimes called to endure. But there was this difference. In the case of his people it is tempered. "He will not suffer you to be tempted above what you are able to bear." In the case of the Saviour, there was no restriction. All that this lower world could do, it did. Its mightiest power was met and overthrown.
Second:—The human element in the conflict. This includes all that his human enemies did, from the time of his arrest until they saw him yield up his spirit. This part of his sufferings is not wholly unknown to his followers. The jeers, the scorn, the ridicule, the ill-treatment, the agonies of death by crucifixion—these have all been experienced, at least partially, by some of his followers.
Third:—The Divine element, the wrath of God; the sword of divine justice smiting God's fellow. This was more than he could bear. He sunk beneath it, broken-hearted.
In what this consisted, it is not given creatures to know. It must ever remain unknown. It was the Eternal Father smiting to death his Eternal Son. Over this the veil must be for ever drawn.
