Menu
‹ Chapter 18 of 193 ›

Camp Meetings;

21 min read · Chapter 18 of 193

AND

"DAYS OF POWER IN THE FOREST TEMPLE."

BY PASTOR J. L. KEYS, OF STREATHAM.

(SECOND PAPER.)

IN the remarkable autobiography of Lorenzo Dow, who was one of the originators of the Methodist Camp Meetings, there are two tractates written by this singular man, one "On Camp Meetings," the other, "A Defence of Camp Meetings." One sentence in the former is an instance of the ingenuity sometimes displayed by preachers in wrenching a few words of Scripture out of their connection to prove their point. Lorenzo having ransacked the Bible for passages to prove the divine appointment of Camp Meetings, finds in the then widespread opposition to them, by professor and profane, a conclusive argument for their scripturalness; our readers will appreciate his logic:— "Just before the consummation of all things, when Satan is loosed, a

'falling away takes place, the wicked compass the camp of the saints,' which could never happen if they had no camp."

These words (Rev. xx. 9) having been thus used by such an authority on the subject, we feel quite at liberty to employ them, "by way of accommodation," as our text at this time.

"They compassed the camp of the saints about." It will plainly appear, by reference to the passage before us, that no allusion is here made to the professing church. Nevertheless, in our consideration of the causes which contributed to the disuse of Camp Meetings, we must not omit to mention the determined opposition of many of the leaders of Methodism, and the dislike of the lovers of "the proprieties" to the wild fire which characterised much of the revival of the time, and even to the zeal which shamed their sloth. The truth in our text will, however, be best illustrated by the fact that the openly profane were the greatest enemies of the "Camp of the Saints," as the following incidents, from among many of the same kind, will abundantly prove. "The Backwoods' Preacher" must here be permitted to tell his own story.

"Our last quarterly meeting was a Camp Meeting. We had a great many tents, and a large turn out for a new country, and perhaps there never was a greater collection of rabble and rowdies. They came drunk, and armed with dirks, clubs, knives, and horsewhips, and swore they would break up the meeting. After interrupting us very much on Saturday night, they collected early on Sunday morning, determined on a general riot. At eight o'clock I was appointed to preach. About the time I was half through my discourse, two very fine dressed young men marched into the congregation with loaded whips, and hats on, and rose up and stood in the midst of the ladies, and began to laugh and talk. They were near the stand, and I requested them to desist, and get off the seats; but they cursed me, and told me to mind my own business, and said they would not get down. I stopped trying to preach, and called for a magistrate. There were two at hand, but I saw they were both afraid. I ordered them to take these men into custody, but they said they could not do it. I told them, as I left the stand, to command me to take them, and I would do it at the risk of my life." Cartwright made a dash at one of the ringleaders, who aimed a blow at him with a whip. Cartwright threw him down, and threatened "to pound his chest well if he didn't keep quiet." A rescue was attempted, in which a drunken magistrate took part. Cartwright delivered his prisoner to "a friend of order," and when the justice made a stroke at him he parried it, threw him down, and "jumped on him." There was, in short, a general mêles; "the friends of order" rushed by hundreds on the mob; thirty were taken prisoners, and placed under guard in a tent till the following Monday, when they were then marched off, tried, convicted, and fined. In the meantime, however, order having been restored, an attempt was made to resume the preaching on the Sunday, but no preachers were to be found willing to hold forth. "Seeing we had fallen on evil times," says Peter, "my spirit was stirred within me. I said to the elder, 'I feel a clear conscience, for under the necessity of the circumstances we have done right; and now I ask you to let me preach.' 'Do,' said the elder, 'for there is no other man on

55

the ground can do it.' The encampment was lighted up, the trumpet blown, I rose in the stand and required every soul to leave the tents and come down into the congregation. There was a general rush to the stand. I requested the brethren, if ever they prayed in all their lives, to pray now. My voice was strong and clear, and my preaching was more of an exhortation and encouragement than anything else. My text was, 'The gates of hell shall not prevail.' In about thirty minutes the power of God fell in every direction, right and left, front and rear. It was supposed that not less than three hundred fell like dead men in mighty battle, and there was no need of calling mourners, for they were strewed all over the camp ground; loud wailings went up to heaven from sinners, and a general shout from Christians, so that the noise was heard afar off. Our meeting lasted all night, and Monday, and Monday night, and when we closed on Tuesday there were two hundred who had professed religion, and about that number joined the church."

On another occasion, at a large Camp Meeting, he adopted very different tactics in dealing with the rowdies. Knowing that a gang was present, bent on mischief, and learning who were the ringleaders—two brothers, "sons of fine members of the Methodist Episcopal Church"—he went to one of the brothers, and told him he wanted his help in keeping order, saying, "These rowdies are all afraid of you; and if you will help me, you shall be captain, and choose your own men." "He said he did not want to engage in that way; but if I would not bind him up too close, but let him have a little fun, a way off, he would then promise me that we should have good order in the encampment through the meeting.

"There came into the congregation a young, awkward fellow, that would trespass on our rules by seating himself all the time among the ladies. It was very fashionable at that time for the gentlemen to roach their hair; and this young man had a mighty bushy roached head of hair. I took him out several times from among the women, but he would soon be back again. I told J. P. I wished he would attend to this young man. 'Very well,' said he; and immediately sent off and got a pair of scissors, and planted his company about half a mile off; then sent for this young fellow, under the pretence of giving him something to drink. When they got him out there, two of them, one on each side, stepped up to him with drawn dirks, and told him they did not mean to hurt him if he would be quiet; but if he resisted or halloed he was a dead man. They said they only wanted to roach his hair, and put him in the newest Nashville fashion. The fellow was scared almost to death, but made no resistance whatever. Then one with the scissors commenced cutting his hair, and it was haggled all over at a masterly rate. When they were done shearing him they let him go, and he came straight to the camp-ground. Just as he entered it, I met him; he was pale as a cloth. He took off his hat, and said, 'See here, Mr. Cartwright, what them rowdies have done!' I had very hard work to keep down my risibilities; but I told him he had better say nothing about it; for if he did they might serve him worse. He soon disappeared, and interrupted us no more during the meeting."

These are not exceptional stories; the former scene was often

repeated. The rowdies would frequently lay their plans with the determination of breaking up the assemblies. They would have their waggons and tents for whisky shops and groggeries, and there were plenty of fellows of the baser sort to vend eatables, tobacco, and cigars. Every precaution was taken by the leaders to preserve order, by securing the services of constables, and sometimes a magistrate, or a sheriff or two, but on more than one occasion these worthies fraternised with the roughs rather than with the quiet and orderly part of the assembly; and on one occasion Cartwright took a magistrate into custody, and had him tried and fined. On a subsequent occasion, he having seized a very violent fellow, "jerked him over the waggon-bed, in which he was standing, among his whisky-harrels, and, as he fell, jumped on him," then informed him that if he did not surrender he would hurt him; the deputy-sheriff came up, and ordered Cartwright to let his prisoner go, threatening to knock him over, if he did not do so. "I told him," says Peter, "if he struck to make a sure lick; for the next was mine. An officer then commanded me to take this deputy-sheriff, and I did so. They marched him off with thirteen of the mob and the whisky-seller, and had them tried and fined. Doubtless there were many then as now, who would gravely question the propriety of Peter's conduct in taking the law into his own hands, whereas by the divine law it was enjoined that members of the church militant should be 'no strikers,' but this true successor of the apostles did not always realise the immediate presence of his Lord, and, like his great namesake, he used arguments which made the ears of his Master's foes to tingle, such as the Master himself would have forbidden; but we may well pardon any misguided zeal in the modern instances, as the Saviour did in the case of his early disciple; for our Peter himself confessed that although a believer in the theory of entire sanctification, he, at the time of these occurrences, was only sanctified 'in spots.'"

We must now leave this part of our subject, as we can find no record of Camp Meetings later than 1841, at which the riot just described took place. In 1844, the subject of slavery greatly agitated the Methodist Episcopal Church, and "the great secession" took place. We think it may be assumed that from this period there was a general falling off in Camp Meetings, which some years later elicited the following lament from Peter Cartwright:—"I am sorry to say that the Methodist Episcopal Church of late years, since they have become numerous and wealthy, have almost let Camp Meetings die out. I am very certain that the most successful part of my ministry has been on the camp ground. There the Word of God has reached the hearts of thousands that otherwise, in all probability, never would have been reached by the ordinary means of grace. Their practicability and usefulness have, to some extent, been tested this year, 1856, in my district, Pleasant Plains; and I greatly desire to see a revival of Camp Meetings in the Methodist Episcopal Church before I go hence and am no more, or before I leave the walls of Zion. Come, my Methodist brethren, you can well afford to spend one week in each year, in each circuit or station, on the tented field. But there must be a general rally; it will be but a small burden if there is a general turn out; but if a few only tent, it will be burdensome, and will finally destroy Camp Meetings altogether."

57

With the changed circumstances of the country, the large growth of cities, the greatly increased facilities for travelling, and the higher respect for law and authority, during the last thirty years, a corresponding change took place in the character of Camp Meetings. When they were held, the difficulties to be overcome no longer arose from the rowdy element, but from a more refined species of worldliness; the opposition was not avowed, nay, the very idea of opposition would have been scouted. Public opinion had altered, but the enemy of all good works had merely modified his tactics to meet the different circumstances of the case, he had transformed himself into an angel of light; but his success was no less marked than when his myrmidons were most pronounced in their determination to stop the work of God. "Camp Meetings had become, to a large extent, places of recreation and pleasant social intercourse. Families secured their tenting-ground, put up swings for their children, arranged for the favourite croquet-game, and, in short, prepared for a week or ten days' relaxation in the grove. All this was very agreeable in its social and recreative features; but giving it the name of a Camp Meeting was a misnomer: and then the spirit of speculation was rife. Perhaps some weak society had a debt on their church or parsonage, or found it difficult to support a minister and pay other expenses; and they resolved to hold a Camp Meeting to help them out of their dilemma. Hence, the letting of privileges to keep boarding-tents, or stands for the sale of confectionery and tobacco, to the highest bidders. Unconverted men and nominal professors of religion were quick to avail themselves of the opportunities afforded to make money, and were not scrupulous oftentimes as to the means. The law of the Sabbath was shamefully violated at some of these meetings. On that holy day the country for miles around was in an uproar. Ice-cream and other unnecessary things were freely sold on that as on other days of the week; and the scene bore close analogy to Buayan's picture of Vanity Fair. Ministers, too, were carried away by the current. They were to be seen at the tent-door, or in the grove, smoking cigars, and engaged in jocose conversation; and this, perhaps, while a handful of devoted men and women were struggling to conduct a prayer-meeting in front of the stand, with earth and hell arrayed against them. It is needless to say that conversions were rare on those occasions, and the work of sanctification small indeed. Here and there were honourable examples of Camp Meetings being run on different principles, and where a good degree of saving work was accomplished, but they were exceptions."

While many, in view of this state of things, were asking the question, "Whether Camp Meetings had not better be wholly abandoned?" there were others who saw in the institution a means of promoting the revival of doctrine and practice, the neglect of which they deplored. Believing that "the doctrine of ENTIRE HOLINESS was the great peculiarity of Methodism, and that it was her divinely ordered province to spread it throughout the land," they gave marked prominence to it in their ministrations, and sought the sympathy and co-operation of kindred minds in "reviving their peculiar work in the recollection of their people," and thus "marshalling them for noble advances."

We must here let the author of "Days of Power" give in his own words the account of the rise and progress of the "National Camp Meeting movement," reminding our readers that we are not discussing the doctrines enunciated, but merely giving a general history of the peculiar institution itself.

In 1867 a meeting of "ministers and laymen favourable to holding a Camp Meeting, the special object of which shall be the promotion of the work of entire sanctification," was convened by circular in the Methodist Book Room, Philadelphia. The call was very explicit. It was not to be an open question. The desirability and practicability had already been settled in the study of Rev. J. S. Inskip, New York. The meeting was simply to determine time and place, and make arrangements.

We can only afford space for a few sentences from the record of the day's proceedings at "The First Council." To irreverent ears they will sound rather spread-eagley, but such must bear in mind that the people whose national emblem is the eagle, are capable of higher flights of language than those whose escutcheon can only boast a sleepy old lion. The preliminary meeting is thus described:—

"Hallowed memories cluster around the council-chamber at 1018, Arch-street, Philadelphia. The morning of Thursday, June 13, 1867, will never be forgotten. It was an auspicious morning. A holy atmosphere seemed to pervade the room. The rustle of angels' wings was almost perceptible to mortal ear. The presence of the triune God—Father, Son, and Holy Ghost—was distinctly apprehended. Every face was bright; every spirit was joyous. Never did good men grasp each other more warmly by the hand. Who composed that assembly? Brother Osborn was there, ready to stand in his lot, and never more satisfied than that this was of God. The time-honoured Dr. Roberts occupied his place, his countenance glowing with delight. . . . Rev. J. S. Inskip shouted aloud the praises of God as he grasped each fraternal hand: he was full-nerved for the battle. The presiding elder, Rev. W. E. Belfard, genial, kind-spirited, determined, was in the company. The beloved disciple—our now ascended brother, Rev. A. Cookman—with his saintly face and dignified mien, was ready to be consecrated on this altar. . . . There was also mingling in that convocation a tall form, with a thoughtful countenance and martial bearing, looking as if he could lead valiant troops into action: that was Rev. Ruliff V. Lawrence, now ascended, like the beloved Cookman, to 'the palace of angels and of God.' After describing, in a similar style, an earnest prayer, the writer says, "A solemn awe rested upon the whole company. A divine hush was upon every spirit. The wealth of eternity was in every bosom," &c., &c., &c.

VINELAND, thirty miles below Philadelphia, was the scene of the first Holiness Camp Meeting. It is a town with a population of about ten thousand, "characterised by intelligence, culture, and social refinement." No place for the sale of intoxicating liquors is allowed within its precincts. It has, in the strongest form, a Prohibitory Law. The encampment was located in a city park, so called, embracing about forty acres. A large bower was constructed, covered over with branches of trees, and a very large tent was also

59

erected, and every arrangement made for the comfort and convenience of the assembled thousands. The entire programme is not given, for the writer has seen fit to describe the proceedings at this and the subsequent meetings, year after year, under different topical chapters, and we must follow his plan for brevity's sake, merely giving here a few sentences from the description of the Dedicatory Service as a sample of the high-flown style in which the entire work is written. "The morning had come. It was a morning to which thousands had looked with profoundest interest. In every part of the land, in unnumbered Christian homes, VINELAND was in devout minds; and on its behalf many prayers were ascending to heaven. It was a clear, beautiful morning. A bright July sun was shining upon the encampment. Recent rains had fallen opportunely. A genial atmosphere pervaded the forest temple. The encompassing tokens were full of promise. The people were summoned to gather around the consecrated stand. It was a thrilling hour. . . . Methodists, Presbyterians, Baptists, Congregationalists, Episcopalians, and Friends, sat side by side, and awaited the first note with almost breathless interest. Every heart was beating in holy unison. They waited in solemn stillness. Angels on poised pinions were just above the worshippers. At length Rev. J. S. Inskip stepped forward, according to appointment. A divine commission was on his brow. The sound of his Master's footsteps was behind him. The light of heaven was in his eye; his countenance was full of joy; his tread was firm; his voice clear and strong. He struck the key-note, which sent its vibrations into the depths of every soul. THE BATTLE HYMN, now for ever memorable in camp meeting history, was sung.

'There is a fountain filled with blood,' &c.

The voices of holy men and women caught it up, and rolled it grandly upon the July air. It swept through the park like a tide of heavenly melody. It really seemed as though the celestial orchestra was joining in the glad song. From that moment 'The blood, the blood, the blood of the Lamb,' became the rallying cry, and to this standard the hosts of God's elect, of every name, have been steadily crowding to their places at the front, to join in the mightiest conflict with sin and hell that the world has ever seen."

We are willing to believe that our good taste, or rather the want of it, is at fault in our failure to enjoy this style of stating the simple fact that a good earnest brother gave out a well-known hymn; but we trust we may at least be pardoned for observing that we are glad the "Acts of the Apostles" was not written by so eloquent a brother, otherwise a fourpenny Testament, or even a five shilling one, would have been for ever an impossibility. We must not digress, however, but continue our extracts from the records before us.

The Vineland meetings lasted more than a week, and were so great a success that arrangements were made for a similar gathering at Manheim the following year, 1868. At this meeting "three hundred ministers, and, on one particular day, twenty-five thousand persons were present, and yet the most perfect order prevailed." In 1869, Round Lake, New York, was selected, a very lovely spot. On the

shore of the lake is a thickly shaded grove, "and there is an abundant supply of spring water distributed through the avenues in pipes." In the interval between the Round Lake meeting and the next annual campaign funds were collected for the purchase of a monster tent, to be the property of the Association, that the meetings might not suffer through unfavourable weather. This tent, or "The Tabernacle," as it was named, was ninety feet wide and one hundred and thirty feet long, and would accommodate three thousand persons; its cost was between four and five hundred pounds. In 1870, so great was the interest taken in the previous meetings, that three meetings were held at different places. In 1871 one of the meetings was held, "by special invitation, at the hospitable residence of R. Pearsall Smith, of Philadelphia, a brother beloved in this holy warfare." In 1872, "a grand programme was marked out for this year. Many were startled by the announcement of six national Camp Meetings." This is the latest period to which the accounts before us are brought down; we therefore proceed to extract from each of the different chapters a few items, and leave our readers to judge of the present aspect of the revived Camp Meeting movement in America.

POWER IN THE FOREST PULPIT.—Under this head we have outlines of very many of the discourses. These have, by a strict adherence to the object of the Association, always been on the one theme of holiness; and the following are some of the utterances taken from the whole range of the meetings, "at which," says our author, "no new theory was to be advanced, but simply a reiteration of the old Bible doctrine, as taught by Mr. Wesley and others."

Rev. J. Inskip, "proceeding to consider the way of entering upon this exalted state, repudiated strongly the growth theory, faith being the sole condition. In defining the faith by which we are entirely sanctified, he inquired, What are we to believe? and took occasion to expose certain prevailing errors. We are not, as some say, to believe that we are sanctified. Nothing can be more absurd than to say that we must believe that we are, in order that we may be sanctified."

In another sermon the same preacher "defined entire sanctification to be the acceptance, this moment, of Jesus as a full and perfect Saviour. The advantages of this spiritual condition were twofold. First, purity, the soul being made whiter than snow. Second, regular and continuous growth, growth in the knowledge and love of Jesus Christ."

Rev. J. S. Parker, at the same meeting, said, "When the work of entire purity was wrought, the uprisings of carnality were no longer felt, and the graces existed without alloy."

Rev. Dr. Reilly, on "Growth in Grace," "showed that all carnality must be removed from the nature in order to a true and rapid growth in grace. He concluded with a thrilling relation of his own experience of the blessing."

We are not favoured with an outline of any address by Mr. R. Pearsall Smith, but another well-known name appears in this connection, that of Dr. Boardman, "in whose hands the last public service at Des Plaines was placed. The terms used [in his discourse] differed somewhat from those commonly employed by Methodists,

61

but it was the same blessed doctrine of full salvation." So much for the doctrine which formed the staple of the discourses delivered. A long chapter is next devoted to a detail of the results of such preaching, under the head of "sanctifying power in the forest temple," in which it is stated that the leaders "have especially aimed to prevent persons who have forfeited their justification by unfaithfulness, and who need to do their first works over again, from mistaking restored justification for entire sanctification." The italics are our own. We are informed that one feature has been "the realisation of sanctifying power by many of God's ministers." As to the vast auditories, hundreds, or perhaps we ought to say thousands, are said to have obtained the like blessing, which they openly declared at love-feasts, or at special periods of the meetings reserved for testimony. The expressions of very many, however show that their experience was very much more orthodox than the theology to which they thought they were so much indebted, for it is very evident their language was that of those who have just realised their interest in Christ, their justification by faith, and the rest that remaineth for the people of God.

At the services especially directed to the work of conversion, among which especial attention was paid to the young, great results were achieved, and we are told that large numbers were savingly converted. We devoutly hope that the increase of spiritual life in the churches there, and the great day itself, may show that the thousands then received a justification they did not afterwards forfeit, but that being really justified freely by his grace they proved the truth of the eternal word: "Whom he justified, them he also sanctified; and whom he sanctified, them he also glorified." To those who believe in a forfeitable justification we would commend the study of this golden chain, and also the injunction, "What God hath joined together let not man put asunder." Far be it from our thoughts even to say one word that would tend to depreciate the work of earnest servants of our Master, much as we may differ from them in our views, not of minor points only, but on questions of gravest import. We can object heartily to style, and mode, and doctrine, and yet more heartily rejoice that Christ is preached; "yes, we therein do rejoice, and will rejoice."

After our previous article was in print, a good brother who was present at some of the meetings has put into our hands copies of the "Advocate of Holiness," the organ of the National Camp Meeting Association, from which we learn that during the year 1873 the meetings have been carried on with even more vigour, and with greater spiritual results, than in preceding years. One untoward event, however, had nearly marred the success of the meetings held at Baltimore. During a terrific storm "the Tabernacle" was blown down, and became a complete wreck. It had travelled not less than twenty-five thousand miles, and become much worn, and the friends were anxiously debating about the necessity of procuring another tent, "when the Lord put an end to all inquiries by putting an end to the Tabernacle. The good people of Baltimore claimed the privilege of furnishing a new one, and raised the money on the spot to do it." "It is estimated," says the writer, "that at the Baltimore meetings more than four hundred souls were converted, and a still larger number sanctified."

We have thus far tried to show the character of Camp Meetings, the causes of their decay, and the efforts at this day being made for their restoration and wider usefulness. Their practicability in America is abundantly proved by recent facts. Of their desirability, not to say necessity, our author well remarks: "No matter how much churches may be multiplied, there will always be masses of people that cannot be reached by ordinary instrumentalities. They will not go to the churches, but they will go to the forest temple, prompted by curiosity or the desire of recreation; and although the motive leading them to the enclosure may be faulty, once there, the truth may pierce their guilty spirits, and their salvation be effected."

In conclusion, more than a passing remark might be thought to be necessary upon the Camp Meetings of our esteemed brethren the Primitive Methodists, more especially as the stirring accounts of the earliest American Camp Meetings which appeared in Methodist magazines, and the labours of Lorenzo Dow in this country, exercised so great an influence upon the founders of the denomination. While admitting to the full the great moral and spiritual results of the open-air gatherings of our Primitive friends "from the first day until now," we have not been able to discover in the History of the Connexion by Mr. Petty any record of a camping-out, in the American sense of the term. In this little island, of which an American is reported to have said that his enjoyment of its natural beauties was greatly marred by his perpetual fear, lest, when he took a walk before breakfast, he might fall off its edge, there can be few localities where remaining night after night in waggons or under canvas would be necessary. Even were it necessary, would it be practicable? How many squires or lords of the manor would welcome to their domain, or even to their neighbourhood, a camp of the "friends of holiness"? Have not they, and oftentimes the "parsons" too, even within the past few years, driven our brethren from the common and the village-green?

Our public parks are free to the votaries of folly, the Sabbath-breaking beau-monde, and the "Sunday bands"; these latter, forsooth, have become institutions, by express sanction of the powers that be; while the preachers of righteousness are banished from "the people's parks." May the Lord hasten the day of which he hath spoken by the prophet, saying, "My tabernacle shall be with them: and the heathen shall know that I the Lord do sanctify Israel, when my sanctuary shall be in the midst of them for evermore."

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate