Failure of Voluntarism

IF our space had allowed us opportunity, we intended to reply to the charge of inconsistency brought against us by the church party, because, while calling the voluntary principle a giant, we yet admit the poverty of many Dissenting ministers. The answer is very easy. The poverty of a portion of the ministry is an evil equally incident to any system of support. The church of England has a society, whose report is before us, for relieving poor clergy, which even assists them with gifts of old clothes. We have before us an advertisement in The Rock, in which charity is asked for a clergyman who has been starving on potatoes and buttermilk. It is clear, then, that any argument from the failures of the voluntary principle would equally tell against the state-pay method, and therefore it is unfair to quote it on either side. The voluntary principle is a giant, and does wonders; and although its failures are grievous, it must be remembered that its burdens are enormous.
Men of inferior abilities, who mistake their calling, will always be in want in the ministry, as they would have been anywhere else. This is not the fault of any system, but a law of nature. To make this evil as light as possible should be the care of all of either party, but they should not throw at each other un-generous taunts concerning an evil painful alike to us all.—C. H. S.
