Menu
‹ Chapter 20 of 201 ›

The Holy Club

17 min read · Chapter 20 of 201

EVEN so enlightened a writer as Mr. Borrow pronounces the eighteenth century to have been "the happy days for Englishmen in general;" for, says he, "peace and plenty were in the land, and a contented population, and everything went well." While not disposed to cross swords with the accomplished traveller, we still maintain that the notion of an uncommon prosperity having been enjoyed during the period in question, though accepted by gipsies, is not believed in by ordinary readers of history. The upper sections of the middle classes probably found it easier to live when there was little competition; and existing mansions, with their spacious gardens, still speak of the quiet ease which could be enjoyed under certain conditions in the days of the first Georges; but were the times such as any reasonable being would wish to recall? In what does national prosperity consist? Was not the eighteenth century a time of moral deadness and of spiritual darkness, a time of retrogression rather than of advancement? The golden opportunities of the Revolution of 1688 were gone for ever, and high promises were not realised. Among politicians patriotism gave place to mere expediency, and, because the influence of Puritanism was wanting, religion flagged, and even threatened to die out of the land. The Dissenters were fast lapsing into a heartless rationalism, while the Established clergy promulgated a morality they did not practise. The children of devoted sires lifted up their voices against being righteous overmuch, and Laodicea was the model church of the period.

In the days of George the Second, when Walpole and Queen Caroline ruled, England greatly needed a Christian leaven of some sort, so that even that which characterised THE HOLY CLUB, which raised its voice at Oxford in 1729, was far better than none at all. There was but little religion abroad, and few to teach the gospel or to exemplify its precepts in their lives; many of the clergy lived scandalous lives, and evangelical preachers were few and far between. Certain advanced philanthropists were beginning to perceive the necessity of founding charity schools, though even these more than half believed that learning was a luxury for well-to-do people, and not a heritage for the multitude at all. The main roads of the country were infested with robbers, who sometimes affected to mix chivalry with their crime. The Jesuits and the Jacobites were alike busy, though the adherents of the Stuart dynasty, since their reverses in 1715, were not able to effect much beyond imparting a feeling of unrest to the political world. It was the golden age of thieving, gipsyism, and crime, and yet the punishment of wrongdoing was never more sanguinary.

It is not difficult to imagine what life must have been in the English

* I. The Oxford Methodists. By Rev. L. Tyerman. Hodder and Stoughton.

II. The Life and Times of the Rev. John Wesley, M.A., Founder of the Methodists. By the Rev. L. Tyerman. Hodder and Stoughton.

III. The Life and Times of the Rev. Samuel Wesley, M.A., Rector of Epworth, and Father of the Revs. John and Charles Wesley, the Founders of the Methodists, By L. Tyerman. Hodder and Stoughton.

79

University cities in such an age. Luxury and indigence, learning and ignorance, reigned in proximity. Every sect outside the Established Church was despised, while the best friends of Anglicanism mourned over the failure of their favourite system to convert the masses. Each university was a rendezvous for the young and the dissipated. Thither resorted fashionable rakes who desired to carry off with a minimum of work the prestige bestowed by a classical training, and to these gentry sports and wine parties constituted the chief attractions of life. Judicious or worldly-wise parents desired to see their sons conform to the reigning order of things, and to avoid being too religious. How incredulously, then, must the town have listened to the news that gay, cultured Oxford had actually set up a prayer-meeting—that young men, whose birth, knowledge, and connections eminently fitted them for a short life and a merry one, had changed pleasure for austerity, and indulgence for religion.

Robert Kirkham, one of the first to join the company, had until latterly known no richer earthly enjoyment than such as belonged to calf's head and bacon, and jugs of the best cider. There was at least this advantage peculiar to the times, those who would be religious were forced to be really in earnest. There were no half-way houses for the accommodation of religious loiterers in 1729. The Holy Club became entirely separate from the great world outside its little circle, social joys were relinquished, and a rigid separation set up. Robert Kirkham, who was moved to forego the delights of good cheer for an ascetic life, was a friend of the Wesleys in their youth, and Robert's fair and accomplished sister Betty very narrowly missed becoming the wife of the founder of Methodism. The characters of both Robert and his sister must have exhibited many interesting points, and hence we regretfully lose sight of them in the dim distance of years. Other names also promised to rise into prominence, but passed away into oblivion. There was W. Morgan, who, dying a monomaniac, was pointed at as a victim of enthusiasm by persons who understood his disease as imperfectly as they did his religion. There was also his brother, Charles Morgan, whom the attractions of the Holy Club drew away from greyhounds and libertines, and made him feel a yearning after higher things. We catch a passing glimpse of one and another, and then they recede, to be hidden from view for ever. The lives of those early Methodists were full of promise; some abundantly fulfilled the most sanguine expectation, and others accomplished little, or never relinquished the pharisaism with which the Club commenced.

The Oxford Methodists, as they first appeared, were a self-denying, self-righteous race. People are necessarily self-denying when they would purchase heaven by their own deeds. It is surely worth a little fasting, toil, and bodily suffering if Paradise can be won by such simple means. Such professors derive much satisfaction from their self-denials, and feel a contentment like that of marketers who give a good price for a good thing. They went about the business of saving themselves with the steady determination of heroism. While their words of prayer and exhortation ascended from prisons, hospitals, and cottages, and while debtors and felons were taught to read their Bibles, these eager workers were themselves unaware of the grand truth that

salvation is by faith in Christ. They were slaves of an ideal standard of righteousness to which they would fain have attained. They fasted and prayed, and were rigorous in their lives, without gaining the peace for which they pined. Yet who may cast a stone at them? They had misread Scripture, and therefore failed to teach the gospel in its fulness, but any men are praiseworthy who in an age of declension witness for the need of religion, and denounce the shameless sins of the community.

Of the Wesleys and Whitefield we will say nothing here, as our aim is only to mention the stars of the second and third magnitude in this article. But those three eminent men were the elect of God to carry out to practical and beneficial results that which the Holy Club could not have compassed by reason of its ignorance of salvation by grace. They outstripped the others in grace as well as gift, and their work abides to this day.

In its earliest days, while all the members were alike in the dark concerning the leading doctrines of religion, a bond of fraternity bound the members of The Holy Club together; but when, in subsequent years, certain members became enlightened an impassable wall of separation rose up between old acquaintances, those who remained high churchmen standing proudly aloof from the more liberal evangelicals. One of the brotherhood, John Clayton, a strict, formal churchman of a severe type, and of a haughty pharisaic spirit, disdained until the end of his days to soil his ecclesiastical linen by associating with the Wesleys after they renounced self-righteousness to lay hold on Christ, and to preach a free gospel to the poor. For such an unsullied being as John Clayton to have stooped to fraternise with companions who officiated in barns, on commons, or even in the streets, would have been too great a condescension. Yet as a man he was surprisingly stedfast in adherence to principle, and scorned to swim with the stream. So strong was his attachment to "The Church," and to the deposed royal family, that he refused to acknowledge the Hanoverian Succession, and was episcopally suspended for taking part in the rising for the Stuarts in 1745. He was stationed at Manchester; and, though Manchester was a comparatively small town in those days, it was not too insignificant to play a part in contemporary history. As we look upon it through the glass of history, one scene after another passes before us in rapid succession. The Rebels think they have a fair chance of reclaiming England for Charles Edward and popery. Music, illuminations, and bonfires give éclat to the Young Pretender's proclamation. Every charm which native beauty and rank can give to the occasion is there! The invader is feted and caressed, praised and encouraged, until he supposes himself to be a chivalrous hero destined to free England from the German yoke. Clouds gather; the war-blast is blown, and reverses overtake what was thought to be a march of triumph. Defiant standards have to be lowered, lights put out, and the heads of leading Jacobites instead of the Stuarts' proud ensign stud the Manchester Exchange. Amid these scenes moves John Clayton, a late member of the Oxford Holy Club. Though he escaped with his head, he never forsook his principles. Bowing to no other sovereign than "James the Third," he would have accounted it a

81

privilege to have been permitted to pluck the beard of "the Hanoverian usurper."

Coming back to the Holy Club, Benjamin Ingham strikes us as a character of another mould. He was one of the early friends of Wesley at Oxford, but in consequence of his seceding to the Moravians, and accepting their doctrines, he partially separated himself from his former associates. During college days he lived a willing captive of the enthusiasm which struck root in the University, and perplexed himself with scruples and questions which would not now-a-days occur to rational men, such as—Was it excusable, if driven by necessity, to sleep in the same house with a Quaker? What should be done if a friend appeared on a fast-day and required you to dispense hospitality? and other such moral dilemmas. To such a man the politics of the day presented few attractions; he was too deeply engrossed with the heavy, self-imposed tasks of fasting, reading, and visiting; and so he remained until the light of a better belief enabled him to rise from the grovelling doctrine of salvation by human merit. Prior to becoming fully enlightened his zeal carried him across the Atlantic to labour among the Indians of Savannah. Subsequently he visited Germany, and extended his acquaintance among the Moravians, who were then attracting notice in England, and upon joining their communion he turned his back on former friends.

In his native county of Yorkshire this intrepid evangelist found his life-work. Being earnestly aggressive, his manner of working gained little favour among Anglican conservatives, who professed to see in ignorance and spiritual blindness the best securities of public order. Squires, parsons, and churchwardens, comfortably fixed in their respective spheres, disliked being startled out of their somnolent habits by the awakening voice of the innovator who purposed giving the benighted peasantry more religion than could be found in the parish church. Bishops also were as prudent in those days as in our own, and in response to popular clamour the Methodist was shut out from the Yorkshire pulpits. In this way dignitaries of the church forwarded the work they desired to suppress by driving the most effective preachers away from the narrow boundaries of ecclesiastical buildings into the fields and highways. We may estimate the power wielded by Ingham and his compeers by the fierce attacks of the newspaper press. The majority of journalists were then violent partisans, each defending his clique by insult and invective, such as are now characteristic of street quarrels. If in our own days an evangelist were reviled by clerical pharisees, and called a visionary, an impious cheat, and a fit subject for Bridewell, and all this in a leading London journal, he would consult his own judgment as to the need of a rejoinder, and would probably find in silence not only the most dignified, but the most telling defence. Preachers, however, could not thus ignore their enemies in the times of George the Second. Though they might succeed in turning Yorkshire upside down, they knew that the missiles of an enraged mob were less dangerous, in one sense, than the insidious charges of unprincipled libellers, and hence the press was both feared and made use of by the early Methodists. The clergy of Yorkshire had, however, other argu-

6

ments in their quiver than such as are usually shot at a venture by literary controversialists. A "Rev. George White," a magisterial vicar, headed a mob, appointed the constable of the parish second officer, and proceeded to break up one of Ingham's congregations, dragging the preacher and one or two others along the street, like common felons, to the hall of justice.

But while the man whose labours resulted in the formation of scores of churches in the largest English county came in for a large share of popular abhorrence, other strange things were happening. What must have been the surprise in aristocratic circles when the news gained currency that a Methodist itinerant who valued faith above earthly possessions, had won the affections of Lady Margaret, a daughter of the Earl of Huntingdon, and furthermore, had actually made Lady Margaret his wife. What, perhaps, made the match still more monstrous in the opinion of gossips, was the happiness of the couple during twenty-seven years. Society was outraged because they did not quarrel like cat and dog. Lady Margaret was a gem of womanhood—one such as not every preacher may hope to win. Who, indeed, can properly estimate the influence of such a woman? She is supposed to have been the means of converting her brother's wife, the Countess of Huntingdon, one of the greatest benefactors of the century.

The saddest reminiscence of Ingham is that he ultimately marred his life-work by imbibing the sentiments of Sandeman, whose heresies were likened to a "Northern blast."

Ingham's contemporary, John Gambold, though a still more unsatisfactory character, died in faith and hope in 1771. Coming out from the Church of England, he joined the Moravians and allowed his fine intellect and liberal education to serve the cause of the erratic Count Zinzendorf, and he did so in days when Moravianism was synonymous with many foolish extravagances.

In his direct association with the early Methodists, Count Zinzendorf makes a considerable figure in the story of the eighteenth century. The Count's family occupied a high position, his father having been a minister of State under the King of Poland. Having been early left an orphan, Zinzendorf enjoyed the acquaintance of Spencer, a celebrated pietist of the times, but, perhaps, he derived still more solid advantage from being placed under the care of Augustus Francke, in the orphan house at Halle. He early showed his enthusiastic nature by instituting among his companions a society called "The Grain of Mustard Seed." This bent of mind being unsatisfactory to his friends, the young scholar was placed at the University of Wittenburge, where it was hoped he would improve in a manner worthy of his brilliant prospects. The Count, however, was not to be diverted from his prescribed course. He held religious meetings, and though opponents say that his life was not free from frivolities, he seems to have been sincerely anxious to arrive at truth. He began preaching when about twenty years of age, and cultivated the friendship of such solid divines as crossed his path. In the fashionable circles among which he moved he was regarded as a phenomenon, and being cultivated, talented, and handsome, was permitted to hold up his head with the highest. At Paris he attracted attention by his able and impressive addresses,

83

though in the age of Voltaire it would have been singular if he had not earned a fair share of ridicule; indeed, his indiscreet zeal secured him his full measure.

When Zinzendorf was in his twenty-second year a change in his life occurred, consequent on one of those inexplicable circumstances which frequently illustrate the workings of Providence. A stranger, belonging to a sect of whom the Count had probably never heard, begged an interview. The stranger—Christian David—told a remarkable story. It appeared that, in spite of the efforts of the Austrians to crush them, the followers of John Huss still lived in Moravia, and on account of the hardships suffered by these poor people, David demanded the Count's sympathy on their behalf. Zinzendorf's enthusiasm was fired, and when some would have given only advice, he volunteered help. He invited the Moravians to settle on his own estate, and hence originated the colony of Herrnhut. The colony increased in numbers, and from being their protector Zinzendorf became their leader and apologist. He was a hard-working and zealous man, and travelled extensively in the cause of the gospel, but when he grew older he contracted strange doctrines and fancies, so that we doubt if his death, in 1760, was not rather a relief than a loss to the Moravian brotherhood. Such was the man and the system with which the Wesleys at one time seemed to be in danger of becoming entangled.

It is agreeable to turn from the mistakes of Moravianism to James Hervey, who, with the exception of Whitefield and the Wesleys, is still the best remembered member of the Oxford Holy Club. The culture and taste of to-day detect many faults in the laboured style of this author, but Hervey pleased the polite ears of his own age, and his fame still survives in the homes of England. He was a gentle creature, overflowing with love and amiability. His mind was delicate and refined, while such was his physical weakness that had he abstained wholly from work no one could have charged him with wanton idleness. At Oxford he ranked high among the pharisaic Holy Club, having been nothing behind the chiefest in his efforts to save himself. He penned elegant letters to extol virtue and self-denial, though he understood little about the Christian life. But such a man could not continue to read the Bible and maintain his acquaintance with Whitefield without arriving at a clearer understanding of religion: his eyes were opened, and with no small joy he perceived that salvation is by faith alone. When the great change occurred Hervey was a young man of twenty-four, residing with a gentleman in Devon, and amid the congenial scenes of the beautiful West, or in the grounds of Hartland Abbey, the first notes were made of the "Reflections" and "Meditations." In his elegant retreat all things conspired to aid the author in his work, and, to crown all, he had a Christian host who prized his society. During three years Hervey discharged the duties of curate of Bideford, winning the love of the people in an eminent degree.

On one occasion we meet with Hervey among the crowd at Bath, whither he may have gone to drink the waters. In that age Bath was the fashionable capital of England, a city where the rich and the gay kept constant holiday. There, as a prince among pleasure-seekers, was found Richard Nash, surnamed the "Beau." Envied and admired

by weak persons like himself, and pitied by others, the celebrated fop was not overlooked by the observant curate, who wrote him a letter of faithful warning, such as few pleasure-hunters are privileged to receive. Hervey alluded to a case of too-late repentance, a striking scene witnessed by himself. "I remembered you, sir," wrote the earnest curate, "for I discerned too near an agreement and correspondence between the deceased and yourself. They are alike, said I, in their ways, and what shall hinder them from being alike in their end? The course of their actions was equally full of sin and folly, and why should not the period of them be equally full of horror and distress? I am grievously afraid for the survivor, lest, as he lives the life, so he should die the death of this wretched man, and his latter end should be like his." The effect produced on the gambling devotee of fashion was probably transient, though the letter was not destroyed.

Leaving the West, Hervey became curate to his father, whom he finally succeeded, and hence we associate his life with Weston Flavel. We see him in Northamptonshire surviving from year to year, with his life hanging on a thread, and often apparently not worth a day's purchase. His usual circle of acquaintance was limited, for such a man's friendship was not courted by the indifferent clergy, nor did Hervey, with his fragile body and retiring nature, see aught attractive in the society of roystering county gentry. Death literally stood by while he worked, but the overshadowing night of the grave only stimulated him to more earnest effort. He distributed his entire literary profits in charity.

Certain restoratives for consumptives effective of good in the present day were unknown a century ago, and the most eminent physicians were powerless to relieve Hervey's disorder. Bleeding and change of air were perhaps the two most popular remedies in vogue. In 1750 Hervey removed to London to try what the metropolitan air would do for his drooping system, and here he tarried at the house of Mr. Whitefield and other distinguished friends.

After his father's death Hervey, by succeeding to the livings of Weston Flavel and a neighbouring parish, gave the enemy some reason to reflect on his conduct as a pluralist. He acted conscientiously, however, and was beloved by the poor parishioners, to whom he preached effectively without notes. In looking back on the life-work of a man like this, the matter for wonder is that one so debilitated should have been enabled by grace and strength of will to battle against weakness, and to make five talents gain five others in a manner which would reflect credit on the strongest. Though in his latter years an unfortunate misunderstanding separated Hervey and Wesley, the rector is still accounted a chief among that noble band of Methodists who, in the gloomiest period of a dark century, first groped out of darkness themselves, and then set up lamps for others. While the two greatest preachers of the age laboured to awaken the multitude to a sense of their condition, Hervey's quieter task consisted in placing the gospel before cultivated minds; and the wide difference between ordinary church-goers of that age and our own appears in the fact that our author always supposed his works to be unsuited to the taste and capacity of common people. During many years prior to his death each day might have

85

been considered the last of Hervey's life. Like Baxter he spoke as a dying man to dying men; and his faint spark of life went out, like the final flash of a long-flickering lamp, on Christmas-day, 1758.

Many other names occur of men who, having a zeal for religion, were contemptuously styled Methodists by the wise people of the eighteenth century. Now-a-days, many of these would not differ from ordinary evangelical ministers; but to the dead world in which they lived they were zealots, righteous overmuch. Not that these men were all alike worthy. Some never deviated from the pharisaism in which they set out, and one, in the person of Wesley Hall, lapsed into profligacy and contempt.

To Mr. Tyerman, the industrious historian of Methodism, the reading world is considerably indebted. He is a workman who needeth not to be ashamed, and though exceptions may be taken to some portions of his books, they will win favour from this and from another generation as monuments of patient research. The broad stream of the Methodist Reformation, as inaugurated by Whitefield and Wesley, divided into two heads, representing the theological sentiments of the two leaders; but in Wesleyanism and Calvinism there are more points of agreement than of divergence, and it is well to keep these in the foreground.—G.H.P.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate