Menu
‹ Chapter 87 of 234 ›

A Fifth Monarchy Man — By Edward Leach

16 min read · Chapter 87 of 234

POOR Oliver Cromwell! Hated by his foes, detested yet feared by foreign nations, and annoyed by his injudicious friends, he seems to have struggled through a host of difficulties that would have driven a less clear-headed man hopelessly mad. The more we read of his sayings and doings, and his emotions and conflicts, the more we admire and wonder at him. As every old musty document is turned up by Dr. Dryasdust and his colleagues, we find additional evidence of the justness of Oliver's administration, and of his love of uprightness. When those grim and dull mounds of unsorted and uncalendared state-papers, now lying in wretched confusion in Fetter Lane, shall be arranged, and digested, Cromwell's deeds will shine forth in a still nobler light. The progress which Mr. Hardy has made in this work has not been great, but the papers already discovered are of so important a character as to materially alter many aspects of the eventful history in which Charles the First played so conspicuous a part. What will be the result of further researches it is impossible to guess; but this fact is sufficiently clear, that Oliver Cromwell's character and wisdom have gained immensely by the investigations made of late years.

The bringing to light a number of documents giving the history of one of Cromwell's troublesome contemporaries will still further manifest the wisdom of the Protector's severities towards a rather mystical race of fanatics, who were as mad as "March hares." A Fifth Monarchy man was by no means a contemptible character, nor so entirely harmless as not to be feared. In an age of great excitement, when there were numbers of prowling plotters against the Commonwealth, he was a dangerous person. He was a sort of combination of a Fenian, a rabid Plymouth Brother, a millenarian, and a Chartist—full of political mischievousness, love for abusing and distorting Scripture, passionate madness for the reign of saints, and the extermination of monarchies and all Roman Catholics. His favourite cry was, "Overturn, overturn, overturn." That "much-abused Scripture," as Cromwell used to gravely call it, was for ever at the end of his noisy tongue. All the Old Testament prophecies were ransacked to collect such passages as might be twisted to mean something in harmony with the revolutionary

notions of the Fifth Monarchy men. "Curse ye Meroz," and "the sword of the Lord, and of Gideon" were, of course, used as watchwords of their policy. Accustomed to scenes of civil warfare, the horrors of a military reign were not felt by these fanatics as they might have been had they lived in more peaceful times. They had muddled their heads with certain portions of the book of Daniel, until they were convinced that the Assyrian, Persian, Greek and Roman monarchies had passed away, and that a fifth monarchy ought at once to be instituted, in which the saints would reign with Christ. Their gospel having originated with the army, was to be promulgated by military means; and in order to bring about the universal reign of Protestantism, they urged the vigorous use of the sword throughout the world. At first, it was hoped that Cromwell would head these restless saints in a great war against the Papacy, and be the David before whom the Philistines should flee in the great day of the Lord at Armageddon. He had already manifested most noble sympathy on behalf of the downtrodden Protestants of Europe, and the idea of his asserting the rights of the godly throughout the Continent, was not altogether insane. Macaulay acknowledges that the Protector would have had the heart of England with him in a general religious European war. "His victories would have been bailed with an unanimous enthusiasm unknown in the country since the rout of the Armada, and would have effaced the stain which one act, condemned by the general voice of the nation, has left on his splendid fame." But Cromwell was too much of a Christian to inaugurate a reign of blood, and he preferred to endure the vindictiveness of the Fifth Monarchy men rather than to follow a policy which, if successful, would have exterminated the lovers of error, but would at the same moment have degraded truth.

We cannot form a more accurate notion of what a Fifth Monarchy man was, than by picturing before us the life and opinions of Mr. John Rogers, whose history has just been published for the first time, in a beautifully got-up book, which will not be extensively read, on account of its documental character. Rogers was a descendant of eminent and godly men, his father being Nehemiah Rogers, the author of the "Figless Fig-tree" (1659), "The Fast Friend" (1658), and some other similar unique works of varied excellence. He was born in 1627. According to his own account, he was, at the age of ten, scared at the thoughts of hell. One minister frightening him by saying, "O you knotty, rugged, proud piece of flesh! you stony, rocky, flinty, hard heart, what wilt thou do when thou art roaring in hell amongst the damned?" With these and other equally strong appeals, his mind began to be troubled. He was further awakened by his own father, who "preaching upon the Good Samaritan, and showing his compassion, &c., preached and pressed so powerfully, that I was thrown into a trembling as lying under the guilt of Christ's blood, and was long perplexed about it." He had a number of strange visions, and his dreams and nervous excitements are told us in forcible and sometimes in beautifully figurative language. For several years he seemed to be a resident in the black gulf of despair, and frequently his distractions of mind bordered on lunacy. "I prayed," he says, "fasted, mourned, got into corners, yea, many times, being, as I was, ashamed to make my case known. I have ran into

209

barns, stables, anywhere, pretending as if I had business, on purpose to pray, sigh, weep, knocking my breast, curse that ever I was born, wishing I were a stone, anything but what I was, for fear of hell and the the devils, whom I thought I saw every foot in several ugly shapes and forms, according to my fancies, and sometimes with great rolling flaming eyes like saucers, having sparkling firebrands in the one of their hands, and with the other reaching at me to tear me away to torments." The reader will perceive that Rogers had a great dread of hell, and for five or six years, he says, he durst not go to sleep, excepting in a praying attitude, lest the devils should not find him in a suppliant posture. His excitability grew to religious madness. In his distracted fits, he would cry out, "I am damned! I am damned! I am sure I can't be saved—it is impossible. Oh, hell! hell! hell fire about me! the devils are at me! and I thought I heard the damned roaring and raving, and saw them as 'twere roasting in everlasting torments.'" But enough of this side of the picture.

Relief came in an extraordinary dream, which was "confirmed and seconded by prayer and the Word." He had not long enjoyed an assurance of salvation before he was tried. His father did not seem to have any sympathy with him, and was harsh enough to turn him out of doors. He wandered about, begging at cottages, "forced for life to try all sorts of things, and eat leather, and drink water, and eat old quills and pens, where I could pick them up out of the dust, roasted in a few coals which were left in the chamber where I was, and I assayed sometimes to eat grass, and did it; yea, I grew to that height of penury and famine that I sometimes tried to eat my own fingers, biting them till I could endure it no longer; then tearing my hair and crying." He had strong temptations—"the Devil did often tempt me to study necromancy and nigromancy, and to make use of magic;" that is to say, he was tempted to do unlawful things that he might become rich; but he repulsed the enemy, who, however, returned to tempt him to commit suicide. At last, however, by a strange and affecting circumstance, he was engaged to teach "gentlemen's children, at my Lord Brudenel's house." At this time he received a call for the ministry, and accepted Presbyterian ordination as a minister. Convinced of the justice of the Parliament's cause, he became a volunteer, "and performed those services in the field against the common enemy, of which he boasted afterwards." He married in 1647-8, a daughter of Sir Robert Payne, of Midloe, Hunts., and became rector of Purleigh, "one of the best livings in those parts," but being too restless to remain there, he hired a curate, renounced Presbyterianism, joined the Independents, became Lecturer at St. Thomas Apostle's, in the City—paying his curate £30 or £40 per annum out of a salary of £200 for supplying him at Purleigh, and asserting, with questionable modesty, in a letter to Cromwell, "I do profess it from my heart, that the greatest temptation I should fear falling into would be great honour, esteem, place, preferment, or means too much or unfit for me." This was strange consistency, especially for one who was notorious for his boastfulness. He became a violent political preacher, was sent by Parliament to Dublin, at a salary of £200, but was soon tired of Ireland and things Irish; and "the Anabaptists" being very powerful there, they gave him great

15

trouble. He soon returned to St. Thomas Apostle, and became a full-blown Fifth Monarchy man. Meanwhile he was deprived of his income as rector of Purleigh, on the ground of non-residence, at which he was greatly angered, as is evidenced from his letter to his late parishioners, which he signed as "Your affectionate friend and late your minister, in the hot bowels of love to you," &c.

Having been a Presbyterian himself, he was, of course, well qualified to write vigorously against all who followed with that community; this he did with all the virulence imaginable. The gentlemen of the bar were also the objects of his warmest indignation. No room was allowed for lawyers in the millennium of the Fifth Monarchy men, who thought them to be as little fitted for heaven as publishers are considered to be by disappointed authors, or policemen by vindictive costermongers. Rogers submitted what he termed "a handful of proposals, fetched from the Commonwealth of Israel" for the government of the country; these were afterwards called the "five fingered proposals." They were followed up by advice which must have amused and perplexed plain-speaking Cromwell.

Rogers published two works—both bearing dreadfully long titles; one entitled, "Bethshemesh," which was written against the Presbyterian clergy; and the other, "Sagir; or, Doomsday drawing nigh, with Thunder and Lightning to Lawyers"—was an ingenious protest against tithes and lawyers. "The two plagues of this nation," we are assured, "rose up both from the bottomless smoke, and are the priests and the lawyers," and "they must fall together, seeing ever since Edward the Third's time in England, they were advanced together, as to their height and interest. The lawyers are tyrants and oppressors of the civil state, and may well be compared to the locusts, mentioned Rev. ix. 3. &c., even as the priests are the tyrants and oppressors of the ecclesiastical state." The following are among his reasons for comparing lawyers to locusts (the reader must here read Rev. ix. 2—10). They are unclean creatures, many times translated grasshoppers, or bodily oppressors. For multitude—"Oh! what heaps of this noisome vermin may you see at a time in the Temple of Westminster Hall." For variety of orders: but here our author only condescends to tell us it were lost labour "to reckon up the variety of orders and degrees of this brood of the beast, distinguished by several forms, sects, and habits of divers fashions." For their earthly, insatiable dispositions: the following is a type of the remainder—"Locusts have a leap like grasshoppers, and so have the lawyers; for, like the leopards, they get their prey saliendo, by leaps, which are sometimes very large; and as to the things of God, or religious exercises, we shall find few of them frequent them unless by leaps now and then." Funny, is it not, good reader? And, as if to crown the whole, we are told that lawyers, like these locusts, have stings in their tails (Rev. ix. 10), and employ "the most cursed, graceless villains they can get," which was quite true, and may be partially true even to this day. They are condemned also, for their "monster-formity, or monstrous deformity."

The following lengthy passage condensed from "Sagir," declares the advent of the Fifth Monarchy, and affords a good example of the mischievous, fantastic and ridiculous method of dealing with the prophetical

211

parts of Scripture which was common among the Fifth Monarchy men:—

"Daniel tells us of four Beasts. The last of these Beasts had ten horns, amongst which rose another little horn, and this little horn persecuted the saints till the judgment sat, when they took away his dominion and destroyed it for ever.

"Now the four Beasts are the four great monarchies; the ten horns are the ten European kingdoms which arose out of the last of those monarchies. As concerning the little horn 'with much assurance and clear sight,' he asserts it to be William the Conqueror and his Norman successors, all fierce persecutors of the saints, but cut off at last and for ever by 'the Judgment which was anno 1648, in that High Court of Judicature erected for the King's trial.' After this comes the Fifth Monarchy. By 1660, the work of this monarchy is to get as far as Rome, and by 1666, is to be visible in all the earth. It will come mysteriously, suddenly, and terribly, and will redeem the people—1st, from ecclesiastical bondage, decrees, councils, orders, and ordinances of the Pope, priest, prelate, or the like; 2nd, from civil bondage and slavery, or those bloody, base, unjust, accursed, tyrannical laws and sin—monopolizing lawyers as now oppress and afflict the people. And so he calls on the Parliament—the Barebones Parliament, then sitting—to prepare everything for the entry of the Fifth Monarchy; and in order to this: 1. To appoint none except the saints to place or office. 2. To abolish all those unjust and cruel laws, and to pull down those courts, terms, and lawyers, yea, and tithes too, which have occasioned such actions, continued complaints, and vexations to the people, and wrongs to God and men, good and bad. 3. To set up God's law alone, being that in Deut. vi. 1.

"These are the Commandments (i. e. the ten in two tables given to Moses on Mount Sinai, Exod. xx.) 'the Statutes' (i. e. the several cases arising out of each commandment tending to establish and confirm each command) 'and the judgments' (i. e. the sentence upon the breach of every law, now, and what the punishment must be). Now this law, statute-book and judgment-seat of God, must be set up in the Fifth Monarchy, and then shall we be restored to (1), God's laws; (2), in our own language; (3), read and expounded, and made known to the people; (4), at free cost, without charge; (5), justice will be had at home then, and judges sit in all the gates of the cities; (6), and every man plead his own cause—then no need of lawyers; (7), justice will not be delayed but speedy; (8), and executed without gainsaying, according to the law (set) of God, and without respect of persons; (9), then judges shall be as at first, and justice also in every city; and (10), then the Lord will be our only law-giver, and the law abide for ever, without alteration, as there is now, and ought to be, in the forms of men. 'Wherefore, if you be men, whom the Lord will own and honour in the work, up then and about it.' . . . The Lord Jesus awaken you with the noise of the Monarchy which is swift in motion and now nigh us, lest you be surprised!"

Rogers soon found that the government could not wink at the violent, furious treason which was being nursed in the hearts of the Fifth Monarchy men. All the sermons of their preachers were filled with bitter invectives against Cromwell, who was called Antichrist with as little reason as Louis Napoleon has been similarly denominated by some modern fanatics. Cromwell bore with the nonsense of the new sect as long as he could, consistent with the public safety; but finding the mischief spreading, he ordered some of the more notorious offenders, Rogers included, into custody. In his "Prison boon," Rogers gives a glowing description, highly tinctured with his half-mad fancies, of the dealings of the gaolers with him, in which he inveighs bitterly against all who have offended and illused him. The Lord, he says, allowed the

snail a shell, but his enemies would not permit his wife and children to have a shell for themselves, excepting that of his prison. Undoubtedly he suffered much while in prison, and the death of his two babes sorely afflicted him. The way in which he "received a call" to write this treatise, is not a little amusing. A sister, who is described as "a choice servant of Christ and his church," had had "a week's close communion and conference with the Lord, in heavenly visits and visions," during which she was desired to tell Rogers, that the Lamb's Book should be unsealed, and the vision opened to him, bidding him be of good cheer, for he should shortly know his own work and what Israel ought to do. He thereupon dreams that some huge ripe mulberries fell into his mouth; after which "men of much wisdom" came to him, telling him that it was the "incessant expectation of the saints in London to hear some news of the prison vision." Then—for he was a great dreamer, and built most of his nonsense on his dreams—he saw in his sleep a great dragon, "which perished without power of hurting," and the Lord told him that the day when the saints should rule, and the Beast would be dethroned, was at hand. Unfortunately, however, the Lord could not have revealed anything of the kind, since it did not come true.

At the petition of some friends, Cromwell decided upon giving an audience to Mr. Rogers, "to satisfy them" as he said, "that you suffer as an evil-doer." Rogers was not disposed to be satisfied on that point, but wished to be tried. Oliver's shrewdness led him to understand the character of the man with whom he was dealing, and when he grimly answered, "As you please, but if he is tried I assure you he will be hung," he satisfied the demands of the misdemeanant. The narrative of the conference between the Protector and the prisoner is evidently written by an over-friendly hand, but it reveals the fact that Rogers and his party had a monopoly of furious epithets and choice Billingsgate. We cannot find room for a condensation of the interesting account; but there are certain characteristic points which must be given. Oliver's strong common sense and quaintness appear on every page. He had to deal with a semi-maniac magpie, who persisted in talking. "You will talk," Oliver told him, "although it be nothing to purpose." He suffered not for the gospel's sake (continued his lordship, speaking most emphatically), but as a railer, seducer, a busy-body in other men's matters, and a stirrer up of sedition. "To say that this his suffering is for the gospel, is making Christ the patron of such things; it is blasphemy to call suffering for evil-doing suffering for the gospel." And rising to the dignity and importance of the occasion, the Protector called God to witness whether any man in England was suffering for the testimony of Jesus. "Nay," added he with grim shrewdness, "do not lift up your hands to your eyes, for there is no man in England which suffers so." Rogers persisted he was not an evil-doer, and was ready to prove his innocence. "Ah," answered the Protector, with cruel irony, "we know you are ready enough." In his usual nimble way, Rogers twisted Scripture to show that he was suffering for the gospel. Whereat, Cromwell answered sadly—

"I grieve that you call this the gospel; for every one is ready to come and say, 'This is the gospel,' with words in their mouths, and say this is the mean-

213

ing of the Scripture: but there wants the power of godliness, for Christ and his disciples will not speak evil of no man."

Oliver's grammar, it will be seen, frequently trips—for he was not nice on such matters when he was fighting flesh-and-blood foes. Rogers gets warm, calls Oliver a "sophister," and speaks daringly. Oliver finds it needful frequently to reiterate his previous statements and charges, and so the discussion goes on most unsatisfactorily. "I know that you never preached the covenant of grace; I know you are ignorant of the covenant, nay, for all your lifting up your eyes, it is so. Nay, I know you well enough," continued he, incisively, "and I know your principles; though you are but a young man, yet you have been in many places, and are known well enough." This was an unkind cut at Rogers' past restless and not quite satisfactory history. The conversation then proceeds by a circuitous route from the main point, until Cromwell brings it back again. Rogers talks like a naughty, cross old woman, scolding the informers and those who believed in them. He charges the latter with the crime for which the Fifth Monarchy men were notoriously famous, namely, making incongruous selections from Scripture to suit certain ends. Oliver again gets excited; Rogers begins to argue like a thorough-bred "Hyper," whose arguments are like John Bright's Scotch terrier—the head and tail of which do not seem to differ. Then comes a lull, broken only by Cromwell's charging Rogers with bad grammar. "Ha! are drunkenness and swearing, opinions then?" Oliver muddles his arguments, and gets tired of this talk, and pants for fresh air and common sense. When the prisoner enters upon certain explanations about the Beast—his dominion, and how soon it will be ended, plain Oliver confessed he did not understand the science of Beastiology; and Rogers, "speaking with a high voice and great alacrity," as was his manner, "made the courtiers scoff at him as if he were a madman." Meanwhile the chatter drags along heavily, until Cromwell is exasperated, and dislocates his sentences, and finally says emphatically, "I tell you there wants brotherly love, and the several sorts of forms (sects?) would cut the throats of one another, should I not keep the peace. . . . . . It is fit to keep all these forms out of power."

Thus ended the business, and Rogers was sent to prison at Windsor. His imprisonment lasted from 1654 to 1657; but he found the way to the Tower again, was liberated, fled to Utrecht, at the age of thirty-three, became Doctor of Medicine, but fond of a vagrant life, he left for England, and, in 1663, his existence is attested to by an entry in a spy-book, as pastor of a church in St. Mary Magdalene's parish, Bermondsey, and a practiser of physic. His death is said to be uncertain, but the Eclectic of March notices, that "Mr. Chester, in his account of the genealogy of Rogers, the martyr, says, 'an entry in the register of the parish of St. Mary Magdalene, Bermondsey, records the burial of one of his name on the 22nd of July, 1670, and doubtless has reference to him.'" That being the case, Rogers died when quite a young man, after spending a fitful life, which might have been attended by most dangerous consequences to the State. A godly man, but a political firebrand, whose conduct and opinions made it necessary that he should be confined somewhere, that he might be out of mischief.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate