Menu
‹ Chapter 54 of 206 ›

A Christian Soldier's Letter

9 min read · Chapter 54 of 206

ALTHOUGH some people have held the opinion, and have even ventured to assert, that War and the Gospel were totally irreconcilable, it may be a comfort to those whose consciences are uneasy upon this point, to learn that a celebrated Scotch divine has recently shown that such fears are groundless.

Many passages in the following letter, which are given in quotation marks, are evidently extracted from a sermon by Norman Macleod, D.D., recently preached before the Queen, and published by Royal command. How far the arguments justifying War can be made to harmonize with the New Testament passages also quoted, the reader will judge.

Bois de M——,

Dec. 23rd, 1870.

DEAR CHRISTIAN BRETHREN,

Secreted, as we are, behind the trees of this wood, in the hope of getting a shot at you before you see us, we think it well, nevertheless, to assure you by this record—penned for all whom it may concern—that no other feelings than those of Christian love animate us. We especially desire that you may be free from the suspicion that anything of hatred or unkindly feeling influences our actions. “Whoso hateth his brother is a murderer, and ye know that no murderer hath eternal life abiding in him.” Do not, therefore, misunderstand us. We believe the course we are taking to be a right† one, justified by the teaching and religion of Christ. Were it otherwise, we should stand self-condemned! For anything like thoughtlessness or recklessness in matters, like this, of life and death, must obviously be sin of the deepest dye.

Desirous, as we are, and as all Christians should be, to promote the benefit of our fellow-creatures, and believing that, in the over-ruling of the Most High, the richest and most permanent blessings to the human race are often brought about through the instrumentality of suffering, we trust that you will not misunderstand the sincerity of our purpose, but recognise in our bullets the great fact, long ago proclaimed, that “To everything there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the heaven………..A time of war.” Eccles. iii. 1, 8.

Though we can scarcely affirm that “the weapons of our warfare are not carnal,” yet as “truly chivalrous” gentlemen, free from “all personal hate and love of blood,” we entreat you not to think too much

* We do not know by whom this letter is published, or we would have asked the author’s leave to print it. As we could not do that, we have taken French leave, as the proverb has it, and hope the author will not be angry with us; in fact, we are sure he will not be, for we do but second his design by giving his clever ironical letter a wider circulation.

† “Again, I cannot but think that what inspires us with admiration and respect for those engaged in war, is the idea that it embodies and expresses on a great scale the sublime principle of self-sacrifice; that the battle-field on which thousands of our best and bravest, in obedience to command, and in the name of the nation, willingly suffer and die because it is right, and because their country ‘expects every man to do his duty,’ becomes a consecrated altar. The ideal warrior would thus be the most Christian man, because he alone is able truly to offer himself unto God as a willing sacrifice.”—“War and Judgment,” by Norman Macleod, D.D.

11

of the wounds we inflict. When we consider the immense blessing of peace, and how often this has been helped by protracted, and what some persons have styled savage war, we trust that you will overlook the painful part of it, and admit, when we meet together to render an account of the deeds done in the body, at the bar of the Great Judge of all the earth, that in thus taking the lives of as many of you as we can, our object has simply been "the upholding of Law and Righteousness," in the true spirit of the words of our Lord, "I say unto you, That ye resist not evil." In the exercise of "that common sense and spiritual judgment which our Great Teacher ever assumed to be possessed by those whom he taught," you will doubtless understand that the letter of these words refers exclusively to "personal hatred, retaliation, and revenge," and wisely discriminate between any sinful action of that sort, and the kindly feeling in which, for the future good of mankind, we stretch your bodies lifeless upon the earth. And if, "at the command of our country," it sometimes becomes necessary to run individuals of you through the heart with our bayonets, yet be assured that we do not at such times regard you as individuals, but merely as parts of a whole community! We might not hate or injure one of you singly. That would be sinful and contrary to the command of Christ. But shooting a hundred or a thousand of you, in a collective sense, must not be suspected of having any hatred, or wrath, or anger, or malice in it, even though it involves the greatest possible injury that man can inflict upon his fellow-man! If we were really hating a multitude of men when we are shooting them, the Bible would certainly condemn us; but the art of doing all this without giving way to sin, is one of the triumphs of modern religion, and is, in fact, getting the blind side of the devil himself.

It is for this reason, and not from the low motives that some wars have been caused by, that we are induced to fire upon you. And if the very sky be reddened with the glare of our artillery, may it not be one way of letting our "light so shine before men, that they may see" our "good works," &c.?

Rest assured that we only call you "enemies" to express an idea which for the time-being is necessary. We wish well to you and your families, and trust that the widows and orphans of any of you that we are so fortunate as to hit, will also admit that all such matters of private personal detail must be merged in the public good. They will clearly understand that we shoot you in love—love to the great cause of Truth, while a partial and temporary sacrifice of this kind tends (if we may believe history) to the benefit of the whole human race. You will remember that war "embodies and expresses on a great scale the sublime principle of self-sacrifice."

Therefore, dear fellow believers, if some of our friends who have been entrusted with the business of throwing monster exploding shells among you, so far succeed as that many of you become fearfully mutilated, and in this state be left, without further attention, for a few days and nights in the keen frosty air; still, if that be the Divine will—and you know that the Most High reigns among the children of men—we doubt not that you and your relatives will accept it as one of the mysteries of the kingdom of heaven, and even be glad that you are

163

made instrumental in the development of those vast national and social advantages which build up the strength and greatness of a people. There is nothing in the ancient and exploded law of "an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth," which at all influences our actions towards you. What is popularly called "horrible carnage," your shrieks of agony, your dying groans, are all, if you could only see it, brought about in obedience to the command of our one Master, "Whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them." Do not we expose ourselves in like manner for the same great end? Is not "the ideal warrior the most Christian man, because he alone is able truly to offer himself unto God as a willing sacrifice"? Though perhaps a secret hope may cling to a few of us, that the advance of truth, *in this precise way*, may not be made manifest in *our* persons, yet, knowing, as we do, that God is "ruling over us, and revealing his will by general laws," we handle the triggers of our rifles with the firmness and fearlessness which true Christian courage alone can give. You know people are not left solely to the operation of natural laws. God is not an unseen lawgiver. He is "the Everlasting King. And, if we have received this conviction, we have received a very precious gift, calculated to inspire us with reverence and godly fear." In his allwise disposal, the weaker and more effeminate of nations must give way. "By the terrible trial and decision of war, the stronger, more manly, or more civilized races have gradually and necessarily dominated over the weaker, more luxurious, or more barbarous ones, and thus made government and progress possible by allying them with power and skill." Because, Power, the strength which enables a nation to equip and maintain a mighty army; Skill, the ingenuity to devise terrific engines of destruction; and Courage, one of the noblest of gifts—are all signs of superiority; they are signs of the possession of that which you must acknowledge with us, ought to be promoted at any cost, and receive their due reward.

And though, during the first two or three centuries (when its advance was by far the most rapid) the Christian religion was not assisted by War; for then no weapon was raised to shield it, nor sword unsheathed in its defence; yet there was an exceptional reason for that, seeing that the prophetic words respecting it were, "Not by might, nor by power, but by my Spirit, saith the Lord of Hosts."

It is by the energy and confidence which religion gives, that war, in Christian hands, becomes so effective! Our vast ingenuity is taxed to make our implements and missiles as destructive as possible. Whereas savages kill one by one, in their sinful and ignorant affrays; we tear thousands to pieces in a few hours! God has blessed us with a knowledge of mechanical and chemical science, and in this way we make our learning and acquirements redound to his praise.

Let no one persuade you therefore that in the war now raging there is anything "diabolical." For though some eye-witnesses of the more painful parts of it have been impious enough to revile our prayers and thanksgivings to the God of Battles, and to say that the devil only was wanted here; don't believe them! The truth has always been maligned, and the base suggestion is a scandalous stigma upon "God-fearing men of education and intelligence, capable," like us, "of engaging in

war with a holy, devout, humble, and reverent spirit." Do not "add to our anxieties the dread suspicion that our work is sinful"! It is only an obscure form of love, which will bear fruit after many days!

Neither let the thought trouble you that there is always a strong resemblance between the details of war and the details of murder. We are liable to look too much at the mere surface of things. Though the "natural man" may see the natural only, the "spiritual man" has a deeper discernment. And although some may think that shooting our fellow believers is scarcely in harmony with the example of him who laid down his life for his enemies, and who declared, "I came not to destroy men's lives, but to save them," yet, in obedience to the command of our country, we freely ask the blessing of God upon our efforts to aim correctly, and praise him when the bloody work is over, who alone giveth the victory.

And suppose that, after all, you do not entirely agree with us in sentiment, nor approve the course we feel called upon to adopt; you must not forget that your nation may have been too much lifted up by the pride of wealth, or in some other way may have sinned and incurred the Divine displeasure! Is it not better that a few scores of thousands of you should be "put out of the way" as a general chastisement, than that your nation should continue in sin? God "will never spare punishment, however severe, in order to foster the good, or save it from destruction." So that whichever way you look at our conduct, you cannot fail to see the love which pervades all. Be encouraged, then, we beseech you (or, if none of you survive, then those who have to perform the last earthly office for you)—be encouraged firmly to believe that "the future historian who recognises God in history, will be able to trace, in some form or other," to the course we pursue towards you, "many great and permanent blessings, in proportion to the sufferings" you endure, "and to the spirit in which these may be received."

And when all these light afflictions are passed, we hope that you will greet us—your destroyers—joyfully at the great tribunal, where we shall each receive according to the deeds done in the body, and hear the solemn words pronounced, "Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me." Matthew xxv. 40. Yours, &c.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate