Menu
‹ Chapter 161 of 203 ›

GIANT DESPAIR

6 min read · Chapter 161 of 203

WHAT marvellous vicissitudes are there in Christian experience! What heights and depths! What variations of light and shade! What sudden transitions from midnight to noonday, and from noonday to the gloom of night! What frequent and rapid alternations of sunshine and storm! These "are the works of the Lord and his wonders in the deep. For he commandeth and raiseth up the stormy wind, which lifieth up the waves thereof. They mount up to the heaven, they go down again to the depths: their soul is melted because of trouble. They reel to and fro, and stagger like a drunken man, and are at their wit's end. Then they cry unto the Lord in their trouble, and he bringeth them out of their distresses. He maketh the storm a calm so that the waves thereof are still." The alternations are inexplicable to others, but they are well understood by Christians themselves. In the pursuit of great objects in the things of this life, such changes are common to men. The competitor in the Olympic race, in ancient times, felt the deepest emotions struggling within him. Thousands of spectators were intensely excited on his

behalf, but none knew but himself the dreadful alternations of hope and fear in his own breast. The merchant, whose whole fortune is risked in a single undertaking, is tortured with continual interchanges of confidence and despair. "Now they do it to obtain a corruptible crown; but we an incorruptible." Think of the object which the Christian pilgrim has in view, and the awful alternative of missing the prize, and the reasons of his deep and mingled emotions must be obvious to all. They are changes of feelings, or experience, strictly so called; and not of moral principles, or of doctrinal views. In proportion to his desire to seize the prize, will be his eagerness in its pursuit; and in proportion to his striving, will be the agonizing intermission of hope and fear. It is the magnitude of the object which he has in view that demands such anxieties and cares. These are the deep things of God, and are known to those only who are of God. The majestic river, with its foaming cataract, and its resistless flow, now silently reflecting in its deep bosom the glories of the peaceful heavens, and now breaking the silence with the voice of many waters, as the voice of a great thunder, is not to be judged by the murmuring rill. "The world knoweth us not, because it knew him not."—Him, who, "for the joy that was set before him, endured the cross and despised the shame."

We have now to behold Bunyan's Pilgrim under the cruel and crushing influence of Giant Despair. This is preceded by the pleasantest part of his past pilgrimage. He has walked and slept, in company with Hopeful, by the banks of a river surrounded by green trees, with all manner of fruits, and for several days and nights. The way then becomes rough. In By-path Meadow, a smooth path seems to lay parallel with the rough road before them. Here they pause, and by the advice of Pilgrim, they enter upon it. They have not gone far, before they meet with Vain-Confidence, who falls into a deep pit and is dashed to pieces, just before them. Who was this Vain-Confidence? It was Pilgrim's own vain confidence, without doubt, which had led him astray. He had "asked him whither that way led?" He said, "To the Celestial Gate." "Look," said Christian, "did I not tell you so? By this you may see we are right." Now that Vain-Confidence is dashed to pieces, and Hopeful says, "Where are we now?" Pilgrim is silent, as mistrusting that he had led him out of the way. He had been guided by vain confidence rather than by hope. Night suddenly comes on, and amidst rain, and thunder, and lightning, Pilgrim and Hopeful endeavour to retrace their steps. At length they fall to sleep from very weariness, and in this state are discovered in the morning by Giant Despair, on whose grounds they had trespassed, and are taken by him into Doubting Castle. Here they are put into a dark and filthy dungeon, from Wednesday morning till Saturday night, without food and without anyone to visit them. The next morning, by the advice of his wife Diffidence, Giant Despair goes into the dungeon, and with a cudgel beats them unmercifully. The next night he recommends them to put an end to their own existence, as the best way of putting an end to their miseries; from which Pilgrim is prevented by the influence of Hopeful. The Giant, soon after returning, is enraged to find they have not taken his advice. The next morning he takes them into the castle-yard to see the bones and skulls of many who had there died, and then leads them back to their dungeon. The next night, after they had prayed, Pilgrim recollects that he had a key in his bosom, called Promise, that would open any lock in Doubting-Castle. "Then," said Hopeful, "that is good news, good brother; pluck it out of thy bosom and try." With this he soon opens the dungeon door, and the door of the castle-yard, and the iron gate; and they run back to the stile in By-path Meadow, and are glad to find themselves, once more, in the King's highway.

It is admitted by all interpreters that Giant Despair and his wife Diffidence are not characters apart from Pilgrim's own experience. They would, doubtless, have given them a separate existence if they could. Their theory demanded it of them, and nothing but the absurdity of carrying it out in this instance prevented them. Dr. Cheever says: "The personification of Despair

475

is one of the most instructive and beautiful portions of Bunyan's Allegory." Again he says: "All this is related as a story with such natural incidents, with such power of character, and such vivid colouring, that no story of a life could be more graphic; and yet it is allegory, it is the experience of the mind alone; but allegory so perfect, the experience so touched into life, that each becomes either, and may be perfect story or allegory, as you please." It cannot, we think, be "perfect story or allegory," in itself considered. A perfect story may be included in the allegory, but the allegory itself is not the story. We take it to be a perfect allegory, or, in other words, an allegorical representation of literal realities. It is not fiction, properly so called. Fiction is a description of what is literally false, allegory of what is literally true. The allegory itself is not to be literally taken, and yet this, we humbly conceive, has been repeatedly done in the interpretation of this book. The confusion to which it leads is evident in the instance before us. Hopeful is a real person, Giant Despair is not. Why the one and not the other? If Giant Despair be the personification of Despair, why should not Hopeful be the personification of hope? Why should despair and hope, the two conflicting principles in the mind of Pilgrim, be so differently portrayed that one should be his own experience, and the other the experience of some other person, the one within him, the other without, the one his own despair, the other another's hope? Carry out your literal theory to the full, we say, if that be your rule of interpretation. Let a "perfect allegory" be the rule, and no inconsistency occurs. Christian is the only person on this occasion; and his is the only name that could not be a mere personification. By-path Meadow, Vain-Confidence, Giant Despair, the wife Diffidence, Hopeful, Doubting-Castle, the foul Dungeon, are all contained in the one individual experience.

The influence of Hopeful is evidently the part which his hope would take, when tempted first to vain confidence, and then to despair; and without which he certainly has no hope of his own. Hopeful was more inclined than Pilgrim to turn aside to view the silver mine at the invitation of Demas, while Pilgrim was more inclined than Hopeful to choose the path in By-path meadow. The one was in sight, and the other not. Hope that is seen is not hope. Hopeful was no great scholar, but was scholar enough to read the inscription upon a pillar by the road side, "Remember Lot's wife," because that spake eloquently of the necessity of fleeing for refuge to the hope set before us. Hopeful was silent during the days and nights they were lying down in green pastures and beside the still waters; because, "if a man hope for that which he sees not, then doth he patiently wait for it." Of By-path meadow, Hopeful says to Pilgrim, "I was afraid of it at the very first, and therefore gave you that gentle caution. I would have spoken plainer, but that you are older than I." Of course, every man is older than his own hope, but not necessarily older than the hope of another. Hopeful takes the lead back, as Pilgrim had done when they went astray. Hopeful is Pilgrim's only companion in Doubting Castle, prevents him from destroying himself, and encourages him to hope against hope, so that he was literally saved by Hope. When the key of promise was discovered in Pilgrim's bosom, Hopeful recognised it at once as the way of deliverance; for hope gives the key of promise its adaptation and power. Thus Hopeful takes the very part which every Christian's hope would take in similar circumstances, and is therefore his own hope, and needs not be that of another.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate