Notices of Books
The Systematic Bible Teacher. S. W. Partridge and Co., 9, Paternoster-row.
THE editor of this monthly magazine is an enthusiast in Sunday-school work. The plan proposed, if not the best obtainable, is a very good one, and, with some modifications to suit individual schools, will work much good wherever carried out. We wish that catechisms were more used, and we think that much scriptural truth might be conveyed in the hymns, which we like to hear the youngsters constantly sing. The best system, after all, is the growth of love, study, and prayer, rather than of books.
Long Evenings, and Work to do in Them. By Mrs. BAYLY. Author of "Ragged Homes," etc. Nisbet and Co.
MRS. BAYLY speaks very glowingly of the teaching of our deceased friend Mr. John Offord, and thus proves her own clearness of judgment, for he was indeed a great teacher; not so much a preacher to the many as a teacher of those who would in turn teach others. Mrs. Bayly's book is intended for reading to intelligent classes of men or women, who may be got together and interested in the best things. She chats away very pleasantly about Wycliffe and Tyndale, and touches on a great variety of subjects with good sense and piety combined, and a piquante sauce of anecdote to render the whole attractive. We marked two of her little incidents as well worth quoting, and we will append them when we have said that her introductory chapter upon classes for working men strikes us as very useful and suggestive.
"I forget now what led to it, but presently one of the newly arrived said abruptly, 'I don't know what can be the use of talking to people so much about religion, because they say God knows everything, that he has planned who shall be saved and who lost, and therefore it can be of no use taking so much trouble,' and then turning to me, he said, 'I suppose, ma'am, you believe
that God knows and plans everything, and that nothing can be altered?'
"I said, 'I do; I believe he knows how many of us are in this room, and who will get out first; but for all that, supposing I am anxious to catch a train, or for any other reason want to be away as quickly as possible, I shall gather up my books, and get near to the door, so as to be ready to leave the room the moment the meeting is over.' I went on to say, 'I think in the week you employ yourself in shoemaking, for I have seen you at work as I have passed your shop. Now, as you are so much impressed with the thought that God knows and has planned everything, you must suppose he knows how many pairs of boots or shoes you will make in a week; but this belief will not influence you in your actions. You will get up to-morrow morning with the determination of making as many as you possibly can. The same with a merchant; he may believe in God's knowledge of every minute detail of his affairs, even to the number of bales of goods he may sell in a week, but you never hear of a man of business making this an excuse for staying at home and idling away his time. He does not believe that his goods will get sold without exertion on his own part, in making the necessary arrangements.' The man replied, 'Well, that seems clear enough so far, but it is hard to say where things begin and end.' 'Yes,' I said, 'not hard only, but impossible. You have brought before us a great mystery, which divines call "God's sovereignty and man's responsibility." I have not explained it at all, because I do not understand it myself. The only thing which is at all clear to me is that we ought to bring as much common sense to bear upon spiritual as upon temporal things. For whatever kind of riches we may be seeking, we must STRIVE.'"
"There are many who will understand and sympathise with the man who, in returning a book lent him, said, 'I can't say much about the book any way; there's such a bother of words in it, I can't get at anything for the words.'"
337
The Revolt of the Field. By ARTHUR CLAYDEN. Hodder and Stoughton.
A WELL written sketch of the rise and progress of the movement among the agricultural labourers, known as "The National Agricultural Labourers' Union." Its author was the companion of Mr. Arch in his journey to Canada, and the book itself may serve as a guide to the historian who in some future day will show the wondering world how difficult it was to settle questions of plain right in this doubly-dyed conservative land of ours; and what strange pranks before high heaven were played by men who were called Justices of the Peace.
Darwinism and Design; or, Creation by Evolution. By GEORGE ST. CLAIR. Hodder and Stoughton.
IF Darwinism does not exclude, it does not fully include, the argument of Design. It favours the disbelief, rather than the belief, of a great first cause. It reverses the law of cause and effect, and gives a tendency to creation to raise itself in the scale of being, rather than to fall back into its original nothingness. If greater beings are evolved from less, the power must be in them, or given to them; and if in them we have a chain of effects producing causes more powerful than themselves; we cannot accept, therefore, the apology here made for Darwinism in reference to design. It fails, too, in the defence of the theory at the point in which we look for the clearest demonstration; and, like all other writings upon the subject, is weakest where we look for most strength. The difference between organic and inorganic matter, between vegetation and instinct, and between instinct and reason are clearly defined; but it fails to show the transition from one to the other, and to produce examples in which that process is still going on. If it be a law of nature that plants become animals, and animals become men, we ought not to know this from the investigations of science, but in the same way as we know that a seed passes into a plant, an egg into a bird, and an infant into a man. Such writers often serve to confirm us in long-admitted truths by proving their contraries to be absurd.
Sermons on the Epistle to the Galatians. Old Thoughts for New Times. By SAMUEL PEARSON, M.A., Liverpool. James Clarke and Co.
WE do not often see a book in which the truth is at once so fully admitted, and so dreadfully obscured. Not even the doctrine of justification by faith can be let alone, it is stated in so many words, and then explained into the clouds. One leaf of Luther on the Galatians would be worth a pile of these sermons as high as the Monument.
The Holy Catholic Church: the Communion of Saints. By the Rev. BENJAMIN GREGORY. 2, Castle Street, City Road, and 66, Paternoster Row.
THIS is a discourse delivered in connection with the Wesleyan Methodist Conference at Newcastle. It is not, however, either explanatory or laudatory of that one, or of any other, sectional division, but of the whole church of Christ from its first formation to the present time. The true church is shown to consist of all sincere and consistent believers in Christ's gospel; and its distinction as such from the world, from mere professors, and from those who have embraced false systems of Christianity, is clearly stated and defended. It is too sanguine, we think, in its expectations that some form of church government may yet be devised between episcopacy and the independency of individual churches, in which all true Christians may be induced to unite. The same forbearance, it is supposed, and apparent irregularity which was allowed in apostolic times in the extension of the church and in the administration of its ordinances, may lead to the same oneness in distinction from the world, and to the same community of privileges. There may be unity in spirit, in doctrine, and in zeal, without uniformity in church discipline. The uniformity at least must be the effect of these, and must not be sought as the procuring cause. We admire the catholicity of spirit, and the high principles by which this discourse is characterised, and we presume that no person could read it without obtaining some addition to his knowledge of the New Testament from its perusal.
Cautions for Doubters. By the Rev. J. H. TItcombe, B.A. Religious Tract Society.
WE are always pleased to see the works of Mr. Titcombe—those in defence of the Church of England because they are so weak, and those in defence of the gospel because they are so strong. If doubting were but candid inquiry, such works as this would satisfy it, and we trust that with many honest readers this will be the result: but, alas, with the ordinary sceptic argument is useless; his heart is opposed to the gospel and will not be convinced of its truth. Mr. Titcombe has done well to prepare this book of cautions, and those who have sceptical friends will do well to put it in their way. We would commend it in the warmest terms.
The True Text of the Old Testament. By JAS. BRODIE, A.M. Edinburgh: Johnstone, Hunter, and Co.
THE author endeavours to show that the Septuagint is the true standard for the text of the Old Testament. No doubt some difficulties vanish if we adopt it instead of the Jewish version, but on the whole we cannot agree with the author that the proposed new version for the English should be based on what is avowedly itself a translation. We agree in much that is advanced as to the language of the Jews in the time of our Lord; but we deny that in their speech there was much difference, some still using the sacred tongue in the Hebrew, others the Greek, while the mass of the people would speak in a patois allied to the Syriac. Any one who has journeyed in the border cantons of Switzerland will understand how mingled a language may be employed by the same people amongst themselves, and yet they will understand sometimes two, and even three other tongues to some extent, and use them, though not in a scholarly way, yet in a manner sufficient for all practical purposes. A public teacher would employ all the dialects on different occasions as was most desirable, hence, perhaps, some verbal differences in the accounts of our Lord's discourses.
The Young Christian Armed; or, the Duty he Owes to God. A Manual of Scripture Evidence, Faith, and Practice, for Youth. By Rev. CHARLES HOLE. Longmans, Green, and Co.
WHEN Mr. Hole touches upon baptism, he flounders in a fearful manner. Because a child may be regenerated when it is baptised, he justifies the use in every case of the declaration that the child is regenerate. As well argue that because the moon may be at the full we are justified in solemnly declaring that it is. This is bad morality, and is not divinity at all. Putting this aside, we set great store by Mr. Hole's book, and believe that the training of young people in its arguments would go far to restrain the spread of scepticism, and, under God, to raise up a race of well-grounded believers. The chapter upon "The Wages of Sin" is not only Scriptural, but well and forcibly written, the spirit of the book is devout, and its teachings soundly evangelical. For schools in connection with the Church of England the manual is admirably adapted, and it ought to be universally used in them.
A Nation's Right to Worship God. By the Rev. C. HODGE, D.D. Nisbet and Co.
IF it be indeed true that an influential party of Americans are trying to mix up the kingdom of God with the Republican constitution of the United States, we can only say that they are commencing to go backward. We have heard of an epitaph which runs thus: "I was well, I wanted to be better, and here I lie dead;" it would have been far better to leave well alone. The admirable method of leaving the churches to do their work while the government has attended to its own department, has worked so well in the States that only those who are given to change can wish to tamper with it. While men of all religions belong to a nation, the very highest recognition of the God of justice is to do that which is just and right, and the best recognition of the Christian religion is to fashion laws according to its spirit, and to avoid taking the slightest advantage against unbelievers, or making them parties to a profession with which they do not sympathise. This pamphlet is not to our mind at all.
339
A Golden Sunset; being an Account of the Last Days of Hannah Broomfield. By the Author of "Morning and Night Watches." Nisbet and Co.
VERILY book-making is an easy trade now-a-days; you write a memoir of about seventy pages, and then add seventy pages more of hymns, which are in every hymnbook, with the information that the subject of your slender narrative was very fond of them. We should have commended the little narrative, but as it is hardly fair to double the size of the book by tacking on such a quantity of well-known hymns, we shall not be a party to the practice. When half of a book is made up of hymns which everybody knows, it ought to be stated upon the title-page, that buyers may know what they are purchasing.
The Life of Thomas Vasey. By his Widow. Elliot Stock, 62, Paternoster Row.
A CROICE specimen of Wesleyan ministers of the past generation, of whom some remain to this day. If any wish to know of what materials such men were made, let them read this book. It is full of Methodism, but they will forget all that in admiration of untiring zeal, and mental activity, and ready utterance, devoted to the one object of saving souls. They will find here a rare combination of ministerial gifts and graces. There is an adaptation of gospel principles, in mild radiance or in dazzling brightness, and in fact in all the varieties of light and shade, to the pulpit and the platform, the council board and the domestic circle. Though written, or, rather, compiled by his widow, we venture to call it a manly exhibition of true Christian manhood.
The Period of the Reformation. By LUDWIG HAUSSER. Translated by Mrs. G. STURGE. In two volumes. Strahan and Co., 56, Ludgate Hill.
THE whole period over which the Reformation extended, and the whole area which it covered, are historically narrated in these volumes. They differ from D'Aubigné's History of the Reformation as the letter that killeth from the Spirit that giveth life. The work is not,
however, without its use to those who wish for correct and authentic information upon all matters connected with the long and characteristic, but fruitless struggles of the Roman Church to retain its entire ascendancy over the nations of Europe. The same struggle is going on to this day. A State church dies hard, but die it must.
The Modern Avernus. The Descent of England: How Far? A question for Parliament and the Constituencies. Hatchards, Piccadilly.
No one can possibly go further than we do in our detestation of the principles which have always actuated the Church of Rome, and therefore we are altogether opposed to the spirit of this volume. This Junius, whoever he may be, wants to abrogate the Catholic Emancipation Act, and so deprive the Catholics of a portion of their civil rights, because of their religion. This is just what Popery itself would do with Protestants if it were in power, and we should be sorry to believe that any true Christians have become so degraded as to follow such an example. We entertain the most intense disgust for Romanism, but we would not deprive a Romanist of one jot of his just liberties as a man and a citizen. The question of Romanism is not one for the Parliament and the constituencies; let them mind their own business, and religiously let religion alone. Our trust is in the Lord of Hosts, and not in premiers, peers, or Parliaments. Papists are always looking for political power and pickings; give us a genuine revival of religion, and they may do what they like. Our Popish church of England is the great evil of the hour, and as it is a State Church, the State may alter it, and ought to do so; but over free churches the State has no control, and it is essentially unrighteous to clamour to the mob to put any body of people under penalty because of their religion, be that religion what it may. Bating the politics of this book, it is an earnest protest against Rome, and we are in full sympathy with it; but the politics are its main feature, and as an earnest Protestant we disclaim all complicity with them.
The Human Nature of Christ. By the Rev. N. Rouse. Hamilton, Adams and Co.
WE have no hesitation in affirming that the author of this book understands neither the human nature of Christ nor his own. To account for the exemption of the human nature of Christ from hereditary corruption, we are informed that there was no federal relationship between Adam and his posterity, and consequently no entail of original sin. The Virgin Mary was sinless from her birth, and there have been many other sinless human beings, as John the Baptist and John the Evangelist. When the Lord looked down from heaven upon the children of men he found none righteous—no, not one, but the Rev. N. Rouse has found many. These views are advocated with great seriousness, and with all the ingenuity with which ready writers can make a great display of Scripture interpretations in support of a pretended discovery of some new feature of revealed truth. These errors are not the less injurious because of the truths with which they are blended, but the more so. As might be expected, it would be in vain to look here for any truth which would tend to set the heart a-glow with devotional feeling.
The Paradise of Martyrs. By THOMAS COOPER. Hodder and Stoughton, 27, Paternoster Row.
WE like the prose writings of this author better than his poetry, which partly arises, without doubt, from our constitutional taste for solid truths rather than for poetic imaginations, but not entirely so. Mr. Cooper here gives us his meditations, in the form of dreams, and he dreams well, intelligently, and devoutly, but somewhat incoherently, as all dreamers must necessarily do. The history of Christian martyrdom, many incidents in his own per-
sonal history, the beauties of nature, and the employments of the spirits of just men made perfect, are promiscuously blended. We do not think less of Mr. Cooper, however, for his poetry, but more—more of his mental and more of his spiritual power. The poetry, though never rising to the highest elevation, so as to cover all the high hills that are under the whole heaven, is throughout above the ordinary level, and calculated to inspire us with the greatness and glory of its theme.
Animals and their Young. By HARLAND COULTAS. Partridge and Co.
OUTWARDLY a book to make little eyes sparkle with delight, and inwardly a work calculated to soften the heart and inspire the tenderest feelings towards animals. The drawings by Harrison Weir are simply perfection, and they are supplied with no stinted hand, for there are twenty-four full-page illustrations by that eminent artist, and even more headpieces by J. Nicholson, a worthy pupil of Wm. Bewick; the printing is in the best style, and the binding attractive in the highest degree. Such works it is a religious duty to circulate among the young, a handsome birth-day present could not be selected from all the booksellers' catalogues in London.
The Holy Life. Morgan and Scott, 12, Paternoster Buildings, E.C.
THREE short narratives of what we are expected to consider as Christian experience. As all three have attained in their own judgments to a sinless life, we leave our readers to decide upon the scripturalness of the views here propounded. For our own part, we believe that in them—that is, in their flesh—there dwelleth no good thing, and that their book is as full of the seeds of corruption as themselves. They say that they have no sin; they deceive themselves, and the truth is not in them.
