The Ritualism of Nonconformity — By Vernon J. Charlesworth
THE Ritualistic practices of a large and powerful section of the Established Church have provoked the indignant hostility of the Evangelical party of the same communion, who accuse them of acting contrary to the rules of the church. But while the Book of Common Prayer remains the standard of appeal, its elasticity is such that each party may claim its sanction for the peculiar doctrines which they hold and teach, and the form of worship they adopt. The Sacramentalists have as great a right to maintain an ornate ritual as the Evangelicals have to adopt a service which their opponents pronounce bald. In the present condition of affairs it is impossible to decide the controversy for the angry disputants, and were it not that the Establishment owes its existence to an Act of Parliament passed by the popular vote, and, moreover, claims to embrace every citizen in the realm, we should have no desire to interfere. Viewing the parties as mere parties, striving for power, we should be content to leave them to the fate of the Kilkenny cats, and rejoice when only the tails remained as the record of the unseemly strife. But it is impossible to remain quiet without incurring grave moral responsibility, since we are involved with the rest of our fellow-citizens in the doings of this national church. We must, therefore, use every legitimate influence to relieve the nation of a system which is fatal to the peace of the community, and inimical to the interests of Christianity. We have been too tolerant of the abuse of those monopolies which our forefathers conceded by Act of Parliament; and, as reform is impossible, we must cancel those monopolies, and thus terminate the wrongs under which we are made to suffer. The patronage, endowment, and control of the church of Christ by a Parliament which may be pagan or infidel, is a grievance which every disciple of Christ feels, and every honest citizen should refuse to maintain. The Establishment, like the deadly upas, has flung its shadow over the entire nation, and its withering influence has been injurious to true spiritual life; but the axe is laid to the root of the tree, and, despite the pathetic plea of those whose interests have grown up beneath its noxious shade—
"Woodman, spare that tree
Touch not a single bough;
In youth it sheltered me,
And I'll protect it now,"
171
the well-aimed blows of freedom's champions will hurl it to the ground, and its fall shall redound to the glory of God. This is the ultimate issue of our Nonconformity, and we dare not rest until our prophecy shall become historic fact, and the church shall be free.
While conceding to all men the liberty to worship God according to the dictates of conscience, enlightened by the word of God, we are constrained to urge a kindly remonstrance when we have reason to believe that they are not acting under such influence. As the Episcopalians have surrendered their freedom by subscription to the legal formularies of their church, remonstrance is vain as far as they are concerned. But many of our Nonconformist friends, who are under no such yoke, are in danger of allowing their liberty to approach licence, and to them we venture to propose a few questions with the view of eliciting the fact that the spirit of Ritualism which they deplore in the State Church animates several of their cherished customs. We are free to admit that in some instances these customs are maintained without due regard to their significance, and that the imputation of priestly assumption will be met with an emphatic denial; still, this does not weaken our argument, for we contend that it is highly impolitic to lend our sanction to anything which savours of priestcraft. A jealous regard for the glory of God and the freedom of conscience necessitates our abstinence from practices which may in themselves be lawful if it can be shown that they are not expedient. The protest which we are called upon to utter against sacerdotalism must not be weakened by compromise, or by partial indulgence in the same evil. The watchword "No truce with Rome," means, also, no friendship with Rome's allies; and the cry of "No Popery" can only be consistently urged when its ritualistic germs have been uprooted from the soil of our Nonconformity.
1. I would ask, in the first place, Is not the Lord's Supper deprived of its apostolic simplicity, and a mysterious importance attached to it, when the minister is separated from the people by a communion rail? Is not this essentially ritualistic? There can be no doubt that the rail is a relic of the Romish church, and is a symbol suggestive of priestly position and power. While the members of churches allow themselves to be excluded from the charmed circle, they are mere recipients, and not communicants, in the truest sense of the word, and the doctrine of the equality of believers is practically ignored. The minister who is thus separated from the people occupies a position which our Lord never claimed, for he sat at the table with the twelve, and so familiar was his intercourse with them that one of them leaned on his breast at supper. To receive the elements from the hand of a minister, who is railed off from the people, or from a priest bedecked with the sacerdotal vestments of the Romish church, is the same in principle. In each case priestly functions are conceded to the celebrant. That considerable importance is attached to the position of the minister is proved by the fact that lay members are seldom permitted to occupy it; and, in most cases, when a church is without a settled pastor they will forego the privilege of the Lord's Supper for a time, unless the services of a recognised minister can be secured. That our Wesleyan brethren still maintain the humiliating custom of compelling the
worshipper to kneel outside the communion rail to receive the elements is a sufficient proof of our assertion, that some Nonconformists are not clear of the charge of sacerdotalism. One of the purposes intended by the Lord's Supper is to assert and illustrate the "oneness of the body of Christ," and any ritual which obscures this doctrine is fraught with danger to Christian liberty. The table should be placed in such a position that the worshippers may surround it, and thus assert their equality in Christ while enjoying the social feast. To avoid anything like disorder, or unseemly conduct, it is desirable that the pastor should preside, but this concession should lend no sanction to the assumption of priestly prerogative.
2. Are not the vestments worn by many Nonconformist ministers an indication that they claim to be an exclusive body, charged with the performance of certain functions which they alone are competent to discharge? Hotel waiters and undertakers may don a white tie without exciting any special remark; the custom has no significance with them; but a minister wears it not merely as a badge of distinction, but as a symbol of personal sanctity and priestly office. Had not the white cravat been used as a badge of clerical office, our Nonconformist ministers would never have assumed it. We are glad to note, however, that many of them have now given up this priestly rag, and we trust it will soon fall into general disuse. The plea that the people will not be able to distinguish ministers from laymen is an idle one, for it is now a matter of speculation when an individual appears in a white cravat whether he is a minister, a waiter, or an undertaker; and it not unfrequently happens that a shabby preacher is put down as belonging to one of the other persuasions. There are some ministers of our acquaintance whose coat and vest are of the true episcopal cut; perhaps they are doomed to wear them to atone for the incompetence of their laundress, but the probability is that they "magnify their office" in this way. We have come to regard this dress as an assertion of sacerdotal claims, and as an official badge to distinguish clerics from the (so-called) laity. The Geneva gown, with cassock and bands, has no advantage to justify its use, and is only admissible as a badge of academical distinction; and even then its adoption by Nonconformists is a doubtful expedient, from the fact of its association with the corrupt religion of the Romish Church. Those who have no fellowship or sympathy with her abominations should be satisfied with the costume of an ordinary English gentleman. There is nothing so mysterious in the ministerial office as to require a symbolic dress to give it expression, and every true minister will scorn to work upon the fears of the illiterate, or to command their reverence by its assumption.
3. Does not the rigid exclusion of the laity from any part in the conduct of the public services of many churches on the Lord's-day suggest the minister's claim to be the only ordained person competent to their performance? In many churches there are men possessed of gifts in prayer and exhortation equal, and in some cases superior to those of their minister, but they are ignored in his presence, and generally during his absence also. The pulpit must be occupied by an accredited minister, and no mere layman, however gifted, must obtrude
173
within its sacred bounds. Competence is thus sacrificed to status, and power to reputation. The familiar phrases, "Divine service is performed," and "So-and-so officiated to-day," betray the fact that ordinary worshippers concede to the minister the prerogative of a priest. He is regarded as presenting to God the sacrifice of the people's worship; and to such an extent are they influenced by this belief that a large proportion would not enter the place of worship at all if it were known beforehand that brother Jones, the worthy deacon, would give expression to their "prayers and supplications," and address to them "the word of exhortation." Why should not a minister call around him men who have received a divine gift, the exercise of which is essential to "the edification of the body of Christ"? This could be done without detriment to the pastoral office, and probably to the advantage of the pastor himself. While urging this, we disavow all sympathy with that system under which the pastoral office is ignored. "Obey them which have the rule over you, and submit yourselves," is the divine command to the whole brotherhood of Christ.
Although marriage is now a civil contract, the custom obtains generally for the minister to preside at its celebration. The Church of Rome regards it as a sacrament, if her priests sanction the bond, and this accounts for the origin of the desire for a minister to perform the ceremony. On several occasions we have been requested to rush to a neighbouring chapel in time to administer the legal formulae before the fatal hour of twelve, because the minister chosen had failed to keep his engagement, and the bridal pair would not consent to be married without a minister. In many cases weak-minded Dissenters elect to be married according to the rites of the Established Church, in order to secure the services of a regular priest. In this way the people themselves are responsible for supporting the sacerdotal claims of the clergy and maintaining the ritualism of Dissent. We, of course, admit the desirability of marriage being "sanctified by the Word of God and prayer," but we strongly oppose the assumption that the presence of a minister is a sine qua non.
In our judgment, the minister is no more competent to administer the ordinance of baptism than any godly member of the church, and to concede the claim that he is so, ascribes to him a power to which he has no especial right. We do not urge this to weaken the legitimate influence of a truly gifted pastor, but to point out the fact that the spirit of ritualism still animates the custom which our churches sanction, a custom fraught with danger to our Christian liberty. All honour to the men whom God has called to the ministry, and upon whom the gift of the Holy Ghost has been bestowed; let them guard their office with a holy jealousy; but let us not tolerate an assumption of power by which they claim to have "dominion over our faith."
4. Is it not of the nature of ritualism to regard a place of worship as a sacred building, from which fact a certain importance is attached to worship therein, which it would not otherwise possess? Do not our ministers lend their sanction to this belief when they sacrifice the utility of a building to its ecclesiastical character, and call it the "house of God"? "The place of assembly," or "meeting house," is a far more appropriate name than either "church" or "chapel."
Beautiful architecture and artistic decorations tend to divert the thoughts of the worshipper from the one object of worship, and often prevent the soul from rising on the wings of faith to the "place where God's honour dwelleth." The present dispensation takes its character from the fact that God has set aside those sanctities of time, of person, and of place, which were the prominent features of the old. We have no hallowed days but the Lord's-day, no sacred priest but Jesus, and no holy place but heaven. To rise to the height of true spiritual worship we must "look not at the things which are seen, but at the things which are not seen." Music, and painting, and sculpture are not essential to true devotion, but too often engross the soul and degrade the worshipper into a mere sensuous devotee. The writer of the beautiful hymn, "Nearer to Thee," expresses our thought of worship in the following lines:—
"And when on joyful wing
Cleaving the skies,
Sun, moon, and stars forgot,
Upward I rise;
Still, all my song shall be,
Nearer, my God, to thee,
Nearer to thee."
"Boldness to enter into the veil" is a privilege to which many are strangers—the decorous observance of ceremonials being their chief concern. It is to be feared that multitudes of so-called worshippers never rise to the apprehension of God as the object of worship, and fail to realise the priestly ministry of the Lord Jesus Christ.
We have been present at the service in splendid cathedrals and elaborate churches without experiencing the thrill of a holy emotion, and we have enjoyed hallowed seasons of true worship in conventicles, innocent of ornament or beauty, and have often been lifted heavenwards by a simple service in a humble cottage. "Ye are God's house," believers, and he recognises no other. The place of worship is "where two or three are gathered in the name of Jesus," the gathering in his name being the only condition which commands his presence. In the apostolic days separate buildings for worship were unknown, if we except the Jewish Synagogue, hence we read of the "church in the house." Nowadays the order is reversed, and people speak of "going out to church." Why? Because they have been taught to believe that an appointed, if not a consecrated place, and an ordained minister are essential to the acceptance of their worship. All this is of the nature of ritualism; freedom is surrendered to usurped authority, and the conscience is degraded by the arts of priestcraft. "I speak as unto wise men; judge ye what I say."
[Our friend Mr. Charlesworth has written with characteristic warmth of heart upon a subject which needs ventilation. He has not exhausted the subject, nor perhaps written upon it with exactness enough to screen him from criticism, but his paper will serve as a first shot to commence the battle. Mr. Charlesworth is best acquainted with Congregational churches, and others of that fashion, hence much of what he has written will not apply to Baptists: but we also have quite enough of this Ritualism in other forms, and we purpose in a future
173
paper to bare our sword against it. There is good reason for asking concerning many practices—Are these scriptural or are they only traditions of the fathers? A little ritualism in one generation may develop into downright Popery in a few years, therefore it is well to take these things as they arise, and crush them in the bud. So far as we are personally concerned, our abomination of priestcraft is so intense that we would rather be called "demon" than "priest."—ED.]
