The Pogery of the Twenty-sixth Article of the Church of England
Of the Unworthiness of the Ministers, which hinders not the effect of the Sacrament.
"ALTHOUGH in the visible church the evil be ever mingled with the good, and sometimes the evil have chief authority in the ministration of the Word and Sacraments, yet forasmuch as they do not the same in their own name, but in Christ's, and do minister by his commission and authority, we may use their ministry, both in hearing the Word of God, and in receiving of the sacraments. Neither is the effect of Christ's ordinance taken away by their wickedness, nor the grace of God's gifts diminished from such as by faith and rightly do receive the sacraments ministered unto them: which be effectual, because of Christ's institution and promise, although they be administered by evil men. Nevertheless, it appertaineth to the discipline of the church that enquiry be made of evil ministers, and that they be accused by those that have knowledge of their offences; and finally being found guilty, by just judgment be deposed."
Here are two propositions which, if they were now put forth for the first time by any but Papists and Ritualists, would excite astonishment and grief amongst all true Christians. Only imagine certain evangelical bishops, deans, and rectors, that we could name, publishing in a locale of their own these statements of this Article, what an outcry there would be of "Sacramentalism," "Popery," etc., "among the prophets;" and how would godly churchmen exclaim, "What next?" But the article is three hundred years old, and has been subscribed by a hundred thousand good, bad, and indifferent clergymen of every school, and "what everybody says must be true;" that is, a corporate conscience cannot be wrong, especially when it is the corporate consciences of good men. Need I remark that such a conscience God does not recognise? We shall be judged, not as communities, but as individuals, and, therefore, "we should count money after our fathers," lest a paternal mistake should ruin us.
Let us, then, look at the said article from the standpoint of to-day, and examine it as freely as if it had just issued from the Convocation of 1869.
First.—It is affirmed, ex cathedra, "that sometimes evil men have chief authority in the ministration of the Word and Sacraments, and that they minister by Christ's commission and authority."
Now, it is obvious that by "evil men" here we are to understand, not such veiled hypocrites as Judas, but openly wicked ecclesiastics, drunkards, fornicators, gamblers, and such like: for no oracle would be needed to tell Christians that they may "use the ministry" of men who, whatever they may be in reality, to all appearance are good and true.
But is this shocking statement scriptural? Nay, is it not blasphemous! What! an adulterer, impenitent, and still breaking the seventh commandment; yea, a murderer, preaching, baptising, and administering the bread and wine, "by the commission and authority of Christ!"
According to the canons, the holiest saint in the world, who finds fault with the Prayer Book is excommunicated "ipso facto," without judge or jury—but according to this article the filthiest sinner on earth, who is in "holy orders," though his filthiness be notorious, may continue his ministry, "by the commission and authority of Christ," until he be found guilty in open court, and "be deposed." What is this but to make Christ himself responsible for the scandal of such ministers? and what is this but blasphemy?
Secondly.—As a corollary to this proposition, it is declared that Christians "may use the ministry" of these "evil men" both in hearing the Word of God and in receiving the sacrament," of course, if they preach, and administer the ordinances "by the authority of Christ." But what a reductio ad nauseam! A child of God "may" (according to the canons he must) listen to the known hypocritical preaching of a child of the devil, in "holy orders," and receive the Lord's Supper from his visibly filthy hands. This too is fathered on Christ! who "promises" the "grace of God's gifts" to all believers, through "the ministrations of evil men."
If all this is not the very quintessence of Popery, which makes office and rite everything, officer and administrator nothing, then the question, "what is in a name?" has no force, and Popery called Protestantism loses name and character together.
Nay, if all this is not blasphemy, then "Christ and Belial" have "fellowship" in the most sacred offices of religion. Baptismal regeneration and episcopal confirmation are bad, very bad; but the doctrines of this Twenty-sixth Article are incomparably worse.
After this, I need not add one word about evangelical clerical subscription, or evangelical lay sanction.
I subscribe myself,
A PENITENT EX-SUBSCRIBER.
