Test methods of conducting Public Worship
MUCH has been said and written of late upon the manner in which the religious services of Nonconformists are conducted. A certain uniform method, or nearly so, has been observed by them for several generations, which is now considered to be dull and uninviting, and inadequate to the demands of the present age. The first seceders from the established church would naturally retain a considerable portion of its formularies; they were not likely to renounce them all at once. Its greatest divergencies from Scripture teaching would at first occupy their thoughts, and afterwards its lesser deviations in detail; just as Luther was led gradually to see the abominations of Romanism, and would have required another lifetime to have seen and abandoned them altogether. Succeeding generations of Nonconformists completed the separation from the national church by forsaking its Prayer Book and its services entirely. They shook off the dust of their feet as a testimony against them. They professed to derive nothing from them, and established an order of worship according to their own views of the requirements of the gospel. This was of the simplest kind: including singing, reading the Scriptures, extemporaneous prayer, and preaching. This sufficed for our forefathers, for the most devout and learned of those whose faith and fervour were not inferior to our own. They relied not upon external attractions to divine worship, but were wholly taken up with the idea that the true worshippers are they that worship the Father in spirit and in truth. In this they may have gone too far. It may have been with them a matter of necessity more than of choice, and other circumstances might have toned down their stern and vigorous practices. If they erred, however, it was on the right side. It was on the side of God rather than of men. It gave an aspect to Christ's kingdom of not being of this world, of having no fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness, and of forsaking all to follow Christ. We are inclined to think that it was this testimony of theirs, on the side of an unearthly and unadorned gospel against an external Christianity, that gradually roused the nation to more religious concern; and that the continuance of precisely the same order of means, instinct with new life, in proportion to the occasion, would have secured the happiest results. Instead of this, we have seen Nonconformity looking more favourably upon what it had conscientiously disowned, and re-assuming, as soon as it was able, what it professed to have triumphantly abandoned; and at a time when those very external forms were magnified by their opponents into living realities, and that were going back both in spirit and practice to the abominations of Rome. In one respect this may be the time to have churches, and liturgies, and chanting in imitation of others, but in another respect it is the very worst time that could have been chosen. It is a time in which a determined and combined stand should have been made for the simplicity of gospel doctrines and of gospel worship in opposition to human notions of Christianity and human forms of worship. Ample accommodation might have been made for the growing influence of Dissent in strict conformity with good taste, and sufficient interest might have been given to its original services, without appropriating to itself any part of what it had long professed to disapprove. There was room for improvement in conducting its services, in order to keep pace with the
advancement of the age in intelligence and civilisation; but new methods of devotion and teaching were far less required than the infusion of new life into the old ones. The singing needed to be made more scientific and sentimental. The reading needed to be enlivened by expository pauses and tones. The praying needed more of the earnestness and adaptation that betoken preparation both of mind and heart. The preaching needed more variety, more force, and more directness of appeal.
We have been led to make these observations by a book which has recently come under our notice, upon "The best methods of conducting Public Worship," by the Rev. J. Spencer Pearsall; the object of which is not so much to advocate new modes of worship, as to strengthen the things that remain. The introduction of new forms of worship is neither approved nor condemned. Suggestions are given to help those who are feeling their way to a satisfactory decision upon the subject; and it is not difficult to see the direction to which they tend in the author's own mind. We are bound, however, to admire the self-control that holds them in abeyance, and confines itself to that which is well ordered in all things and sure. The management of existing forms of public worship amongst Nonconformists, as here recommended, will, in our own view suffice and preclude the necessity for any other. We have our doubts respecting the advantages to be gained by a repetition of reading and praying in the midst of the service. Several short prayers from the same individual with brief intervals have not, we believe, any example in Scripture, and are not in full harmony with the laws of devotion. The only examples we have of such repetitions are of the same prayer. It is objectionable, too, in point of time. Better have the long prayer less long, with the introductory prayer a little less short, than so many changes before attention is required to the sermon. If, however, in the arrangement of the order of services we slightly differ from Mr. Pearsall, we can scarcely speak in too high terms of his description of the several parts of public worship in which we are agreed. Everything relating to the management of religious services and ordinances is judiciously and devoutly considered.
It is not requisite, we are told, that the same order of service should be observed in all places, or in the several services of the same sanctuary; and yet it would be desirable that as much uniformity as the differences of circumstances will allow should be preserved. The whole should be conducted by one presiding minister, which is more likely to secure uniformity of sentiment and feeling, and to give the least possible occasion for distracting thoughts in the minds of the worshippers. His appearance should be with solemnity without superstition, with composure without obtrusiveness, with anxiety without fear. Especially should his tones and gesture be gentle and unexciting at first, that the audience may be gradually prepared for that which is impassioned or familiar; and even to the last there should be nothing inconsistent with the character of one who is either speaking to man for God, or to God for man. Preparation should be made for prayer as well as for preaching, though not of the same kind or in the same degree. No one would presume, without premeditation, to make petition to a fellow being for some great and undeserved favour; how much less should we be hasty to utter anything before God! To a neglect of preparation the sameness,
75
barrenness, and irregularity of extemporaneous prayer, which are frequently complained of, are chiefly to be attributed. Let a suitable preparation be desired and sought, and it will generally come. Quiet meditation, with the occasional uplifting of the soul, will often suggest at once the whole train of blessings to be implored. To feel the whole prayer is better than to think it out; but to think it out is better than not to think at all. The Spirit of grace and of supplications should be sought for supplications, and not merely in them. The preparation of the heart in man as well as the answer of the tongue, is from the Lord; and this preparation, as well as the answer of the tongue, is given by the use of appointed means. Devotional reading and meditation will supply all that is needful for the gift and grace of prayer. Prayer should be prayer, not preaching. It should not be literary either in sentiment or composition, but unstudied, simple. It should not be rambling, but definite. It should not be controversial. It should not be scolding or denunciatory. It should not be brawling or too vehement. It should be appropriate in matter, and manner, and length, to the occasion. How beautiful, and yet sublime, how sublime, and yet beautiful is public prayer, when free from common defects, and just what it should be! For the management of prayer-meetings much valuable advice is given in the volume before us. Upon preaching too, and its adaption to the present age, we have some important suggestions. As the object of the writer, however, is devotional rather than theological he gives us the opinions of others upon this subject rather than his own
In the service of song he is certainly not behind its greatest admirers in our day. In this department of worship, great changes have been made, and still are in progress. These changes some may think are not all for the better, and we are not disposed to condemn them as void of all taste, or as too old fashioned in their notions on that account. Musical worship in itself is so dubious and undefined, that it is not easy to distinguish between that which comes into the church on the side of earth or of heaven. Musical and devotional emotions are easily mistaken for each other; and while some might encourage their union to the utmost on this account, others for the same reason might deem it prudent to put it under considerable restraint. Music, we are often told, has been a power for great good in the church, but, has it not also been a power for much evil? If we would turn it to the greatest good let it be freed, as far as possible, from those peculiar features of it which have been incentives to evil. Why could not the true church have a music of its own, a music corresponding with its simplicity, its unity, its chastened fervour, its many voices, its separation from the world, its pure devotion? Let congregational singing be the effect of cultivation and of care; but let it be of the congregation rather than of the choir, of the heart rather than of musical instruments, and of melody unto the Lord rather than to men. Directions are here given for the administration of the Lord's Supper, for conducting prayer-meetings, and for guidance in family prayer. It is, therefore, a thoroughly useful book, which does not exhaust the theme, but places it in a stronger light than has ever before appeared. We recommend it to all who would faithfully adhere to the apostolic injunction, "Let all things be done decently and in order." G. R.
