Pulpit Power
YOU know, my clerical brethren,* "the Fourth Estate" has made itself merry of late on the great number of sermons annually preached in this supposed sermon-ridden realm of ours. You have been told that one of the greatest modern miracles is the sublime patience of church and chapel-goers, whilst listening to the ordinary compound of small conversational talk, theological technicality, evangelical mediocrity, or diluted Scripture-paraphrasing which it is said so largely prevails in these latter days. Sermonising is, say your critics, a degenerated art; and it is confidently stated that the power of the pulpit will never be so great as it was before the days when the Press reared its head in conflict with a long-established monopoly. Learned men, the best scholars, and literary minds, are divorced from the church; and—whether for the wholesomeness of the world or not, is not apparent—are linked with the grandees of a modern estate, which is exercising far greater influence than its
* It would seem that the author throughout this paper, by a pleasant fiction of the imagination in which the Grub-street fraternity sometimes indulge, conceives he is addressing a clerical assemblage. The paper has not been read before any such audience, as will be seen from the following note which the writer has left on the margin—"November 30. To write a paper on pulpit-power; thankful I have not to read it to any audience, clerical or non clerical."
21
once formidable rival. Caxton has beaten Chrysostom from the field; and long primer and bourgeois have put down sounding boards and red cushions. "The common run of sermons," observes a popular magazine, noted mostly for its sensational novels, "can never have been much better or much worse than they are, and it is curious that people should be surprised at their quality." And again, "The really remarkable point about sermons is, that there are so many preachers who do succeed in getting a certain kind of attention from their hearers;" for preaching "is, in many cases, positively repulsive." This, somewhat refined, is also the outcry of a contemporary magazine of Broad Church principles, which treats its readers to suggestive remedies for pulpit decay, such as, for instance, the necessity of a more judicious adjustment of clerical labour. Some parsons, it assures us, who are eminently fitted for reading the Church services, and attending to visitation and other similar work—to be, as I should put it, the fag-outs of clergydom, never having any innings—are out of their proper sphere in the pulpit. Then, too, Jupiter thunders; and is out-thundered by Jupiter-Junior, who gravely assures us that modern sermons are "fit only for children and sentimental women!" There are several newspaper "Amens" to this judicial decision; and so what with being charged with spiritualising that "blessed word, Mesopotamia," and indulging in universal mediocrity, dreary platitude, and utter want of any copious irrigation of scholarship, the verdict from all the jurors seems to be, that the pulpit must be locked up, and perhaps the church too, or the full tide of fervour turned into other solemnities of public worship, which must receive extra ornamentation to make them attractive to the taste. Or, as those would have it who respect not ecclesiastical finery and sacerdotalism of any sort, but Erastianism and moral teaching pure and simple, it would be worth consideration whether half-hours from the standard divines would not satisfy the common want. This might be properly done, it is thought, were the authorship in every case acknowledged; otherwise that irrepressible Dogberry would exclaim, as he might do even now, of the breach of the Eighth Commandment, "It is flat burglary as ever was committed."
It is very evident, and for your consolation this flattering thought may, my Nonconformist brethren, be nourished, that the complaints of the dearth of sermons of intrinsic merit come from the Episcopal sect. By the side of the conservative and churchy Bishop of Oxford, at the recent Church Congress at York, stood a "layman," who almost unsweepingly condemned the sermons of his church; and declared that they were not "literary compositions," but "rambling, unconnected strings of remarks, good perhaps and valuable in themselves, but cohering by no bond of unity." However desirable it may be to go to public service, to gain, as George Herbert said, "patience and a blessing," there is a disposition abroad to get something more. Dean Alford affords his brethren a glimpse of what has been done by Nonconformist divines, to make amends for the deficiencies of Episcopalianism. Hear him: "Already the Nonconformists have passed us by in Biblical scholarship and ministerial training; the specimens which we have given of their sermons are such as the Church of England in our day could hardly show."*
* Contemporary Review, July, 1866.
Not that Nonconformists have attained that for which they are supposed earnestly to seek, for among many of them there is an inclination to depreciate the pulpit and to exalt the pew. But voluntaryism has largely maintained its position in the world as a power for producing spiritual good; and by it, the pulpit has ever been recognized as the Thermopylæ of Christendom. One distinguished Nonconformist, who, since his new birth, has spent most of his life in the pulpit, recently assured some students for the ministry, that the work of the pulpit was far more important than visitation of the sick, pastoral visitation, the organization of useful and benevolent institutions, platform speaking, magazine editing, or writing. And our conviction as Christian men, anxious for the promulgation of the divine message, the salvation of men, the upraising of God's glory, is—whichever way we turn—that the foolishness of preaching still continues to be the medium for heaven's blessings; and that it would become a serious question, "How shall they hear without a preacher?" were we not persuaded of the full propriety of the only answer that can be truthfully given to it. My literary friend, the power of the pulpit is too immense for it to die out so spasmodically as you may hope it will. The utterance of living, burning thought, will to the end of this world's existence continue to stir or subdue the emotions, influence the conduct, and affect the history of our land; still will it, despite the maudlin sentimentalism of an effeminate vestment-worship, host-elevations, incense-boats on the one side, and classic uniformity and dulness on the other, be the God-accepted means of conveying pardon to every man who will believe on the Lord Jesus Christ.
On you, however, my clerics, rests a heavy responsibility which nought but constant faith in Omnipotence and incessant activity of thought, sifting enquiry, and close preparatory study of the secondary as well as primary elements of pulpit success, can possibly meet. Having true piety in your hearts, and a distinct call for the work, you have diligently to divest yourselves of all unsuitable qualities, lest you become the unhappy possessor of the far too common "gift of dispersion"
Of the absolutely necessary spiritual and moral qualifications for ministerial work nothing need now be said; to the method and manner—important in every aspect of so wide a subject—I shall at this time confine myself. It has been said that preaching is better studied as an art on the Continent than here; and we may each profit by the advice of a French Protestant, who recently delivered a course of useful lectures on this subject.* M. Coquerel is well qualified by an experience of more than forty years in the pulpit, close study of the models and masters of eloquence, and long observation of Continental styles of oratory, to give advice to you all, my well-informed brethren. M. Coquerel believes, as we all should do, that preaching is the first duty of the ministry, and consequently he recommends most earnestly the diligent study of the art of eloquence. He believes that to study the science is a most useful means of progress in it. This has been the universal experience of the greatest orators, who have gladly acknow-
* "Preacher's Counsellor, or Practical Observations on Preaching," by ATHENAS COQUEREL, translated by Rev. R. A. Bertram, London: Elliot Stock; to whom I am indebted for early proof sheets of M. Coquerel's valuable and suggestive work.
23
ledged that good advice has saved them from many painful experiments, and helped them to greater perfection.
I have heard of an English platform orator who acquired his passionate style from "spouting" to the waves on the sea-beach. Many talented ministers of thoughtful, studious habits, find an hour or two's contemplative walking in the fields to be eminently useful in studying for pulpit work. Sermons have frequently been preached to the rocks and sparrows prior to their delivery in the pulpit; and no one ought to be more grateful for this gratuitous service than the farmers, who at such seasons might dispense with the less musical noise of youthful scarecrows. But this practice has, it is said, led to imitation of others' mannerisms. "I do not believe in models for imitations," says M. Coquerel. "No mirror can reflect an orator; look at yourself in a glass while you are reciting or extemporising, and you will no longer be yourself; the image will falsify the reality; the care of paving attention to yourself will take away all that is natural in your delivery, and you will see only a bad substitute for yourself." Indeed, imitation, as we all must know, is so akin to mimickry, that it is a disgraceful resort wholly unworthy of the dignity of Christian workmanship. According to Rapin, M. Amyrault, who spoke through his nose, had some very stupid imitators among certain students. Some of the characteristics of our successful and popular English preachers would scarcely bear imitation without ludicrous results. A very talented Congregational minister has the habit of springing up and down in the pulpit, and in the midst of really noble eloquence his body frequently gravitates towards the head of the unconscious clerk below. All eccentricities of manner should merely be looked upon as curiosities. Then, too, there is a bad habit of using imitative gestures, which in a person who is not essentially dramatic in delivery, is a grave defect. When a fact is simply put before a congregation, it requires no gesture to help to fasten it upon the attention. Monotony is seldom accompanied by a faithful government of the expressive movements of the body. On this point Coquerel observes:—"I knew a preacher who never commenced a phrase without passing into the falsetto; another who liked to quote the passage of Isaiah (ix. 6.), 'The government shall be upon his shoulder,' and never quoted it without putting his hand upon his own." Our author sums up strongly against allegorical preaching; but it is the distortion of Scripture that he evidently condemns most—the fictitious allegory, which is inexcusable, because the sacred books "abound in allegories, in apologues, in images of marvellous variety, richness, and beauty, and because an eloquence which has a liking for this kind of pictures has always this inexhaustible source at its discretion. A certain amount of inventiveness is allowable, and a fruitful imagination may draw striking teachings from the simplest incidents. Here is an exceedingly ingenious plan of a sermon, by Bouillier, upon the parable of the Hidden Treasure (Matt. xiii. 44); the fourth point will not, however, bear criticism:—
"1. The value of the doctrine of grace: it is a treasure.
"2. The little attention which is paid to it by the majority of men: it remains hid in a field.
"3. The goodness of God who grants it to us without any right, without any merit on our part: the man finds this treasure.
be allowed. The bare skeleton of a sermon is about the least important part to the hearer, he shuns it as he would the skeleton of a man. Let sermons be well clothed with living thought, and they will fasten themselves on the mind more surely than if the actual construction were vividly seen upon the first hearing. It is the thought which takes hold of the hearer; and the rest follows naturally. Of course, divisions must be resorted to, but they should all be suggested by the text. "Our friend Lazarus sleepeth; but I go that I may awake him out of sleep." Here, says Teissèdre l'Ange, "let us show in what respect we may call death a sleep; let us prove that this sleep will undoubtedly be followed by an awaking, and that it is necessary to be a friend to Jesus that this awaking be fortunate." M. Coquerel thinks the following to be a happy and fruitful division from a text, namely, "to lay down the problems the solutions of which it invites us to seek—to give the interrogative form to the thoughts which it suggests: the sermon and its different parts becomes the answer. By this method the ideas present themselves voluntarily." He gives Gen. ii. 17, "Thou shalt surely die," as an illustration. "Questions: Who pronounces this terrible sentence? Against whom is it uttered? What kind of death is spoken of? What is the moment of its execution? How can it be escaped?"
Everything depends upon the order, connection, and gradation of the ideas contained in a sermon. "The hearer," says Coquerel, should "always comprehend by what path he is being conducted," and from the commencement to the close of the discourse, he should be "led on without effort, by natural, easily managed transitions, from development to development, from exhortation to exhortation, until the end is reached." "Let any one represent a discourse," he continues to say with a grim smile, "proceeding in a sense the opposite of natural gradation: the exordium is full of vivacity and heat, the commencement or the entry into the subject is more calm; the end of the discourse is cold and languishes; the peroration is icy, and the sermon expires, like one of the lamps of the foolish virgins, for want of nourishment."
The age, it has been said again and again, does not want scholarship, but popular preaching. Truth to tell, it wants and demands both. The highest attainment of pulpit oratory is that which succeeds in combining both the intellectual and thoughtful with the essentially popular element. Divorce the two, and we have on one side, cold, calculating, critical, and lifeless preaching, and on the other side, the passionate twaddle which may tickle the senses, but will not profit the soul. The pulpit was not designed for the most exalted critics, but for those who can influence the heart and guide the actions aright. The truest inspiration from God is consecrated to the work of unfolding "the unsearchable riches of Christ." "The man who can gather numbers to hear the word of God," says a modern writer,* "and who by his appeals can arrest their attention, convince their judgment, stimulate their conscience, and quicken their whole spiritual being, is in the highest sense of the term, a great preacher." To which we should all heartily subscribe our emphatic "Amen."
EDWARD LEACH.
* British Quarterly Review.
