Menu
‹ Chapter 27 of 206 ›

The Annihilation Controversy

5 min read · Chapter 27 of 206

We have received the following letters from our esteemed friend, Mr. Rogers. He may very cheerfully abide the sneers of Mr. White, who is so genial a gentleman that he would not betray so much temper if he had not been severely smitten. The dogmatism of the Editor of the Rainbow is noteworthy; the controversy is pretty well over when the ipse dixit of Dr. Leask stands instead of argument.

To the Editor of the "Sword and the Trowel."

Camberwell, January 6th, 1871.

DEAR SIR,—The Rev. Edward White has declined the controversy with me upon the subject of eternal punishment from, to use his own words, "a natural reluctance to be involved further with a gentleman who always writes in the tone of a tutor, and one possessing the rare power of assertion requisite for converting untrained youths, from town and country, in little more than two years, into expositors of God's word, and pastors of Baptist congregations." The Editor of the "Rainbow" refuses to insert any further communication from me upon the subject, in these words:—"Rev. G. Rogers will please excuse us. It is a waste of time and space to say more on the subject. Eternal suffering is not the doctrine of Scripture."

Yours truly, G. ROGERS.

The following is the letter refused insertion in the "Rainbow."

DEAR SIR,—Mr. White's reply to what he has styled my bold and audacious challenge, demands some further observations from me. The points to have been discussed by him are, 1. Whether there are not instances in the New Testament in which the doctrine of eternal punishment is affirmed as decisively and fully as it could have been affirmed in the Greek language? Whether, in fact, the eternal happiness of the righteous, or the eternity of God, is expressed in stronger terms? 2. Whether there are any instances in which the limitation of future punishment is as clearly and fully affirmed? and 3. Whether there are indirect allusions, figurative illustrations and inferential intimations, sufficiently numerous and powerful, to qualify the plainest declarations upon the subject? Of the first of these enquiries, in which the whole challenge consisted, and which admits of one reply only, Yes! or No! no notice whatever is taken. The second, which alone could have nullified the first, is also passed over in silence. To the third, which by itself can have no force, Mr. White's observations are limited. He says the doctrine of eternal punishment would have been conveyed more clearly in the Scriptures if such expressions as "death," "perishing," "destruction," being "killed," "burnt up as like chaff and tares," "blotted from the book of life," "broken to shivers," "ground to powder," and "dashed

89

to pieces like a potter's vessel," had not been used. But what evidence is there that these expressions were intended to teach the nature or duration, or anything beyond the certainty, the suddenness, and the completeness of the punishment of the wicked? All of duration included in the literal and conventional meaning of these terms is confined to this life, and no more applies to Mr. White's view of the duration of punishment after death than our own. Mr. White surely did not expect that figurative illustrations of eternity itself could be taken from the things of time? It would be just as wise to maintain that the doctrine of the eternity of God, and of the happiness of the righteous, is impaired because figurative representations of them are taken from temporal things. Mr. White further avers that the eternity of future punishment would have been more clearly taught in Scripture if man's natural immortality had been affirmed. Supposing, however, the soul to be naturally and necessarily immortal, there would have been no need to have affirmed it in connection with eternal death any more than in connection with eternal life. If natural immortality were included in life in Christ, a distinct proposition ought far more to have been given to that effect.

Mr. White replies, further, that if warning had been given against taking the terms life and life eternal, in the sense of duration of existence, the doctrine of a natural immortality would have been more clearly revealed. We needed foot notes, he thinks, to prevent us from taking these terms in a physical sense. Much more we conceive, did we require foot notes to inform us that physical, as well as spiritual, life was included in those terms. This physical idea forced into combination with the spiritual idea of life in Christ is the great assumption upon which Mr. White's theory is built. Why foisted into this figurative description of the benefits derived from an interest in Christ any more than in his being our light, a door, or a vine? Does Mr. White really suppose that he has discovered a similar combination of ideas in our speaking of the destruction of the soul, as including "separation from God and perpetual misery"? Surely these two things are far more closely allied than physical and spiritual life.

One more instance in which Mr. White suggests that the eternity of future punishment might have been more fully revealed, would have been by more frequent, and, as I understand him to mean, more terrible descriptions upon the subject. Another writer, at the same time, gives a similar reply. The question, however, is not how often the eternity of suffering needed to be revealed, in order to command our belief, but whether it has not been revealed as plainly and fully as words could express?

It is to a small part only of my paper that Mr. White has condescended to reply. The bearing of the subject upon the redemption scheme, and upon the Lamb for ever upon the throne, he cautiously avoids. His allusions to myself personally, and to the College with which I am connected, are wholly irrelevant to the occasion; and in my opinion would have been better omitted for his sake rather than my own. I trust I have had no other aim than to defend what I hold to be the teaching of the word of God; nor am I conscious of having transgressed the rules of fair controversy in so doing.

G ROGERS.

THERE are some things we must deny ourselves for others' sakes. Though a man could run his horse full speed without danger to himself, yet he would do very ill to come scouring through a town where children are in the way. Thus some things thou mayst do without sin to thee, if there were no weak Christians in the way to ride over, and so bruise their tender consciences. But, alas! this is too narrow a path for mere professors to walk in nowadays; they must have more scope for their loose hearts, or else they and their profession must part.—Gurnall.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate