Menu
‹ Chapter 18 of 188 ›

The Founder of Pennsylvania — By G. Holden Pike — [Part Ii.]

15 min read · Chapter 18 of 188

BUT while the peace-loving and philanthropic Quakers were congratulating one another over the quick progress of civilisation in their colony; while the young city, Philadelphia, was raising her roofs and towers above the virgin wastes; and while the enlightened governor was himself sending home accounts of the limitless animal, vegetable, and mineral resources of his unexplored forests, letters from England arrived with sombre news, and with news such as filled many noble hearts with grief and concern. His wife Guli, whom Penn very fondly loved, was ailing. His dear friend, the patriotic Algernon Sydney, had perished by the axe of the executioner; and enemies were already at work blackening the Governor's character with the government of James the Second. Penn perceived the necessity of at once returning home.

A stumbling-block in the path of many good people has been Penn's friendly connection with the royal House of Stuart. They have been unable to comprehend how a man of high patriotism and of undoubted piety could live on intimate, or even affable, terms with a character like James the Second. Before making hasty conclusions, such persons should take care to properly understand Penn's surroundings, and the relation of parties in England. James the Second was the Quaker Governor's appointed guardian, so that the acquaintance with the king came to Penn more as an inheritance of his house than as anything he himself had sought. The king treated him with great uprightness and kindness; why, therefore, should the Quaker have quarrelled with his sovereign merely because their principles were at variance. It would have been both unchristian and impolitic to have lived on unfriendly terms with the king and government in such times; and those who raised the cry of "Trimmer" or "Jesuit," knew well enough that Penn counted royal favour, and all worldly advantage, light as feathers when weighed against religious principle. By frequenting the court, he exercised a great and beneficial influence in favour of the oppressed Nonconformists. It was largely owing to his instrumentality that more than twelve hundred Quakers were released from their dungeons at one time. Then while his heart was wrung with anguish over the atrocities of "The Bloody Assize," he begged twenty persons from among the condemned victims for the American settlement, where peace and plenty awaited them. In every work which promised to advance religion, or to promote the welfare of man, he was ever ready to take a lion's share.

His hands were now full of business connected with his province and home matters: besides which the boundary of his territory was disputed by Lord Baltimore. Hence Penn took lodgings at Kensington, so as to be near the court at Whitehall; and to Kensington, therefore, Guli and her family were removed.

55

While Penn thus lived in London, ready to defend his rights and character, he tried unceasingly to exercise a good influence over the strong-headed James after that monarch's accession to the throne. Had Penn's advice, offered day after day in the royal closet, been accepted and acted upon, instead of living to stir up strife, to become the ruin of his house and a by-word among European nations, James would have stood forth as an enlightened reformer and the benefactor of his country, whom posterity would have remembered with respect. Penn would have healed the quarrel which occurred between the King and the University of Oxford; he would have saved James from the humiliation he suffered in the affair of the Seven Bishops, and also from the ruin engendered by a long catalogue of lesser blunders. As an advocate of entire freedom of conscience, the Quaker hailed the indulgence of 1687 as a real boon under the circumstances, even while he mistrusted any concessions not sanctioned by Act of Parliament. James's mistakes brought him to ruin; but the chronicles of the day will show that whatever the King did to promote his own discomfiture and to bring disaster on his subjects, he did in opposition to the views, and, in many instances, contrary to the advice of the unflinchingly outspoken and patriotic Quaker.

After the Revolution, Penn found himself overwhelmed with trouble of various kinds. The principles on which the great reforms of the Revolution were founded were Penn's own; but none the less on that account was he suspected by the new government. The timeservers of the hour, over anxious, like all their race, to profit by any means within reach, stood ready to inform against a man they hated, and in the meantime they renewed the old charges of Jesuitism and other crimes. To lying slanders were now added a new accusation—that of being in treasonable communication with James in exile. Penn was arrested and arraigned before the authorities, but his ingenuous behaviour and straitforward replies ensured an honourable acquittal. Besides slanders, other things exercised a baneful influence on the governor's fortunes. William the Third was almost instinctively a man of war, and his greatness most appeared when he fought with the enemies of freedom in the open field. The one great object for which William lived, and to secure which he consented to rule as King of England, was that of crushing Louis the Fourteenth—the arch enemy of the peace and prosperity of Europe. The French were established in Canada, and on that account it accorded with English policy to establish a more warlike rule in Pennsylvania than that of Penn, the peace-loving governor, whose only arms of defence and aggression were such as the gospel supplied. Accordingly during thirty months the province was placed under the authority of Colonel Fletcher. This blow fell heavily on a man who loved the colony he had planted with as much unselfishness as a father might love a family. It was an unexpected return, moreover, for the toil and self-denial to which Penn had been subjected, for instead of having enriched himself by securing a property of twenty million acres of land, he had actually become impoverished by the transaction. To these trials were now added other sorrows in the loss of his wife and eldest son by death. Penn would have been weighed down by calamity had not sustaining

grace borne him up. As it was, he found himself well supported—so well, indeed, that nothing sufficed to hinder his usefulness. He laboured still in writing for the press and in preaching the gospel. His name also appears among those Quakers who visited Peter the Great at Deptford with the laudable object of converting that semi-barbarian to Christianity.

In 1699 Penn again embarked for the New World, having been reinvested with the governorship of his province. The manor house he erected for himself on the Delaware River was called Pennsbury. Surrounded by an estate of six thousand acres, including beautiful and well-kept pleasure grounds and productive kitchen-gardens, Pennsbury must have embodied the realisation of its owner's most cherished daydreams. On all hands nature blossomed and budded like the garden of the Lord. It was a land of plenty and of peace. "The mansion-house was erected on a moderate eminence," we are told. "A broad walk through an avenue of poplars led to the river, descending from the upper terrace to the lower grounds by a flight of steps. The house was surrounded by gardens and lawns, and the more distant woods were opened in vistas, looking down the river and upward to the falls. These woods had been laid out in walks at the proprietary's first visit, and the preservation of the trees is enjoined in several of his letters. The proprietor sent out from England walnuts, hawthorns, hazels, fruit-trees, and a great variety of rarest seeds and roots. While in this country he procured from Maryland several panniers of trees and shrubs indigenous in that province, and he directed by his letters that the most beautiful wild flowers should be transplanted into his gardens. On the whole, his directions indicate a love of nature and an elegance of taste which are very remarkable."*

Penn could enjoy an elegant retreat in the wilderness-like Pennsbury in a manner which a mere worldly man could never have done. Not having coveted wealth for wealth's sake, he could yet appreciate the gifts of Providence. He was as humble as he was condescending. Though he kept a coach, as he would have done in England, the vehicle was seldom used, the roads over the new country being so indifferent that the Governor preferred travelling either on horseback or in a barge. While out riding he once picked up a bare-footed little girl, and placing the delighted urchin behind his saddle, carried her to her destination. But if amiable and obliging, Governor Penn was not free from prejudice, or what would be called prejudice in these days of psuedo-liberalism. Thus he abhorred tobacco, as appears in a passage of the New Jersey Historical Collections. When passing in his barge between Philadelphia and Pennsbury, he frequently stopped at Burlington to see Governor Jennings, of New Jersey, who was also an eminent minister among Friends. On one occasion, Jennings and some of his friends were enjoying their tobacco, a practice which the gentlemanly Penn disliked. On hearing that Penn's barge was in sight, they put away their pipes, that their friend might not be annoyed, and endeavoured to conceal from him what they were about. He came upon them, however,

* Quoted by Janney, from "Fisher's Discourse on the Private Life of William Penn."

57

somewhat suddenly, and pleasantly remarked that he was glad they had sufficient sense of propriety to be ashamed of the practice. Jennings, rarely at a loss for an answer, rejoined, that they were "not ashamed, but desisted to avoid hurting a weak brother!"

While living thus in the midst of the prosperous colony which he had founded, we must remember that the source of the Governor's strength was God himself. Penn sought daily supplies of grace with an earnestness which few now-a-days would consider practicable. He lived in an atmosphere of devotion and prayer. Three times every day did the inmates of Pennsbury meet to worship their Maker. Thus we are told that "When he was visiting meetings in Pennsylvania, he lodged one night at Merion, where a boy, about twelve years old, son of the person at whose house he lodged, being a lad of curiosity, and not often seeing such great men, privately crept to his chamber, up a flight of steps on the outside of the building. On peeping through the latchot-hole, he was struck with awe in beholding this great man upon his knees by the bed-side, and in hearing what he said, for he could distinctly hear him in prayer and thanksgiving that he was then provided for in the wilderness."

Penn went out on his last voyage with the intention of finishing his days at Pennsbury, and he had taken his second wife and family thither. This intention was frustrated by the activity of enemies in England. It was sought to deprive the governor of his colony by Act of Parliament, and therefore again, to defend his rights, he hastened home in the fall of 1701. The obnoxious Bill was abandoned, and, with the accession of Anne, Penn rose again into court favour, though he never returned to Pennsbury.

We are conscious of a feeling of sadness as we follow this great man to those closing years of a busy and eventful life, when disease added its burden to the weight of years, and when his noble intellect became partially clouded. Having always believed the world to be vanity, he now realized the truth of what he had believed. In prosperity he showed that he counted such days as lost wherein no progress was made towards the higher life: now he tasted the blessedness of having run a course which had been a life-long preparation for death. After carefully looking into Penn's character and life-work, we cannot discover that mere ambition weighed with him in founding the colony named after his house. Probably a more unselfish character does not shed its lustre over the page of English history. To such men disaster never comes. Life is to them a discipline for immortality, the lights and shades of which are equally turned to profit. Yet, as seen from the human standpoint, what a depressing spectacle does Penn, in his last years, present to view. His estate was impoverished by the expenses of the colony, and he suffered as the victim of shameless cheats and two-faced friends. Many dearly-cherished hopes were disappointed. His first-born son lay in the grave. A second son—also a child of the beloved Guli—as a worn-out profligate, broken both in purse and health, was hiding on the Continent, far from the sight of virtuous connexions. The younger children of the Governor's second wife alone stood around him in his last days at Ruscombe, in Berkshire, in 1718. It, indeed, was a happy day when the Governor's spirit passed into the rest which,

for half-a-century, he had eagerly anticipated, and from which even the cares of Pennsylvania could never divert his thoughts.

After seeing what we have of the character of this godly Quaker, it will be as well to deal with some of the charges which have been brought against him. How such charges could have found supporters with actually no substantiating evidence, such as would weigh with any intelligent jury, must remain among "the curiosities of literature." In regard to these charges, it must be remembered that Macaulay would naturally entertain prejudice against one, who, partly by accident—on account of "property, not popery"—was a friend of James the Second, and consequently, though a Reformer instead of a Jacobite, was still not an adherent of the historian's great idol, William the Third. It will be observed, also, that while for the majority of the charges Macaulay quotes some sort of an authority, other assertions have nothing more substantial than rhetoric for a foundation. One of this class occurs in the "History," under the year 1685. After detailing Penn's prosperity and power at court, Macaulay says: "He paid dear, however, for this seeming prosperity. Even his own sect looked coldly on him, and requited his services with obloquy." The archives of Devonshire House, where Penn worshipped, disprove this gratuitous calumny by showing that he attended there throughout the year in question, and was held in honour by the people.

But the most notorious of Macaulay's charges relates to the ransom-money exacted after Monmouth's defeat from the Taunton girls, between whom and the ladies at court Penn is alleged to have stood as acting agent. It can be clearly proved that he who really did act as agent in this wicked traffic was one George Penne, whose occupation consisted in business of this description. The only authority for implicating William Penn in a transaction from which he would have shrunk in disgust, is a letter by Lord Sunderland, among the State Papers, and addressed to "Mr. Penne," which, by some remarkable false reasoning, in a footnote published in 1857, Macaulay maintains was written to the Founder of Pennsylvania. Let it be remembered that the only warrant for associating the Quaker with the Taunton proceedings is the following now celebrated letter:—

"Whitehall, Feb. 13, 1685-6.

"Mr. Penne,—Her Majesty's Maids of Honour having acquainted me that they designe to employ you and Mr. Walden in making a composition with the Relations of the Maids of Taunton for the high Misdemeanour they have been guilty of, I do at their request hereby let you know that His Majesty has been pleased to give their Fines to the said Maids of Honour, and therefore recommend it to Mr. Walden and you to make the most advantageous composition you can in their behalf.—I am, Sir, your humble servant,

"SUNDERLAND."

Penn's name was not Penne, and accordingly Macaulay argues that surnames were formerly spelt in various ways—an assertion which does not appear to be true to the extent we are expected to believe. It is inconceivable that Lord Sunderland, with whom Penn had been on terms of friendship from childhood, would have written such a letter to one of the first men of the town, and it would have been still more remarkable had the minister in this letter made an unfortunate exception

59

to his usual way of spelling his friend's name. On no occasion does Lord Sunderland write Penne for Penn when addressing the Governor, and though ministers of state may assume a cold style when writing officially to acquaintances, they do not address gentlemen in language only suitable for grovelling pardon-mongers.

A still more baseless charge occurs in connection with the celebrated Baptist pastor William Kiffen. The king wished to seduce Kiffen by the bribe of an alderman's gown, and, according to Macaulay, Penn was employed in the business of seduction. The pastor himself tells us that he appealed to Penn, seeking to secure his services as mediator, and it is impossible to prove from Kiffen's memoirs that Penn acted otherwise than as a mediator to serve the Baptist, whose "Meeting" stood within bow-shot of the Quakers' Devonshire House.

But as if bent on blasting once and for ever the character of a good man, who happened not to be a worshipper of William the Third, Penn is accused by Macaulay of having been guilty of "simony of a peculiarly disreputable kind." This comes out in connection with the dispute between the King and the Fellows of Magdalen College, Oxford. Penn did meet the Fellows, but in what character? "Macaulay's story of this meeting is a comedy of errors," says Mr. Dixon, quoting authorities in support of the assertion. "He is wrong on every point—the time, the place, the method, and the motive of this interview. Macaulay describes the time of meeting as immediately after James left Oxford, while the King was 'greatly incensed and mortified by his defeat.' This was early in September. The meeting was not really held till five weeks later, October 9, 1687. Macaulay gives the place as Oxford. It was really held at Eton, near Windsor, where Penn had then a country house. Macaulay described the method of this interview as a visit made by Penn to Hough and other Fellows. The actual method was a deputation from the college to Penn; a deputation of which Hough was the head; a deputation which had to follow Penn to Eton, and to ask his leave to occupy a morning of his time. Macaulay describes the motive of the interview as a design of Penn to make the Fellows compromise their course. The actual motive was a strong desire on the part of Hough and other fellows to procure Penn's powerful mediation and support with James."

There are other charges adduced against the Quaker, such as that of inciting the deposed King to invade England by foreign troops, and the proof offered is that the French agent, Avaux, mentions one "M. Pen" as among James's correspondents. It can be proved to demonstration that Avaux's "M. Pen" was Neville Pen, one of the paid Jacobite spies who infested the court of William the Third. This same Neville, and not William Penn, proposed that "James should make a descent on England with thirty thousand men," which piece of treason Macaulay puts down as usual to the credit of the innocent Governor of Pennsylvania. There was a paid Jacobite spy then living in London of the name of Williamson, and the only basis of proof on which the historian's charge can rest is a paper sent by Williamson to the court at St. Germains, which runs as follows:—"Mr. Penn says that your Majesty has had several occasions, but never any so favourable as the the present," &c. After quoting this letter Mr. Dixon says:—

"With the utmost confidence I say that William Penn never wrote and never spoke this stuff. Penn never used the phrase 'Your Majesty,' here used four times in as many lines. Penn never called Louis the Fourteenth 'the most Christian King.' The first expression shows that 'Mr. Penn' was not a Quaker; the second expression shows that 'Mr. Penn' was a Catholic. . . . Was there any 'Mr. Penn' in James's pay whose place in such a list would be where Captain Williamson puts him? Yes; we know there was. 'Mr. Penn' was Neville Penn. Neville Penn was acquainted with Williamson. Neville Penn was a paid agent. . . . Neville Penn was a Roman Catholic. Neville Penn would address James as 'Your Majesty,' and assuredly speak of Louis as 'the most Christian King.'"

These charges, as mean as they are false, will ultimately damage the historical accuracy of the writer who published them far more than they will affect the reputation of the Founder of Pennsylvania. Rhetoric and literary art have done their worst in attempting to blacken a great man's memory, but character is safe when the man's whole life contradicts the fictions of traducers, and is corroborated by the very State Papers on which the charges are based. We believe it was Lord Brougham who spoke of a celebrated historian as "a tolerably good writer of romances." To what degree the sarcasm is true we need not enquire. We regard the author referred to as a brilliant example of a school which will not offend the worldly by speaking too well of Christianity; and will not risk its prestige among a better class by openly deprecating religion. These writers are educated at the University of Fair-speech under Professors Timeserver and Anything. Though able to write brilliant sentences, and occasionally to do good service, they are not always competent to appreciate a great and noble character such as was WILLIAM PENN, FOUNDER OF PENNSYLVANIA.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate