The Primitive Church of the Highlands
TO trace the footprints of religion in a world like ours, a world whose records are dismal with recitals of wrong-doing and of bloodshed, is to look on the bright side of history. It is not unprofitable to withdraw the mind from these times of keen competition and of hastening to be rich, by transporting our thoughts to ages when British wealth lay undeveloped, and when wood and moor occupied the sites of many towns, which, in their grim majesty, are now the recognised offspring of modern industry. We shall take the reader to days when Christianity had not contracted the corruptions which provoked the Reformation; when the discipline of institutions set apart for learning and piety had not degenerated into the mock austerities of a later monachism; when, in fine, the missionaries of Iona, as preachers of Christ, and as agents of civilization, were the glory of the church, and were earning for themselves a fame as lasting as time, in "that illustrious isle, which was once the luminary of the Caledonian regions, whence savage clans and roving barbarians derived the benefits of knowledge, and the blessings of religion."
A worthy interest in the resting-places of religion very widely differs from the relic-worship of popery. Cowards, it is true, are not transformed by walking over ground where heroes have fought; nor are the worldly-minded likely to grow religious by indulging sentimental emotions, and gratifying an archaeological curiosity among the ashes of the saints. Nevertheless, such as prize the faith may sometimes gather comfort, instruction and encouragement from reviewing the labours of those who have ended the toilsome day.
Iona, as only our youngest readers need be told, is one of the Hebrides or western islands of Scotland, situated thirty-six miles from the mainland in 56° 59' north latitude. The area of the islet is two thousand acres, the length being about three miles, and the breadth little more than one mile. To this speck in the Atlantic hundreds of tourists are attracted annually; for from its shores the Highlands of Scotland first received the light of the gospel.
The celebrated evangelist whom we know by his Latinized name of Columba—the star of the sixth century—was born in the year 521, and reckoned among his ancestors several kings of Ireland. In those days the Emerald Isle was the chief asylum of Christianity, its population being the most faithful of any among European nations. Being thus blessed in the country of his birth, the future missionary received such a pious and learned training as well qualified him for his future onerous undertakings, while a docile and becoming bearing in youth caused him to be called a little saint by the grave presbyters who conducted his education. On returning to Ireland after a Continental tour, he might have been excused as a youth had his brilliant prospects occasioned pride and elation. He could have commanded an enviable
* I. Iona. By the Duke of Argyll. London: 1870.
II. Saint Columba, Apostle of Caledonia. By the Count De Montalembert. Edinburgh and London: 1868.
station in his own beloved Erin, or have shone in case and idleness at the Court of France; but he conquered his passionate love of country, relinquished alluring worldly prospects, and even surrendered his estate for love of the gospel.
Romanists class Columba among their monks and apostles with as little reason as can be found to justify their beginning their catalogue of popes with the name of Peter. It would have been a good service to the cause of Protestantism, had the Duke of Argyll cleared the memory of this primitive pastor from the lies and legends with which Rome has burdened it; for even Montalembert, with his genial humour and unmistakable powers of graphic delineation, has contributed almost more than his share towards transforming the grand old Christian hero of the Hebrides into a mere saint of the Romish calendar.
Our present purpose is to invite attention to the life of a man, whom all admit to have been a great evangelist; who laboured before Rome, put forth her iniquitous pretensions, and defiled itself with virgin-worship. Columba recognised no Pope of Rome, and invoked no saints; yet Romanists, who never lack boldness when the honour of their hierarchy is at stake, claim him as a father, and Iona as one of their sacred places. By invention and exaggeration, monkish writers have marred the missionary's beautiful life; besides so interweaving the facts of his life with absurdities, that only with care and difficulty can the truth be recovered from an entangled web of falsehood. The pastor or abbot—either term will suit him—lived in an age not only far remote from ours, but when many waves of trouble rolled over the face of society. It is hard for modern students to realise his position, and the more so because legend-makers and miracle-mongers have made free with his history and times. His life supplied materials well suited to the requirements of superstitious biographers. As a Christian hero in the broadest sense, he gave his strength to the best of causes, and spent his life in combating the dominion of sin in the uninviting empire of the Picts and Scots. It should also be remembered, that the chroniclers of the dark ages wrote for an unlettered audience upon whom the recital of legends and miracles was supposed to exercise an influence favourable to the church. Indeed, "inventing" seems to be a common-place infirmity of man; for on whom has he practised his petty art more than on Christ and his apostles? In the case of Columba, after brushing aside the cobwebs of tradition with which superstition has obscured his memory, we behold a man whose enthusiasm in propagating the faith surpassed the strongest yearnings of nature, and whose chosen constituents were the most needy, because the least civilized tribes of the British Isles.
Notwithstanding the changes usually effected on the surface of countries by the action of time, there are places where the lapse of thirteen hundred years has only slightly altered the aspect of nature. Iona is a striking example of this durability. The island is supposed never to have grown any trees, and this deficiency continues to impart to its shores that sombre appearance which sufficed not to repel the Columban band in the sixth century. But what may be said of the island's "everlasting hills" will not be true of its architectural remains. The present ruins are no link between the times of Columba, his
207
simple gospel itinerants, and our own days; and what interest attaches to these is only such as belongs to ordinary relics of the Roman ascendancy. No vestige of any building in which the first missionaries worshipped or slept is now found; for church and college were both of wood.
Of the circumstances that conduced to Columba's undertaking a mission to the Picts, and to his selecting Iona for a station, we are almost entirely ignorant. There is a tradition that his leaving Ireland was an involuntary flight on account of civil squabbles; but it is far more likely that the life-exile of the missionary and his disciples resulted from the love of Christ and a desire to spread his kingdom. The manner of their selecting Iona is affectionately—almost poetically—explained. While seeking a settlement with the fragile barque wherein he left the shores of Erin, he is said to have landed both at Islay and Oransa, and to have re-embarked because from their hills Ireland could be descried. On going ashore at Iona, its most lofty eminences were put to the same test, and because no faint trace of the beloved country stretched across the horizon, the isle became their adopted home, while its most celebrated eminence received the lasting name of The Cairn of Farewell to Ireland.
Till the middle of the sixth century, Iona was the last refuge of Druidism in the North; and therefore to Columba belongs the credit of having supplanted a deep-rooted superstition by the gospel. The accounts which have descended of this man and his fellow-workers, who henceforth sowed broadcast among the barbarians the unsearchable riches of Christ, are welcome glimpses into the simple customs of those days. They solicited no tithes from neighbouring kings. The same hands which administered medicine to the sick and copied the Scriptures for distribution, cultivated the island slopes for personal wants. The missionaries sowed, sheared, and milked for their own living, while they toiled hard in proclaiming the gospel. The art of draining being then imperfectly understood, they were obliged to select for cropping such tracts as were drained by nature, and thus only cultivated the Western side of the island.
Columba, whom Romanism has canonized that she may appropriate the honour attached to his spotless life and illustrious labours, cannot reasonably be claimed by the Romish church at all. Saint though he was, a more descriptive name than "saint" would be Primitive Apostle of the Highlands. When, in the forty-second year of his age, he settled at Iona, the rule of Rome had not risen in ascendancy, nor did the Bishop of Rome exercise authority over the British church. Columba had no sympathy for the Western order of ecclesiastical polity, for after returning from his European wanderings in his younger days, he is supposed to have been a Reformer in principle. If this was so, and if Ireland became imbued with the leaven of false doctrine earlier than the other parts of our empire, it is not unreasonable to suppose that Columba and his associates may have resigned home and country to preserve their purity of faith.
Here, then, Columba founded his monastery, if monastery it may be called; for the monachism of Iona, as exemplified by the Culdees thirteen hundred years ago, essentially differed from the discipline of
later convents. Subtle corruptions may have somewhat adulterated the faith, and fanatics and enthusiasts may have counterfeited the graces of Christianity, yet the daily life of an Irish convent of those days would be more truly expressed were we to call it a college. It was properly a retreat for the cultivation of learning—a quiet asylum wherein the students were chiefly engaged in copying the sacred oracles. The inmates were often laymen, who retired only for a time to improve their education, it not having been compulsory until the fourteenth century for monks to take orders.
Though, as before intimated, there is no building on Iona dating its foundations from the time of Columba, the now fast decaying cathedral is thought by the Duke of Argyll to occupy about the same site as did the primitive wooden sanctuary. This was probably a rude structure, covered by a thatched roof, and with four pieces of metal fastened together for a bell. The field of labour was broad and inviting, and the missionaries reaped an abundant harvest. Like all noble natures employed in the cause of righteousness, their desires were large. They did not set up a spiritual lighthouse for any limited area. They might have practised nightly vigils and studied sacred literature for themselves only, and have gathered a select church in the desert of heathendom, until Iona should become a garden walled around. Happily it was ordered otherwise. The isle became a thriving missionary station. The indefatigable pastor drew his highest pleasure from widening the empire of Christ's peaceful kingdom. In his own island—now the property of the college by royal grant—he assiduously followed every good work. Reading, praying for success, copying the Bible, and tilling the soil, were employments of which he seemed never to weary. Nor was this all. He often put to sea in his wattle boat on preaching expeditions to the neighbouring islanders, or to the fierce heathens of the mainland; for whose ignorance, fends, and political and social woes he offered the universal panacea of Christ crucified. The far-reaching darkness in which he lived apparently inflamed Columba's zeal for the light; and his poverty—if indeed that state may be called poverty wherein a man of simple tastes has all his wants supplied—seems to have produced only the grateful effect of freeing him from care.
Thus did the good work proceed. Though as Protestants we keep no saints' calendar, we enrol this old pastor among the saints. His life was so holy, so entirely self-denying, and so successful a conflict with the powers of darkness, that right-minded persons are reasonably aggrieved when the name of such a labourer is appropriated by a church, against whose corruptions his career was a living protest. His delight was in the Scriptures. The breath of his life was prayer. Believing that he enjoyed life and found work bracing to his soul, we do not accept the legendary fables abounding in the catalogue of the old man's austerities. To have sanctioned such follies would have been foreign to his nature. We believe he could rejoice in a well-filled barn; but not that he discovered a peculiar virtue in reducing his diet to nettle soup. His powerful frame, his voice of vast compass, and his handsome and ever pleasant countenance, spoke of plain but generous nourishment. He comprehended Christianity too well to fall into that caricaturing of piety which modern monkery presents to us.
209
The institution at Iona in these early days was not a monastery, nor were Columba and his coadjutors monks, according to the modern acceptance of the word. The brotherhood imposed on themselves no useless rigours. They taught the liberal arts to their benighted flocks, and so far as their resources admitted, lived comfortably themselves. They were not the slaves of a superior, though they recognised lovingly the authority of Columba. They made no vows of poverty; and though no women resided on the island, no ecclesiastical crotchets debarred the scholars from having homes and wives elsewhere. They were physicians and instructors in agriculture and practical science, as well as religious teachers. It was not surprising that, blessed by the presence of such friends in need, the Picts should have magnified their medical cures into miracles, and their gospel preachings into preternatural utterances. Such a mission could not be otherwise than pre-eminently successful. Branch colleges sprang up in rapid succession in the distance. During his life-time Columba founded at least a hundred stations similar to the parent one at Iona, besides planting three hundred congregations. His agents penetrated everywhere within a radius of several hundred miles. They made themselves heard on the mainland of Scotland, in the north of England, in Ireland, and even on the northern shores of Europe. Nor did they confine themselves to educating the heathen; they stoutly opposed the innovations of the western church by refusing to keep Easter as appointed, or to sanction other Romish customs. Whatever the Papacy may do, by means of so respectable an agent as Montalembert, to appropriate the spoils of Iona, it is notorious that the light emanating from "the isle of the western sea" declined with the triumph of Romish ascendancy, till, in the eleventh century, just after the Conquest, the sun of its good influence went down for ever.
We repeat our proposition: Columba established a missionary station; he did not gather a monastic clan. These early evangelists knew nothing of what Rome includes in monachism. They were monks of a similar mould to Carey and his companions, by whom the paganism of India was so valiantly assailed. What tended to bless the soul, and to restore the dignity of human nature, the Culdees taught according to the light they possessed; and to describe their procedure as anything foreign to this is to libel their characters, and to misread their lives.
We shall not be expected to do justice to so wide a subject as the history of Iona in the brief space allotted to this article; nor would the toil yield a handsome profit were we to disinter the countless fables and legends which, on this absorbing topic, have been collected by the industry, or invented by the ingenuity, of man. We have incidentally referred to the personal appearance of the great missionary. If correctly portrayed by his biographers, he was singularly fitted for his office in those tumultuous days, and in those barbaric regions, when fends between the discipline of the church and the civil power were not uncommon occurrences. From what has been said it will be inferred that Columba's presence was very commanding. Broad and open, his countenance usually carried a smile, excepting when wrong-doing called for a rebuke; or when, as he has been known to do, he followed a robber with imprecations into the very ocean.
Romanists are not the only perverters of the history of Columba.
14
Some who can discover no plain man's pathway to heaven outside the pale of the Church of England, draw inferences from this source in support of their pretensions. Bishops were then ordained; but be it remembered that they were not appointed to sees or palaces; and from the number then flourishing in Ireland we conclude that they were simply what all bishops should be—working ministers. An anecdote is related of one of the order, who, disguised as a layman, crossed from Erin to Iona; but who, being detected by the abbot, received many brotherly civilities. From so simple a fact, Dr. Todd, in his "Life of St. Patrick," concludes that thus early in the history of our country, extraordinary honours were paid to episcopal dignitaries; on what a slender foundation may vast edifices be built! In the island of Iona no prelatical jurisdiction was recognised.
We now come to the good old man's last days. Ample accounts are extant of the manner of his encountering the last enemy; and when shorn of fable and nonsense, enough remains to edify and interest an enquirer. With the lights which imparted new interest to the heavens, and appeared in the earth to signalize the old abbot's departure: and with the angels by whom the air was peopled, we have nothing to do, further than laying them aside as dreams of the pervert Adamnum,* or as inventions of a subsequent monkish era. It was in May, of the year 597, that Columba felt his end to be approaching. Though in the south of England May is esteemed a delicious month, in a higher latitude it retains many of the chills and mists of winter. Not able now to take his perilous voyages with the message of life, nor even competent to walk the circumference of his little empire, the pastor seated in a car, yet visits the brethren who are sowing the spring seed on the western side of the island. As their kind master solemnly assures them of his impending dissolution, the poor itinerants may well seek relief in weeping. He tells them how aforetime he had longed to depart and be with Christ his Lord, and only for their sakes had willingly remained a little longer. The Sabbath comes; and during worship in the little church, an ecstatic joy is observed suffusing Columba's countenance, and he tells his associates he has seen an angel. Of this circumstance Dr. Alexander has observed: "Perhaps the whole scene was the result of one of those strong presentiments of the approaching presence of Christ, through his messenger death, which are often vouchsafed to his servants who have nearly finished their course and are looking for his appearing." After this he visits the stores, and exclaims, "I congratulate my friends, since I must so soon leave them, that they have food enough in store for another winter." The day is Saturday, and he says it will prove the day of his release; and that the Sabbath of the Old Dispensation will indeed bring rest to his soul. Because his seventy-seven years do not allow of his walking without
* Born nearly thirty years after Columba's death, Adamnum became abbot of Iona in 679, and remained till 704. His life is important, because it shows how repugnant to the brotherhood were the encroachings of Rome. Having visited the southern churches, Adamnum, who was not intellectually strong, was completely converted to the Roman order; and his strenuous, but unsuccessful endeavours to press the acceptance of his new ideas on the Culdees is thought to have hastened his end.
211
difficulty, nor any distance without resting, he sits down to regain breath, when an old white horse—a faithful servant of the brotherhood—walks to the spot and betrays a semi-consciousness of the catastrophe about to happen. An attendant, called Diarmaid, is about to drive the animal away to its pasture, when Columba interferes: "No, suffer him: suffer this creature which loves me; why should not the poor irrational brute lament the loss of his master as well as you intelligent men?" He retired that night, and soon after attended worship in the church, but from this exertion fell down in a fit, and died surrounded by weeping attendants. He may be said to have literally laboured on to the last hour. His chief delight and laborious occupation was the work of copying the Scriptures; and previously to going in to the church he was observed busy at this beloved employment, the words with which he eaded the day and his life-mission being those of the Psalmist:—"The young lions do lack, and suffer hunger: but they that seek the Lord shall not want any good thing."
Of the volumes which have suggested this article little need be said. Whatever comes from the pen of the Duke of Argyll is sure to command attention. "Iona" is chastely written and attractively illustrated; but the noble author might have made his work better serve the cause of religion had he shown us more clearly how opposed to subsequent innovations of the Papacy were the faith and discipline of Columba's community. The Duke speaks of "the celebration of the mass" as having taken place in the church shortly before the abbot's decease: this expression is singularly unhappy when the testimony of history proves that the superstitious usages now called "the mass" were introduced in a much later century.
But what answer shall be made to that Romanist enthusiasm for "the conversion of England," which found an eloquent exponent in the Count de Montalembert? The Duke of Argyll says, pointedly: "An indiscriminate admiration of mediæval superstitions, and the absence of all endeavours to sift fact from fiction in the narrative we possess of Columba's life, mar the reality of the picture which Montalembert gives us of the past." There is no doubt that the missionaries of Iona, claimed by the French academician as his own, and whose trials and triumphs he graphically portrays, were precisely the kind of people whom his church, in a later age, selected as fuel for Smithfield fires, and as material for Bartholomew massacres. What would their amiable Bonner have said to "monks" who taught justification by faith; who invoked neither saints nor angels, and whose sense of decency would have been shocked by virgin-worship; monks, whose only absolver from sin was Christ, whom confirmation never troubled, and who would have denied the doctrine of the Real Presence? Such was the early communion at Iona. It was a Protestant church before the Reformation; and long after Rome claimed the supremacy, the Culdees' discipline, as it found a shelter in Hebridean hovels, or in obscure retreats on the mainland, preserved its life of faith through the dark ages, and lived to protest against clerical corruptions and false teaching.
It is both curious and provoking to find a writer so able and so genial as Montalembert misstating facts, contradicting history, and building with great literary skill upon the unworthy basis of pious frauds and
mediæval dreams. Iona in the sixth century—shedding forth her gospel light in rays broad and strong, and thus making herself a blessing to every accessible shore—was without the pale of Rome. The evil day wherein she acknowledged the Pope saw her ancient glory eclipsed. The story of later times—the sunsetting of the heroic age—need not be recited. In the meantime, Iona may properly continue to attract the interest of summer tourists; for did she not cast forth from her shores seeds of grace which are still germinating in our British Isles? A mere speck on the map, this island has a noble history; and when, in the promised age of universal Christian prosperity, the historian shall describe the devastating inundation of popery, relieving his picture by showing how here and there truth found a shelter—
"Columba's happy isle will rear
Her towers above the flood."
