Ritualism — By J. A. Spurgeon
A PAPER READ AT THE ANNUAL CONFERENCE OF THE PASTORS' COLLEGE.
WHAT do we mean by Ritualism? This is a question which requires some consideration, in order to answer it fully and definitely. To our mind, it is unfiledged and callow Papacy, which only needs maturing to develop into the genuine article itself. It disclaims the name of Protestantism, and has made definite overtures to Rome, though with scant success. It is a halting, and if it were not for the solemn principles involved, a ludicrous counterfeiting of
* For our authorities, see "Report of the Royal Commission on Ritual, published 1867;" "The Little Primer, a Handbook of Christian Doctrine;" "Manual of Devotions and Directions for Members of the Church of England;" "The Little Office Book."
Romanism in its worst and most arrogant form. It would be all that Rome is, but that its Episcopal leading-strings, state control, and silver cradle, keep it awhile in check. If Rome be compared to a lamp, Ritualism is but the rushlight; and both belong to the night and have no connection with the great orb of day, God's own Sun, whose beams give light and life. As the paltry fountains of Trafalgar Square are to the splendour of those of the Crystal Palace, so is Ritualism to Romanism; and both hold the same position to the truth of the Bible, that these human contrivances do to the simple magnificence and grand simplicity of God's hydraulics, the sun and the winds, the clouds and the sea—giving us the rains and dews, the fountains and rivers, to water and fertilise the whole world.
At the outset we object to Ritualism, first, as unscriptural, using the word as distinguished from anti-scriptural. The appeal on the part of its advocates is not to the Bible, but to tradition, to the Fathers, to the acts and councils of fallible men. It has its source, confessedly, rather in the darkness of the middle ages than in the teaching of that Truth whose entrance giveth the true light; and it seeks to perpetuate the performances and the habiliments of a corrupted and comparatively modern system, rather than the doctrines and spirit of the faith once delivered to the saints. It is in its origin alike too old, and too new. Too old, we say, as it does not draw its existence daily from the Bible, as our world does its light each morn from the sun; too new, we add, for it does not catch its flame from the cloven Tongue of Fire at Pentecost, and the altar of the early church; but from the dull glimmer of the mediæval shrine, and the glitter of a semi-pagan fire which overran the church, and consumed its vitality under the reign of that baptised heathen, Constantine the Great. It has clearly added to the words of the Book of the Prophecy, and will have to reap the plagues which are written in that book.
Its favourite position, that outward acts can symbolise truth, and that they can convey, through physical deeds, spiritual blessings, is, we remark, secondly, as unphilosophic as it is unscriptural. To teach chiefly by symbols is as difficult and uncertain as to write in hieroglyphics; and in both cases there is an equally imperative demand for a key to solve the riddle. Let any symbolic deed be performed, and it will be susceptible of as many interpretations as the divergence of thought and judgment in men can append to it. We remember reading a story of one whose hobby it was to find out a universal language of symbolism. He was promised to be introduced to a professor of the art at some university. The learned professors in despair at being expected to produce such a curious person, had recourse to a one-eyed butcher. The interview was arranged—the enthusiast held up one finger, the butcher held up two—the reply was given by the elevation of three. The butcher then closed his fist in a rage, and extended his arm towards the stranger. Here the interview closed, the gentleman being perfectly satisfied. But what did all this teach? He of the symbolic language explained that he held up one finger to intimate that there was one God; the reply by the two fingers was the twofold nature of Christ: the further extension of three fingers showed the Trinity, and the closed fist intimated the perfect unity of the Godhead. The butcher's explanation of the interview, however, was different; in a fury of wrath he said, "The man held up one finger to taunt me with only having one eye. I held up two fingers to show that my eye was as good as his two; and then he held three to suggest that we had only as many eyes between us, whereupon I clenched my fist, to show him that if he did not mind what he was after I would knock him down." Such is the value of symbolic teaching as compared with the simple preaching of the gospel to every creature, so that every man can hear in the tongue in which he was born the wonderful works and mercy of the Lord. A candle lighted may intimate that Christ is the light of the world, but it may also teach that men are in darkness and need some light, and are walking by sparks of their own kindling. Extinguishing a number of candles, one after the other, may teach the successive trials of our Lord, culminating in
219
total darkness, and his bitter cry, "My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?" but it may also teach that the candle of the wicked shall be put out, or that evil men and seducers wax worse and worse, or anything else you please.
Nor is it less absurd that men should assert the possibility of communicating life by such deeds as sprinkling a few drops of water on an infant's face—the changing of elements of bread and wine into the real presence and body of our Lord by the uttering of certain words—the imparting of the Holy Ghost by laying on of hands, not because of a fresh inspiration received themselves, connecting them anew with the Fountain Head, but by virtue of a continuity which never existed, and which has been as a matter of history rendered impossible time after time. If these things were stated as having taken place in the laboratory of a chemist, in the studio of some philosopher, or in the manufactory of an inventor, one laugh of scorn at the ridiculousness of the pretensions would be raised to cry down the deceivers. These pretensions are not as the wonders of divine acting, superhuman and supernatural—they are opposed to all we know and to all we have revealed. These men are the agents of, and profess by manifest causes to produce, mystic effects which bear no relation to the deeds at all. Our judgment, which always requires for every effect an adequate cause, and for every cause an appropriate effect, revolts from the bare idea of spiritual salvation by materialistic manipulation, and on the basis of soundest philosophy is compelled to condemn the assertions of Ritualism as bad in principle, and opposed to all ascertained facts.
A more serious charge, however, is that Ritualism is opposed to Scripture, and deludes men into the belief of a lie.
We will take up the different points of Ritualistic teaching, and show that the Bible flatly contradicts its assertions.
Priesthood.—The Ritualists would have us to receive the ministers of their communion as priests, meaning by it "sacrificing priests," ἱερεύς, a name which in no single instance is ever applied to the ministers of the gospel in the New Testament, and yet this would have been a natural word for Jewish writers to employ, familiar as they must have been with it from daily associations with the temple and synagogue; but, as we believe, they designedly left it unused, as not conveying the truth they wished to teach. The words employed are first:
Εὐαγγελιστῆς, an evangelist—one who announces good news, but certainly not one who offers a sacrifice.
ποιμὴν, a shepherd, a pastor—who feeds and shepherds the flock—not slays and sacrifices to make an oblation.
Another name is ἐπίσκοπος, an overlooker, or overseer, to watch over and survey the church of God, but certainly with no view to make propitiation for its sins.
A fourth name is πρεσβύτερος, a presbyter, or elder. This is no doubt the origin of the word "priest," through either the German, prester, or the French, prêtre; but our modern use of the word is identical rather with the Latin, sacerdos, and both by Romanists and Ritualists is meant to define a class of men who have a right to make a sacrifice, and forgive, or at least, secure pardon for sins.
One other word remains, διάκονος, a servant, or deacon, to wait upon the church, and to be a δούλος, or slave to the church's Lord.
The word ἱερεύς is not used to denote an officer of the church, because such office ceased when our great High Priest by one offering perfected for ever them which are sanctified. To use it now is to insult the perfection of his work, and to invade the dignity of an office which is his alone. Moreover, the use made of the word ἱερεύς in the Bible is as significant as its suppression where some would have it to be employed. It is applied to the whole church. "Ye," says Peter, "are a chosen generation, a royal priesthood" (Βασίλειον ἱεράτευμα). It is our office (all of us) to do good and to communicate, for with such sacrifices (ταιάνταις θυσίασις) God is well pleased. By our risen Lord we are to present spiritual sacrifices to our God. Let us offer the sacrifice of praise (θυσίαν
civious). Each child, however young, each sister in the church, however poor or aged, is as much a priest (leprosy) as was the apostle Peter himself.
Moreover, no provision is made in the New Testament for a priestly office as apart from the universal priesthood of Christians. No words are employed which would suit their purpose to-day, new ones have to be coined for the occasion. There are no directions for the performance of their most solemn ceremonies. All is human, if not worse, and no shred of Scripture is to be produced for the confirmation of their claims to special priesthood with its attendant rites and ceremonies.
We are prepared to go a step further, and challenge an appeal to the early Fathers (those junior students of the church, rather than its tutors) for any teaching there which will justify the modern pretensions to a priesthood which excludes any of the believers: "All ye are brethren." When he arose from the grave, and in triumph passed into the skies, he gave gifts to men. "Some apostles, and some prophets, and some evangelists, and some pastors and teachers, for the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ." No mention is here made of priests, nor any reference to a sacrifice; and when any claim to introduce these, we reply, "Paul we know, and Cephas we know, but who are ye."
In the full and detailed directions to Timothy no reference is made to any of the duties of a priest, and the want of a precept here is to our mind a precept in itself. Where the Bible is silent, we are deaf, and where it has no command, we desire not, will not, indeed cannot, obey. Nor is it necessary. The officers given to the church are ample. They are "for the perfecting of the saints," and we can well afford to dispense with the "priest." "The work of the ministry" can be done without them, the body of the Lord be edified in their absence, and all this will suffice "till we come in the unity of the faith unto the perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ," and with that we are content. We shall be satisfied when we awake up in his likeness.
Ceremonies.—Two symbolic ordinances have been instituted by the great Head of the church. Both of them when rightly used a means of grace to the recipients, and a testimony to those who are still out of the way. These the Ritualists take, and so mutilate and expand, that nothing is left of the original but the name.
Baptism, which was designed of the Lord to exhibit the invisible baptism of the Holy Ghost which, acting upon every part of the man's spiritual being, recreates him so that he is born again—beautifully shadowing forth the burial with Christ, and our death in and with him to the world, that we may in and with him also rise to a newness of life. Our testimony of obedience to the invitation of one whose we are, and whom we pledge ourselves to serve.
Now, it would be thought that those who call especial attention to the ceremonies of the church would have been anxious to secure the exactest adherence to the model revealed in the word of God, but the opposite is the case. The method is changed, and another subject is adopted, while additions are made which destroy yet more the spirit and design of the ordinance. No longer an immersion, it is a dropping and crossing. No longer a believer, an intelligent agent, but an unconscious, helpless babe; no type of a Spirit already received, and a pledging into the service of our God, in whom they have already exercised a faith which has brought salvation and everlasting life; but by this human deed the spirit is to be imparted, the service of God is to be assumed, the life eternal is to be bestowed, and they are to be "made children of God, and inheritors of the kingdom of heaven." The bare mention of the facts is their refutation. To expose them to the light is to destroy them, for there is no life in them. Was it in order to find basins and fonts in which to sprinkle babies that John went to Enon near to Salim, or because there was much water there? Did the infants of that day feel their original depravity, and before overt acts of sin had taken place in their lives, did they confess the sin in which they were born, as they came to John to be baptised of him in Jordan, confessing their sins? or was the
221
ancient method an act of conscious homage on the part of disciples who wished to have part openly in a kingdom of heaven they had sought after and found, and thus felt it became them as heirs of glory and followers of Christ to fulfil all righteousness, as their Lord by example and precept had enjoined?
The Lord's-supper.—In connection with the memorial of our Lord's agony and love, the Ritualists outdo themselves in folly and inventiveness.
As if to preclude all error in the matter, or change of method in administering the ordinance, the apostle Paul left an inspired record of the form delivered unto himself, and which he had handed on to the church at Corinth. A form beautiful in its simplicity, and yet highly instructive in its details. Here are no pomp and show, no gorgeous vestments, and unknown incantations, no tinkling bell nor wreathed cloud of incense, no prostrations and gentiflexions, nor yet elevations and adorations. All is simple, as befits an ordinance which is as duly administered in a cottage as in a palace, in a barn or cave and den of the earth, as in some splendid cathedral, or magnificent house built for God. It is meet that that ordinance should be void of intricate and expensive ceremonies, or mystic pretensions, seeing that it may be administered in the breaking of bread from house to house, and used by any hands which are cleansed in faith and prayer, and prepared by the power of God, albeit hard with toil, or worn and wasted by pain and age. They destroy the beautiful simplicity of the ordinance, and with that its power; and beside an empty ceremony, we stand with Mary weeping because they have taken away our Lord, and we know not where they have laid him.
No reference is made to any renewal of our Lord's sacrifice by the apostles. Paul speaks in one place of "always bearing about in the body the dying of the Lord Jesus." Again, "I bear in my body the marks of the Lord Jesus;" again, "who now rejoice in my sufferings for you, and fill up that which is behind of the afflictions of Christ in my flesh, for his body's sake, which is the church." Now without staying to explain these passages, they clearly are not connected with the Lord's-supper. By personal suffering for Christ, and thus following him, Paul repeated in himself the life and death of our Lord. Such a sacrificing still becomes us, going to him without the camp bearing his reproach.
"Buried with him in baptism unto death." "As oft as ye do this, ye do show the Lord's death till he come." "O foolish Galatians, who hath hewitched you that ye should not obey the truth, before whose eyes Jesus Christ hath been evidently set forth, crucified among you." Another set of texts, but certainly nothing that favours transubstantiation or consubstantiation—the real presence or anything approaching to it, in the elements of the Lord's Supper. These are all connected with teaching, and are acts which relate to the whole church, and not to any particular officer in it. Jesus is set forth in baptism, in the Lord's-supper, in the lives and preaching of his saints; but he is not repeated, his death is not died afresh, nor is his body once more recreated. All is symbol, and the whole church shares in the honour of being a living epistle of her Lord, known and read of all men.
One passage is at times quoted with a desire to prove that the apostles were then engaged in some such ceremonies as the Ritualists indulged in. In the thirteenth of Acts, the apostles and others are thus spoken of:—"As they ministered to the Lord and fasted." And turning to the Greek Testament you will see the original to be λειτουργούνται δὲ αὐτῶν. Now the word there employed is used of kings λειτουργοὶ θεοῦ—ministers of God. Another use of it is, λειτουργικὰ πνεύματα—"Ministering spirits," meaning the angels, so that this cannot be held to be any special priestly act, such as administrating a sacrament like the Ritualists' mass. Upon this as upon other points it becomes us to be on our guard, lest we be wise above what is written, and turn aside to cunningly devised fables.
As to the Mass itself, for so they delight to call it, in which they affirm that there is the "real presence" of Christ, and are therefore reverent to the crumbs of bread or wafer, because it is the body of Christ, and are particular about the
drops of wine on a moustache, as you may have noticed in some of their papers, because it is the blood of Christ. If Christ is actually present in flesh, how can the ordinance be for the remembrance of him, for the memory exercises itself only on absent objects? With this agrees the passage, While we are at home in the body we are absent from the Lord; and again, We have a great high priest that is passed into the heavens, "Jesus the Son of God." "Whom the heavens must receive till the time of the restitution of all things." If the reply is, "Christ says, This is my body," we answer that same expression is used more than thirty times in the Bible, and this is the only instance in which they desire a literal and material signification to be given to it. "Now no Scripture is of private interpretation." This one instance must follow the rest, and especially so, seeing that when it was uttered, Christ's real body was there, apart from the elements of bread and wine, and the bread held forth was no part of his flesh which he was about to give them for a cannibal feast, for such it would have been if his words were to be taken away from their spiritual import, and held to be literally true.
The passage. "My flesh is meat indeed, and my blood is drink indeed—he that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me and I in him," so often quoted at the communion table, was uttered when there was no such ordinance in existence—before the Master's death, and to disciples who had not then received the Lord's-supper, yet who were nevertheless living on Christ, for his own words are, "Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of Man, and drink his blood, ye have no life in you. Whoso eateth my flesh and drinketh my blood, hath eternal life." It is not allowable then to append this quotation as a literal explanation to an ordinance not then instituted, seeing that the only import of the words at the time when spoken, was manifestly and of necessity a spiritual one.
Can it be a sacrifice at all? Seeing that, first, there is no priest, as we have already shown. Second.—No mention made of an altar, the Bible word being a "table," and the Homilies of the Church of England speak only of "the Lord's board." Third: No victim—for our Lord does not suffer again, repeating his agony. "Who, once sacrificed, art continually offered;" so says one of their manuals when addressing our Lord, even using the word "propitiation" to describe what they mean by the term. Now, it is either another propitiation in addition to our Lord's, which we certainly do not need (and to say that we do is to insult the perfection of his work), or else it is merely a symbolising of the first. It cannot be the original sacrifice repeated again, for no deed can be twice done; when repeated, it is a second act, and no longer the previous one. Men may advertise the capture of Magdala, but though there may be a mimic battle, a storming of a fort, and the firing of guns, etc., it is not the capture of Magdala, and cannot be, for that can only take place once. So with the death of Christ. He cannot himself undo his death and die it again. He himself has said, "It is finished." All beyond this is a lie if it pretends to anything else than a bringing his death to our remembrance, and a showing of it forth until he come. To adore the elements is nothing short of idolatry if Christ be not really in them; and to hold that he is bodily present, is opposed to Scripture, and to common sense; and to those who attach any importance to such a fact, we add, it is denounced by the authorities and standards of the established church of the land.
Dogmas.—Now, briefly on the topic of their DOGMAS, and teaching on other matters.
In perusing their devotional works, you will find addresses made to Mary, adoring her and invoking her intercession, as in the following extracts:—
"Hail, Mary; pray for no now and at the hour of death."
"May blessed Mary, ever virgin, and all thy saints intercede for them."
Speaking also at times of a "patron saint." Now, all this is opposed to the spirit and teaching of Christianity. We have need of no other Mediator than
223
the Daysman, our God or Kinsman, who lays his hand upon us both. A man, touched as our faithful High Priest, with a sense of our infirmities, seeing he has felt the same, and yet a God, able to make intercession for all according to their need. Such passages as the following, to our mind, at once destroy this hankering after saint worship, which is only another form of idolatry. The rebuke of the angel, when the apostle fell at his feet to worship him, "See thou do it not: for I am thy fellow servant: worship God." "Lord, to whom shall we go? Thou hast the words of eternal life." "There is one God and one Mediator between God and man, the Man, Christ Jesus." Through him we both have access by one Spirit to the Father." "If any man sin, we have an Advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous." "He is able to save to the uttermost all that come unto God by him." "Neither is there salvation in any other, for there is none other name under heaven given among men whereby we must be saved."
Absolution is another form of error in their teaching, joined with its attendant, confession of sin and penances, "such as kneeling upon a marble slab, bare-kneed for five hours, repeating certain penitential psalms and prayers." The evils of the confessional and the abuses of the pretended power of absolution I need not detail. The Ritualists advocate both. A correspondent has furnished me with a copy of directions, published by the authorities in connection with St. Alban's Church, Holborn. One of them is as follows:—
