England's Break with Antichrist — By G. Holden Pike
THE abundant and goodly fare of England was proverbial among foreigners in the olden time; but of all the viands on which French and German natives feasted during visits to our island, and fondly remembered when again housed in their own leaner continental provinces, was that proud joint, knighted by Henry the Eighth. Most of our readers are capable of relishing a loin of beef, and they doubtless also prize it the more for the true, though humble, part it played in the Reformation. One day—a day destined to be eventful and fruitful of events—Henry was hunting in Windsor Great Forest. Having the misfortune to miss his path, and separate from his party, his Majesty found himself at dinner-time before the gates of Reading Monastery—in those days as likely a house wherein to meet with animal comforts as the Reform Club would be in our own. Preserving his disguise, Henry knocked with the dignity becoming an illustrious stranger, and on entering the hall found the table crowded with dishes for a sumptuous mid-day repast. Seating himself, the guest and his Tudor appetite did justice, or, as a poorer host would have thought, more than justice, to what was before him. But my lord Abbot, being a man given to hospitality, rejoiced at entertaining a stranger so competent to enjoy a dinner. Every delicacy procurable by the revenue of a wealthy monastery was at the service of the august visitor, who, however, prompted by a simpler than an ecclesiastical taste, observed, "I will stick to this Sir-loin." Quoth the "holy" man, unable to restrain his envious astonishment, "I would give
FROWAL. JUNE 1, 1870.
ENGLAND'S BREAK WITH ANTICHRIST.
271
£100 to be able to eat with corresponding gusto; but, alas! my weak and
qualmish stomach can hardly digest the wing of a fowl." Probably a frown
shaded Henry's brow, while in thought only he answered, I know how to cure
your qualms. A few days subsequently some officers arrested the Abbot, and with-
out any explanation summarily imprisoned him. As week by week he lan-
guished away the weary hours, he must have vainly sought the origin of his
trouble; but no clue to the mystery enlightened his den, and no omen of
liberty cheered his solitude. Sunrise and sunset came and went, each bringing
a spare meal of bread and water. Then at length, at a convenient season, the
King visited the prison. Shielding himself from observation, Henry ordered
the prisoner from his cell, and directed that a sirloin of beef should be set
before him. When the famished wretch, with greedy appetite, had eaten till
the bones were bare, Henry stood forth and cried, "Sir Abbot, I have cured
you of your qualms, give me my £100." The fine was taken, and the fatal seed-
thought sown, which spread its empire until the tide of public opinion told
against the luxurious iniquity of monasticism.
It is more than difficult, it is impossible, either for historians to portray, or
for readers to imagine, the true condition of England at the accession of Henry
the Eighth, in 1509. Ignorance and priestcraft prolonged their hateful alliance;
and, enchained by the first, the people were too often the victims of vicious
ecclesiastics, who, encouraged by their successful encroachings on the domain
of the politician, were apparently bent on annihilating the last vestige of liberty.
The secular arm might oppress, but such oppression weighed lightly against the
religious bondage which debarred the people from the benefit of laws grown
obsolete from long disuse. For the most part the ecclesiastical revenues minis-
tered to the luxurious indolence of priests, who, instead of attending to their
cures, whether in the parish or the diocese, rarely, and in some instances
never, set foot in the country they were paid to benefit, but which they lived
to defraud. Thus England, at the eve of the Reformation, differed almost as
greatly from our Great Britain as does one planet from another. In times
when even persons of title could be found who were unable to read, it naturally
followed that the moral condition of the lower orders was correspondingly
distressing. One redeeming tint slightly enlivens the dark picture. The
peasantry appear to have enjoyed a more plentiful provision than they do in
this age of progress. Each farmer presided at the head of a household com-
posed of his own family and a troop of hinds; and the common board which all
surrounded, was daily loaded with coarse abundance, while the halls of lords
and squires were centres of hospitality for travellers to call at and refresh them-
selves. But no thanks are due to Popery for a state of things belonging to a
thin population, and an abundance of cheap land. Feudal customs were
departing, and the first symptoms of a rupture with Antichrist was the sense of
tyranny to which the people were awakening, while learning to distrust the clerical
ascendancy. Nor was the religious anarchy without those intellectual stars so
common to any historical crisis, and in this instance so capable of shedding a
happier light than they really gave forth. As years rolled on More, Cromwell,
and Wolsey, not to mention Henry himself, are the great actors in English
history; and, though unfortunately these were not Christian examples, they
were men whose genius and scholarship the most gifted might envy.
One of the earliest ruptures between the clergy and the secular power, or, as
may be truly said, between the populace and Antichrist, occurred soon after the
close of the fifteenth century; and this catastrophe, so fruitful in results, was
occasioned by the evil passions of the clergy. In proportion as the church grew
corrupt, it showed a disposition to encroach; and bad became worse, until the
abandoned priesthood claimed entire exemption from legal penalties. Villains
of every degree, whose crimes as laymen were too black to be paraded with
impunity, sought holy orders, so that under a pastor's cloak they might revel in
lustful riot, such as in ordinary citizens the magistrate discouraged by summary
punishment. The time had arrived when this clerical license was destined to
THE SWORD AND THE
TROWELL, JUNE 1, 1870.
receive an ominous check, by means of what, as times went, was a trivial circumstance—the murder of Richard Hunne, a deed that, happily, redounded with terrible force on the heads of those who gave it their sanction. This same Hunne, a merchant citizen of London, refused payment of some trifling ecclesiastical fee. A legal quarrel ensuing, the defendant, as advised by counsel, took counter-proceedings against the priests, on the strength of their illegal procedure. The bare thought of being resisted by a mere trader, became insupportable, and stirred up the worst passions of the holy brethren, who, consequently, with a ferocity peculiar to Rome in her day of ascendancy, hunted down their victim, murdered him in his cell, as wild beasts do their prey, and to give completeness to their singular infamy, the priests arraigned the lifeless Hunne on a charge of heresy, and, on conviction, condemned his corpse to the flames. Favourable as the times still were to the perpetration of such deeds of blackness, this wickedness was too enormous to be hidden. The angry murmurs closely following, by refusing to be stifled, troubled the church, and made the assassins tremble. A crime had been ventured on for the purpose of striking terror into refractory hearts: it only awakened indignation and a desire for vengeance. Fain would the churchmen have undone their work; but there was no repairing and no receding. "After that day," says Burnet, "the city of London was never well affected to the Popish clergy." Wickliffe had laboured at sowing; his disciples had watered with tears and blood the first seeds of the Reformation; and now in the fire which consumed the corpse of the murdered tailor, the priests were beginning to annihilate their own ascendancy. That Smithfield fire, like a beacon, sent forth a sure and early warning of England's break with Antichrist.
Thus the early years of the sixteenth century saw Rome's dominion threatened in England, as well as on the Continent. In Britain the voice of hope and warning, which a century before had died in a wail around Wickliffe's grave, was being revived. Startled, yet scarcely awakened to a sense of danger, the clergy dreamed not of defeat in the approaching contest. It is true that by art and diligence, they sought to trample out what they called the new opinions; and they imagined the respirations of new-born liberty would be stifled, if those precious seeds of the Reformation, the tracts and Testaments of Germany, could be seized in the English ports. But when hope of success receded as the stream of knowledge widened and deepened, the priests became almost desperate in their fanatical alarm at the prospect of a decaying interest. Even the King attempted to write down the Reformation. The fierce opposition of those directly interested, was of a character such as evil spirits might have inspired. The offence of introducing into their households the Lord's Prayer and the Ten Commandments, in the vulgar tongue, brought eight persons to the stake in 1519.
We have no sympathy with a religious indifference which classes Popery among harmless superstitions; for no superstition can be professed with impunity, and in the dismal train of spiritual impostures, Romanism stands out as the darkest and basest. A system binding itself to persecute on principle, besides cherishing unholy institutions, and forbidding the Bible to the people, is surely but a caricature of the truth of the New Covenant. In the insolence of pride, Rome pronounces herself unchangeable and infallible; and so far as the dogma concerns her hatred to an unsullied faith, her love of cruelty, and abject superstition, we are prepared to endorse it. The light of the Cross is death to her high pretensions: for she thrives best in heathenish darkness, which is blighting to genuine religion. It is too true. Rome is unchangeable; but she is so in the worst sense. Give her the power, and her influence would again be exerted to enthral the nations. The murderous Inquisition would be revived; and texts quoted in justification of rackings, burnings, and enclosing of living offenders in brick and mortar coffins; truth would be poisoned at every fountain, and the moral atmosphere polluted by exhalations from ten thousand sinks of iniquity named after religion. As of yore, Antichrist is under an
TEDWEL, JUNE 1, 1870.
ENGLAND'S BREAK WITH ANTICHRIST.
273
obligation to extirpate opponents; so that what some would consider a charitable bearing to such a semi-political heresy, might, on closer inspection, be found to be a suicidal charity. That England was enabled to cast adrift the false church, assume the garments of truth, and become the asylum of liberty, ought to awaken feelings of deeper gratitude than arise from the fullest tide of commercial prosperity.
Yet the Roman church never tires of dinning in the ears of the world her pretensions to apostolical succession, and consequently to the possession of an unsullied faith handed down from the first age of Christianity. What is the answer of history to these pretensions? At first the change brought by the New Covenant was deemed so complete, that Christians in general were believed to be a universal priesthood, and only for the sake of expedience were powers to dispense ordinances confined to a class. When times grow easier, or when peace followed persecution, pride entered the hearts of important officers, until something mysterious was alleged to belong to ordination, and until "priest" became a term of superiority unknown to the first Christians.
Thus to contrast the noble faith and simple worship of an earlier age with the semi-pagan pomp of Rome during her unchallenged ascendancy, is somewhat like comparing pure morning sunlight with the artificial glare of a midnight haunt. In days when the church was purified by the fire of persecution, professors were devout and plain livers. Without courting danger they were wont to evince a rare bravery in facing peril. Death was scarcely terrible to communities that so keenly realised the truth of instant immortality. Their deacons assiduously looked to the poor. Pastors were required to be men of sober conversation, and to possess cultivated intellects. If men of substance, as they often were, they set an example of hospitality; if poor, they lived on labourer's hire in the midst of a united brotherhood.
To Wickliffe the honour undoubtedly belongs of opening the breach with Rome; and a monkish quarrel had much to do with promoting the original rupture. Islip, archbishop of Canterbury, founded at Oxford a college for eight secular and three monkish students, and appointed Wickliffe president. Circumstances transpired that made it necessary to eject the monks on account of quarrelsomeness. In the meantime Islip died, and Langham his successor on re-admitting the friars, dismissed Wickliffe, who according to prevailing custom appealed to a foreign court, and lived to see the dispute become a stream of controversy wider and deeper than the friends of Rome desired. By such means were the eyes of Wickliffe opened to the abuses of the church; and to the understanding of himself and party, the rapacity of popes, the indifferent or even licentious lives of dignitaries and parish teachers, and the seizing of English benefices by foreigners, who neither understood English nor resided in England, told against Rome with a force such as mere opposition could not have ensured. Thus did Wickliffe and his little band volunteer for the pioneering work of reformation. Severely simple in their living, and stimulated in their work by an elevated piety, the foot-prints of these evangelists long appeared as green spots in that desert land, separating the era of purity of faith from the Reformation. Eating but plain fare, and wearing coarse garments, these prophets of better days travelled the country, "Leaving here and there," says Froude, "their costly treasures as seed-points of life."
