Special Aspects of the Church of Christ in England, — And The Demands Therefore Made Upon The Ministry
BY PASTOR R. H. ROBERTS, OF CORNWALL ROAD CHAPEL, NOTTING HILL.
IN order to indicate at once the scope of this paper, let me say that the special aspects which I wish to treat of are First, and chiefly, the position now held by the sacramental and sacerdotal school of thought in the church of Christ as by law established; and Secondly, in a very few closing words, the position occupied in relation to the world by that portion of the church of Christ which claims the proud privilege of maintaining, in the purest integrity, the principles of him whose "kingdom is not of this world."
I. The position held by the sacerdotal and sacramental school. I begin by assuming that the doctrines of the so-called Ritualists are sufficiently well known to relieve me from the necessity of showing, at any length, that they differ in no essential point from those of the church of Rome, save in the refusal to acknowledge the supremacy of the pope. Proofs of this may be found in Dr. Pusey's second letter to Dr. Newman, the third part of the "Eirenicon;" in a review of which in the "Church Times" for April 8th, occur the following sentences: "The identity of principle existing between us (i.e., the Ritualists and Romanists) on the nature and the functions of the church and her Divine Author, in matters of faith, inspires us with the hope that the difficulties (in the way of re-union) may be overcome; what the whole church
[THE SWORD AND THE TROWEL. JUNE 1, 1870.
receives, that we receive; what the whole church anathematises, we anathematise also. Private judgment has no place wherever a general Council has spoken." "Instructed Catholics among ourselves know that no Roman doctrine is inconsistent with faith in the sole merits of Christ; that the Tridentine decrees about tradition are not destructive of the august veneration due to the holy saints; that the reverence paid to sacred images is no violation of the divine rights of worship, and so on." "The difference, to a great extent, is a mere difference of words." "With regard to justification, Dr. Pusey has for many years felt and taught that we held nothing which Rome does not equally hold," and so on, I add to the end of the article. Other proof could be given if time allowed or if need demanded.
2. I would observe that their object is sufficiently plain, and to do them justice, honestly announced. We perhaps should not place implicit reliance upon indirect testimony, furnished by a recent letter of Dr. Newman's; but the following quotation, also from the "Church Times," puts the matter beyond doubt: "We are busy hunting down the doctrines of the Reformation, and have no intention of foregoing the chase till we have extirpated them." After this, it would be weakness in us to hesitate to accept their own account of the meaning of the movement; and it becomes a very interesting and important question what progress is this party making in this country, what position does it hold in that church which claims to be the Bulwark of the Reformation. They themselves speak in language of exultant triumph; they talk of "the ball lying at their feet," and "of the battle being virtually won;" whilst the leaders of the evangelical party are using the language either of despondency, or of desperation, plaintively complaining that they are "frowned upon by bishops for protesting against Romanism," and talking wildly of "sinking the ship rather than allowing it to be steered into the harbour of Rome." Now is there any real ground for this exultation on the one hand, and this despondency on the other? I think there is very serious ground indeed; and I proceed to submit the reasons for this belief.
(1.) No one can fail to notice the boldness with which they are allowed to advocate their doctrines, both from the pulpit and through the press; they make no secret of the views which they hold, nor do they attempt any concealment; and yet they remain members of and teachers in that church which is established in order that it may be a barrier against the inroad of those very doctrines which they are thus openly, and with impunity, doing all they can to spread. But—
2. Let us glance at the actual statistics which they can present. There were in London in 1868, 545 churches; in 1870, 830; there were weekly holy communions in 1868, 129; in 1870, 169; daily holy communions in 1868, 11; in 1870, 20; early holy communions in 1868, 125; in 1870, 159; choral holy communions in 1868, 28; in 1870, 63; daily services in 1868, 99; in 1870, 132: surpliced choirs in 1868, 98, in 1870, 137; Eucharistic vestments in 1868, 11; in 1870, 20; with regard to which the "Church Times" remarks, "All this is very satisfactory. The addition to the number of churches in the three years has been less than a sixth, and the proportionate number of weekly celebrations should have been at the most 21, whereas it has
TROWEL. JUNE 1, 1870.
SPECIAL ASPECTS OF THE CHURCH.
263
really been 40. In like manner the increase of daily celebrations has been 9 instead of 2; early celebrations 34 instead of 21; choral celebrations 35 instead of 5; daily services 33 instead of 17; surpliced choirs 39 instead of 16; vestments 9 instead of 2." Now these statistics do not by any means indicate a uniform stage of advanced or rather retrograde belief, but they do serve to show in which way the current is setting, and combined with the undoubted vigour displayed during the recent twelve days' mission, prove that their jubilant congratulations are not altogether empty boasts, but based upon marks of progress which are by no means to be despised. And this has taken place in spite, or perhaps we ought to say to a certain extent in consequence, of the lawsuits which have been instituted against them; prosecution and persecution are near enough in sound to be easily and tellingly interchanged, and the results in this instance only confirm the truth which all history teaches us, that persecution always defeats its own ends and succeeds in helping to spread the doctrines which it seeks to crush out. Its effects on the Ritualists may be gathered from the following quotations out of speeches by two clergymen delivered at the last annual meeting of the English Church Union, and received with "laughter and cheers." The first said, "Perhaps, after all, there was a great advantage in being persecuted. It gained them sympathy from the public, it made no difference in the congregation, and for his own part, it made no difference in the services." (Laughter.) Another clergyman, who is also a baronet, thus spoke, "As he interpreted it (the recent decision of Sir R. Phillimore) they really were forbidden to stand at the north side." (Now this must, for some reason, be a most frightful calamity, for in the next sentence we read,) "He had not given up the altar lights, loud cheers, but he thought he would relinquish them sooner than give up the north side." Nor is there any reason for believing that this policy will succeed better in the future than it has done in the past; for, of course, no decision has any effect until the bishops put it in force, and there are many reasons why they will feel disinclined to interfere if they can possibly avoid it; and even if they do, it is a very doubtful question whether they will be obeyed, for nothing strikes one more forcibly than the tone of bitter, nay, almost angry contempt in which members of the Church of England, of all shades of opinion, speak of the Episcopal bench. I venture to affirm that the leading pastors of our own free church are looked up to with a vast deal more of respect than is rendered to the hierarchy by law established by a large proportion of that church which is supposed to be consolidated by the firmest ties of ecclesiastical discipline.
We give one or two examples of the criticisms indulged in, though not by any means the most outspoken that could be selected. "If instead of persecuting the clergymen who do their work, his lordship (the Bishop of London) would give an eye occasionally to those who do not, we should perhaps be spared such a scandal as that of seeing Mr. Rogers, the Rector of St. Botolph's, Bishopsgate, advertised as about to preside at a lecture of Mr. Spurgeon's, to be delivered in one meeting house in aid of the funds needed for keeping up another." At a recent meeting of the Church Association, Mr. Ryle is reported to have spoken as follows:—
"The final court of appeal should be composed of good laymen, and
[THE SWORD AND THE TROWEL, JUNE 1, 1870.
should not be handed over to the tender mercies of deans and bishops. He had the greatest possible respect for episcopacy in the abstract. . . . When they saw such specimens of episcopal judgment as they had seen in the Upper House of Convocation lately, he thought they would agree with him, that the sooner they took away from the bishops the power of deciding in final courts of appeal, the better it would be." And further in the same speech: "The bishops have a perfect horror of the Church Associationists; whilst Archbishop Lycurgus had been received with open arms, a body of men, the lovers of the Church of England, the clergy of the Church of England, protesting against Romanism, and standing up for the truths of the Reformation, banding themselves together to hand down to their children the church unaltered, were being looked upon with frowns and suspicion and receiving the cold shoulder." How much therefore may be expected from the interference of the bishops, may be judged of from extracts like these, which might be almost indefinitely multiplied. But, supposing they do succeed in putting down certain ritualistic practices, how much is gained? Have they touched the root of the evil, the pernicious doctrines of which those are but the outward drapery and ornaments? By no means—the persecution will simply make the doctrines to which the ritual is only a subordinate witness dearer than ever—nor can they effect any more, for it is a curious feature in the Established Church of this country, that in spite of its articles, and creeds, and homilies, and liturgies, etc., the doctrine held by it at this very moment is "an unknown quantity," and almost all it can do by an appeal to the law, is to put out a candle or strip off a vestment. Its teachers may proclaim rank Romanism, or the most barren Rationalism, and the church will be impotent to stop their mouths.
But the most startling occurrence perhaps of any is the reception given to the Archbishop of Syra and Tenedos at the consecration of the Greek Church in Liverpool. On that occasion the Anglican church was represented officially by two clergymen. One as the representative of the Archbishop of Canterbury, who occupied a stall at the right hand of the throne; and another, the principal of the Liverpool College, as the representative of the Archbishop of York and the Bishop of Chester; and "regret was signified by the latter prelate, that a severe domestic affliction prevented his attendance at the ceremony, and he also expressed his disappointment that the consecration being fixed for a Sunday, many of his clergy were prevented from attending, and thus showing their respect for the orthodox Greek church." In an address delivered by the Rev. Cecil Wray, on behalf of forty priests and deacons in Liverpool and Birkenhead, occur the following sentences:—"The holy church, of which your Grace is so distinguished a representative, has ever been regarded by the church in this country with profound reverence and sincere sympathy." "Commending ourselves to your Grace's prayers, we earnestly request you to remember us in your intercession at the celebration of the holy mysteries." "At the request of the deputation, the archbishop pronounced the benediction, the ministers present kneeling, and at the conclusion, crossing themselves." And this degradation of English liberty and English manliness is witnessed almost unmoved in this nineteenth century, in a church which claims to be the chief defender
TROWEL. JUNE 1, 1870.
SPECIAL ASPECTS OF THE CHURCH.
265
of divine truth! I should have thought that the pitiful spectacle would have evoked a tempest of righteous indignation, and that a cry of scorn would have rung from one end of the land to the other. But the archbishop, to whom this shameless adulation is offered, is received as the guest of the highest ecclesiastical dignitaries, is toasted and feasted by even Dean Stanley, is deluged with addresses of congratulation and pious devotion wherever he moves, is entreated by a crowd of kneeling worshippers to let one drop at least of the precious mystic ointment fall out of the episcopal alabaster box, even though it be but "the benediction" in Greek. Well may the Ritualists exult, for "the tide has indeed risen," as they affirm, and to a height which might make us pause in anxious alarm, were it not that our trust is in the God of truth, and in the omnipotence of his word. "The Lord sitteth upon the flood," and though "the waves lift up their voice, the Lord on high is mightier than the noise of many waters."
But to go on for one moment longer with our examination of the signs of the advance of spiritual corruption, we light upon a most curious and instructive debate which took place recently in the Lower House of Convocation. The following resolution was submitted by the suffragan Bishop of Nottingham:—
"That a representation from this House be made to their lordships, the bishops, respectfully requesting them to address, through the president, a letter of brotherly affection to the Abuna of the Abyssinian church, inviting to mutual intercessory prayer, and to such further communication as may lead to intercommunion between our long-severed churches." This was seconded by Dean Stanley, who, in the course of his remarks, however, acknowledged that what, as he affirmed, had been "untruly said of an amiable and estimable prelate, was true of the Abuna of Abyssinia, namely, that he is a prelate of the most corrupt church in Christendom." Now, is it in the smallest degree likely, that after an archbishop of the church, which, in its doctrines and its practice is, to say the least of it, as corrupt as Rome, has been received with open arms by the highest authorities of the established Anglican church—after he and the community which he represents have been courted and caressed, and flattered, and flirted with, in a way which is nothing less than a disgrace to our Protestantism—after a resolution has been carried in one of the highest ecclesiastical synods, expressing a desire to enter into fellowship with—what shall I call it—a church?—nay, only the abandoned wreck of a ruined and blasted shrine—a fellowship denied to Protestant Nonconformists! Is it, I say, likely that any action now taken for the professed object of suppressing Ritualism, will excite the smallest respect, or appear to nine out of ten anything more than a delusion and a sham? Is it likely that the effects thus produced will be counteracted by such paltry acts of authority as the removal of "a tapestry screen," or "a silver cross," or the extinguishing of a candle, or the prohibition of the north side of the altar to the priest? Does it not seem far more probable, that what would otherwise sound like the astounding and impudent libel of a high church organ, is in reality a sad but undoubted truth. "No one will now deny that the moment the Church of England is free, intercommunion with the holy Eastern church will be openly resumed." A
[THE SWORD AND THE TROWEL. JUNE 1, 1870.
confession, by-the-way, as significant in its form as it is astonishing in its substance, since it acknowledges that the Church of England is in bondage, and that it is practising something very much like dissimulation.
There are, I confess, some hopeful signs to be observed. The present Council in Rome is a very hopeful one. I know of no such striking example of "strong delusion" as that which is forcing upon an unwilling community the dogma of papal infallibility. And I confess I cannot help feeling the desire that the pope may be left alone, and permitted to succeed in his designs, for it will be a fatal blow, not only to the hope of reunion cherished by many in this country, but to the power of popery throughout the world. Still there is enough and more than enough to make all the true followers of Christ, not anxious, but more than usually watchful and earnest, and especially is there a call upon us as ministers of the Lord Jesus to be standing, standing each at his post, clothed from head to foot with "the whole armour of God; that we may be able to withstand in the evil day, and having done all, to stand."
II. Our position as ministers of him whose "kingdom is not of this world." I think the time is come when we should insist upon it openly and more strenuously than ever, that the church shall be separated from the state. There ought to be no hesitation or compromise. There are, I know, signs that the connection must sooner or later come to an end, and that perhaps the event is not very far distant, but we may be sure of this, that the position and prestige given by this relationship will not be relinquished by those who profit from it one day sooner than they are compelled by the necessities of the situation; and it is our duty to help on the emancipation and "hasten the coming of the day of God." I have a very strong opinion that we are occupying our true place, not when we follow in the halting course of any minister of the state, however distinguished, in the enunciation of a policy, but when we lead the van as the ministers of the King of kings in the fearless and emphatic and uncompromising proclamation of our principles. I often fear that there is at present the danger of our being the champions of statecraft (using the word in no bad sense) instead of untrammelled expounders of the truth of him who died on Calvary, because from the very first he flung out the folds of a banner which had emblazoned upon it, "My kingdom is not of this world: I am come to bear witness to the truth."
This of course is only an individual opinion, but I think I shall carry you with me when I say that we ought to make our people clearly and fully acquainted with what Ritualism really is and what it means. That name is a very deceptive one, and hides a multitude of sins from their eyes: no doubt there is a good deal in Ritualism proper which is ridiculous and nothing more. We feel inclined only to laugh when men supposed to be possessed of common sense and enlightened by the Spirit of God, and claiming to be successors par excellence of the apostle Paul, will seriously and eagerly debate whether "candles shall be lighted when not wanted for the purpose of giving light (I am quoting the very words employed*), and carried on Candlemas day or used at the reading
* See reports of the Council of the English Church Union on the "Wix and Purchas judgments."
TROWEL. JUNE 1, 1870.
SPECIAL ASPECTS OF THE CHURCH.
267
of the gospel;" whether "when the gospel is read the gospeller shall be attended by acolytes and crucifer;" whether "candles and ashes and palms shall be blessed;" whether "the alms bason shall be elevated at the presenting of alms, and then removed to a side table;" whether "the gospel-book shall be kissed before reading the gospel;" whether "tippels shall be of a circular form"!!! whether "the epistle shall be read with the back to the people"; whether "there shall be a stuffed dove (!!!) over the altar on Whitsunday;" &c. One asks in wonder are these the occupations of men, or are they the nursery amusements of babes in Christ? But then people are apt to be deluded and to fancy that what is absurd is therefore harmless; they get a notion that at the worst it is only a question about trifles, when in reality it is a question of truth, a question of life and death. And then on the other hand there is a good deal about the movement that is to some minds very attractive: their Catholic desire for unity is paraded with a sincerity which is really touching: that very pomp and pageantry which you despise is to people of a feminine and sentimental turn of mind unspeakably fascinating; besides, there is an earnestness about them which cannot be disputed, and zeal, even in a bad cause, must always produce an effect. Now God forbid that we should convert the pulpit into an arena for embittered debate, or desecrate its lofty purpose by noisy clap-trap declamation. Nevertheless I hold it is not only legitimate, but imperatively required, that we should by this or by some equally effective means expose the corruption, which this Ritualism does in reality cover, and show that it is not simply exuberant foliage growing out of the tree of life, but a heap of dead branches, and leaves, and flowers gathered from Rome, decking out whilst it conceals the crucifix; that it is not simply an extravagant adornment with which a questionable taste has decked out the fair form of truth, but that beneath that garish veil, there is the hateful visage of one of the most promising of the offspring of the Man of Sin.
Still more, however, is it needful that we should be thoroughly grounded in, and hold and teach intelligently, the great principles of the Reformation in all their legitimate development, and that we should be animated by the grand spirit of fearless faithfulness and unflinching self-sacrifice, which enabled the reformers to draw and to use the sword of the Spirit with such splendid effect, and to become puissant champions of the Cross of Christ. What with them was an inspiration, a living, moving, constraining impulse, is with us in danger of being hardened and degraded into a dogma, a badge of party, and a convenient shibboleth of controversy. The patriots of the past that fought and won the first campaigns, are in danger of being replaced by the mere professional standing army of to-day. They will prove to be the successors of apostles and reformers who are baptised with apostolic spirit, and anointed with Pentecostal fire. May God grant us that unspeakable honour.
Still further let me add, that pre-eminently is it of importance that we as ministers should be characterised by an intense attachment to the Lord Jesus Christ; our personal devotion to him, and our zeal in his cause must be beyond suspicion—we must be "burning as well as shining lights." It is a complaint often urged,
[THE SWORD AND THE
THOWEL, JUNE 1, 1870.
that Protestantism tends to coldness and infidelity; that the piety
which it permits, is at best only the glitter of an intellectual
iceberg, and not the glow of a fiery furnace. Now we must make it
plain that it is possible to unite the very tenderest attachment with
the manliest robustness: that it is possible to burn with the ardour
of Paul in our love to the Saviour, whilst we rise with the free spirit
of Paul above the beggarly elements of a sentimental symbolism.
I feel very, very strongly the importance of this deep, ardent, personal
attachment of the soul to Jesus, as of a bride to her husband, who in her
eyes is "the chiefest among ten thousand, and the altogether lovely."
The greatest aid to the progress of Romanism which we can render, will
be coldness towards Christ: let it but be suspected that we fail to
apprehend the real presence of a living Redeemer, whom having not
seen we love, and we shall be fatal witnesses against our boasted Pro-
testantism, monuments of the fact that we needed the discipline of
children, that we were not fit to be treated as men. On the other hand,
let us show indisputably, without being at all gushing, that our love
is the natural and necessary outflow of a fount of emotion as deep
and as unfailing as that which throbbed in the breast of the great
Apostle of the Gentiles, and then the gospel light of three centuries ago
will never be extinguished: even though the waters rise, it will
rise above them and float over them, and cast its clear and guiding
beam in a path of light across the surging deep, because it never can
fail to occupy the same position as he does, "Who walketh in the midst
of the golden candlesticks," and says to every one of his faithful followers
as he walks also upon the raging billows, "I am with you always."
I urge this the more strongly, because of another mischief which
is making its appearance in the church of Christ, especially as repre-
sented in the Nouconformist denominations. No one can doubt or deny
that whether for good or evil, a very great change has taken place in
the modes of thought and habits of life of those who are the proper
descendants of the Puritans, and the tendency of this change has been
continuously towards a greater conformity to what is technically called
"the world." So great has been the advance made, that I very often
find myself asking the question, What special distinguishing differences
are there now to separate clearly and at once the ordinary Christian
from the decent respectable man of the world? It is said, and said with
truth, that everything becomes religious if performed in a religious
spirit—and business and pleasure are elevated into sacred things if done
unto the Lord—but this alluring and high-sounding talk is in danger of
being abused. Sometimes when I listen to it, I call to mind the story
told, I think, of an Irish dragoon. He was heard to boast that he had
taken a prisoner. "Bring him along then," was the response. "He won't
let me," was the odd reply. And when they came to look, the reason
was plain enough, for the so-called prisoner was a man on foot whom
the dragoon had attacked, but who, seizing the bridle of his adversary's
horse was leading both rider and steed into the enemy's camp. I some-
times fear our boasted conquest and capture of the world is very
much of that character; in endeavouring to take hold of and subdue the
world to our control, it looks remarkably as if the world had taken us
prisoners and were running away with us. Or to change the figure, it
TROWER, JUNE 1, 1870.
OBJECTION AND REPLY.
269
sometimes seems as if the life of the church—which ought to be a deep-rooted, all-pervading enthusiasm—were becoming a merely decent, respectable fashion. It is to be feared that the church has become something like that old heathen statue, which represented the river Orontes rising out of the feet of Antioch—a marble figure, beautiful to look at, but still only a figure of the swift-flowing river, a petrified allegory of the heavenly spring. If this should ever take place, Nonconformity is doomed, it is nothing if it is not intensely spiritual. All the more need, therefore, is there for us to cultivate that personal attachment to Christ, out of which alone the living water will flow.
"The church will always go a little beyond its ministers in conformity to the world, and linger behind them in conformity to Christ." As we are leaders in name, so let us also be leaders in truth—leaders in this respect, that we press nearest and get closest to him who is the great Author and Finisher of the faith; and by our chivalrous daring evermore keep the hearts of our people in a blaze of enthusiasm, inspiring them by our example to love and to good works.
