Menu
‹ Chapter 143 of 223 ›

Tradition and the Fathers — By Charles Stokes Carey

9 min read · Chapter 143 of 223

CONSCIOUS of the weakness of their cause so long as the controversy is confined to the Scriptures, and, though supported, also contradicted by the formularies of their own church, High Church writers commonly take shelter in the mists of Christian antiquity. They assert that the Bible must be interpreted by the writings of "the Fathers," that is, of the Divines of the first five or six centuries;* and they also assert that these writings contain an apostolic tradition by which we have to complete and define much which the New Testament has left unsettled or undeveloped.

We reject this appeal to tradition for the following reasons:—

1. To say that the Scriptures are insufficient for our guidance is to leave the laity helpless in the hands of the clergy. Laymen in that case have neither the learning nor the leisure requisite for ascertaining what they are required to believe. The New Testament can give them no instruction, it can at least assist their devotions. For want of the right interpretation they will certainly mistake its teachings, and probably through this mistake fall away from "the Church" and perish.

2. If the Fathers only can give us the true explanation of Scripture, why is not that explanation given to the world by authority? There is surely erudition enough for such a task among the Anglican clergy, and the great wealth of their church might be expended in cheapening the volumes which contained the precious treasure. And then what inestimable benefits would ensue! The practices and doctrines of the church would be seen to rest on an immutable basis, and by such overwhelming evidence in their favour Evangelicalism and Dissent would be at once annihilated.

3. The teaching of the Established Church is directly opposed to this High Church theory. She asserts the sufficiency of Scripture, at least, so it appears to the unassisted reason. "Holy Scripture," says the Sixth Article, "containeth all things necessary to salvation, so that whatsoever is not read therein nor proved thereby is not to be required of any man that it should be believed as an Article of Faith." Again, in The Ordering of Priests, the candidate is asked, "Are you persuaded that the Holy Scriptures contain sufficiently all doctrine required of necessity for eternal salvation?" and he answers, "I am so persuaded." High Churchmen are persuaded of nothing of the kind; at least

* St. Bernard (died 1153) is called the last of the fathers.

they must interpret the question and answer in a "non-natural" manner. Again, in the Homily On Reading the Scriptures; "In Holy Scripture is fully contained what we ought to do, and what to eschew; what to believe, what to love, and what to look for at God's hands at length."

4. Many great Divines of the Established Church hold the same position. We quote only two. The "judicious" Hooker in his Ecclesiastical Polity says: "To urge anything as part of that supernatural and celestially revealed truth which God hath taught, and not to show it in Scripture, this did the ancient fathers evermore think unlawful, impious, execrable." And Bishop Jeremy Taylor in his Liberty of Prophesying is equally outspoken. "The fathers were infinitely deceived in their account and enumeration of traditions." "No church at this day admits one half the things which certainly by the fathers were called traditions apostolical."

5. On this one subject the fathers themselves agreed with the most decided Protestants. Thus Cyprian (Bp. of Carthage, A.D. 248-258): "Let this tradition of Christ in the Gospels, and of the apostles in their Epistles, be held sacred. . . . Custom without truth, is only antiquated error." And Chrysostom (Bp. of Constantinople, 397-407): "The prophets and apostles have made themselves understood by all, so as that every one, and for himself, might be able to learn, in the mere hearing of the Scripture read, what they declare. And Augustine (Bp. of Hippo, 395-430): "Whatever is beside the Scripture reject it, lest ye wander into clouds." And Theodoret (Bp. of Cyrus in Syria, 420-458): "Eranistes. I would be glad to know how the ancient fathers of the church understood that passage—'the word was made flesh.' Orthodoxus. Thou oughtest to have yielded assent to the proofs adduced from the apostles and prophets, but," &c.

In the words of Bp. Jewell: "In the Canonical Scriptures all that is necessary for our salvation is abundantly and plainly contained, as Origen, St. Augustine, St. Chrysostom, and St. Cyril, have taught us." After such testimonies we breath freely once more. High Churchmen send us to the fathers, and the fathers send us back to the Bible. So, after some circumlocution, we find their own authorities justifying our appeal to the New Testament.

6. It is evident that as depositories of any apostolic tradition, the works of those fathers who lived nearest the times of the apostles must be more important than those of a later date. But very little has come down to us from the century which followed the martyrdom of St. Peter and St. Paul (A.D. 70-170), and about that little there is great confusion and uncertainty. The so-called epistle of Barnabas is spurious. A companion of St. Paul could have written nothing so egregiously silly. The epistle of Clement (Bp. of Rome, 91-101), "genuine in the main," says Neander, "is not exempt from considerable interpolations. His second epistle is manifestly nothing but the fragment of a homily." Of fifteen letters attributed to Ignatius (Bp. of Antioch, died 107), eight are acknowledged on all hands to be forgeries. Of the remaining seven, the same great authority says, "even the briefer revision has been much interpolated." Nay, there is reason to believe that only the three letters found in the Syriac language are the genuine productions of Ignatius. How absurd to send us for our faith to such documents as these!

7. The fathers lacked many helps to Biblical interpretation which we possess. None of them but Origen (b. A.D. 185, d. 256) and Jerome (fl. 378-420) had any sufficient knowledge of Hebrew. It is doubtful whether Augustine knew Greek. Justin Martyr (fl. 140-164) quotes neither the Epistles of St. Paul nor the Gospel of St. John. Moreover the principles of interpretation adopted by many of the Fathers were exceedingly erroneous. Origen saw in the Scriptures three senses—the literal, the moral, and the mystical; the latter being either the mystic allegorical or the mystic anagogical. An accessible example of patristic interpretation is the explanation of Gen. i., generally added to Augustine's Confessions, and the work of that "great Church Father." It is commentary run mad.

375

8. The fathers taught many doctrines which "the Church" has distinctly repudiated. Papias (first half of second century) Justin Martyr, Irenæus (Bp. of Lyons, A.D. 178), Commodian (in the third century), all held gross views of the millennium. Hermas (supposed to be the Hermas mentioned in Rom. xvi. 14), in his "Shepherd," a work much admired by the early Christians, says, "the Son is the Holy Spirit," "the Holy Spirit is the Son of God." Origen taught that the Holy Spirit was created through the Son. According to Lactantius (died 325), it is a mistake to say God has no outward form. Augustine, if Bp. Jewell tells the truth, leaves us a wide liberty of belief as to Purgatory. "Sometimes he saith there is such a place, sometimes he doubts if there be, and at other times he positively denies there is any such a place at all."

9. Worse than all this, some of the most celebrated of the fathers taught the accursed doctrine that it is right to tell a lie for the glory of God. "Most of the Church Fathers of this period" (A.D. 324-451), says Gieseler, "maintained lax principles concerning veracity, which threatened the very foundations of genuine virtue." The otherwise great and good Chrysostom fell into this error. His disciple, John Cassian (early in the fifth century), says that lying must be used as a poison is used in medicine, and that, as God looks at the intention, some men may be justified by a lie, and others commit a deadly sin by telling the truth. Jerome also defended the lawfulness of lying under certain circumstances in a controversy with Augustine, who, to his eternal honour, maintained the immutable obligation of truth.

10. Ambrose is quoted in defence of the "Church doctrine" of absolution. Before the reader pays any deference to his authority, let him ponder well the following facts, gathered chiefly from a letter written by himself. In the year 387 the people of Milan desired Ambrose, their bishop, who was at that time engaged in a contest with the Arians, to consecrate a certain church in the same way as the Roman church (in Milan) had been consecrated. He consented to do so in case he could find any martyrs' relics, and having a presentiment that some would be discovered, ordered the earth to be removed in the space before the shrine of SS. Felix and Nabar. Thereupon the holy martyrs began to bestir themselves, so that an urn was snatched up and thrown down, and there came to light the remains of two men, of great size, "such as a former age used to produce," the bones entire, together with an abundance of blood. Augustine says the bodies of the martyrs were found, Ambrose himself says their bones. By means of these relics, a blind man, named Severus, a butcher by trade, recovered his sight, and men possessed with devils were compelled to confess the Trinity. The martyrs were discovered to be SS. Protasius and Gervasius, and Ambrose gained a victory over the Arians. Respecting this history, we must choose between two alternatives. Either God wrought a series of stupendous miracles, and thereby sanctioned an exceeding veneration of relics; or, Ambrose, no doubt with good intentions, was the prime agent in a series of the most appalling frauds ever perpetrated by man. The facts of the case preclude the third possibility, that he was himself the innocent victim of deception.

11. Augustine also has been quoted as an authority upon absolution; but he, though one of the most able and spiritual of the fathers, was by no means free from the superstitions of his time. In his great work on the City of God, he coolly relates among others the following childish stories:—One Tribunitius Hesperius, a man well known to him, found that the animals and servants on an estate of his were injured by evil spirits, who however ceased to annoy them after one of his presbyters had "offered there the body of Christ." [Mark the hideous impiety.] Now Hesperius, in order to keep himself from harm, had hung up in his bed-room some "holy earth," brought from Jerusalem, which, when the plague was removed, he thought it irreverent to keep there any longer. He, therefore, with the allowance of Augustine and of another bishop, buried it, and made the spot a place for prayer. To this place was

brought a youthful cripple, who, after praying there, went away healed. Again, a poor tailor of Hippo, having lost his cloak, begged of the twenty martyrs, who had a shrine at Hippo, to clothe him. Going away, he saw on the sea-shore a large fish, which he sold to a cook for 300 pence (folles). But when the cook cut the fish open he found inside a gold ring, which he honestly gave to the tailor, saying, "See how the twenty martyrs have clothed thee!" We add nothing to such absurdities. They speak for themselves, "foaming out their own shame."

12. The Rev. M. F. Sadler speaks of Cyril of Alexandria (Bp there, A. D. 442--434), as raised up by God to defend the incarnation. Could it be imagined that this Cyril is one of the most hateful men history makes known to us? The following are some of the events of his life, as related in the English Cyclopædia. "His episcopal power was first displayed in shutting up and plundering the churches of the Puritan sect, founded by Novatian. He headed a furious mob of fanatics, who drove out all the numerous Jewish population from Alexandria [the Jews had been settled there more than 700 years]. An attack was made on the governor of the city by 500 monks, and one who severely wounded him having suffered death on the rack, Cyril made him out to be a glorious martyr. Hypathia was an accomplished lady philosopher in the city. Ecclesiastical historians state that Cyril vowed her destruction, and a party of wretches, whom Nicephorus expressly declares to have been Cyril's clergy, dragged her into a church, stripped her, and tore her to pieces" [her flesh was scraped from her bones with oyster shells]. Are high churchmen not ashamed to quote such authorities?

But time would fail to tell of the mistakes and follies of these writers, and of the church system to which they belonged; of the homage paid to relics and saints, of the lying miracles, of the monkish fables, of the ghastly austerities, of the more ghastly vices, of the sham holiness, of the actual laxity, which disgraced the "Catholic church" in the times of Chrysostom, of Ambrose, and of Augustine. Anything more hopeless than to seek for truth amid the confusions of these times, and the uncertainties of an earlier age, can hardly be imagined, and we turn with relief from the muddy waters of ecclesiastical antiquity to that pellucid and life-giving river which ever flows for us in the teaching of the Redeemer, of St. Paul, and of St. John.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate