America and its Churches — [First Paper.]
AMERICA has greatly suffered from a plethora of gossipy writers who have been only too eager to record their hastily-formed impressions of its people and their habits. It is with this country as with departed great men. "No sooner," says Carlyle, in his essay on Richter, "does a great man depart, and leave his character as public property, than a crowd of little men rushes towards it. There they are gathered together, blinking up to it with such vision as they have, scanning it from afar, hovering round it this way and that, each cunningly endeavouring, by all arts, to catch some reflex of it in the little mirror of himself; though, many times, this mirror is so twisted with convexities and concavities, and indeed so extremely small in size, that to expect any true image, or any image whatever from it, is out of the question." Such surface-observers have been more anxious to search for materials for a sensational book than for such information as shall really present a fair picture of America and its people. We need not judge any nation by its caricatures; we Englishmen should not fare supremely well if thus estimated, and our foibles, if less amusing, are as grave as those of the Yankee. It would be as unfair. Swift tells us, to judge a great people by the dregs at the bottom as by the froth at the top. The music-hall habitues are not the type of ordinary Englishmen, any more than the frivolous pigeon-shooters of Hurlingham are the representatives of the brave and manly Britisher. So far has this evil of misrepresentation gone, that a candid and generous critic is liable to the charge of flattery. Such a charge has, we find, been made against Dr. Macaulay, the editor of one of our most popular family journals, who has written a temperate book, for the sketchiness of which he apologises, as being his "First Impressions of America and its People." We are at issue with the writer on some points, and think that had he studied more fully the religious newspapers of the United States, some little errors might have been avoided, and perhaps a more interesting book written.* As it is, however, we have here one really honest attempt to do justice to the character of a people closely allied to us, as they proudly boast, by blood, by community of language, by literature and religion—a people of high sensitiveness, a little jealous because deeply attached to the old mother country. Dr. Macaulay says truly, that the Americans would bear ten times as much from any other nation. "They care more for the good opinion of England than of all the world besides." On the other hand, the heterogeneous population of that country, with its strong and, politically speaking, fanatic elements, at times sway the government too much towards the adoption of measures neither politic nor just. The recent piece of "sharp practice" in the Alabama claims Englishmen of all politics have unanimously resented; but, if we understand the drift of public feeling as reflected in the representative papers which come over
* Across the Ferry: First Impressions of America and its People. By J. Macaulay, M.A., M.D., London; Hodder and Stoughton.
17
to us with welcome regularity, the difficulty has throughout been more diplomatic than real.
Dr. Macaulay very pitifully puts the Englishman's feeling of surprise on landing in New York. "Is it New York or New York that I am in?" Porters, Custom-house examiners, boatmen, lightermen, hackney coachmen, omnibus conductors, were all unmistakably Irish. Irish names greet you everywhere. Irish girls wait at tables, serve as chambermaids, wait in shops. Emigration makes a vast improvement in their fortunes. More persevering, industrious, and thrifty, because possessing greater opportunities in New York than in the "ould country," or in England, where they are too often excluded from all but a certain number of employments, they live in plenty and comfort. Still there are in New York the lowest strata of Irish, as poor and unimprovable as the Irish denizens of St. Giles's. Yet the improvement witnessed should not mislead the observer. Probably, there is no race of people more passionately fond of their native land, "melancholy ocean" included, than the Irish. This patriotism saturates the songs they sing with wild enthusiasm even in their more prosperous condition abroad. They would return if they could with advantage, any day, to the Emerald Isle. The burden of one of their favourite songs is that, if the land to which they emigrate be fifty times as fair as it be represented, they'll never forget the land they have left. A popular song entitled "The Wearing of the Green," and expressing intense indignation against "the laws forbidding the shamrock to grow on Irish ground," occurs this stanza:—
"When the law can stop the blades of grass from growing as they grow,
And when the leaves in summer time their verdure do not show,
Then I will change the colour I wear in my cabbeen:
But till that day, plaze God, I'll stick to wearing of the green."
And in the following verses, we may see much with which we cannot fail to sympathise:—
"Sure, Paddy's heart is in his band, as all the world does know,
His praties and his whisky he will share with friend or foe;
His door is always open to the stranger passing by;
He never thinks of saying, 'None but Irish need apply.'
And in Columbia's history his name is ranking high;
Thin shame upon the knaves that write 'No Irish need apply.'
"Ould Ireland on the battle field a lasting fame has made;
We all have heard of Meagher's men, and Corcoran's brigade;
Though fools may flout and bigots rave, and fanatics may cry,
Yet when they want good fighting men, the Irish may apply;
And when for freedom and the right they raise the battle cry,
Then the rebel ranks begin to think 'No Irish need apply.'
It is a pity that a nation so full of the noblest impulses should have ever become, as it still is, the prey of the priests. Nor can we think that in escaping from Ireland the people get free from this oppressive spell. In past days, the emigrants have become good Protestants; but Dr. Macaulay is quite right in his statement that "the influence of the Roman Catholic Church over its members is more generally retained." He instances the fact that the number of Catholic schools is
263
largely increasing, and "the Christian brothers," a trained order for supplying teachers, is a great and increasing power. In a paper just to hand, we alight upon an article showing that New York is heavily taxed for the support of the charitable institutions and schools managed by this body. It is a sad mistake, which we hope may soon be rectified, that so much money should be given to various denominations for these purposes out of the municipal treasury. The Papists, as a consequence, get the lion's share. Thus, within the last three years, they have received 1,396,388 dols. 51 cents. for the support of their institutions, while all the other religious bodies put together received only 329,313 dols. 64 cents. In addition to this large gratuity, the Catholics have received from the city, in land grants and leases on nominal rent, the huge sum of 3,500,000 dols.—so that, in all, nearly five millions of dollars of public money and property have been given away to further the ends of a sect which most people admit to be an obstruction to any nation's true liberty and prosperity. This malversation of municipal funds and sectarian greed will, in the end, work serious mischief for New York. The hot burning words of Dr. Fulton, in his recently published sermon, on "Rome in America," should be scattered broadcast over that country. Speaking of the corruption recently made manifest to the disgrace of municipal government in New York, Dr. Fulton says:—
"The worst day of old Rome's wickedness, when the empire was put up at auction, seemed to have returned. Millions of money flowed into the coffers of the Church of Rome. Magnificent churches, cathedrals, hospitals, and other structures rose on every hand, while taxes increased, and robbery and crime stalked defiantly abroad. Why was it? There is but one answer. Romanism had infected the city, filled the offices, and ruled the hour. The result was there what it was in Rome in the year 1516, before modern Protestantism was born, when Machiavelli wrote, 'The nearer the people are to Rome, the less devotion they have. By the scandalous example of the court of Rome Italy has lost every principle of piety and every sentiment of religion.' Is it not so in New York? Will it not be so everywhere? Pulpits of Protestant churches have thundered against corruption, while Rome laughs and pardons the thieves if she is permitted to share in the spoils. And why? Because as New York sinks in infamy, in corruption, in degradation, Roman Catholic institutions rise on every hand, as monuments of a people's shame, and as gravestones of liberty."
So far, however, from decreasing, the Papists are only increasing, their demands. They are, of course, as in our own country, bitterly opposed to undenominational teaching. With them everything is "godless" that is not Popish; and, consequently, they urge strenuously and unceasingly that their rate-supported schools should be "placed under the control of the church." "There must be no compromise" says their chief newspaper; "the Catholic who now insists on supporting the public schools betrays his religion, and the true interests of society." In a spirit of superstition worthy of the Middle Ages, this same paper goes on to say that, "the day for liberal Catholicity and honeyed words about the good faith of 'our dissenting brethren' has gone by, and we must plant ourselves on the church alone." Happily, the free religious forces in America are strong enough to resist the encroachments of this mediæval nonsense. But we have here an evidence of
what Romanism is still. It has lost none of its old pretensions. May it never recover its old power! Here and there, however, in a country where there is no established church, we find evidences of a kind of enlightened or modified Popery. Thus, last month, there was a reception or recognition at New York, when Dr. McGlynn actually went out of his way to propitiate the Protestants. He practically gave up his belief in the exclusive powers of the Romish Church, by saying that those outside her pale, might be admitted into heaven. "I, a Catholic minister of God," said this priest of Popery, "teach from this altar that the most approved Catholic theology is, that while we must all follow the truth, those who are not fully informed are naturally excused from the fulfilment of precepts which they do not know, and will not be condemned for their ignorance." This is unaccountable liberality, for which we should think the doctor will be brought to task, since, unfortunately for himself, the Pope, his master, in his famous Syllabus of eighty errors, condemned, and bade all his children to condemn the error that, "we may entertain at least a well-founded hope of the eternal salvation of those who are in no manner in the true church of Christ."
Dr. Macaulay, we notice, while admitting the advantages which arise through the absence in the United States of a State-allied Church, does not commit himself to the Free Church principle. He says enough, however, to strengthen us in holding that principle. The foolish notion that the absence of a State Church implies a low public religious feeling is pronounced to be a great mistake. "Religion pervades the nation," he says, "to a far greater extent than in any country of the Old World, and Christianity is far more honoured and influential in every department of public and social as well as domestic life. . . . In legislation and government, whether of the Republic or of separate states, there is more frequent reference to religion than with ourselves." A recent number of an influential paper, published in New York, informs us that in the United States the proportion of professing Christians to the population is one to eight—an estimate that goes far to justify all that has been said of the religious character of the American nation. Leaving out for the present the manifestation of this religiousness in the common schools, a number of interesting facts which we have culled from a variety of sources may indicate to our readers the nature of the religious life of the people. Here is Dr. Macaulay's testimony to begin with: there is a prevalent national respect for religion evidenced in the fact that at the recommendation (not by the compulsory powers) of the President, national mercies are celebrated by praise and prayer in fifty thousand churches on "Thanksgiving Day." The Sabbath is better and more generally kept; the churches and schools better filled, and "the increase of churches and church members is far beyond even the rapid ratio of the increase of population." Mr. Harry Jones, an English clergyman, writes thus to the Guardian:—"The people have reversed the process with which we are familiar in England. Instead of having money begged for them by others for a church, they build it themselves; and instead of having a parson set among them, they look about, and call some one to be their minister." Christianity flourishes better on free church soil than in the old mother country. The statistics compiled by a
265
Baltimore correspondent of one of our English journals corroborate the statement we have quoted from the New York paper. There are 4,808,618 members of the various orthodox churches in the States, which is about one-eighth part of the entire population, and of these nearly one-seventh are engaged in the work of Sunday-school teaching. Here is a summary of the statistics:—
| Ministers of religion of various denominations | 71,429 |
| --- | --- |
| Church members | 4,808,618 |
| Sunday-school teachers | 651,277 |
| " scholars | 4,808,618 |
The college system is on a larger scale than in this country. There are as many as 368 of these institutions in the United States, 261 of which are supported by the religious denominations. We find that these institutions contain about 3,000 instructors, and nearly 50,000 pupils. There are 35 colleges for the Methodists, the united church membership of which body (Episcopal Methodists and others) is 2,713,811, and the entire number of ministers 39,889. The Baptist churches are next in point of numbers, the membership being over two millions. The numbers are thus given in the Nonconformist:—
| (1.) Regular Baptist Church. | | | |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Ministers | 10,818 | Members | 1,410,493 |
| S. S. teachers | 56,515 | S. S. scholars | 473,664 |
| (2.) Other Baptist Churches. | | | |
| Ministers, abt. | 2,200 | Members, abt. | 590,000 |
| S. S. teachers, abt. | 14,000 | S. S. scholars | 603,403 |
There are 38 colleges belonging to the Baptists, while the Roman Catholics boast of 54 such institutions. The progress of our denomination in the States is truly wonderful; the more so when it is considered that five millions of the population are foreign born. The denomination had its rise there in persecution. The leaders of the first Baptist church in Boston were repeatedly fined and imprisoned, and this continued until the colony of Pennsylvania was founded by William Penn, and civil and religious liberty was fully granted. At the end of 1750 there were 58 Baptist churches in existence, and these speedily multiplied during the succeeding forty years, so that at the end of that period there were no fewer than 872 churches, with a membership of 64,975. The increase during the next forty years (between the years 1790 and 1830) shows an improvement simply astounding. The 872 churches became 5,000—an increase of two churches every week. Nor were these Christian communities, as is the case so painfully and so largely in our country, small and feeble, for Baptists constituted one to every thirty-four of the population. Dr. G. S. Bailey, whose interesting statement on this subject is being circulated in America just now by the Bible and Publication Society, gives the following statistics of the additional period of forty years from 1830 to 1870. "Our population," he says, "has increased from 12,860,000 to 38,500,000, or a three-fold increase. The Baptist churches have increased from about 5,000 to 17,445, an average of six per week for forty years, and in the last twenty years the growth has been one church per
day." The church membership of the regular Baptists averages one to every twenty-seven of the population. During the past twenty years the baptisms have averaged 13,000 per week. The growth of the Baptists during the last forty years is no small satisfaction to those who in this country are battling against obloquy and reproach for a truth which is the surest bulwark against all superstition and Ritualism. Not only is the denomination larger by more than a million members than it was forty years ago, but there are, as in England, among other denominations a large number who have rejected infant baptism as inconsistent with the word of God. Dr. Bailey observes, "About seven-eighths of our foreign population came from the Continent of Europe, or from Catholic countries. If, with the blessing of God upon our efforts, we have not only kept pace with the growth of population in this country the last forty years, when our population has been so largely increased by foreign immigration, but have increased 450 per cent., while the population has increased but 300 per cent., we have reason to thank God and take courage." As, indeed, we think they have, and we hope and believe that our brethren will, with their increased numbers, not forget their graver responsibilities. It is intended in 1876 to celebrate the hundredth anniversary of America's National Independence, and in connection therewith it has been suggested by one of the many able Baptist papers, that a volume should be prepared, showing what Baptists have done in the work of evangelisation, education, literature, social improvement, public enterprise; and this, if done without undue self-glorification, may be useful to all concerned in the progress of Christ's kingdom. On this subject we are rejoiced to see an admirable article in the National Baptist—one of the best-edited of our contemporaries—which gives no evidence of desire to rest upon the achievements of the past, a fault from which English Baptists were once not altogether free. "Thank God," exclaims our vigorous friend, "we have no denominational machinery that can keep up for us the semblance of activity after the life has departed. Whatever may be said of other ecclesiastical organisations a Baptist Church must be buried when it is dead, and this is a great advantage. Our outward efficiency is a the measure of an inward life, and our apparent unity is the measure of a real agreement." There are some Baptist Churches in England which, if honest, would repent and die, so destitute are they of vigorous vitality; and we quite agree with Dr. Culross, who once observed, if we remember aright, that an unspiritual and inactive Baptist Church was the last church in the world of which to be a member.
When it is remembered that the Episcopal Churches in America have a membership under that of the Reformed (Dutch and German) Churches—and fewer ministers than the Methodists, Baptists, Presbyterians, or Congregationalists,* we need not be surprised that the pretensions of the English curatedom to be the only true ministers of Christ's Church, are laughed to scorn by our American brethren. It may be remembered that the Bishop of Exeter, at a recent ordination service, stated that he had no hesitation in saying that
* Here are the figures:—Methodist ministers, 39,889; Baptist, 13,018; Presbyterian, 7,454; Congregational, 3,194; Episcopal, 2,951.
267
he regarded the ministers of every denomination in the country as true ministers of Christ; the Lord, he said, had so blessed their work that he could not doubt for one moment that their word had his approval, and that he had sent them. Trained as this Broad Church prelate had been in a communion which has not learnt to tolerate Dissent, or look upon it with other than the most exclusive and bigoted notions, these words were regarded by English Nonconformists as an honourable concession; the American papers, however, look with surprise upon such impertinent liberality, and refuse to commend it. The Bishop of Exeter, says one paper, the Richmond Herald, has uttered sentiments, just in themselves, but absurd in the mouth of that official. This is how it strikes an American, unaccustomed to official patronage in religious matters.
If voluntaryism be anywhere a giant, it would be such in a country entirely free from state endowments. The following extract from the Baltimore letter already referred to is sufficiently interesting and important to give in full:—
"The resources of the re-united and combined Presbyterian Church for all purposes for 1871, including pastoral support, and exclusive of the so-called Five Million Fund, averaged about 20 dols. per member. (Say nearly £4.) The following is, it will be obvious, fragmentary:—
| | Dols. |
| --- | --- |
| Presbyterian Church | 20 |
| The Reformed Church averaged | 24 |
| The Reformed (Dutch) | 17.75 |
| The Presbyterian Church (South) | 11.25 |
| The United Presbyterian Church | 11.14 |
| The United Brethren | 5.33 |
Taking the average of these six religious bodies, we have about 15 dols. per member (nearly £3). If this were a fair average of all denominations, we should have an aggregate of about 70,000,000 dols. per annum as the contributions of Christian willinghood for the support and spread of the gospel and its institutions in the United States. I do not think that this general aggregate can fall below 50,000,000 dols. (say £10,000,000) per annum. Now if religious zeal and self-sacrifice can draw forth such immense sums from professors of Christianity here annually, will it not exhibit a similar power with you, when all hinderances are removed?
I will ask the attention of your readers to one other aspect of Church finance, as seen here. The Methodist Episcopal Church report 13,373 church edifices belonging to that denomination; valued at 52,614,591 dols.; also 4,179 parsonages, valued at 7,203,513 dols. Here we have nearly 60,000,000 dols. of church property (about £12,000,000.), owned by a single branch of the Universal Church in this country, all of which has been contributed by the free will of its members."
The majority of ministers in most countries are not over-paid. Even the church that luxuriates in bloated bishoprics and fat livings by the hundred is blessed with a large army of half-starved, barely-clad, curates. In America, ministers are, on the whole, better paid. "Stingy churches" are tabooed. In some of their religious newspapers we have read exposures of such churches individually made, that they might be ashamed of their meanness. We have one such exposure before us.
It has reference to the failure of the Indiana Baptists to sustain Franklin College, and plain-speaking we read too. "We have abundant resources," says the writer. "Indeed, when I think of our efforts, of our gifts, I blush to remember how rich we are. I scarcely know among us any that can be called a poor church." Here follows a plain reflection upon the farmers,—a class which, rightly or wrongly, seem to be regarded as proverbially stingy everywhere. "It is a matter of notoriety that multitudes of our wealthy churches do nothing, outside of starving their own minister." Here is an exposure evidently meant to lead to repentance and earnest amendment. And then the editor of a St. Louis paper pointedly adds to the extract; "Even our St. Louis Baptists are fast learning the most efficient way of doing nothing." If the American religious newspapers be occasionally too personal, they, at least, constitute a power which faithless, mean, and inactive churches would dread. But ministerial stipends are not to be judged by the exceptions. To strike the average would be to include the incompetent men who have simply mistaken their calling, and the humbler preachers, whose gifts are spare. Yet we find it stated (and stated with no satisfaction) that on an average the salary of each pastor in the United States ranges from four hundred to six hundred dollars per annum. Some churches pay very large salaries and most are exceedingly generous. The Broadway Tabernacle church, New York, recently found it necessary to elect a pastor, Dr. Thompson, whose works are well-known in our country, being compelled to resign through ill-health. An invitation was addressed to and accepted by Mr. Taylor, a Presbyterian minister of Liverpool. During the interval between the resignation of the old and the arrival of the new pastor, Professor Hitchcock officiated, and in addition to a liberal stipend, received, at the close of his services, a cheque for eleven hundred dollars.
With the following interesting and, to us Englishmen, novel sort of incident, we close this our first paper:—
"Rev. James E. Welch, D.D., had a very agreeable surprise on his eighty-third birthday. A goodly number of his friends and parishioners took quiet possession of his beautiful residence, Rose Hill, for the day. They filled his rooms and loaded his tables without permission or invitation. They brought with them tokens of appreciation and gratitude for himself and his estimable lady. They sung, conversed, made speeches, and listened with attention, respect, and veneration to the words in response of our venerable father, who has laboured continually and faithfully in the ministry for sixty years. He was a pioneer preacher west of the Mississippi; organised the first Sunday School, and is still labouring on a widely-extended circuit. He is hale, robust, and vigorous—retains his powers of mind, and is a powerful preacher. May he be spared to us yet many years."
This is surely a more excellent way of treating an aged servant of Christ than leaving him to societies for aged and infirm ministers, after he has spent his youth and manhood in the service of the churches.
E. L.