More than a century passed, and it was found that the painful seed-sowing of the Lollards had been expended on good ground. On the ever-memorable last day of October, 1517, Luther posted his protest against indulgences on Wittenburgh Cathedral, and henceforth Wittenburgh became the centre of the Reformation. Instead of undertaking pilgrimages to bejewelled shrines, where pseudo relics were marketed at famine prices, travellers having nobler objects, now proceeded in ominous earnestness to the old city where genuine gospel truth was gratuitously preached. People received the light with a species of wondering gratitude, such as modern Bible-owners can hardly realise. And what was it which sufficed to shake the Continent, to trouble its rulers, and to
18
[THE SWORD AND THE TROWEL. JUNE 1, 1870.
threaten with extinction the greatest and most corrupt hierarchy the world has ever seen? It was nothing but the awakening of the people to the old truth of salvation by faith in Christ.
The first abettors of the Reformation in England were persons of mean social position; but the fact rather adds to than detracts from the glory of the epoch, that truth rooted itself among the humble until it commanded the respect of the great. The year 1525 saw the formation in the capital of a society, the germ of many a more pretentious counterpart. A few citizen traders, with piety as genuine as the fire from heaven that of old consumed the sacrifice, formed themselves into a body for disseminating religion. They met stealthily, suffered the hardships peculiar to their profession in those days, and their agents risked life and liberty in traversing the country with Testaments and religious publications.
A community must indeed be deadened in moral perception by misrule, when its members are unable to detect wrong in their rulers and pastoral overseers. England never sank to this degradation; for though her educated citizens saw with other eyes than the vulgar, and acted from different motives, all in common saw that great evils were obstructing national prosperity, and annihilating religious life. The crowd regarded with disgust the fat living of the clergy, and the every-day splendour of their superiors, because with all their simplicity they hated hypocrisy. Henry himself, as he angrily witnessed the extravagance of the Reading monks, or as, in 1521, in company with Charles the Fifth, he knelt before A'Becket's shrine, must have been moved by similar emotions; for though it would be hard to prove that mercenariness prompted the confiscation of church property, he may have thought that the State could make good use of what the priests abused. However much, whether as a ruler or a man, Henry miscarried, he was very sagacious. With unmistakable Tudor instinct, he made events he could not avert redound to his royal advantage, besides turning revolutions of public opinion into channels he could himself control, rather than risk defeat and ruin in combating them as did his successors the Stuarts. The government indeed was wakeful, but the sunrise of the Reformation found the clergy sleeping. During weary centuries of darkness they apportioned themselves what was comfortable and easy to bear, in the meantime threatening with spiritual terrors such as presumed to assail their sacred enclosure by exposing the evils corrupting the whole fabric of the church. The commencement of the great rupture came in reaction. As the providence of God has so often ordered, wickedness overreached itself. The lofty insolence of popes, the libertinism of cardinals and bishops, the unconcealed licentiousness of priests, and the avarice of the whole clerical body, even before the rise of Wickliffe, awakened misgivings in the minds of the few able to discern between good and evil. Such men as Roger Bacon, and Robert Grosshead, bishop of Lincoln, if not actually open reformers, were to the Reformation what Lord Bacon was to science—pointers of others into fruitful paths.
As already shown, in the instance of the Reformation, great results were achieved by means of humble instruments. The great ones of the earth, however, were not idle. If we regard the daily acts of the three leading European Kings, Henry the Eighth, Francis the First, and Charles the Fifth, we shall see them always influenced by greedy desires, often acting without principle, and apparently with no other wish for their subjects' weal than such as was included in ministering to their own selfishness. Yet, nevertheless, though they may have done it by inadvertence, these men really forwarded the cause of truth. Among them, moving hither and thither, we see Henry's great minister, Wolsey, allowing his powerful mind to speed its force in pandering to self-conceit, and to waste its energies in chasing the phantom of the tiara. Led astray by ambition, he suffers himself to be used as a cat's-paw by the emperor, so long as the siren deceiver keeps him loyal; but we see Wolsey seeking vengeance by means of France when the death of two popes effectually tests the hollowness of Spanish promises. We see Charles
TROWELL, JUNE 1, 1870.
ENGLAND'S BREAK WITH ANTICHRIST.
275
the Fifth in unprincipled avarice evince many degrading passions; and France is acting as the dupe of a revengeful woman, or becoming the captive of Spain: while Henry, in a manner little suspected either by himself or people, stands before Europe the puppet of Wolsey, assuming enmity or friendship to France as dictated by priestly ambition. Watched from this distant standpoint, how steadily and surely the great movement proceeds. How, in a manner calculated to make us hopeful for the future, is good seen to be brought out of evil. How prominently does the hand of God appear overruling righteous and bad men's actions! Like some imposing building, too great to be viewed in close proximity, but which stands out in proportions of chaste magnificence when seen from a distance, so the workings of Providence are more manifest to us after the lapse of three centuries, than they could have been to Luther and Tyndale. Providence was working when Wolsey, by his childish love of showy parade, his proud bearing and enormous wealth, bred popular discontent, and promoted his own fall; and providence or the hand of God, brought lasting good out of the bickerings and hollow friendships of European potentates. Hence the widening of the rupture with Rome represented the growth of the Reformation. The crowned actors in the scene, though able to misuse their power, were yet powerless to stunt the growth of public opinion in three countries; and, therefore, those writers who aver that Protestantism sprang from the evil passions of a bad king, are either ignorant or dishonest historians. Had not Henry the Eighth broken with Rome, he would have risked the alternative of breaking with England.
In the meantime, the day of hope and knowledge was breaking. People who hitherto had been wont to repair to their parish church as to a sanctuarium of undefiled Christianity, occasionally disgraced by renegade priests, and who had supposed the church to be really infallible, on the rising of the heavy cloud of ignorance, saw through the dread illusion. Men who had not the gospel in their hearts could now perceive that its pure profession was but caricatured by the illiterate and sensual pastors who, instead of feeding their flock, were greater transgressors than their parishioners, from the fact of having more leisure for wickedness. Now, however, retribution had come, and the ill-gotten ascendancy of the priests tottered on its base, and threatened by its fall to stir up civil war and social anarchy. The petition sent up to the King by the Commons, after the fall of Wolsey, was the offspring of national discontent and indignation. This remarkable document is one of the best aids extant for arriving at clear views of the state of England at an unparalleled conjuncture of circumstances. Then, as now, the House of Commons followed rather than formed public opinion: and, prior to the crisis of this "great session" of 1529, as Burnet calls it, popular disgust had not been altogether restrained. In some instances priests had been maltreated in the streets, and driven from doorways followed by the execrations of indignant householders. The ecclesiastics, unwise in their generation, unheeded these straws upon the stream, until the national murmurings became a torrent unmanageable and irresistible. Their petition descends to minute particulars: and when these Catholic Commoners complain of the growth of heresy, the fact shows that they eyed the abuses of the church from no Protestant standpoint. The bishops are depicted as intolerant and overbearing. Convocation, by enacting certain laws, ensured the aggrandisement of the clergy and the oppression of the laity. While church dignitaries abused their power, the inferior clergy were sufficiently shameless and Simoniæal to demand money for administering the sacraments. To the common scandal of Christendom, the children of bishops were installed into numberless benefices. The excessive number of holydays encouraged idleness instead of promoting piety in the populace. This petition, here only alluded to rather than summarised, provoked an equally elaborate reply, chiefly remarkable for falsehood and dishonesty. Thus the religious contest of the sixteenth century in England, at its opening was not a controversy between Protestantism and Popery but a difference between grasping churchmen and the secular power.
THE SWORD AND THE
TROWEL. JUNE 1, 1870.
By the end of the session many valuable reforms were granted, and the ecclesiastics shorn of a portion of their iniquitous power. Nevertheless, the priests acted as though a temporary blight merely had settled on their heritage, which, passing away with the turbulent times, would leave abuses as they were. But the storm thickened. Warnings in the low murmurings of the people troubled England, and the louder voices of foreign reformers were awakening the Continent into action. In this country the discomfited churchmen sought the most unlikely means of relief; and, opposed as the public were to the priests' unholy living and defective teaching, those priests themselves were their own worst enemies; but the proving of this proposition must be deferred till another opportunity.
