Joseph of Arimathea — By Wildon Carr, Newcastle-On-Tyne
AGAIN and again had our most blessed Lord forewarned his disciples of his death. "The Son of man shall be betrayed into the hands of sinners." With terrible reality the prediction had been fulfilled. He had been in the hands of the chief priests and scribes—the council of the nation—and they condemned him to death. He had then been delivered into the hands of the Gentiles, and they had mocked him, scourged him, crucified him. In very deed he was in the hands of the wicked, and they did to him whatsoever they listed. Say, "It was for less than eighteen hours;" those eighteen hours appear like an eternity in the volume of their incident, and the magnitude of their consequences. Yet was it but a small moment that the Father hid his face, that the Son was forsaken! It is finished! He has yielded up his spirit into the Father's hands: his body must not remain in the hands of sinners any longer. That precious body of Jesus must be recovered before sunset. Forthwith it is transferred into other hands. Faithful friends and fond women have got possession of that sweet corpse, all cold, pale, mangled, bruised as it is. The last dishonour has been done to it. No sooner, therefore, has the expiring cry of the sufferer been uttered, than the body, or ever it was taken down from the cross, is demanded by and conceded to one of our Lord's disciples. Joseph of Arimathea is the person whose name for a few hours occupies the most distinguished place in gospel history. It was he who went in boldly unto Pilate, craved the body, brought it away, wrapped it in fine linen, and provided the sepulchre in which it was entombed. The incident is so touching, the reference to Joseph so pointed, that we may linger upon the sacred episode a little while with pleasure as well as profit.
Who was this Joseph of Arimathea? Has full justice ever been done to his character? The name "Joseph," has a positive charm about it, since the memory of worthy men has made it fragrant. That patriarch to whom it was first given, bequeathed it to posterity with unblemished lustre. In the life-story of Jesus of Nazareth, this name "Joseph," holds an interesting, though a subordinate place. One Joseph superintended his birth, and another Joseph was found to superintend his burial. "There is many a gem in earth and sea," said Bishop Hall, "that never greets the eye." These Josephs, however, were brought up out of obscurity to sparkle with chaste and delicate purity. It is worthy of notice, that each of the four evangelists has in similar and corresponding terms, albeit with a graceful variety, drawn our attention to Joseph of Arimathea. He is mentioned with honour by them all. Matthew unequivocally tells us that he was "a disciple of Jesus." Mark says, that "he waited for the kingdom of God." Luke bears witness that "he was a good man and just." John affirms that "he was a disciple of Jesus;" but then he adds some significant words, "secretly for fear of the Jews." This little parenthesis appears to have thrown a shade over his reputation, otherwise without a flaw, at least among commentators, who, in their zeal to draw truthful portraits,
247
have habitually given singular prominence to anything that looks like a scar upon the face of any one of the saints. Let us with the independence of thought that becomes us, take the general fashion of his character first, and we shall be better able to judge of other matters afterwards.
"He was a disciple of Jesus." This he could not have been had he not been a believer. His heart must have been true, or the Holy Spirit would not have inspired so decided an acknowledgment of him. A disciple is one whose faith rests upon Jesus with a far higher motive than a mere perception of his moral excellencies. The essential dignity of his Person, and the special mission which, as the Christ, the anointed of God, he had received from the Father, must have entered into the profoundest convictions of the man's soul before he could be accounted a disciple. We will not at present ask how much he knew, for he was, as the designation implies, a learner; but he could not be that, if he did not apprehend the right of Jesus to teach with authority, and the duty of all who heard him to accept with implicit confidence every sentence that fell from his lips. As a disciple, he must have owned Jesus as his "Lord," and placed his mind in subjection to learn of him. Nor is this all. He had made an open profession of his allegiance to Christ; otherwise, it were impossible that he could, in the proper evangelical sense of the word, be a disciple. This admits of no exception; we have never heard of a case in which any man was called a disciple by Jesus against his own will. The Roman Catholics may now and then claim that such-and-such a man of note became a pervert of theirs in his dying moments, when he was too exhausted to speak other than a whisper in the priest's ear; but such a proceeding at any time is suspicious; and as for the nature of a good confession, it must be bold and unequivocal to give it any value. The evangelist Matthew tells us that Joseph of Arimathea was a disciple of Jesus, and the same evangelist tells us the absolute rule that Jesus himself laid down on the subject of discipleship: "Whosoever therefore shall confess me before men, him will I confess also before my Father which is in heaven. But whosoever shall deny me before men, him will I also deny before my Father which is in heaven." Matt. x. 32. The infraction of this law would involve such an anomaly, that nought but itself could be its parallel. To wit, John the Baptist had disciples. The question may arise, "Was Herod, the Tetrarch, one of John's disciples?" We should marvel at the man who answered, "Yes." Yet the evidence in favour of such a conclusion is so strong, that it is unassailable on every point but one—he never professed to be. "Herod feared John, knowing that he was a just man and a holy, and observed him; and when he heard him, he did many things, and heard him gladly." Mark vi. 20. So Herod believed in John's holiness; he was a hearer of John; he did many things John told him; and took a pleasure in John's ministry. This was no secret, but thoroughly open to public observation. Did all these things put together make him a disciple, seeing he never professed or made a formal avowment? I trow not.
Joseph of Arimathea was a disciple of Jesus; and therefore our Lord must have known him, and admitted him to private intercourse with himself. It were outrageous to suppose that hearing rumours about
Christ, or standing in coq.—unrecognised by the crowd—or saying confidentially to a private friend, that he had the highest possible opinion of Jesus of Nazareth, would have constituted him a disciple; more particularly when the distinction it implies was so honourable that it was often courted by those on whom it was not bestowed. “Whosoever,” said Jesus, “doth not bear his cross, and come after me, cannot be my disciple.” The privilege had been little worth aspiring after did it not bring the possessor into the company and companionship of our blessed Lord. And apart from all inference or argument, the impression produced on our minds by the record of evangelists is, that Joseph was well known to them as one of their own number. When they tell of one Simon, a Cyrenian, who bore the Saviour’s cross, they speak of him as a stranger; but when Joseph of Arimathea obtains possession of the sacred body, they speak of him as an acquaintance, not better known than trusted and honourably esteemed among them. The Marys, who watched the proceedings intently, did not look at him with suspicion, and say, “Who is that strange man that has just come from Pilate, with a Roman officer, to take the body down from the cross?” No. They knew him well; they did not wait for an invitation to come into his house and gaze on the dear disfigured body, or to go into the garden that was Joseph’s private property, or to sit down by the sepulchre, or to stay in the garden after Joseph had left it. Joseph of Arimathea was a disciple of Jesus—I am sure he was; as true-hearted a man as ever bore the name of Christian.
This Joseph was one “who also himself waited for the kingdom of God.” Both Mark and Luke tell us this. Does not such a statement at once identify him with those devout persons in Judea, who, like Simeon and Anna, were looking for the Saviour, and prepared to welcome him at the time of his advent? The testimony is very emphatic. It is much the same as though in our days one should ask us if a certain nobleman is a believer? and we should answer, “Indeed he is; his sentiments are thoroughly evangelical, and he holds millenarian views.” We have no reason to think that Joseph had been converted during the period of our Lord’s three years’ public ministry. He was a saint before that; one of those saints who so happily connect the two economies, and practically illustrate the identity of the covenant of grace, and the identity of the church of God, notwithstanding the difference of dispensations. An intense believer in the Messiah; a diligent student of prophecy; one who waited for the consolation of Israel; “an Israelite indeed, in whom there was no guile;” his faith had a deeper root and a more intelligent apprehension (as we shall presently see) than ever was, or probably than could have been, acquired by standing amongst a throng of people and observing the miracles that Jesus wrought among unbelievers. He was enlightened, not by any revelation immediately made to himself, but by a knowledge of those Scriptures that Daniel studied, to look beyond the earthly polity of the Jewish nation, of which he was a patriotic upholder, for the kingdom of God which is to be established in righteousness and true holiness. In Jesus he discerned the rightful heir, the Son, to whom the Father had said, “Thy throne, O God, is for ever and ever: a sceptre of righteousness is the sceptre of thy kingdom.”
249
We are heartily glad there were such men. Had there been none of this class at the time of the incarnation, we might have doubted whether Samuel, or David, or Isaiah, would have recognised Jesus as the Messiah, in the case of his having been born at Bethlehem in their days. Now we know they would. The light of prophecy was sufficient where the hearts of men were true, and their enquiry diligent.
The same Joseph was a good man and just. This is Luke's commendation, and it is expressive of a beautiful eulogy both on his private and public character. "A good man," according to the common phraseology of Scripture, means a kind, gentle, merciful, benevolent individual—one whose heart was generous, and his manners amiable. He was "just" likewise; perfectly clear, in his official position, from those violations of equity, under the pretence of administering law, which disgraced the Jewish rulers of those days. If he did make long prayers, he certainly did not devour widows' houses. His reputation was untarnished by a single mean, base, knavish transaction. Thank God that the race of merciful upright men is not extinct! Their goodness adorns any home, and their justness is like burnished gold at the magistrates' table or on the bench of judges.
We have carefully observed the description that the three evangelists (or as our German brethren would say, the synoptical evangelists), give of Joseph. It will now be requisite to examine the latest gospel, that of John. He concurs with Matthew in pronouncing him "a disciple of Jesus." Yet he is generally supposed to have qualified this praise with the notice of a serious blemish. His words, as we are wont to read them, are "but secretly for fear of the Jews." Nor dare we contradict that this is a fair translation of the Greek κεκρυμμένος δὲ διὰ τὸν φόβον τῶν Ἰουδαίων. We do, however, humbly submit that the words are capable of another meaning; that while philology might have rested content, if there were no other gospel than John's, history demands a revision, and the original Greek is capable of yielding gracefully to the necessity of the case. We will address ourselves to the mother tongue first, and then we will produce our strong reasons from the coherency of the whole narrative. "Secrecy" and "fear," are the two matters in question; howbeit "secrecy" is not always clandestine, and "fear" is sometimes applied to a disposition that is neither base nor effeminate. We have met with learned lexicographers who presumed to think that the life of believers was hid with Christ in God, and the manna was hidden in the heavenly temple, rather as precious treasures are kept in reserve, than as pilfered goods are stowed away out of sight, and yet in both these passages the same word κρυπτω is employed. We have known apostles inculcate "fear," φοβος, as a grace worthy of Christian emulation. Paul, to wit, has admonished us to "render to all their dues, tribute to whom tribute, custom to whom custom, fear to whom fear, honour to whom honour." This is precisely what we suppose Joseph of Arimathea did. Peter offers similar counsel when he admonishes "servants to be subject to their masters with all fear," and wives to be in subjection to their own husbands, even if they did not obey the word, and to show chaste conversation, coupled with "fear"—the same sort of fear, as we conjecture, that Joseph had among the Jews. It may, however, be proven beyond conjecture, that this is the true and the
only true consideration, which with the least colour of integrity can be put on John's meaning.
Let us now address ourselves to the patent facts. There are three things that John does not mention which the other evangelists have severally recorded; and there is one thing which John supplies us with in lieu of their information. They state the circumstances, while he, writing many years afterwards, an argumentative gospel, states the consequence of those circumstances. Matthew tells us that he was "a rich man." Mark tells us that he was "an honourable counsellor." Luke gives us to understand that he was one of the Sanhedrim: "The same had not consented to the counsel and deed of them" that condemned Christ. Now what does John say to all this? Why; he tells us that he was "reserved" in his deportment, as gentlemen holding office generally are; and that he "feared," held in respect and reverence the Jews, as it was admirably becoming that he should. If John's remark implies a slur, the whole narrative is thrown into wild confusion. If, on the other hand, it is intended to interpret the history, nothing he could have said would have put it in a clearer light. Considering what we know of Joseph's character as a Christian, the slightest timidity would have been irreconcilable with it. Taking into account what we know of him as a man of some distinction in Jerusalem at that time, we should anticipate rather more polish and refinement in his demeanour than was ordinarily found among the Galileans. It will do us good to study these incidentals. What is it to be a gentleman, or more particularly, a Christian gentleman, such as we take Joseph of Arimathea to have been? Birth, education, taste, and self-control, all have a bearing in that direction. Joseph was a man of property, most probably inherited from his ancestors. It is not likely he had acquired it as Zaccheus did his, out of the degradation of his country; or as pawnbrokers sometimes grow rich, out of other people's poverty; or as knavish speculators of these days do, when trading on the depreciation of commercial securities. He was of Arimathea, and he had derived good breeding as well as landed estates from his parents. Brought up as a counsellor, he must have been a man of education—not only a student of books, but a companion of scholars—acquiring with knowledge those proprieties of behaviour which enable a man to acquit himself civilly, even in the presence of those with whom he has little or no sympathy. Evidently he was a man of good abilities, so that, apart from his holding strong views in opposition to the council, he won the respect of those chief priests and scribes who sneered at his religious sentiments. Habituated to self-control, when it was wise to be silent, he could hold his peace; when it was prudent to let his actions speak, he could make a minority respectable; and when it was important to show energy, he was the very man for a crisis. As such, John has touched the vital point when he says, "A disciple of Jesus, but a reserved man in deference to the Jews."
Not as a disciple of Jesus, but as one of the Sanhedrim, he went in to Pilate, and, in his official capacity, demanded the body of a Jewish prisoner, who had just been executed by Gentile authority. Yet, as a disciple of Jesus, not as one of the Sanhedrim, he brought that holy body into his house, carried it into his garden, and interred it in his own tomb.
This part of the story is of importance. The character of Joseph is
251
interpreted by it, while it serves in turn to make the history transparent. Counsellor Joseph goes in boldly to Pilate, with the confidence of office, to make a formal application for the body. Pilate looks astonished at first, having only a few hours before sanctioned the execution; and asks, with evident surprise, if he is already dead. In fact, he calls the centurion to certify it. On the centurion's assurance, he makes no demur whatever. Knowing Joseph well, as a leading man among the Jews, and as a renowned lawyer, not likely to be faulty in any question of legal forms, he gives the order without hesitation. Of course, Pilate was not likely to be acquainted with any of Joseph's nicer points of religious peculiarity. His public character was sufficient for all the purposes.
A richer meditation awaits us. The entombment of Jesus is not to be overlooked, though it does appear but as a brief episode in the gospel narrative. We had never heard of Joseph but for the tenderness of his feelings, the promptness of his action, and the generosity of his conduct on that sad and doleful evening. Yet, when the trouble of that hour has passed away, without leaving a trace behind, the memorial of him abides—the virtue of his deed has an immortal fragrance. There appears no reason to suppose that the substantial confidence he reposed in Jesus had received so great a shock, or that his mind was in such a state of morbid distraction, as other disciples too palpably exhibited his whole conduct was consistent with a thorough self-possession. Is not this exactly what we might have expected of him? While they, who had been drawn very much by sensible evidences, were endeavouring to live by their own experience, and alternating with the flush or chill that every fresh occurrence occasioned them, he was steadfast in the faith, as one who had long cherished the most enlightened views of the kingdom of God. Not indeed that he had shuddered less feelingly at the terrible crime of the nation he loved; nor yet that he had mourned less tenderly the sorrows and the sufferings of the Son of man; but that he saw more clearly the course by which the Messiah must enter the kingdom. He loses not a moment in that awful juncture. The body of Jesus of Nazareth is to be esteemed beyond the remains of murdered innocence. It is "God's Holy One," which shall not see corruption. The method of God's providence is wonderful. It is much to be suspected that no unholy hands even so much as touched "the Holy One" after his last cry. Mark has recorded the conversion of the centurion who "saw that he so cried out, and gave up the ghost;" has informed us that he there and then confessed the highest article of the Christian faith, saying, "Truly this man was the Son of God;" and has apprised us that this was the very man whom Pilate unwittingly called to him to ask if he were already dead. We can hardly credit it that other hands than those of Joseph and this centurion were engaged in lifting Jesus down from the cross. But the manner of Joseph's proceeding challenges our notice. When he obtained Pilate's leave to take possession of the body, it still hung on that gibbet as he had died. He did not go off in unseemly haste to Calvary, but he deliberately went out from the governor's presence, entered a shop, and made a purchase of fine linen (Mark xv. 46); then, as he took the body down, he wrapped it in the linen, as befitted its holiness. Linen is the proper vestment of
the holy. It is always so spoken of in the Scriptures both of the Old and the New Testament. There is no exception to this, unless it be the yarn that Solomon imported out of Egypt (1 Kings x. 28), or the clothing of the rich man, at whose gate poor Lazarus lay; and even in this latter instance "the fine linen" of his apparel was sanctimonious. Nicodemus came with his spices to preserve the body; but Nicodemus had not half so much faith as Joseph. That sweet incorruptible body needed no embalming. Joseph knew this. He understood that the linen ephod was that which became it most. Precious faith!
There is a moral that rises to the surface and challenges our notice. It is not altogether unimportant to the formation of Christian character, or the extension of Christian service, upon what particular doctrines of God's covenant the anchor of our faith grips. Our vessels are sure to heave and undulate violently in a storm, if we have no better grapnel than our own experience to steady us. We can see at a glance that Joseph's hope had a holdfast within the veil, for he was waiting for the kingdom of God. This was very different from the two disciples who were journeying to Emmaus, with nothing else to talk about but "the things which had come to pass in Jerusalem in these days." From stem to stern their vessel is tossing up and down. "We trusted that it had been he which should have redeemed Israel." Then they told "what certain women said;" what "astonishment some of our company felt;" what "visions of angels had been seen, and what they were reported to have said." This was the kind of conversation with which they entertained the Lord. How should he reply but with rebuke? "O fools, and slow of heart to believe all that the prophets have spoken!" Take your cue from the Scriptures of truth, rather than from the best authenticated narrative of your own times. If this were wise for them, how much more for us? That was the kind or degree of faith Joseph possessed. The sure word of prophecy cheered him; current events could not disconcert him.
With exquisite brevity the burial is described. Three things Joseph did: "He laid the body in his own new tomb, which he had hewn out in the rocks;" "He rolled a great stone to the door of the sepulchre;" "He departed."
What a providence that the tomb was ready, and that it should be of exactly the description which prophecy had foretold! How simple the ceremony! Joseph made it secure, but it was with a rolling stone. Thought he, mayhap, "There lodge, sweet corpse, thou wilt not need the apartments long!" "And he departed." His faith had cast out all tormenting fear. He will leave it to the Marys to sit brooding over their own feelings, and watching the sepulchre, while the pale moon-beams flicker in that sequestered garden. He will leave it to the qualms of guilty conscience which harass those scrupulous Jews, to break their Sabbath in order to affix a seal on the stone, and petition for a Roman guard to keep it safe. He departed—this Joseph of Arimathea; he performed his good office and went away. Not stoically, not with an air of indifference has he left. The night draws on: the Sabbath begins. He has gone home to turn over that well-thumbed roll of the volume of the book in which it is written concerning him, "Thou wilt not leave my soul in hell; neither wilt thou suffer thine Holy One
253
to see corruption." He pursues his course with fresh light on his path, waiting for, and hastening unto, the kingdom of God. His name is embalmed among us. We may rightly feel jealous of a speck on his reputation. The next time we see him, peradventure, he will be mounted on a white horse, following his Lord, himself clothed in fine linen, white and clean. Rev. xix. 14.
It is not without a thrill of pleasure that we make the acquaintance of so fine a specimen of the old Hebrew aristocracy; perhaps about the last of the race, one who retained his deep attachment to the nation, while he embraced with the most ardent affection the great Saviour who had come to be a light to lighten the Gentiles, and afterwards to be the glory of his people Israel. Do not let us be surprised that his name never afterwards occurs in the New Testament. Enough, that his portrait should be taken and hung up conspicuously in its best apartment. In the spread of the gospel, rougher instruments will do the work more effectively. The refinement of his mind, the polish of his manners, the retired studiousness of his personal habits, while qualifying him for one sphere, would disqualify him for another. Thus much, and he is entitled to all our esteem and our affection: he was a disciple of Jesus, "an honourable counsellor," and he also "waited for the kingdom of God."
