Menu
‹ Chapter 43 of 206 ›

A Rebirth out of its Place

6 min read · Chapter 43 of 206

THE Rev. Arthur Wolfe, M.A., Rector of Fornham All Saints, and of Westley, Bury St. Edmunds, late fellow and tutor of Clare College Cambridge, has just published a volume of "Sermons on subjects more or less interesting at the Present Time,"* and we have finished a perusal of them with mingled feelings of pity, pleasure, and amazement. The reverend gentleman is evidently a lover of the truth and holds the doctrines of grace with a firm grasp; herein do we rejoice, yea, and will rejoice. He has much in common with us upon points where his own churchism does not warp his better judgment. The tone of his sermons is vigorous, alike for thought and evident biblical scholarship, but they are marred by a homage to church formularies which is little if at all short of the reverence which he pays to the Bible itself.

If the Bible, and the Bible alone, be the religion of Protestants, the Rev. A. Wolfe, is not one, for he accepts besides the Scriptures another fountain of truth. He says in a sermon upon the Athanasian creed, "We who live now receive what Christ taught through his apostles, and others contemporary with them; in their writings we have handed down to us the faith once delivered to the saints. So then, when in the Athanasian Creed we are required to accept certain statements as the Catholic, that is the Christian faith, our disposition should be to receive them, unless we have reason to think that they assert what

* Longmans, Green, & Co., London.

Christ never taught at all, that they contradict in short, what we read in the Canonical Scriptures." We entirely disagree with the writer, our disposition should be to put away every addition to the complete and finished Word of God and to keep a broad clear line between it and the traditions of men. This fatal adhering to old creeds is the Chinese shoe which cramps not a few of the strong runners into a halting pace, and makes cripples of them for life.

We are glad to find that the author himself is really ashamed of the Athanasian creed, for he says, "It is hardly however to be doubted that our Reformers, had they lived in these present days, would have either removed this creed from the Prayer Book as unnecessary and giving needless offence, or at least, have modified it as, in fact, the Nicene creed after its first publication was modified." And yet the writer of these words will stand up and read this creed which he thus condemns, and add at the close of it, "THIS IS THE CATHOLIC FAITH, WHICH EXCEPT A MAN BELIEVE FAITHFULLY HE CANNOT BE SAVED" ! ! ! !

Is not this trifling with truth? We denounce it as a treachery to all honest speech amongst men; how the writer squares it with his conscience we cannot imagine. We again quote his own words—"Many who think over what they say may possibly find in this creed things about which in their secret hearts they feel a misgiving; and to say that we believe that, which we do not really believe, cannot be right at any time, least of all when we come before him to whom all hearts are open, and from whom no secrets are hid." We agree with this, and hence we brand with our hottest indignation the declaration of total ruin against those who cannot "faithfully believe" the creed to be true; especially when the anathema is publicly pronounced by a person who in another place confesses that the creed might well be modified. Had the wire-drawings of the Athanasian creed been inspired of God, it would still remain an outrage upon all honesty for one believer in it to condemn another to perish everlastingly for his unbelief. He who wishes a creed modified does not believe it, at least he does not so thoroughly believe it as to be qualified to declare another accused for his less veiled unbelief.

Either the late tutor of Clare College, Cambridge, and rector of a couple of churches, says too much, or acts too little. What do our readers say to this as being the exposition of an officer belonging to an episcopal church:—

"In the apostolic times there were clearly, according to Scripture, two 'orders' only—elders attending to things more purely spiritual, teaching guiding, ruling; deacons acting under (?) these elders, distributing the alms of the brethren to the poorer members, dispensing the elements of the Lord's Supper to those present, and carrying them to the absent sick. Scripture knows nothing whatever of bishops as a distinct order. Now, then, let us contrast with this primitive arrangement as furnished by Scripture, according to which we should have in each church a body of presbyters under one of their number presiding, a body of deacons also assisting the presbyters in matters less purely spiritual; contrast with this the state of things which exists among ourselves, and you will be able to judge how far the two are really one and the same."

"Why do I bring forward a subject like this? Because if we, like Israel, have sinned in departing from the form of government given by God at the beginning, then it is right that we should know it and acknowledge it, as the first step to repentance. Such departure from primitive appointments, to which we have succeeded by inheritance, is no ground for schism, but it is for reformation."

But what if there be no reform? Then we suppose because it is inherited it is right to continue in what we condemn, though the Scriptures assert that "what is not of faith is sin." Let protests be made, but if our connection with the evil fosters it, then ACTION clear and public must follow. "Come ye out from the midst of her" is the voice to be obeyed. Would to God that a man so enlightened as Mr. Wolfe would lead the way in a grand

135

disruption movement; such a step would mark an era in England's history bright with hope.

It is a good sign that the author recognises the utter impossibility of discipline in his church while it is itself under the rule of the State. He evidently longs for relief, but confesses with a sigh that "such discipline as would, doubtless, be in force if the church were unfettered by the State cannot any longer even be attempted."

We make another extract or two on the subject of baptism, as we can heartily endorse so much of his teaching on that point:—"Our Lord gave directions to his apostle to go and baptise all nations; but it was those who believed who were to be baptised: and belief implies a creed to which the candidate for baptism must first have given his assent." . . . . "As public confession of sins was in the early church one of the marks of repentance by which a convert showed himself a fit candidate for baptism; so confession of faults after baptism may well be expected from all who continue to trust to the merits of Christ."

How can this good brother hold such views on baptism and then sprinkle infants, who cannot either believe or repent, without doing violence to his published convictions on the matter? The whole book is a painful exhibition of a fettered warrior who is bound to defend a position which he feels cannot be ultimately maintained. We do not hesitate to say that there are subterfuges in argument, and inconsistencies in so-called explanations, which on no other subject would be tolerated among educated men. The most solemn declarations are refined away into contradictions in a manner which, if it were not so awful in its results would be contemptible for its littleness. Oh for Christian manhood enough to break away from every trammel, and come out into the free air and speak without the gag of dead men's creeds muzzling bold, honest speech; or else if the bread of the church must be eaten by those who do not accept her teaching, at least let it be done in a silence which she has a right to demand from those who have given an unfeigned assent and consent to her dogmas and discipline, and who have called the Holy Ghost to witness to the solemn declaration.

We must hold our brother to be wanting either to the truth or to his church, while he holds his present views and takes her pay under a declaration which is no longer the honest fact, whatever it may have been when it was first made.

B.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate