John Wesley in Company with High Churchmen
RENEGADES are always more violent partisans than the original members of the body with which they unite themselves, and their antagonism to the community which they leave is sure to be inveterate. "An old Methodist" who has developed into a priest has therefore set himself with evident delight to the work of converting his former comrades from the error of their ways. With remarkable tact he has gone about his work of proselytism by touching Mr. Wesley's followers upon the very tender point of the personal conduct and teaching of their leader. To assail them from the Bible and their supposed divergences from the example of Christ, is a task we imagine less to his taste, less easy certainly unless the assailant would also involve himself, and less likely to excite public attention. A peculiar affection, carried as we believe quite as far as it should be, binds most Wesleyans to the revered founder of their organisation, and to attack them through their leader, is to touch the apple of their eye. We admire the shrewdness of such a course of action, it is worthy of a Ritualist, in fact, worthy of an older spirit, of whose devices we are not ignorant, for whose evil kingdom the sacramental system is subtly working with terrible results.
No one acquainted with the life of John Wesley and with the results springing therefrom would have readily imagined him to have been, throughout life, an advanced member of the school which boasts of Father Ignatius and Mr. Purchas. Calvinists, as we are, we may have thought that Arminian doctrines have a Popish tendency; but we
TROWEL, MAR. 1, 1870.
JOHN WESLEY.
121
should have admitted with the same breath, that the gracious Spirit has evidently interposed to keep the mass of Wesleyan Arminians from that deadly evil. If we had been on the grand jury, before the trial of Mr. Wesley for high churchism, we should have instantly returned a verdict of "No True Bill." As well accuse George Fox of Anabaptism, or John Bunyan of Mormonism as Wesley of Tractarianism, so we should have thought and said. But now that the case has actually been brought before a public tribunal, we are to our infinite regret, amazed at the amount of evidence which the Accuser of the Brethren is able to set forth, and although we feel morally certain that taking the whole run of Wesley's life, the charge cannot be borne out, and is simply ridiculous, yet with our present light we are forced to admit that his earlier years and certain of his actions and isolated utterances give more than a mere colour of truth to the accusation. That he was simply the founder of a religious order after the fashion of Mr. Lyne, or, to go from the absurd to the marvellous, like Francis Xavier, is the idea insinuated by the "Old Methodist," and that he believed in the real presence, the confessional, penance, apostolical succession, prayers for the dead, and ritualism in general, is the point which he sets himself to prove. Our lament that there should be so much in Mr. Wesley's acts and utterances to furnish materials for the high-churchman's theory is more than equalled by our wonder at the dexterity which makes so much out of these comparatively slender aids, and ignores so entirely the whole weight of his general teaching and behaviour. Some of the items have only to be looked at to be dismissed; the great Arminian Evangelist is said to have approved of prayers for the dead, and the proof cited consists of expressions such as these, "grant that we, with those who are already dead in thy faith and fear, may together partake of a joyful resurrection," "that we all together with those who now sleep in thee, may awake to life everlasting,"—expressions which, whether we endorse them or not, we can all see to be very different from those prayers for the departed which are supposed to influence their condition. There is no likeness between the two. A man may well enough pray the Lord to bring about the time when all his elect in heaven and on earth may receive the resurrection-body, and yet may hate Tractarian prayers for the dead as he hates adultery or murder. So, also, when it is asserted that Mr. Wesley believed in the celibacy of the clergy, the fact that he supposed many advantages to be connected with such a state, is no evidence that he considered it to be a general duty; and when we remember that he took to himself a wife, that fact disposes of the question with all unprejudiced men. Other matters alleged are merely details of worship not peculiar to Ritualists; frequent communion is practised by many among all denominations, fasting was as much in vogue among Puritans as Papists, and is not utterly neglected by ourselves, and the repulsion of evil-doers from the Lord's table is the custom of all Dissenters. To mention these as peculiarities of Ritualists is unfair; and if Mr. Wesley be found to have agreed with them, it is no more clear from this that he was a high-churchman than that he was a Plymouth Brother, a Baptist, or a Congregationalist. Such irrelevant chapters weaken rather than strengthen the arguments of the "Old Methodist."
