New York Waifs and Strays
WHAT plan of action will best ensure that our dangerous classes shall be reclaimed and transformed into useful members of society? How shall we utilize for purposes of good what is now depraved and corrupt? What processes of purification have we within our reach? These questions concern not only Christians, they are of moment to all social economists, who desire to preserve intact the safeguards of civilisation against the powers of evil—against those existing forces which, though now lying dormant could, if awakened and united, speedily lay waste many cherished monuments of this cultured and wealthy age.
Only endeavour to imagine the moral condition of our own great capital. Though, doubtless, yielding in a measure to the mighty efforts put forth for its renovation, London is still the feeder of a stream of
* The Dangerous Classes of New York, and Twenty Years' Work among them. By Charles Loring Brace. (New York: Wynkoop and Hallenbeck. 1872.)
453
vice and crime, broad enough and deep enough to inspire our philanthropists with anguish or even with alarm. The combustibles of human depravity hidden in the slums of Paris have more than once ignited, and in their explosion have carried desolation and death into what were but a few hours before, peaceful streets, alive with industry or gay with scenes of pleasure. Therefore is it that experience teaches us the wisdom of exercising a becoming vigilance over what are justly styled the dangerous classes. The outbreaks in Paris of revolutionary mobs are matters of history: the sorrows of London are before our eyes; and now an author comes forward to affirm that New York is cursed with plague-spots which have "the unhappy fame of containing more human beings packed to the square yard, and stained with more acts of blood and riot, within a given period, than is true of any other equal space of earth in the civilized world!"
New York has peculiarities which need not be mentioned—traits of national character not common to great cities of the Old world. From her insular situation have arisen some evils, not the least being the excessive crowding to which the poor are subjected. We are told of a close packing together of human beings exceeding what can be witnessed even in London: and a prolific source of crime and immorality is the practice of men, women, and children, herding in rookeries where pigs would sicken and die.
Happily New York is well served by earnest philanthropists and charitable societies: but the authorities have yet to learn something from our own sanitary measures, and from such little concessions to the poor as the English institution of workmen's trains. The city, it is true, is exposed in an exceptional manner to many adverse influences. It is a central receptacle for the offscourings of society in other countries, and the contaminating mass, working like an evil leaven corrupts and then destroys what is pure and good. New countries have to contend against special disadvantages. Persons resorting to them may lapse into criminals, or into a lower condition of life than they have been accustomed to lead at home, because moral restraint grows weaker when temptations become more numerous. Among the crowds who seek homes on the American shores, ignorance asserts her ascendancy in an alarming degree: and about a third part of the criminal population are unable either to read or write! Another source of evil in New York has been bad local government. Frauds and official robbery have become rampant as they could not have become in any other place, and not a small share of the penalties thus entailed on the community come home to the poor. It is also observable in new, rich and rapidly rising communities that an impatience to be rich settles down on all classes of the industrial population. We hear about the "increasing aversion of American children, whether poor or rich, to learn anything thoroughly; the boys of the street, like those of our merchants, preferring to make fortunes by lucky and sudden 'turns,' rather than by patient and steady industry."
Mr. Brace, whose long experience in Christian labour among the degraded classes renders him an authority in many departments of philanthropy, offers some pertinent remarks on the relationship existing between crime and excessive drinking. Like other far-sighted friends
29
of true temperance, he does not hope to abolish drunkenness by sweeping acts of Congress, but would have light wines supersede the strong and harmful drinks which are too much appreciated by Americans as well as English. However beneficial the adoption of the temperance pledge may prove in numbers of instances, we may believe that Christianity rather than teetotalism is the only cure for what has become a national sin.
It was in 1852 that Mr. Brace and others banded themselves together as labourers in the work of rescuing the vagrant children of New York. These it was proposed to Christianise prior to making endeavours to raise them socially by providing them honourable situations in commercial houses, or by the preferable procedure of removing them into the country and settling them on the land. Said the introductory circular:
"As means shall come in it is designed to district the city, so that hereafter every ward may have its agent who may be a friend to the vagrant child. 'Boys' Sunday Meetings' have already been formed, which we hope to see extended until every quarter has its place of preaching to boys. With these we intend to connect 'Industrial Schools,' where the great temptations to this class arising from want of work may be removed, and where they can learn an honest trade. Arrangements have been made with manufacturers, by which, if we have the requisite funds to begin, five hundred boys in different localities can be supplied with paying work. We hope to especially be the means of draining the city of these children, by communicating with farmers, manufacturers, or families in the country, who may have need of such for employment. When homeless boys are found by our agents we mean to get them homes in the families of respectable needy persons in the city, and put them in the way of an honest living. We desire, in a word, to bring humane and kindly influences to bear on this forsaken class—to preach in various modes the gospel of Christ to the vagrant children of New York."
Such a society was not likely to die for want of subjects on whom to exercise its charity. Like all great cities, New York has to bewail the existence of notoriously wicked localities, and to these the agents at once directed their attention. In one quarter was found a colony of depraved Germans, called the Rag-Pickers' Den, where "the houses were flaunting with dirty banners," and the yards in the rear were "heaped up with refuse." In another direction was a similar settlement, where even little children were vicious. Nor were lodging-houses for professional thieves wanting. Through one street where rogues fraternised, it was currently believed that droves of cattle could not pass without one or more of the animals being stolen! Other plague-spots existed where human depravity, native and imported, reigned and rioted.
The reclamation of street-boys was begun with an earnest faith which promised good results. It was found that a certain amount of tact and circumspection was needed; for New York Arabs, like their counterparts in London, are not without a sense of independence. They relish what they pay for far better than if the same were gratuitously bestowed; and hence, it is always judicious to cherish the faintest spark of self-respect. Helping the poor to help themselves is the truest charity. Judicious assistance has often ennobled, while mere almsgiving has
455
only fostered vagrancy. These considerations were well understood by those who in 1854 begun collecting funds for a Boys' Lodging-house. Difficulties and discouragements sprang up apace; but they yielded to the perseverance and enthusiasm of Christian enterprise, e. g. :
"An excellent superintendent was found in the person of a carpenter, Mr. C. C. Tracy, who showed remarkable ingenuity and tact in the management of these wild lads. These little subjects regarded the first arrangements with some suspicion and some contempt. To find a good bed offered them for six cents, with a bath thrown in, and a supper for four cents, was a hard fact, which they could rest upon and understand; but the motive was evidently 'gaseous.' There was 'no money in it'—that was clear. The superintendent was probably 'a street preacher,' and this was a trap to get them to Sunday-schools, and so prepare them for the House of Refuge. Still they might have 'a lark' there, and it would be no worse than 'bumming,' i.e., sleeping out. They laid their plans for a general scrimmage in the school-room—first cutting off the gas, and then a row in the bed-room. The superintendent, however, in a bland and benevolent way, nipped their plans in the bud. The gas-pipes were guarded; the rough ringleaders were politely dismissed to the lower door, where an officer looked after their welfare; and when the first boots began to fly from a little fellow's bed he found himself suddenly walked out by a gentle but muscular hand, and left in the cold to shiver over his folly. The others began to feel that a mysterious authority was getting even with them, and thought it better to nestle in their warm beds. Little sleeping, however, was there among them that night; but ejaculations sounded out—such as 'I say, Jim, this is rayther better 'an bummin'—eh?' 'My eyes what soft beds these is!' 'Tom! its 'most as good as a steam gratin', and there aint no M. P.'s to poke neither.' 'I'm glad I aint a bummer to-night!' A good wash and a breakfast sent the lodgers forth in the morning, happier and cleaner, if not better, than when they went in. This night's success established its popularity with the newsboys. The 'Fulton Lodge' soon became a boys' hotel, and one loft was known among them as the 'Astor House.' Quietly and judiciously did Mr. Tracy advance his work among them. 'Boys,' said he one morning, 'there was a gentleman here this morning, who wanted a boy in an office, at three dollars a week.' 'My eyes! Let me go sir!' 'And—me, sir!' 'But he wanted a boy who could write a good hand.' Their countenances fell. 'Well, now, suppose we have a night-school, and learn to write—what do you say boys?' 'Agreed, sir.' And so arose our evening school."
This institution was soon supplemented by a savings'-bank and Sunday-school, and now the boys who are benefited by passing through its doors number several thousands annually. The large sums saved to the community by preventive agencies like these cannot be calculated; and, for such reasons, many of the truly wise cheerfully subscribe the necessary means for carrying on the work, though a large proportion of the current expenses is provided by the boys themselves.
But while making praiseworthy efforts on behalf of boys, girls were not overlooked. Tender hearts were drawn towards the crowds of little slatterns, who shoeless and ragged roamed about the chosen haunts of vice and typhus, and a scheme was matured which should first rescue and then raise them to happiness and usefulness. The plan adopted was similar to what others are carrying out in London. A ragged-school, served both by paid and voluntary teachers, was organised, many of the best families in the city not only sending in subscriptions but entering into the work with heart and hand.
It needed no sagacious foresight to perceive that work so auspiciously inaugurated would prosper under the blessing of heaven, though the harvest reaped in good effected and in evil prevented probably exceeded the expectations of the modest evangelists. They read a lesson which many could learn with profit—to expect as well as to pray for great things. It was not long before an agency was in action which brought hundreds of children under a Christian discipline prior to placing them out in respectable situations—children who otherwise would have grown up into moral pests by sinking to the lowest condition to which women can descend. Though hard-working enthusiastic Christians were at work they became surprised at their own success. Wonderful did it appear when surely and rapidly, by the favour of God, the good seed of truth took root in rough wild natures, or in the hearts of street rovers who already betrayed the impatient American temperament. Ragged-school work is doubtless fraught with discouragement, besides being in a measure unpleasant; but, is it not a fact that little girls, however unfavourable their surroundings, are often peculiarly susceptible of good impressions? When separated from wicked homes and abandoned companions of their own age, they are easily moulded into reformed or even attractive characters. Very cheering is the testimony which comes from New York: "Though living in the same houses with the gay dance-salooners, they (the scholars) had no desire for the company of these bold girls, or to earn their living in this idle and shameful manner. They felt the disgrace of the abandoned life around them, and were soon above it. Though almost invariably the children of drunkards, they did not inherit the appetites of their mothers, or if they did, their new training substituted higher and stronger desires."
Schools of a similar character were also provided for the poor children of the German population. Here the results were quite as encouraging as in other departments, the numbers rescued from lairs of vice and careers of life-long depredation having been very large. Total failures, though necessarily occurring, were few, for out of two thousand scholars, who from time to time were subjected to the Christian and industrial discipline, only five were known to relapse into vicious courses.
What will be their future? the Christian moralist asks himself as he looks over the classes of a ragged-school. In a new country like America there is more likelihood of Romance being mixed up with the fortunes of a street waif than there can be in our older established and perhaps more prosaic England.
"A few years ago (says Mr. Brace) I remember an old shanty on 'Dutchhill,' where a wretched-looking man lived with his pigs and goats, called K—. He was considered a bad man even among his bad neighbours, and the story of him was, (I do not know how true), that he had committed murder, and had escaped the law by some legal quibble. He was a swill-gatherer, and had two little bright-eyed daughters to assist him at home. These came to our Fortieth-street school. They improved very fast, and one used to attract much attention from the ladies by her pretty face and intelligent answers. Nellie finally left the school, and was sent by us to the West. She improved much there, and, after some time spent in different families, came back to the city, where she became 'an operator' on the sewing machine. While at this business and living in a respectable boarding-house, she attracted the attention of a gentleman
457
of some means and position, much older than herself, who at length offered himself to her in marriage. She declined on the ground that she was so much inferior in position to him, and that his family would object. He insisted, and declared that he wished to please himself, not his family, and they were married. He took his wife away to a foreign country, where his business lay, and there she has been a number of years, gradually improving in manners, taste, and education, living like a lady of fortune, with her maid and carriage, and making herself, in every way, a most suitable wife for one who had been so much above her. We had often heard of her good fortune. But during our Christmas festival at the East-river school, she herself came in to see it again and thank those who had been so kind to her. We all knew her at once; and yet she was so changed—a pretty, tasteful-looking young lady, with a graceful manner and a Spanish accent now—all the old stamp of 'Dutch-hill' quite gone, even the brogue lost, and replaced by foreign intonations. She was perfectly simple and unaffected, and thanked us all for our former kindness with the utmost heartiness; and told her story very simply, and how anxious she still was to improve her education, seemingly not ashamed of her poor origin. It is a pleasant circumstance that she has taken out her beloved teacher, Mrs. Hurley, a number of times to drive in her carriage."
Parents among the very poor in New York, however, are far from being all vicious like the denizens of "Rag Pickers' Den" or the mysterious swill-gatherer. The Capital of the New World shelters many who are able to show surpassing examples of faith and patient endurance. One sempstress, after being deserted by a worthless husband, toiled for the support of her little household until overtaken by the weakness of approaching death. Amid the frost and snow of the fierce American winter she used to go forth to a store to fetch bundles of shirts, and on returning, perhaps wet and exhausted, would still toil at the sewing until the small hours of morning, and until the blood which came from her lungs spoke of overtaxed strength. This was all done out of love to her children, two of whom sickened and died only a little time before the mother herself lay upon the bed of death. Her bearing in what appeared a forlorn condition, drew tears of delight from beholders; for the poor needlewoman presented a rare example of simple and rejoicing faith. She spoke of her youth—of its sunny days, and of how differently the world had turned out to the promises of early life. Like a fatigued traveller she lay resting at the end of the mortal journey with such songs in her mouth, as—
"Oh how glad I am to die;
His rod and His staff they comfort me."
In addition to other foreign colonists New York has a number of Italian musicians at Five Points, and to the juveniles of this settlement the attention of the Children's Aid Society was attracted in 1855. The Italians lived in crazy shanties and were the subjects of filth and ignorance, though they were not cursed by the more flagrant sins of great cities. Their heaviest misfortune consisted in living from year to year unnoticed by the charitable and unreached by any Christian agency. This school, when opened, was vehemently denounced by the Romanists until their opposition opportunely ceased. A priest, after projecting a counter-scheme in the interest of popery, suddenly decamped to Italy with the funds he had collected.
The good results of this school soon made themselves manifest. Unwashed little faces which hitherto had usually come in contact with soap-and-water only once a week suddenly brightened into cleanliness, if not into intelligence. Sanitary reforms will always appear in the wake of Christianity: for when in due time these children married and had families of their own, their homes appeared as oases in the squalor and misery which abounded in their vicinity. Many who were thus rescued went abroad into the States to occupy useful positions in various trades and professions, while others returned to their native Italy.
Efforts made on behalf of foreigners proper, however, constituted but a small part of the aggressive work carried on by what may be called the American Ragged School Union. The crowds of uncared for children belonging to the native poor in general were the Society's chosen constituents. Then having carried on their operations to a certain stage the difficult problem awaited solution.—What shall be done with those whom instruction and discipline have reclaimed for honest labour? In common with other great centres of industrial life New York was over-crowded, and therefore it was not to be expected that suitable openings could be found for an army of Arabs amid the keen competition of an over-stocked labour market. A rich, and judged by its productiveness, an almost limitless country lay Westward. The country was fine and inviting; yet probably it was with some misgivings that the question was asked, might the children be sent thither? What? Collect Arabs from the polluted recesses of the capital and scatter them among the untainted rural populace? Would not the farmers resist, and all honest people declaim against their districts being contaminated by a tide of juvenile depravity? These might be valid objections; but compelled by necessity the committee looked hopefully towards those Western farmers to whom "it is of the utmost importance to train up children who shall aid in their work, and be associates of their own children. A servant who is nothing but a servant, would be with them disagreeable and inconvenient. They like to educate their own 'help.' With their overflowing supply of food also, each new mouth in the household brings no drain on their means. Children are a blessing, and the mere feeding of a boy or girl is not considered at all."
The resolution to try the West having been formed, advertisements were inserted in the newspapers, when it was immediately found that in the far-away rural districts openings really did exist for the willing hands who were waiting to fill them. Hundreds of letters came to hand asking for children such as those described; and though certain fastidious employers could not always be supplied with auburn-haired, blue-eyed maidens, nor with well-shaped, strong-limbed, intellectual boys, such as they desired, they were commonly satisfied in the end, e.g.:
"The effort to place the city children of the street in country families revealed a spirit of humanity and kindness, throughout the rural districts, which was truly delightful to see. People bore with these children of poverty, sometimes, as they did not with their own. There was—and not in one or two families alone—a sublime spirit of patience exhibited towards these unfortunate little creatures, a bearing with defects and inherited evils, a forgiving over and over again of sins and wrongs, which showed how deep a hold the spirit of
459
Christ had taken of many of our countrywomen. . . . We formed little companies of emigrants, and after thoroughly cleansing and clothing them, put them under a competent agent, and, first selecting a village where there was a call or opening for such a party, we despatched them to the place. The farming community having been duly notified, there was usually a dense crowd of people at the station awaiting the arrival of the youthful travellers. The sight of the little company of the children of misfortune always touched the hearts of a population naturally generous. They were soon billeted around among the citizens, and the following day a public meeting was called in the church or town-hall, and a committee appointed of leading citizens. The agent then addressed the assembly, stating the benevolent objects of the Society, and something of the history of the children. The sight of their worn faces was a most pathetic enforcement of his arguments. People who were childless came forward to adopt children; others, who had not intended to take any into their families, were induced to apply for them; and many who really wanted the children's labour pressed forward to obtain it."
Very effective in producing the best results was the system of first educating and then removing vagrant children into spheres where their labour was valuable. It is said that the agency might even be extended until it superseded all the orphanages in New York, for eligible situations can readily be found for five thousand children annually. The demand for strong active boys is virtually unlimited, though in the first instance the farmers were not entirely free from misgivings. One asked, "'Won't the boys run away?' 'Did you ever see a cow run away from a hay-stack?' was Mr. Tracy's rejoinder. 'Treat him well and he'll be sure to stay.' And the bland and benevolent manner in which he would reply to an irritated employer, who came back to report that the 'New York boy' had knocked over the milk-pail, and pelted the best cow, and let the cattle in the corn, and left the young turkeys in the rain, &c., &c., was delightful to behold. 'My dear friend, can you expect boys to be perfect at once? Did'nt you ever pelt the cattle when you were a boy?'"
In the course of all these endeavours among the roughs of New York the experiment was tried of providing free news-rooms for the working-classes—rooms where light refreshments could be had, but no intoxicants. This did not at once succeed; for though comfortable well-supplied apartments were secured, the institution had to be regarded as a failure, and was therefore closed. Subsequently, the scheme was revived, and the superintendence was intrusted to a man who had been a celebrated prize-fighter and notorious profligate. It may not often be well for such characters to fill places of publicity and trust; but this man's conversion was so sincere that his may be spoken of as an exceptional case. Under his care the free news rooms were blessed with much success, and hundreds of persons of the classes intended to be benefited, found good by coming into contact with the converted pugilist. Eventually, the superintendent was compelled by circumstances to relinquish his situation, and the rooms were closed, though others of a similar character were opened in different parts of the city.
Another important branch of work undertaken consisted in offering help and encouragement to such friendless and homeless girls as had not wilfully strayed from virtue, and were under eighteen years of age.
A kind of lodging-house was opened, the accommodation of which the inmates paid for, or received gratuitously according to their condition. The subjects especially sought were the unfortunate and destitute rather than the vicious, though some who were actually fallen found their way into the institution.
"The plan seemed at once to reach its objects: the doors opened on a forlorn procession of unfortunates. Girls broke out of houses of vice, where they had been entrapped, leaving every article of dress, except what they wore, behind them; the police brought wretched young wanderers, who had slept on the station floors; the daughters of decent country people, who had come to the town for amusement or employment, and, losing or wasting their means, had walked the streets all the night long, applied for shelter; orphans, selling flowers, or pedling about the theatres; the children of drunkards; the unhappy daughters of families where quarrelling and abuse were the rule; girls who had run away; girls who had been driven away; girls who sought a respite in intervals of vice,—all this most unfortunate throng began to beset the doors of the Girls' Lodging House."
Having reached the classes intended to be benefited, and in regard to admission, having drawn the line where prudence dictated, another grateful harvest of good results was reaped. The gospel knowledge imparted was supplemented by instructions in housewifery and other useful arts. Then, as they became competent, or as situations opened for their reception, these girls, in many instances picked up from the streets, were made comparatively happy for life, and became a blessing instead of a curse to their generation.
Occasionally some real romance enters into the history of these young creatures; for an old scholar has reappeared as a lady staying with her husband at a leading hotel; and naturally she would call at the institution and tell her experience since leaving the friends by whom she was first put in the way of prosperity.
In ten years many thousands of girls passed through the lodging-house, not a few of whom must have been benefited. "Among this number there are many cosily sitting by their own hearth-stones; others are filling positions of usefulness and trust in families and stores; some have been adopted in distant towns, where they fill a daughter's place; and some have gone to return no more. A large number we cannot trace. During this period, three thousand one hundred and one have found employment and gone to situations, or returned to friends. Fifteen thousand four hundred and twenty-nine garments have been cut and made, and distributed among the poor, or used as outfits in sending companies west."
Some worthy success was also achieved in a quarter of the city where the youthful population were exceptionally bad, the boys in particular, becoming a terror to peace-loving people, and known to the police as street-rats. Notorious robberies, and even murders, were committed by characters known as "the nineteenth street gang." In this department the work of the evangelist was uphill indeed, and might have been relinquished in despair, on account of the apparent impossibility of producing any good impressions. Yet faith and perseverance were rewarded, when boys, who seemed incorrigible up to the time of going Westward, were led to see the error of their ways, to repent and to reform.
461
Thus numbers of schools were established in different parts of New York, and each drawing its constituents from slums and rookeries, drafted them off into the labour market of the rural districts. It is cheering to see that our transatlantic friends are not sufficiently engrossed with dollar-earning to become blind to the evils springing from ignorance. So far from being indifferent to the alarming dangers which threaten large empires, when the vicious and ignorant are allowed to multiply and to attract whatever is impure and criminal, the Americans are as ready as ourselves to support any agency which Christian philanthropists may propose for lessening sin and misery. It is well it is so; for in the United States there are five millions of persons over ten years of age who are unable to write, and of this demoralized and demoralizing crowd New York has an undue proportion. "The demagogues of this city would never have won their amazing power but for those sixty thousand persons who never read or write," says Mr. Brace; "It is this class and their associates who made these politicians what they are."
Americans who are working heartily in that noblest of callings—the carrying of the gospel to the very poor, are setting an example which we, on this side of the Atlantic are glad to hear about, and by which we hope to profit. Such a record as the one written by Mr. Brace, as well as the Reports issued by our own Ragged-school Union should teach the kind-hearted among us in what true charity consists. Such reports loudly condemn street almsgiving. Experience has shown that charity may commit mistakes. While hoping that she is relieving the necessitous she may really only be encouraging the idle and vicious. Indiscriminate almsgiving becomes a national moral curse, for it overlooks the poor, who will not parade their poverty, and it encourages the unprincipled, who by cunning and deception gain liberal incomes, and too often live comparatively luxurious lives. Let us be discreet even in our philanthropy. We work in vain if we do not foster self-respect and independence in the poor, by teaching them to help themselves in the true spirit of Christianity.
