Avoiding Controversy — A Word For The Young Believer — A Conversation
A. Good morning, dear brother, I trust you are happy in soul to-day!
B. Thank you, not very, I am somewhat downcast and sad.
A. How is that?
B. Why, I last evening met with our acquaintance Mr. C., and he introduced his favourite theory about the future annihilation of the ungodly. Many of his arguments were such as I could not answer, and this disturbs my soul.
A. What! do you mean to say that he disproved the many plain passages of the word of God which distinctly assert that an eternity of conscious suffering awaits those who die unsaved?
B. By no means. I could have met him on that ground easily enough, but he hardly referred to the word of God at all. His arguments consisted of a number of philosophical questions which fairly baffled me, and when my mind was in a state of complete bewilderment, he enforced his ideas with a great deal of power.
A. You mean to say that he discussed a question which is one of pure revelation, and can only be decided by the declarations of the word of God, on philosophical instead of scriptural grounds; and you, being simply a plain Christian and not a philosopher, were unable to reply to his observations?
B. Just so; and when I managed to introduce a text, he refused to admit its force, because he said it was a mistranslation.
A. Your friend is, then, a scholar, I presume?
B. No; I believe that he does not understand Greek, but as I do not either, I could not contradict him. His main point seemed to be to prove that what I well knew to be the teaching of God's word, was inconsistent with the revealed character of God and the constitution of man, and therefore must be untrue; and he talked so fast, and I must say with so much ingenuity, that I could not refute his arguments at all.
A. And yet no amount of human reasoning will overthrow the plain declarations of the word of God! I am aware of the process by which persons like your friend, generally attempt to pervert simple-hearted Christians from the faith of the gospel. They assail the arguments by which the immortality of the soul is proved; they advance sceptical reflections on the revealed character of God; they quote the opinions of heathens, the fancies of poets, and the writings of philosophers; they appeal to the tender feelings of the human heart, and imply that these should be the standard by which we should judge the character of God; and then, when they have succeeded in baffling the believer, and perhaps have raised anxious doubts and surmisings in his heart, they boldly assert their erroneous views. The question, however, lies in a nutshell. It has nothing to do with metaphysics, but simply concerns the force and value of certain statements in the word of God. Had your friend's view been right, it would have sufficed to have quoted the texts that supported it; but Scripture, as he very well knows, does not bear him out, and hence he finds it needful to call in the aid of the
545
philosophical paradoxes you have mentioned. But Faith receives the record of God, however philosophy may object, human reason demur, or human sentimentality recoil from what is revealed.
B. I am convinced that you are right, and although I am unable to understand all that Mr. C. advanced, my soul is still resting on the declarations of the word of God. As to the eternal punishment of the unsaved, I am assured that God is love, and that the Judge of all the earth will do what is right.
A. I am glad to hear you speak thus, but permit me to say that I think that you did very wrongly in holding a conversation with Mr. C. on the subject. His talking about Greek to one who does not understand it, proves him to be a very pedantic person, especially as he knows nothing about it himself; and no doubt were his philosophical knowledge tested by a really well-read man, it would be found that with the exception of a few scraps and shreds of ill-digested learning, culled from some of the heretical trash that is now so common, his philosophical knowledge is not much more extensive than his acquaintance with Greek.
B. Perhaps so; but I could hardly refuse. He was so kind and sympathising at first, and introduced the subject so stealthily, that I was drawn into a discussion before I well knew what I was about. I knew not how to avoid it. What would you have done?
A. Well, we read of the sleight of men and cunning craftiness whereby they lie in wait to deceive, and your friend apparently affords an illustration of the text. For myself, if Mr. C. had accosted me ever so pleasantly, I should have simply wished him good evening, and passed on.
B. Would that have been kind, dear brother?
A. I am not in the habit of making the question of kindness a primary one. I am accustomed to seek to regulate my conduct in all respects according to the word of God, and I am there told "to mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine which we have learned; and to avoid them." (Romans xvi. 17.) In accordance with this precept, I should have refused to hold a conversation with such a person as Mr. C. His mind is made up on the question. I could have done him no good; and I value my own peace of soul too well to waste words with every crotchety individual who would like to argue with me. Thus my mind is rarely harassed as yours is this morning, and I have leisure of heart to pursue any little service for Jesus that lies before me.
B. But Mr. C. is really a good man, I believe; is it not ill-natured to refuse all fellowship with him? Besides, we are to prove all things, you know!
A. That we are to prove all things I admit, but by this I understand that we are to test all that we hold by the unerring testimony of the word. We shall thus be able with meekness and fear to give a reason for the hope that is in us; but it surely does not mean that we am to DIS-prove the erroneous views of every crack-brained enthusiast who crosses our path. Why, we should never have time for anything else. As to your friend's goodness, I would caution you against being led astray by mere human morality. Error is never so dangerous as when held by good people—this the enemy well knows, and in these days especially, he has many such among his most energetic
36
servants. A sword in a child's hand does little mischief: when held by a strong man it becomes formidable. Had not the prophet in 1 Kings xiii. been a good man, the man of God would never have been induced to listen to his utterances. Beware of error when made attractive by creature amiability. Even if an angel from heaven contradict the truth of God, let him be accursed. Who are better men individually than the Plymouth Brethren, but who more dangerous in the church? By-the-bye, is it true that you were once led astray by their sophistries, too?
B. Yes. A little tract fell into my hands condemning the one-man ministry, as it styled the pastoral office, accusing us of setting aside the Holy Spirit, and repressing his gifts in the church. Then I met with one of their number who continually engaged me in conversation on the subject, and enjoined me to cease to do evil, to come out of Babylon, that I might not be a partaker of her plagues, to take my cross, to follow the despised and rejected One without the camp, and so on. At last he fairly frightened me into a determination to leave our chapel.
A. What a wicked perversion of Scripture! but what did you do?
B. Why, I went at last to our pastor, feeling that I was doing something perfectly heroic, which would entitle me to the reputation of a martyr to the truth.
A. Did he receive you kindly?
B. Extremely so. He merely told me that as these views were new to me I might possibly be mistaken, and suggested that I should write out in full all the texts which convinced me of my three opinions that his position was an unscriptural one, that the Holy Spirit was really quenched in our services, and that I was doing evil by continuing in my present position.
A. How many did you find?
B. NOT ONE. I found that I had been misled by a number of unscriptural assertions and semi-scriptural inferences; but that Brethrenism, as a system, has not one plain text on which to rest. It is true there is much coldness and evil among us; but that is simply saying that the flesh is in us still, while there are far worse evils among the Plymouthites, in spite of the loud professions of their practical separation from evil.
A. I suppose that you were unsettled for some time through this!
B. Yes, for many months. In fact, I gave up my Sunday-school class, and quite left off preaching with the other young men, and I grieve to say that when any of them spoke to me I was very cold and distant, so proud did my fancied light make me.
A. Yes, it is just by appealing to our conceit that Brethrenism makes its way. How thankful you ought to be that you were not so terribly misled!
B. Indeed, I am, but the person to whom I referred was so kind and gentlemanly, and appeared so solicitous for my spiritual welfare, that I could not mistrust anything he said.
A. No doubt. Satan baited his hook cleverly in trying to spoil you by philosophy and vain deceit after the traditions of men. A soft manner, a winning smile, great apparent sanctity, and interest in one's welfare, will make any lie go down with some people; and with such an introduction a book is read without suspicion, as though all must be
547
true which so good a man recommends. Do you know what I should do with a book intended to unsettle my mind?
B. What?
A. I should put it quietly behind the fire, and tell the individual who presented it, that as long as there was a God to be served, souls to be won, and a heaven to be obtained, I had no time to waste in anything of the kind. A man who is radically unsound is to be avoided. In a great house are vessels to dishonour—namely, in the professing church are many God-dishonouring men, such as those of whom we have been speaking. If you get mixed up with them, they will surely interfere with your usefulness, while "If a man therefore purge himself from these, he shall be a vessel unto honour, sanctified, and meet for the Master's use, and prepared unto every good work." (2 Timothy ii. 21.) Happily there are plenty of sound and sensible believers who will be glad to fraternise with true-hearted Christians. Such, and such only, should be sought as companions. Younger members of our churches, and those especially who, like yourself, are a little sensitive and apt to be led astray, should beware of the many deceivers who are to be found on every hand. Let them keep to the footsteps of the flock. Let them shun unsound or even doubtful literature; and as to the herd of wrangling Arminians, P. B's. (excuse the abbreviation), and half christianised infidels who abound—our course is clear, "mark them," "avoid them." In these days, it is one of the enemy's great snares to seek to keep those who might do good service for Jesus in a perpetual ferment through controversies on foolish and unlearned questions. Let us, dear brother, hold fast "the form of sound words," and seek to have at all times some good work in hand. Oh, for a passion for souls! Oh, for a tender heart towards the people of God! Let us seek grace to serve our generation; and while others are tossed about by every wind of doctrine, and fritter away precious time in unprofitable discussions that merely minister to their own pride, may we seek to make his words our motto who said, "For me to live is Christ."
W. J. STYLES.
Lower Holloway.
