Menu
‹ Chapter 163 of 203 ›

Rebirths

10 min read · Chapter 163 of 203

The Human Intellect. By NOAH PORTER,

D.D., LL.D. Strahan and Co., 56,

Ludgate-hill. The Elements of Intel-

lectual Science. By the same Author.

THE latter of these works is an abridged

edition of the former, and yet far ex-

ceeds an ordinary octavo, both in sub-

stance and size. It is not often that

we are called upon to review a book of

this kind. Such a book, indeed, does

not often appear. Writers upon mental

science, and especially such as enter

thoroughly into the subject, are few and

far between. From Plato and Aristotle

down to the present time even professed

treatises upon the subject have been

exceedingly rare. Occasionally some

master mind has appeared and ruled

with undisputed authority in these dis-

tant and obscure regions of thought.

Many have looked upon it as cloud-land,

where they would not have reigned if

they could; and others as superior

realms, where they could not if they

would. The effort required to turn the

thoughts of the mind upon itself with suffi-

cient intensity and assiduity to elaborate

a system of laws of mental operations is

so prodigious, that we need not be sur-

prised that it should be so uncommon,

and that it should inspire those who are

unaccustomed to such exercises with

reverential awe, and an undue amount

of intellectual homage. Few, therefore,

have ruled in these realms of thought;

but their influence has been great even

where their writings have been un-

known. The philosophy of Plato and of

Aristotle may be traced in the theology

of both the Greek and Latin fathers

of the early ages of the Christian church.

In later times the metaphysics of

French philosophers had a pernicious in-

fluence upon the religion of the land.

In our own country Berkeley and Hume,

the former, indeed, unintentionally,

gave encouragement to scepticism and

infidelity. The more modern meta-

physicians, as Reid, Stewart, Brown, and

Hamilton, may be trusted with greater

safety; but there was still great need

of some philosophic genius in this

department of literature in perfect har-

mony with Christianity, and capable of

rendering it subservient to the high

and holy office of Christian teaching.

That need has been supplied in the

volume before us. It is not less elabo-

rately scientific than other treatises upon

the same subject. It freely criticises

the most abstruse investigations of

others, and abounds with results of

profound and independent enquiry. It

would be absurd to suppose that any-

thing like perfection had yet been

attained in the philosophy of mind, but

we think it may be safely affirmed that

the researches of Dr. Porter are an

advance in that direction beyond all

that has preceded. The peculiarities

of his views cannot be here stated. It

may suffice to observe, that much of the

phenomena which other metaphysicians

assign to the organic action of the

material senses and of the brain, are here

attributed to the mind itself. It is the

soul which in the first instance animates

the body, and gradually rises from

thence to the development of its rational, emotional, and involuntary powers. Less is attributed to materialistic influences and more to direct soul influences than in theories which have recently prevailed. The law of association, for instance, is to be found, not in the tendency of one object to recall another, or in the tendency of the senses or the brain to reproduce things in combination with each other, but in the tendency of the mind itself to act more readily in the manner in which it has acted before. The science in this respect is simplified, and is more easily acquired, because it is transferred more to the sphere of actual consciousness, and becomes more profitable as an inducement and help to self-knowledge. The author's own estimate of such studies, derived, without doubt, from his own experience, is deserving of special notice:—

"This discipline to reflection, with the habits which it forms, is valuable because it teaches self-control. He that studies his own powers may learn how to direct and use them. He may learn how to fix his attention, how to invigorate and refresh his memory, how to order and arrange his thoughts. He may discover what are his intellectual defects, and the reasons why he can perform some processes with ease, while others cost painstaking and effort. He may acquire the skill to correct his deficiencies and to overcome his bad habits; to make easy that which was difficult, and pleasant that which was disagreeable. It also lays the foundation for moral improvement. He who would improve his character must first know what his character is. He must discover what are his better and what his worse impulses; what are the points at which he is most easily assailed, and by what sensibilities and emotions he can most readily rally his forces and overcome their assailants. With self-improvement self-government is intimately associated. Indeed, the one cannot exist without the other. He that would make himself better must learn to set himself over against himself as his own master, repressing the evil and educating and encouraging the good. But he that would rule himself must first know himself. He must thoroughly understand the subject whom he would regulate and control. 'Know thyself' was written over the portal of Delphi. It was inculcated by Socrates, that pre-eminent teacher of practical ethics, who, measuring every species of knowledge by its tendency to make man better, regarded this maxim as the summary of wisdom. A Christian poet has said, in the same spirit—

'Unless above himself he can

Exult himself, how mean a thing is man.'"

To these observations may be added the effect which moral culture has upon intellectual discipline. A testimony is borne to this fact in the following words, which we should like to have seen more fully expanded:—

"The person who habitually scrutinises his motives and examines his feelings in the light of the law of duty and of God cannot but cultivate and strengthen his intellect by the process, however humble may be his calling and illiterate his education. Christianity has trained the intellect of the human race to this activity, and hence has been so efficient in educating and elevating the masses of men, even when it has furnished no special intellectual culture."

This quotation shows that Christianity itself promotes mental discipline by the influence of good moral principles upon the understanding, and by the habits of self-reflection it requires. Who has not observed the intellectual clearness and force of the truly pious cottager who has had no other mental discipline? The mind may be improved without the heart, but not the heart without the mind. "Grace and truth come by Jesus Christ." Let Christianity be first studied experimentally and not theoretically only, and then all other truth in due course. This one study will be the best preparation for all the rest. It is the want of this that has associated mental philosophy with the principles of infidelity. True and healthful Christianity will supersede for a time all metaphysical pursuits, and will lay the best foundation for subsequent acquirements. The first period of intellectual culture, according to the system here advocated, is chiefly spent in the exercise of sense-perception and consciousness; the second in the use of the memory and the imagination; the third in reason and emotion; and last of all in the investigation of mental operations themselves. As we must see before we know how we see, and bear before we know how we hear, and feel before we know how we feel, so we must know before we know, how we know and reason before we know how we reason. The study of metaphysics, therefore, is premature until the mind is well developed by the exercise of all its faculties, and should have the last place in a course both of moral and intellectual training

479

Lectures on Preaching. Delivered at Yale College. By HENRY WARD BEECHER. R. D. Dickinson, 73, Farringdon Street.

It would not be possible for Mr. Beecher to speak upon such a theme without uttering many inestimable observations. His versatile genius and vivacious mind naturally find full scope in dilating upon so familiar a topic. Nevertheless, we make bold to say that these sparkling lectures contain much that is very deleterious, and we hope the young men of Yale College will have grace to use the best filter within their reach. Mingled with very much that is excellent, there are passages of the most mischievous kind, which we greatly deplore. The lecturer is far removed from that Henry Ward Beecher whose voice sounded forth "Royal Truths" in years gone by. His allusion to Mr. Spurgeon is worth quoting for its infelicity:—

"Question.—Is it not true that Spurgeon is a follower of Calvin, and is he not an eminent example of success?

"MR. BEECHER—In spite of it, yes; but I do not believe that the camel travels any better, or is any more useful as an animal, for the hump on its back."

Calvinism, it seems, is to Mr. Spurgeon what a hump is to a camel; and Mr. Beecher is of opinion that camels' humps are a mistake. Mr. Beecher's Maker, however, does not think so, or he would not have created camels with humps. Naturalists assure us that the hump is of great importance in the eyes of the Arabs, who judge of the condition of their beasts by the size, shape, and firmness of their humps. They say, and truly, that the camel feeds upon his hump, for in proportion as the animal traverses the sandy wastes, and suffers from privation and fatigue, the mass diminishes; and it is not fit for a long journey till the hump has regained its proportions. Calvinism, then, is the spiritual meat which enables a man to labour on in the ways of Christian service; and, though ridiculed as a hump by those who are only lookers on, those who traverse the weary paths of a wilderness experience, know too well its value to be willing to part with it, even if a Beecher's splendid talents could be given in exchange.

The Life of the Venerable Hugh Bourne. By WILLIAM ANTLITT, D.D. George Lamb, Sutton Street, Commercial Road, E.

WE were prepared for a great treat upon opening this book, and we have been disappointed. The author quotes with such pertinacity that he has produced a collection of elegant extracts, as well as a biography. The work is interesting, and to Primitive Methodists it will be very attractive; but it is not our ideal of a biography. For so plain, and simple-minded, and unaffected a man as Hugh Bourne there was needed not a mosaic of many coloured marbles, but a grand uncarved monolith.

Upward and Onward: a Thought Book for the Threshold of Active Life. By S. W. PARTRIDGE. Partridge and Co.

WE do not wonder that this volume is in the eighth thousand. It cannot be called first-class poetry, but it very nearly approximates thereto. From a single brief chapter we cull the following lines, right worthy of being quoted:

"Faith is the medicine to unsting our cares."

"Thou standest just where thou hast climbed or fall'n;

And if the credit be not all thine own,

Thine own assuredly is all the blame.

Within the rough rind of thy aging heart

Behold the rings of all thy former years.

Thy jest is living still; thou'rt what thou art

Because thou hast been what thou'st been."

"To-morrow disappoints that man alone

Who has despised to-day."

"How old, my brother? Nay, how good art thou?

Tell me thy wisdom, I will tell thy age.

In wisdom many of the young are old,

And many old have not yet learned to live."

Life of Henry Dunster, first President of the Harvard College. By Rev. JEREMIAH CHAPLIN, D.D. Boston [U.S.]: James R. Osgood and Co.

THE life of a great man, whose reputation passed under a cloud of neglect through his fidelity to God's truth and his own conscience. He dared to become a Baptist, and for this reason he was put out of the synagogue. The author, with such a subject before him, ought to have produced a more interesting volume. What is wanted in this life of Dunster is more of Dunster.

The Book of Genesis and Part of the Book of Exodus; a Revised Version, with Marginal References and an Exegetical Commentary. By HENRY ALFORD, D.D., late Dean of Canterbury. Strahan and Co.

DEAN ALFORD undertook to write a Commentary upon the Old Testament. He was taken from among men when he had reached Exodus XXV. The unfinished volume is published exactly as he left it. It will surely be quite needless for us to call attention to the work. Alford is always instructive, though he needs to be read with discernment. Scholarly men only need to know that he has written, and they will at once procure his work.

The Christian Standard; a Weekly Penny Journal of sixteen large quarto pages. Conducted by JAMES GRANT. William Macintosh, 24, Paternoster Row.

We are glad to receive information that Mr. Grant will on the 10th of October commence a new penny religious journal. The Rationalistic and Ritualistic parties are so well represented in the religious penny press that it is time the evangelical school should have its organ also. The remarkable ability of the Latitudinarian papers will demand from Mr. Grant his utmost effort to produce a journal which can compete with them. Since he is no novice at the work we look for great things, and so far as jealousy for the gospel is concerned we feel perfectly safe in his

hands. We wish any man success who will fight against Anythingarianism, and for this reason we look upon Mr. Grant's enterprise with the deepest interest; no man living is a more determined foe of semi-infidelity than our friend. As the upholder of the Christian Standard may his course be triumphant.

On the Religious Truths. By THOMAS LEIGH, Lesswade. Edinburgh: Wm. Oliphant and Co.

DR. BRODIE in a prefatory note to this little volume states that it is the composition of a person in humble life, who has not enjoyed much education. We can only say it is a very great credit to him, for it is a work which a doctor to divinity might have written. It is quite a little hand-book of theology, and might be worked through by Bible classes with great advantage. We hope Mr. Leigh will continue to improve his mind, for his is a mind worth cultivating. Generous friends should encourage such a writer by purchasing the volume.

The Mission of the Holy Ghost; or, the Office and Work of the Comforter in Human Redemption. By Rev. LEWIS R. DUNN. Wesleyan Conference Office.

MARRED, of course, by Arminian views, this work nevertheless contains a clear testimony to Scriptural truths of the highest importance. We are glad that our Wesleyan friends preserve so thoroughly their witness to the essential necessity of the Spirit's work.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate