China's Cry and China's Need — By Thomas P. Harvey
"Non audivi tantum."
HOME ideas of places and people far from us are not unfrequently far from the truth. That this should be so is not at all strange, as our information is often but fragmentary, and from men of widely
different opinions; so that false notions and confused ideas on our part are the result. And not more so of other countries than China. True, books have been written—we might almost say without number—but very often by men who have never seen the country; and lectures given, but principally by men who have kept to the free ports on the coast. Yet, from the many authors who have viewed this vast subject, from as many different stand-points, it is difficult to deduce the truth. On the one hand, we are told with the greatest assurance “that China does not want the gospel.” An equally trustworthy authority as coolly says that “China is holding out its arms for it, and that the people invite us to plant the standard of the Cross on every hill and in every valley throughout the land.” One diplomatist, deceived by the plausible tone of the deceptive Government, tells us “we need to be patient with the Chinese, and use conciliatory measures, and that they will ultimately yield to our demands.” Another diplomatist, representing the same court, asserts that the only thing to make the Chinaman give way is the “iron-clad with its infants.” Again, a good brother missionary will write home to say, that to go away from the free ports into the interior is sheer madness. Another brother, more sanguine and experimental than the former, in glowing words tells us, after travelling in the interior of the country, how peaceably the people behave, and what an “open door” there is for the gospel. Merchants declare that missionaries are at the root of all the troubles in China in connection with the foreigners. Whereas, on the other hand, it is an easy thing for us to show that the foreign trade with China, in some respects, is becoming the very death of the native population—I refer to the sale of that most fearful drug found in Satan’s pharmacopœia, opium.
I make no pretensions to “pen-wielding,” but a desire to lay a few plain facts, the result of my experience during the few years I laboured in China in connection with the China Inland Mission, before the Lord’s people, is my apology for writing.
The subject, China and the Chinese is a vast one. Out of the many different stand-points from which it may be viewed, the ethical, perhaps, belongs more to us than any other. We seek to be plain in dealing with the question in hand, and to this end shall be curt.
Every effect has its cause. That China cries out in anguish is a lamentable fact. What, then, are the causes of its cry.
DIRECT CAUSES. I. The vast system of injustice and tyranny practised by its rulers.
II. The filth and pollution of its towns and cities, and the neglected state of the country.
III. The doctrines and truths inculcated by the priests of Buddha and Tao.
INDIRECT CAUSES. I. Customs concerning women.
II. Idolatry and the rebellions.
III. Opium.
The above-mentioned by no means include all the causes of China’s cry, but they will be sufficient to show the source of much of its sorrow.
We say, then, that “the vast system of injustice and tyranny” incessantly practised upon the people by the rulers is the first, and, we
313
believe, the chief cause. "System," because it extends throughout the land with scarcely an exception, having its root in the "great father of the people," "the son of heaven," the Emperor; and its tributary branches in the lesser rulers. It is a common saying amongst the people that "big fish eat little fish, little fish eat shrimps, and shrimps eat one another." This principle, carried out in all its woful detail, constitutes what we here call "system." If ever the cry of the oppressed entered into the ears of the God of the whole earth, certainly it has when arising from innocent sufferers incarcerated in a Chinese ya-men. A ya-men! And what is a ya-men? Why, a terror to all unofficially associated with it. An earthly department of hell. As well as being the residence of the mandarin (magistrate), it swarms with cunning, cowardly men, whose business it is to carry out the wicked designs of their tyrannical master, the mandarin, so as to enrich both themselves and him, at the expense and suffering of the people. Our Lord's "den of thieves" and Gavazzi's "nest of vipers" are fit descriptions of a Chinese ya-men. To the ear of an Englishman, who has been accustomed from his birth to breathe in an atmosphere of truth and justice, all this sounds strange. Doubtless there are men to be found in our island-home who desire to rule for the benefit of their country, and who ardently long for the welfare of the people; but not so in China. An altogether different motive possesses the Chinaman as he seeks an opulent position in the Government. The country may go to ruin, and the people to starvation, but what cares he so long as his own nest is well feathered; and in proportion to the extent in which his ambition is gratified do the people suffer. Thus much for the paternal love and affection which the (rulers) "fathers" of China exercise towards their own "children" (the people).
Is this the language of an impartial judge? I appeal to those who have been into the interior of China, and have had opportunities of knowing what things are enacted at the ya-mens, whether what has been said is not, if anything, under rather than overrated. No need that you should go to China, you need but read the Pekin Gazette, published in Pekin daily, containing court news, to know the general conduct of Chinese rulers; and the comparatively few cases which you see recorded there, are those of persons who have sufficient interest or means to gain the ear and sympathies of some great official, and bribe him to present a memorial to the throne, begging for justice; whilst the thousands of people who by reason of poverty are unable to go to this extent are compelled to suffer, and often to die in obscurity, the victims of extortion, injustice, and tyranny. Take a couple of cases which I happen to have at hand, from the Pekin Gazette of 23rd of November, 1872. Tsung-chêng reports the two following appeal cases:—
Case 1st.—"Appellant's statement: My name is Chu-Ching-hêng. I live at Nan-yang, prefecture Ho-nan, and get my living by keeping a wine shop. My father having been asked by an old friend, Chiao-chên-ho, to draw up a bill of sale of some land, was taking a glass of wine with him in the shop when a quarrel commenced between him and a man called Tan-te-Kwei, about some gambling debts. My father tried to make peace between them, and succeeded in doing so for the
time being; but the next day Tan-te-Kwei met Chiao-chén-ho and killed him. His friends, however, charged us with the murder, and by bribing the coroner (district magistrate) got him to report that Chiao-chén-ho had been poisoned, in consequence of which my father was put in prison. While there he was subject to all sorts of ill-treatment in order to get money out of him. He was also so cruelly beaten in order to extort a confession of guilt from him, that he died in consequence. I and my brother then appealed to the prefect (magistrate of a department), criminal judge and lieutenant-governor, and orders were sent to the district magistrate to investigate the case; but the Chiao family, by the free use of money, managed to get my brothers flogged and imprisoned. Thus, driven to desperation, I have come to the capital to lay my complaint at the foot of the throne."
Case 2nd.—"A Shantung man (Province in the north), named How-yung-pao, complains that his cousin How-lan, was murdered by Wang-li-hwan, under the following circumstances:—His cousin married a Miss Wu, but the match was by no means a happy one. On the morning of the 7th June last he was found dead, and at first it was supposed that he had committed suicide by hanging. His body, however, exhibited no mark that would justify such a supposition. It was also observed that his wife's sleeves were smeared with blood, and on further examination a pair of white mourning shoes was found concealed on his person. These facts showed clearly enough that there had been foul play, and she then confessed that Wang-li-hwan and his accomplices had climbed in over a wall and throttled the unfortunate How-lan. The case was at once reported to the district magistrate, and an inquest was held on the body, when it was decided that death had been caused by throttling. But by a free use of bribery Wang-li-hwan's uncle managed to get the evidence altered, and thus concealed the real facts of the case from the district magistrate. Then, fearing an appeal would be made to one of the high officials, he bribed the ya-men underlings to put complainant's father, two brothers, and one of his near relatives in prison. There they were severely beaten with a view to force them to say that the case was one of suicide, and not of murder, and eventually all four died in consequence of the ill-usage to which they were subjected. Complainant's aunt appealed to the criminal judge, and a deputy was appointed to try the case in conjunction with the local magistrate, but when she appeared in court she too was seized and given into the custody of the female warder. Unable to stand this kind of treatment any longer, complainant has come to Pekin to appeal to the throne.
Money was the only thing; to obtain which, justice was sold, the innocent were put to death, and the guilty rich upheld. And this is a fair specimen of the kind of rule which Chinese mandarins administer. Take another case, which came under my own notice. A small farmer living in King-hsien (a small city which I have visited with the Scriptures) refused to accede to the unjust demands of the petty magistrate and pay the land taxes twice. The question was brought to the provincial city of Ang-hüoi (in which province King-hsien is situated), Ang-King. Here the petty official falls in with an old acquaintance, who has high rank and great power. Upon understanding the nature of the case in
315
hand, he induced the governor of the province to put the farmer into prison. Into prison he was thrown. A Chinese prison strongly reminds us of the dungeon into which the prophet Jeremiah was cast. In prison, the farmer was suspended from the roof in chains, the balls of his toes resting on the ground. In this position, he was beaten and starved, and promised release, by paying the unjust tax, a large sum of money besides, and publicly acknowledging his wrong in thus appealing. During this time our native helper in the Lord's work there, hearing of the case, found upon enquiry that it was a neighbour of his father's home. Desirous of showing kindness to his friend in trouble, he brought him some food, whereupon he was cast into prison. Other friends turned up and were dealt with in a similar manner.
There was a case of a man in Nankin, whilst I was there, who for a small offence was cast into prison and was fearfully treated. He was afterwards sent to his ruined home, in a dying state, by the mandarin, lest dying in the ya-men the burial expenses would fall upon him.
When the terrible flood visited the north of China in 1871, large quantities of rice, money, and other materials were collected for the people, thousands of whom were houseless, and from the intense cold of a northern winter were dying in great numbers. An amount of this suffering was in a great measure due to the negligence of the mandarins, who were known to have appropriated to their own use much of what was sent for these poor, wretched, starving people. The chief mandarin engaged in the management of this concern, very quietly requested that relief should be sent in money and not in kind—for a very obvious reason. Many more cases of rascality on the part of these rulers might be given, but two others shall suffice. For these we again quote the Pekin Gazette of Dec. 13, 1871:—"A Shantung man named Tsai-chi-fang, complains that his father was waylaid, robbed, and murdered on the evening of the 12th November, 1869. His father had been to town selling a quantity of calico, and was returning home with the money when the murderers met him. Notice of the murder was sent to the district magistrate and the murderers were apprehended. They confessed their guilt, but the magistrate, in order to screen himself from the blame of allowing such a serious crime to take place in his district, kept the culprits in prison, but never reported the case to the higher authorities. Complainant has appealed to the prefect (departmental magistrate) and criminal judge, but neither would investigate his case." Case No. 2. "A Hunan undergraduate named Li-shang-lin and others send a person to the Censorate (at Pekin Court) with a petition stating that the district magistrate of Yung-hsing has arbitrarily raised the value of the Tael (ordinarily worth 6s. 8d. or 7s.) in order to secure a squeeze for himself. In other respects also he has acted tyrannically. He has imprisoned numbers of innocent persons. Complainants have appealed to the Viceroy and others. A deputy was sent to investigate the matter, but his investigation was a mere farce, complainant obtained no redress."
"The people," once said a mandarin, "are a sponge, which we must all squeeze." High Mandarins squeeze those who squeeze the people.
At home, "rogues with rogues are honest men"—but in far Cathay it is the reverse. Take a specimen case, carrying out the maxim we gave at the onset, "big fish eat the little fish." It is well known that the salary allowed by the government for the district magistrates is but some £20 a-year; whereas the office is worth £1,000—more or less as the case may be. The treasurer of the province is deputed to distribute these salaries, which by-the-bye are seldom applied for. The small mandarin knows perfectly well, that to ask for his salary from a higher mandarin would be a "losing transaction." Why? Because these treasurers have two kinds of weights in their ya-mens—heavy and light. The light weights are used to weigh the silver which is sent out, whilst the heavy weights are used for silver which is sent in. Suppose, then, the small mandarin should be so unfortunate as to ask for his fifty or sixty ounces of silver as his annual income, it would not be long before the treasurer would pick out some flaw in the former's government, and threaten that unless the fifty or sixty ounces of silver were paid back, he would be reported to the throne, and become degraded in rank. Quivering under the rod thus shaken over him, and at the unhappy prospect of soon becoming "unhoused from his berth," he willingly pays back the ounces of silver, which are weighed with the heavy weights. Thus for sixty ounces received, he may pay back ninety. Returning from the smart, with keener appetite for money than ever, with increased vigilance he watches for the chance to pounce upon the helpless poor over whom he rules, to reimburse the whole.
From such illegal practices and tyrannical government, is it at all surprising that we find the people poor, depressed, indifferent, and fearing and hating one another? The noble principle, love, which characterises our social relationships at home, and constitutes the basis of our holy religion, is supplanted, jointly, by fear and hate in China.
Enough then upon our first point to shew that the introduction and practice of justice in the officers of the government would not only ameliorate the condition of the people, but would tend to exert a blessed influence in their social life and moral prosperity.
II. Then, for our second cause for 'China's Cry,' namely, "The filth and pollution of its cities and towns: the recurrence of its inundations," &c.
Travelling through some of the cities and towns of Central and Northern China, I was astonished at their filthy condition. There seems to be an utter disregard of all sanitary law. Filth is allowed to accumulate in the streets and houses, from year's end to year's end, seldom an attempt being made for its thorough removal. Perchance an unusually clean and tidy wife may amass sufficient energy to sweep up the house, and remove the year's accumulation of filth into the street, opposite the door, just before the New Year shall have commenced. If China looks clean and gay at all in the whole year, it is then—the time for the great annual ceremony of ancestral worship.
There are cities in the North where only one side of the main streets can be used at once—the other forming the receptacle for filth of all kinds, which in the hot summer sun, bakes hard, when it is walked upon, and becomes the walkable part of the road, whilst the other side is used by the neighbours along the respective streets, to re-
317
ceive all conceivable filth for the next twelve months. Passing up and down the country, through the various cities, towns, and villages, the verdict, "Dirty China, DIRTY CHINA," spontaneously arises from within you. I remember in March '71, travelling from Hai-Cheo to T'sing-K'eo, a small seaport town near Shantung province, twenty miles north of the old mouth of the Yellow River: crossing the wide sandy plain which stretches between the two places, I fell in with the mandarin who governs both places, on his way to the former, Hai-Cheo. He was attended by a most magnificent retinue (for China). There were a hundred foot soldiers, and some twenty officers, underlings, on horseback, in front of whom rode the mandarin; the whole party being heralded by a number of mounted runners, who commanded the people to stand in awe while their master passed. Hai-Cheo certainly was in itself the very picture of wretchedness, but T'sing-K'eo, which was some twenty-three miles beyond, was far worse. Wretched mud huts, streets which would have been far more respectable had they been left unpaved, dilapidated buildings—in fact, the whole place bearing a most wofully neglected aspect. Beyond that, coming right up into the middle of the town, was a canal, and here it terminated. Full of water—stagnant, of course, and judging from its colour and the stench which arose from it, it must have been in that condition for years and years. The stench arising from this alone was enough to lay the whole neighbourhood down in enteric fever. Yet this condition of things was allowed to continue from year to year. The one whose business it was to remedy the evil, was not only too much occupied with his selfish designs, but by illegal taxation and unjust demands, had deprived the people of the power to help themselves. And in case a generous neighbour should undertake at his own cost to remedy the evil, the mandarin, finding one of his subjects possessing sufficient money for such a project, would certainly improve the occasion and "squeeze" money out of him, to fall into his own pocket.
But some will say, Are there no sanitary arrangements in China? No water-pipes, rain-spouts, sewers, drains, and sluices? To all intents and purposes such things do not exist. Sewers there are, but better far would it be if there were none. I remember a street sewer being opened in Nankin. I had passed along the street very often, and at times noticed a heap of rubbish and a stinking pool in one part, but little dreamt that immediately underneath was a yet more vile sewer, until one day I found it opened up. It would indeed be easy, but I must decline entering into details upon this subject, lest the refined sense and taste of some of my fair readers should be shocked.
At times mandarins petition the Government to undertake such work as the banking up of canals and rivers, to prevent recurrence of inundations, the opening up of highways, etc., under the false plea of being deeply interested in the welfare of the people, who suffer terribly, from the former especially. Occasionally they succeed in obtaining grants of large sums of money, large portions of which are pocketed for personal use by the mandarins. The work being imperfectly done, there is a recurrence of these calamities, and the people are again called upon to suffer. Amounts are occasionally given by the Government to remedy sanitary defects in the various cities, but yet seldom a
year passes without two or three persons being drowned in the streets of Pekin itself owing entirely to the neglect of the authorities.
How much cleanliness, adherence to sanitary laws, the carrying out of sanitary improvements and sanitary measures, contribute to our social happiness and moral well-being I leave you, dear readers, to judge. "Cleanliness is next to godliness." The first trait which marks the character of the newly-converted poor, both in our own and other lands, is an improved cleanly condition. Filth exercises a depressing and debasing influence wherever found. Filth and vice, misery and sin, too often go hand-in-hand. So I contend that one secret of China's depression and immorality lies in the filthy condition of its cities and towns. This, again, is greatly owing to the avarice and wanton neglect of its many rulers.
III. Some, doubtless, will say that "Idolatry" should have a prominent place amongst the causes of "China's Cry;" but our experience of the Chinese and their idols leads us to think otherwise. Idols of wood and stone have not the reverence and respect of the Chinese as some would imagine. When pointing out to a Chinese crowd the absurdities of their idols, and the still greater absurdity of worshipping them, they will appreciate what you say, and often laugh at their own folly.
I remember following a respectable man into a temple at Shang-hai and speaking to him of the One true God, the Maker of all things, and the powerless nature of the idol. He apparently appreciated all that was said, and chatted and laughed most heartily, whilst bowing before the idol and going through the ordinary form of idol worship. Then, again, idols in a fragmentary condition, and others in a most dilapidated state, are constantly to be met with both on road sides and in temples, as though no man cared for them. These and other things lead us to think that the doctrines inculcated by the idolatrous priests, rather than the idols, constitute what we here call the third great cause of China's suffering, politically, socially, and physically. The Chinese are taught by their priests to believe that the future world is governed by a similar system of "mandarinate" as the present. Possessing experimental knowledge of the character of the "rulers of this world," it is not at all difficult for the people to conceive of the character of those in "the world to come," especially so when they are told that if anything, the latter are more severe in their government. These yellow-robed, bald-headed sons of Buddha—the priests—who infest the thousand temples and monasteries of the land, take up a position between the two worlds, or rather are said to do so; consequently, are the only medium of communication between the two. They are, moreover, supposed to know the condition of the departed spirits in the world to come, or spirit world, and to make it known to surviving friends in this world, whose duty it is to keep the departed spirits constantly supplied with all that they may need in the exigencies of their state, such as paper money, paper chairs, paper horses, paper sedans, paper clothes, and numbers of other paper articles resembling those in daily use, all of which are supposed to be converted into a useful condition in the spirit world when burnt. It is surpassing strange, but it is continually the case, that the spirits of the departed of rich families are ever and anon falling into terrible calami-
319
ties, and are the subjects of innumerable pressing wants. This seems to be the case in proportion to the prosperity of the friends they have left behind them. [We have not to go to Sinim to see this trick practised; the principles of papal purgatory, the great coffer-filler, are analogous to all this.] The priests only too readily comply with the wishes of the troubled spirits, and acquaint their living friends of their state, and show them that it is only by their immediate liberality to the temples, offering of sacrifices, etc., that the spirits of their departed friends can possibly recover their lost position of bliss. Consequently, the ignorant, easy-make-believe people often, at great personal inconvenience, part with large sums of money, make long pilgrimages, and undergo great hardships, lest they should excite the suspicion that their veneration for ancestors was in the least waning into indifference. Poor families often have the last dollar wrung out of them to meet the demands the priests make for feasts and ceremonies for the dead. I remember the case of a woman who lived just above our mission-station in Nankin;—if I remember rightly it was in a fit of passion that she hanged herself. The spirit having passed away under such unfavourable auspices, the poor daughter, the only remaining child, was compelled to invite some ten or twelve priests of Buddha to the house, and maintain a ceremony night and day for over a fortnight, in order to induce the rulers of the next world to receive the spirit of her mother, and place her in happy circumstances. Far into the night did I hear those senseless "bald-heads" chanting prayers, clapping cymbals, and firing crackers, as I lay quietly in bed. After living at the house on and off for the fortnight, and "squeezing" all the money they possibly could out of the poor young woman, they left her.
Christian people, at home, contribute largely towards the promotion of the work of God; but it is nothing as compared with the amount which is systematically spent by, and extorted from almost EVERY family in China for the worship of the dead and the maintenance of temples and temple worship.
Much is made of "filial piety" in China. In the majority of cases I deny that such a thing exists, nor is it possible that it should. It is filial worship, and not filial piety, that is so universal in China. With the latter we inseparably associate love; but true disinterested love is a gem seldom, if ever, found in the breast of one out of the many hundreds of millions of this unconverted people. Love is unknown to the Chinaman. A Chinese lady who had been married to a foreigner confessed ignorance of any such thing as love.
The Chinese are fond of saying that we ought to "hsieao king fu mu," which literally means "that we ought willingly to serve, obey, and be attentive to father and mother." The same word "king" is used in speaking of the worshipping of idols, which the people are taught to dread. The parents look to their children for all help and support when they are able to render it. All regard it to be right to be attentive to parents, and minister to their wants: so under this plausible pretext the people are continually led to make enormous sacrifices on behalf of their deceased ancestors.
It is this vast system of error and priestcraft, which is constantly forced upon the people, which has to a very great extent
impoverished and sunk them into that low, immoral, and debased condition in which we find them to-day; whilst on the other hand it supports a horde of low, idiotic-looking, opium-smoking priests. It is, indeed, a sad spectacle to see a magnificently built and decorated temple, furnished with gilded furniture, full of costly idols, covering a large area; the nest for priests, the great dupe-shop of all beyond; whilst crowding around outside the temple are the miserable mud-huts, and otherwise dilapidated houses, the homes of the duped, whose walls resound with oaths and curses from men and women, steeped in direst poverty and grossest immorality.
Oh that He to whom has been given the heathen for an inheritance, and whose right it is to reign, would cause the light of the knowledge of the glory of God to shine into the hearts of China's millions, and so emancipate them from the galling chains of tyranny, superstition, and error, which bind them down to wretchedness and woe, misery and despair!