[THE SWORD AND THE
TRUWL. MAR. 1, 1870.
We fear, however, that after making all deductions, a considerable
residuum of truth remains to lend countenance to the assertion that
John Wesley, like many others, was greatly influenced by the manners
of the country whence he came out. He was a Church of England
man, and could not shake off the iron rings from his wrists, though
the links which bound his hands together were effectually snapped.
We wonder the Ritualists do not go in to prove Luther to have
been one of themselves, for there would be even more evidence
to support their claim than they can find in the present case. There
are Lutheran sacramentarians at this day in abundance, but we never
heard of high-church Wesleyans, and surely a tree may be known by
the fruit which comes of it. Somewhere or other in the Wesleyan body
sacramentarianism would have cropped out if it had been an original
deposit of the founder; that it has not done so we take to be very decided
evidence that it was never there.
We are, however, no apologists for Mr. Wesley, if when quotations
are fairly made it can be shown that he believed in Baptismal Regenera-
tion, and we are afraid the task is an easy one. The horrible falsehood
of the catechism is commented upon by him, as if it were a text of
Scripture. He says in his works, vol. xix. 279, 280.
"What are the benefits we receive by baptism? The first of these is the
washing away the guilt of original sin by the application of the merits of Christ's
death. 'As by the offence of one, judgment came upon all men to condemnation,
so by the righteousness of one, the free gift came upon all men to justification
of life.' And the virtue of this free gift, the merits of Christ's life and death,
are applied to us in baptism. 'He gave himself for the church, that he might
sanctify and cleanse it with the washing of water (Eph. v. 25, 26), by the
Word'—namely, in baptism, the ordinary instrument of our justification." And
again at page 280, "By baptism we are admitted into the church, and conse-
quently made members of Christ, its head. For 'as many as are baptised into
Christ,' in his name, 'have thereby put on Christ' (Gal. iii. 27)—that is, are
mystically united to Christ, and made one with him. For 'by one Spirit we are
all baptised into one body' (1 Cor. xii. 13)—namely, 'the church the body of
Christ.' From which spiritual, vital union with him proceeds the influence
of his grace on those that are baptised."
"By baptism we, who were by nature children of wrath, are made the chil-
dren of God. And this Regeneration, which our church in so many places ascribes
to baptism, is more than barely being admitted into the church, though com-
monly connected therewith; being 'grafted into the body of Christ's church,
we are made the children of God by adoption and grace.' By water, then, as
a means—the water of baptism—we are regenerated, or born again; whence
it is also called by the apostle, 'the washing of regeneration. Our church,
therefore, ascribes no greater virtue to baptism than Christ himself has done.
Nor does she ascribe it to the outward washing, but to the inward grace, which
added thereto makes it a sacrament."
The mixing of water with the sacramental wine is proved concerning
Mr. Wesley if the MSS. from which the "Old Methodist" quotes are
genuine, for he writes, "I believe it a duty to observe so far as I can,
to use water in the Eucharist. His belief in an ordained priesthood
deriving power through bishops, is also clear enough, and we doubt
not that if it had been in his power the Wesleyans would to this
hour have been left without the ordinances, unless now and then some
of the anointed of our Anglican Papacy had seceded and carried the
TROWEL. MAR. 1, 1870.
JOHN WESLEY.
123
precious unction with them. How a man like the acute and clever John Wesley could believe in such arrant nonsense as apostolical succession, it is difficult to make out; we should as soon believe an impostor who should pretend that the faculty of telling us our fortune has been handed down to her from the Queen of Sheba, by having her palms anointed with the oil of a sacred toad. Happily, the Methodists were not so weak as their leader on this point, and almost unanimously discarded the superstitious dogma, preferring a ministry to a priesthood. Well may Dr. Rigg suppose that Mr. Wesley's faculties were beginning to fail, and that his judgment was enfeebled towards the end of his career. We fear that on the point of sacerdotal pretensions his intellect never had been clear, but that the smoke of Oxford had blinded his eyes to the follies of Anglican priestcraft. Imagine a man's declaring as a dying testimony that none but priests could administer the sacraments without sin, and warning his preachers to beware lest like Korah, Dathan, and Abiram, they seek the priesthood also." We believe there are few Methodists who would patiently endure even to hear John Wesley himself talk in that fashion.
The worst passage in the entire book, we mean the most seriously damaging to the memory of the great Methodist leader, is that upon Justification by Faith. We confess to having experienced a feeling of horror as we perused the paragraphs which we now give in full. What a man feels when he sees the character of his brother, or bosom friend, withered to the root, we felt in perusing this most painful passage, painful because we fear it is too true. Foibles about casting lots or setting men on one side of the meeting-house and women on the other are pardonable enough, but an uncertain sound upon the great fundamental article of our faith is not to be tolerated though an angel from heaven were guilty of it. An apostle is to be withstood to the face if he errs on this vital point. We know that the doctrine of justification by faith has been overstated by Antinomians in one direction, and Luther has uttered now and then an incautious word, but this does not render it less an error for a minister of Christ to say that we are "rewarded because of our works," or less pernicious to tell sinners that they are to "wait for faith in doing good." Were it not that the evangelical spirit among modern Methodists has been most decided we should fear for a community whose founder could give forth such worse than doubtful utterances; as it is we hope the "Large Minutes" are not binding on Methodists, or we say unhesitatingly that the sooner they are repealed the better. If it be true that such statements remain to this day "the foremost exponent of the doctrines and principles of Wesleyan Methodism," it is a fact to be universally deplored. Every true believer who is found in the Methodist body should see that this matter is looked into, and if it cannot be set right, so that justification by faith alone shall be undoubtedly taught, it is his duty to go where that essential truth is believed, and not to bolster up a system of doctrine involving error on so cardinal a point. Our Methodist friends may well clear themselves on this matter so far as their minutes are concerned, for our hope is that they themselves personally are generally, if not universally, sound upon the matter: by so doing good will come out of
THE SWORD AND THE
TROWEL. MAR. 1, 1870.
evil, and the subtle attacks of the "Old Methodist," and the old serpent
will only lead to the glory of God by the purification of the church.
The redoubtable passage is as follows :—
"The next day, 'Saturday, 28, I showed at large, that the Lord's Supper was
ordained by God, to be a means of conveying to men, either preventing, or
justifying, or sanctifying grace.'"
"Having once laid down (viz. in 1740) the doctrine of justification by faith
in 'the true sense of those words,' Wesley went on from step to step, ever making
it more and more manifest that he had no part or share in the Protestant 'by
faith alone' heresy, and its hideous distortions of the Scriptural and Primitive
doctrine. Already, on this ground, he had withdrawn himself from the Mora-
vians, and the year after (1741) saw him part company with Luther: June,
1741. 'I read over Martin Luther's Comment on the Epistle to the Galatians.
I was utterly ashamed. How have I esteemed this book . . . how blasphem-
ously does he speak of good works and of the law of God! . . . Here (I
apprehend) is the real spring of the grand error of the Moravians. They
follow Luther, for better for worse.' Again, (same date.) 'In the evening I
preached on those words, 'In Christ Jesus neither circumcision availeth any-
thing, nor uncircumcision, but faith which worketh by love.' After reading
Luther's miserable comment upon the text, I thought it my bounden duty
openly to warn the congregation against that dangerous treatise, and to retract
whatever recommendation I might ignorantly have given of it.' 'Aug. 1 (same
year), I had a long conversation with Mr. Ingham (Moravian Methodist). We
both agreed, 1. That none shall finally be saved, who have not, as they had
opportunity, done all good works; and 2. That if a justified person does not
do good, as he has opportunity, he will lose the grace he has received, and if he
'repent' not and 'do the former works,' will perish eternally. But with regard
to the unjustified (if I understand him), we wholly disagreed. He believed, it
is not the will of God, that they should wait for faith in doing good. I believe,
this is the will of God, and that they will never find him unless they seek him
in this way.' Three years later, namely in 1744, Wesley lays down in the first
Methodist Conference the following 'Minutes':—'Q. 1. What is it to be
justified? A. To be pardoned. Q. 2. Is faith the condition of justification?
A. Yes. Q. 3. But must not repentance and works meet for repentance go
before this faith? A. Without doubt; if by repentance you mean conviction
of sin; and by works meet for repentance, obeying God as far as we can, for-
giving our brother, leaving off from evil, doing good, and using his ordinances
according to the power we have received.'"
"Ten years later still (1754) in his Notes on the New Testament, and in all
succeeding editions, on Acts v. 16, 'Be baptised and wash away thy sins,'
Wesley says, 'Baptism administered to real penitents, is both a means and seal
of pardon. Nor did God ordinarily in the Primitive Church bestow this on any
unless through this means.' Two years later than this (1756), Wesley wrote A
Treatise on Baptism, in which he sets forth as his own the ordinary high-church
doctrine of Baptismal Regeneration, and calls 'Baptism the ordinary instrument
of our justification,' xix. 280. This 'sacramental justification,' as modern
Methodists derisively call it, Wesley taught also in respect of the Lord's Supper
(as has already appeared):—'I showed at large,' writes Wesley, 'that the
Lord's supper was ordained by God to be a means of conveying to men . . . .
justifying grace.'"
"In 1767 Wesley threw overboard the watchword of all Protestant com-
munities—justification by faith, as the Article by which a church stands or
falls. After showing, what to him 'appeared clear as the day,' that the gospel
plan of salvation does not require any such belief, he drives home the wedge:—
'But if so, what becomes of Articulus stantis vel cadentis ecclesia? (the article of
a standing or falling church). If so, is it not high time for us, Projicere am-
pullas et sesquipedalia verba—to lay aside big words that have no determinate
TROWEL. MAR. 1, 1870.]
"STOUT HUGH LATIMER."
125
meaning—and to return to the plain word, 'He that feareth God and worketh righteousness is accepted with him'!"
"The wave of re-action swept further, and in 1770, when Wesley was of the ripe age of 67, there appeared the famous 'Large Minutes,' to which Mr. Wesley ever afterwards constantly pointed, as expressing his matured conclusions on the subject: the last edition of which he prepared eighteen months only before his death: in them he says, "We have received it as a maxim, that 'a man is to do nothing, in order to justification:' nothing can be more false. Whoever desires to find favour with God, 'should "cease to do evil and learn to do well." Whoever repents, should do 'works meet for repentance.' And if this is not in order to find favour, what does he do them for? Is not this 'salvation by works?' Not by the merit of works, but by works as a condition. What have we then been disputing about for these thirty years? I am afraid about words. As to merit itself, of which we have been so dreadfully afraid: we are rewarded 'according to our works,' yea, because of our works. How does this differ from 'for the sake of our works?' And how differs this from 'secundum merita operum?'—As our works deserve? Can you split this hair? I doubt, I cannot.' xv. 356, 357.
"This was the last straw which broke the Protestant camel's back. This 'advanced re-actionary' could no further go; and if in these passages which determine what Wesley's view of justification by faith was, throughout every decade of his life after 1738, there be anything which the highest high-churchman does not accept, it is only that John Wesley in this last passage goes further than he."
"Wesley's agreement with himself, and with high-churchmen, is apparent throughout. He held, as they do, that justification (pardon) and salvation are of the grace and love of God alone. Faith, along with repentance and works meet for repentance, is the condition of salvation; the sacraments the means or instruments of it: (Two things perfectly distinct). And, 'That we are justified by faith alone, is spoken to take away clearly all merit of our works, and wholly to ascribe the merit and deserving of our justification to Christ only.' (1766. Ss. ii. 49.) The doctrine of 'faith only,' in any other sense and connection, he expressly disavowed, and with all his heart repudiated. Throughout his long life he waged one unceasing warfare against solifidianism in every shape. And with this, his deep and reverent faith in all Christian ordinances, especially the two greater sacraments, baptism and the holy, Eucharist, was in perfect and closest consistency."
