John Howe and his Life Associations — By G. Holden Pike
THIS article may properly begin at its subject's death-bed, since John Howe's strange procedure in his last moments will sufficiently account for that comparative scantiness of existing materials for sketching his life, which has perplexed and surprised his biographers. We have to imagine a spring morning in the year 1705. The great Puritan, whose sanctified genius has contributed to the profit and delight of so many grateful Christians, lies in the unconsciousness of impending dissolution. In the apartment we notice Dr. George Howe, the pastor's son, who is there to witness his father's departure, and to honour that father's last desires. Howe is supposed to be on the eve of departing; but, anon, those eyes which have so often glowed with enthusiasm over the gospel message, slowly open to evince that some deep anxiety is disturbing the soul within; suddenly and to the surprise of bystanders, temporary strength animates Howe's emaciated body. The invigorating spark flickers sufficiently long to enable the divine to reach a key, to look beseechingly at George, to point to a secretaire, and exclaim, "BURN THOSE PAPERS!" How sternly must curiosity and regret have striven against filial obedience, as Dr. George threw one by one into the fire, those lumps of precious fuel; a "multitude of small volumes," supposed to have been filled with notes illustrative of Cromwell's court, and of the Cromwellian era. We are quite in sympathy with professor Rogers when he is "almost tempted to regret that Howe should have recovered his speech at all, since he could find no better use for it."
Visitors to Dr. Williams's library will not fail to be interested in a striking portrait of John Howe, which as a valued relic of Puritanism, adorns an apartment of that student's rendezvous. How grateful are we to the artist who has so skilfully delineated and bequeathed to us the lines of one of the most expressive of faces! It seems as though the canvas were illuminated with a reflection of the nobler traits of humanity. As we look upon it, imagining the while that the lips are about to open, the painting aids us in accounting for the successful career of so "signal a trophy of the transforming power of the gospel." The man whose countenance so truthfully mirrored his soul, may well have reigned as an oracle among the élite of Nonconformity. Even the testimony of Robert Hall will scarcely sound extravagant, when he tells us that he owed more to Howe, as a divine, than to all the Puritans beside.
The history of the Howes can be traced backward as far as the reign of Charles the First. John, whose piety and genius have immortalised
the family name, was a native of Loughborough, and born in 1630. The parish register, which dates from the reign of Henry the Eighth, contains some entries of interest relating to his connections. Although he had no brother, John had an only sister. The father is supposed to have superseded John Brown, the silenced rector of Loughborough. In after years the Howes became related to the family of Hughes of Plymouth, the daughter of the heroic minister of that seaport having become the wife of our present subject.
At the era of Howe's birth the world was harassed by war and persecution. In England, William Laud, as a little-souled, sour-tempered, and bigoted innovator, was superseding the intelligible gospel by high sounding mummeries. On the Continent, in the horrors of the Thirty Years' War, Roman Catholicism was exercising her predilections for cruelty and devastation. The British king and his favourite prelate were industriously, if unconsciously, disseminating the seeds of civil war. The times were growing sufficiently perilous for few other than time-servers, or such as were utterly indifferent, to be able to pursue their way unscathed. The lynx eyes of Laud, though not omniscient, by the agency of informers searched out delinquents: and their looking into Loughborough was to discover that Master Howe's ministrations were not trimmed down to the letter of the prescribed régime. Indeed, the old preacher manifested presumption enough, and disrespect enough for the authority of the ascendant ecclesiastical powers, to prefer purity of doctrine before stained windows, and to value the example of a living faith above the texture and colour of altar-cloths. What could Laudian disciplinarians do other than eject so obstinate a stickler for "the law and the testimony"? If necessity compelled them to instal a smaller man, a change would at least secure a truer exponent of "the little bishop's" diminutive ideas.
Driven from Loughborough during John's childhood, the Howes sought refuge in Ireland, there to continue till the breaking out of the native rebellion. On returning to England, John studied at Cambridge and Oxford successively, and won the distinction of Master of Arts at each University. As a student, he set a brave example of industrious perseverance, by reading over the classics, the Christian fathers and the schoolmen; and by drawing up a theological system from Scripture, which, in the main, continued his life-long standard of faith. Having completed his college course, our young scholar was ordained at Winwick, in Lancashire, by Charles Hearle of the Westminster Assembly.
Even though we hazard a digression, an honourable mention must be made of Francis Higginson, Howe's principal tutor. Stationed in the ministry at Leicester, he sympathised with divers Nonconformist practices, and accordingly he was made to smart by the Laudian persecutors; but prelatical spite could not drive him from the town. In person and general mien, Higginson proved himself to be not the least remarkable of the Puritan phenomena. He lived frugally and laboured hard; and because three hours deducted from the twenty-four sufficed for sleep, his diurnal of labour became about a third longer than that of less favoured mortals. Many uncommon circumstances combined to impart an interest to Francis Higginson's godly ministry. Once, on his refusing the sacrament to an openly wicked person, the man, in a great passion,
455
rose to leave the sanctuary, but then and there fell down and died. Another townsman occasioned some considerable annoyance, and became the more incensed because he had a wife who valued the old Puritan's ministry. This man carried his opposition to the length of resolving to recount the pastor's crimes before the court of High Commission. While stepping into his saddle he was stricken with a mortal disease, to the prevention of his even starting for London. Yet another episode in Higginson's life will show how many perplexing circumstances could trouble even doctors of divinity in the days of Charles the First. There then lived in Leicester a comfortable churchman, with a digestion far stronger than his brains. Besides rejoicing in the distinction of doctor, this individual held a cathedral prebending and a royal chaplaincy; but notwithstanding his many offices and imposing titles, he found it considerably easier to dispose of a good dinner than to concoct even an indifferent sermon. As regards this particular clergyman, however, he found it to be a sufficiently happy circumstance in his experience, that contemporary etiquette relieved those dullards from preaching whose university curriculum had only qualified them for reading aloud. Like other dullards, our doctor had wit enough to manifest chagrin at his neighbour's success in that mysterious avocation of preaching, in which he, doctor of divinity as he was, so signally failed, much to his depreciation in popular esteem. What more enlightened policy could be adopted than to drive so incorrigible an evangelist from house and home? At any rate, this was the policy which the churchman resolved on honouring; and doubtless, he would have completed his designs, had not after circumstances balked their progress. Occasionally, when the doctor preached, he seems to have been not a little proud of his unedifying platitudes. All things ran on smoothly till, in due course the sheriff appointed him to officiate before the judges, whose circuit included Leicester. Effectively to preach before the dignitaries of the law appeared a very considerable business; but as three months remained wherein to work out a sermon, the doctor essayed to write one out with a few graceful touches of eloquence. A formidable obstacle now appeared: because ideas refused to come at his bidding, the preacher could write but little, and that little was not to his satisfaction. Long and vainly did people point out Higginson as the one man able to help him out of such a dilemma. The divine doubtless thought, there is nothing like independence; and as regards sermon-making, so think we; but how such independence can be asserted when its would be subject has no more thinking power than his quill, is not an easy problem to solve. In the meanwhile, affairs at Leicester were growing peculiarly desperate. The judges were coming, and no creditable discourse would be provided unless it were prepared by the obnoxious Nonconformist. There being no alternative, application was made to Higginson, who accordingly preached to the profit and delight of the townspeople, and of the assize officials. Because mortified, at this demonstration of his mental weakness, Dr. Rector forsook the town, being fairly driven thence by the force of public opinion. He was thus necessitated to seek a retirement such as he had intended forcing on his neighbour.
After these adventures, Higginson settled in Massachusetts, the manner of his going thither being singularly in keeping with other
portions of his life. A company of merchants invited him into their midst, and even dispatched agents to Leicester for the purpose of arranging necessary preliminaries. Having heard of the pastor's liability to arrest, the deputies were tempted to make their visit yield them some innocent pastime. Knocking loudly at the outer gate, they enquired in rude tones for Mr. Higginson, frightening his wife till she hastened to warn her husband of danger, and to entreat him to remain concealed. 'As they entered his hall with an assumed boldness and roughness of address, they presented him with some papers, saying, 'Sir, we come from London: our business is to carry you up to London, as you may see by these papers.' 'I thought so,' exclaimed Mrs. Higginson, and immediately began to weep." These 'papers,' the mention of which had created so much alarm, were merely letters of invitation. The devoted pastor sailed to the New World, in May, 1629; but died in the succeeding August, at the early age of forty-three, leaving a widow and eight children. One of his sons, Francis, and the first author who attacked Quakerism, settled in the church at Kirby-Stephen, Westmoreland—hitherto a place of little note; but henceforth to become immortally associated with the name and works of the Poet Close.
On referring to that esteemed farrago of facts, falsehoods and libels, the Athenae Oxonienses, we find Howe portrayed in more flattering colours than the bias of Wood usually allowed him to use when sketching the characters of Nonconformists. Apparently, our sour-tempered historian repressed his unlovely attributes while handling so illustrious a subject, for he speaks of Howe's abilities as "neat and pleasant:" and of his manners as being affable. On such account, we are to understand, Howe commanded a wide circle of Conformist readers.
But when Wood comes to deal with Howe's father-in-law, George Hughes, he relapses into his Oxford humour, and into his most finished Jacobitical style. Although coming of a plebeian family, Hughes was sufficiently fortunate to get an Oxford education, by which means he became entitled to the posthumous, but equivocal honour, of being arrayed among the galaxy of the Athenae Oxonienses. On leaving the university, the old Puritan encountered divers adventures till appointed lecturer to "The factious town of Plymouth." Because Plymouth was "factious," we are not surprised to find that Hughes daily increased in favour with "the godly party; and that in the "Rebellion" time he proved "proud, haughty and ambitious." At the Restoration he and another "conventicler" found a prison in the island of Nicholas, the confinement reducing their strength till Hughes lay nigh unto death. On that noisome Patmos they may have had a fellow prisoner in the Baptist martyr Abraham Cheare, one of the founders of Nonconformity in Plymouth. Hughes was supposed to be more fortunate than the Baptist, when he obtained his release by giving security in one thousand pounds, with a guarantee not to reside within twenty miles of his former labours. George Hughes and his son Obadiah, as brave confessors, were entirely worthy of their illustrious kinsman, John Howe. The former retired to Knightsbridge, in Devonshire, and there faithfully laboured; or, in the Oxford brogue, he maintained his connection with "the fanatical party." The latter planted the church which yet flourishes in Baker-street, Enfield, Middlesex.
457
Providence, or what were regarded as a chain of providences, smoothed the way for Howe's settlement at Great Torrington—so called to have it distinguished from two other towns of the same name, and respectively designated "Little" and "Black." A feudal castle, erected in 1340, commanded the settlement from the south. The share taken by the town in the Civil Wars was chiefly represented by the defeat of Lord Hopton, by Fairfax, in 1646—a victory which ended the supremacy of the Royalists in the western counties.
On settling at Torrington, Howe may have been perplexed at the prospect of presiding over a divided people. But if perplexed, he could not have been surprised, because that spirit of dissension, so characteristic of the era, was found disturbing the seclusion of old Devonshire towns. The appearance in Torrington of an earnest pastor, and a master mind, had the effect of attracting into reunion the scattered forces, such as had strayed to the Independents, returning to the parish church on Howe's accession.
Although, for the sake of convenience, we class Howe among Presbyterians, he never proved himself a stickler for the letter of the Presbyterian regime. His meek spirit extended its sympathy to the sister denominations; and in this, as well as in other things, he exercised a charity a century before his times. In an age remarkable for bickerings, disputings, and separations over minor matters, Torrington, under Howe, became the rendezvous of such as valued spiritual union; for conferences were held, made up of various parties. These meetings, and the weekly Latin letters, exchanged between the Devonshire pastor, and his father-in-law at Plymouth, reveal much which is favourable in the character of both correspondents.
We are not permitted to profit by any considerable insight into the everyday life of Howe at Torrington. That it was earnest and successful, there is no room for doubting; that it was laborious, in the understood sense of those times, we have conclusive evidence. Such fragmentary accounts, as survive, of Howe's early pastoral experience, at least enlighten us as to the order of those extraordinary last-day services, in which our fathers were wont to invoke heaven's direction in the season of England's bitter trial. These Puritan services lasted from nine in the morning till four in the afternoon, the whole time being occupied by prayer, preaching, and singing. Nothing need be said in defence of our fathers' procedure in these protracted services. The profligacy of the Restoration was partly a reaction against the folly of enforcing wearisome religious forms upon the unconverted.
Of the events which led to Howe's forsaking Torrington, in favour of the Capital, we have more particular information. His removal occurred in 1656—an eventful year in our national annals. It is the reputed year of the Jews' return to England after centuries of absence. While its weeks passed by, the enemies of the Cromwellian government—Royalist and sectaries—were busily working for the maturing of their dark designs. In this year the Protector opened Parliament with a speech, called by Hume, "A farrago;" but of which Carlyle says, "No royal speech like this was ever delivered elsewhere in the world." While trade thrived at home, the power of Spain was successfully resisted abroad. Foreigners had already learned to respect the
name of Great Britain's uncrowned king, and more than that, to respect the language of his guns. At, or about, Christmas, in this year, business or recreation attracted Howe to London. In those Puritan days, as in our own, the Metropolis had many wonders to fascinate pleasure-seekers, many of which the grave sort of visitors did not usually overlook. A principal interest centred in the chapel at Whitehall; and it was expressly to attend that royal service, and to see the sanctuary, as well as the Protector in his pew, that Howe prolonged his holiday, and so undesignedly influenced his whole after career. We seem to see the Devonshire pastor, as in the chilly morning he quietly seats himself among the illustrious company of worshippers. Cromwell's ready intelligent glance detects the presence of the stranger, and quickly reads the expression of superior worth stamped on his noble features. When the service ends, Howe is disconcerted on being requested to preach on the succeeding Sabbath. Excuse and remonstrance are modestly offered; but neither prevails. Because so little used to take refusals, Cromwell will listen to nothing but compliance. Once hearing John Howe, bred a desire to hear him again. His name, therefore, is put down for future service; and, finally, he is requested to reside entirely at court. Escape is seen to be impossible. To remain at Whitehall becomes his only alternative. But what about the heavy hearts at Torrington? They are consoled by an autograph letter from the Protector himself.
This greatness, so suddenly thrust upon him, Howe found to be an unwelcome burden. Cromwell's court was no very desirable situation for a divine of Howe's predilections. Naturally Platonic in temperament, he was, in his procedure, calm and judicious; and therefore, he could not fail to be offended, if not shocked, by much which he saw and heard. Being neither a time-server nor an enthusiast, he never countenanced hypocrisy. His manly honesty prompted a ready and outspoken dissent from unacceptable tenets. Surrounded as he was by so many distasteful associations—distasteful to his deep genuine religious feeling, he passed through his entire court-discipline without offending and without taking offence.
Cromwell's favourite policy conceded liberty to all; but allowed to none a dominant ascendancy. How severely his powers were taxed while keeping in orderly subjection the discordant elements of his court, history may never reveal. A governing genius like Cromwell, when perplexed by surrounding circumstances, naturally, would appropriate what available assistance promised to aid the carrying out of his designs. For such reasons Howe was thoroughly appreciated on account of those services he was able to render to the government.
As an historical character Cromwell stands out, on the dark ground of those troublous days, as a man, who, with discerning glance, could legislate for posterity; and who, because he understood its nature, promoted toleration. But, anon, the thankless task of restraining intolerant parties, overtaxed even his abilities, and Cromwell sauk beneath his burden of care and labour.
While the days of Howe were passing, he crowded their hours with abundant labours—labours belonging to the study, the pulpit, and the government service. During some leisure hours he corresponded with
459
Baxter, and many of the letters interchanged by these illustrious friends are preserved in Dr. Williams's library. Howe paid great deference to what he deemed Baxter's superior knowledge; and therefore highly valued the advice of the Kidderminster oracle. But even Baxter committed many mistakes; and among others, he overestimated Cromwell's power, for he seems to have supposed the Protector really competent to supersede the bickerings of party by the cherished scheme of comprehension. In ecclesiastical matters, Baxter advocated a cautious procedure. He desired his accomplished correspondent to exercise "A secret and silent observance of the infidels and papists who are very high and busy under several garbs." We become curious by noticing how many of these letters are addressed to the post-office in the Poultry, rather than to Whitehall, as though the writer were fearful of unfair play from some crafty court fanatics. Howe confesses his unfitness for a courtier's life in words of overdrawn modesty. Bashful and excessively careful of observing a proper behaviour, he details, in plaintive strains, his awkwardness in, and his unfitness for, his position. The spirit, quite as often as the letter of his epistles, shows what yearnings he had for Torrington.
Thus, with everything about him to delight the body, Howe is far from enjoying real comfort. He is ill at ease among a crowd of sectaries, the hypocrisy of divers among whom is not hidden by apparent religious zeal, nor the ambition of others more than thinly cloaked by high professions, and assumed indifference to earthly honour. While Howe's circumstances in London were as described, his people in Devonshire, deprived of his wiser oversight and faithful guidance, divided themselves into parties, to follow various leaders with weak heads and unsteady hands. We see the pastor the more longing to return into Devonshire, because, while his flock at Torrington is wasted by disunion, all agree to return to orderly allegiance if marshalled by the authoritative voice of John Howe.
Some curious instances occur in the experience of Howe of the manner in which a court chaplain could patronise his friends. Seth Ward, bishop of Exeter at the Restoration, entertained a lifelong regard for Howe, on account of some helpful words he had spoken to the Protector on Ward's behalf. Then again, Dr. Thomas Fuller requested from Howe the favour of "a shove through"—an unfamiliar phrase thus explainable: Dr. Thomas was called on to confront the dreaded Triers—a circumstance on which he drily observed, "I am a very corpulent man to go through a very strait passage." Howe's sage advice secured success and happiness; for, said he in effect, "When questioned, after the usual manner, respecting the work of grace in your soul, make answer, 'I have made a conscience of my very thoughts'"—a sagacious rejoinder, and exactly to the taste of the orthodox Triers.
At length the time arrived for Cromwell to evince unwonted coolness towards his valued chaplain—a change effected by Howe's memorable sermon on Faith in Prayer. At Whitehall, in those stirring days, it became customary to hold peculiar opinions regarding this subject. Faithful Christians, the fashionable teachers averred, during the act of prayer, received intimations that their requests were granted. Howe
argued against the soundness of this tenet in a trenchant discourse; but by the act of its delivery, he snapped the link of that confidential friendship which hitherto had held together chaplain and master. This estrangement may have been more apparent than real, for Howe continued a courtier, till Whitehall shortly afterwards became desolate by the death of Cromwell. If distasteful before, his surroundings were now intolerable. He grew anxious to breathe an atmosphere not heavy with the bickerings of parties, and to exchange unsought honour, and equivocal advantage for usefulness and seclusion at Torrington.
The Restoration had the immediate effect of unmasking courtly hypocrisy. Many counterfeits of religion now hastily superseded a hardly borne restraint by vicious practices. Time-serving king-pleasers sought to rebuild their shattered fortunes on the ruin of the truest servants of the Commonwealth. Torrington promised a field of plunder, too profitable to be silently ignored. Treacherous informers accused Howe of treason; but when opposed by the counter testimony of twenty-one witnesses, the charge could not be sustained. Some spiteful differences existed between the magistrates and the deputy-lieutenants of the county, on which account the mayor of Torrington found himself in trouble. On being re-argued, the case of Howe was declared to have been founded in error, and so, once more, he was formally discharged. His accusers came to no good end: one disappeared; the other committed suicide.
That Act was cruel, perfidious, and suicidal, which could exclude from the Establishment such men as Howe, and the crowd of confessors who manifested as genuine a heroism, though blessed with endowments less resplendent. Legislators, themselves little heeding the restraints of conscience, framed conscientious scruples to perplex the church's ablest and truest defenders. As they regarded the secession, the oppressors remarked how indifferent were the matters thus magnified by the Dissenters into huge proportions. In reality, things pertaining to religion were matters of indifference to profligate courtiers. The Act of Uniformity was the artful device of a faction, who desired the separation which ensued. Cruel predilections characterised the action of the Parliament. The bill came into force immediately prior to the falling due of the yearly tithe, and before numbers could possibly receive the new edition of that Prayer Book, which contained the conditions of their staying in the Church.
