Menu
‹ Chapter 28 of 217 ›

Homewards or Homewards?

19 min read · Chapter 28 of 217

"Quid Rome faciam?—Mentiri nescio."

"What can I do at Rome? I know not how to lie"

BELIEVING as I do that the subtle spirit of idolatry is inherent in man's corrupt nature, and develops itself in a thousand unexpected and often seemingly harmless forms, I venture to think that a fragment of the practical experience of one who has made the journey to Rome and back may serve as a beacon to others. This is my solo motive in publishing this morsel of otherwise uninteresting autobiography.

I was brought up in the straitest sect of Anglicanism. My father was and is one of the most eminent of the clergy of the Church of England. He belongs to the school vulgarly called the High and Dry, i. e. he is equally hostile to all out of the pale of the Establishment, and claims for the Church of England the same authority which Romanists used to claim for the Pope in a general council, and which Romanists nowadays claim for the Pope alone.

* Our contributor has sent us his name and address as a token of good faith. We translate the classical expressions for the benefit of the unlettered reader.

My earliest impression of religion was unmitigated dulness. Family prayers (extracts from the Book of Common Prayer) were duly gabbled over morning and evening, and the result of them was about as effectual as that of water poured upon a duck's back. On Sundays there were the usual two or three services. I remember to this day the great red-lined square pew, on the seat of which I was perched in petticoats and frilled trousers, and "called upon" as a "regenerate" child "to hear sermons" which went in at one ear and out at the other. There was not much Romanizing in those days. Puseyism, now so healthy and rampant, was then in its infancy, and the swarms of ritualists who now darken the face of England were in petticoats and frilled trousers like myself. So the congregation, consisting of what Sydney Smith called "comfortable sinners," used first to sing—

"Awake my soul, and with the sun

Thy daily stage of duty run,

Shake off dull sloth and early rise

To pay thy morning sacrifice,"

it being then noon. Then the service, or rather the three services dragged their slow length along, recited as a duet between the curate and the clerk, accompanied by a devout buzz on the part of the people. And then the venerable white-haired rector mounted the lofty bema and droned away page after page for an hour and more, and the great clock in the tower chimed each quarter musical and slow, till the image of the old gentleman seemed to me to fade away in the sunlight as in a halo of glory, and his somnific tones and still more somnific matter had lulled even his older hearers into a pious trance—dulcis et alta quies, placidæque simillima morti.*

It was my boyish ambition to be a soldier. But my father had strong views about soldiers. He would never, he said, allow his son to be "a licensed cut-throat." I was to be "educated for the Church;" and after four years at a public school and working my way to the head of the sixth form, I went up to Oxford and was matriculated as commoner of St. Magnus, where I soon after gained the senior scholarship of the year.

At Oxford I passed four years, intellectually the most precious, morally the most worthless of my life. Gibbon says, he left Oxford with an amount of learning which might have puzzled a doctor, and a degree of ignorance of which a schoolboy would have been ashamed. For my part, I can honestly say, that I imbibed there the morality as well as the philosophy of the Pagan world. There were no economical undergraduates in those days. People who could not afford it, no more thought of sending their sons to Oxford than they now think of sending them into the Guards. None of us knew or cared to know what perquisites the butler or the manciple enjoyed. We should as soon have thought of looking after the morals of our private servants. We never quarrelled with our bread and butter nor with those who spread it. One stingy peer, whose enormous rent-roll made him more sensitive in money matters than the rest of us, did indeed once upon a time complain to the Head of the college, because on coming in late and being unable to get anything but mutton chops, he found them

* "A sweet and deep repose, and very like peaceful death."

69

afterwards charged in his kitchen bill as a regular dinner. But he was soon taught not to speak evil of the powers below. "Well, sir," said the Head, "all I can say is, I hope it may be the last time I shall hear of a nobleman of my college dining on chops." Our stately chef de cuisine, in his snow-white cap and apron, would have fainted at the odious imputation of such rapacity as has recently been attributed to menials of his rank in the columns of the "Times." He used to drive into Oxford from his villa in a brougham and pair, and had one daughter who was an heiress, and afterwards married a curate. Capital dinners he gave us, and if there ever came a dish into hall ill-cooked, it was the duty of the steward of that table to summon the chef into his presence and solemnly fine him a guinea, which he paid next day to the Bursar with touching resignation. He was indeed an artiste, and knew what was due to the dignity of his profession.

But I digress. Every college has its speciality. Who does not know, for instance, how inferior socially are the St. Chad's men? It was the speciality of the St. Magnus' men to do everything. Hunting, rowing, tennis, racquets, fives, billiards, pool, cricket, sparring, steeple-chasing, nothing came amiss to them. They all drank deep, and some of them read hard — in the vacations. Dons of other colleges would wonder how it was so many of the St. Magnus' men, myself amongst them, ever took a "first" in the schools; and when such dissipated reprobates found time to read. Like the Athenians of the time of Pericles, we piqued ourselves on our supremacy. Of course we were freethinkers. Such admirable Crichtons could scarcely be expected to become as little children. We no more believed Christianity than Cicero believed in the pecking of the sacred chickens. Indeed, if we had been ever so disposed to believe, our faith must have succumbed to a series of "university sermons," so ordered that the sermon of the afternoon should refute or neutralize the sermon of the morning; for while the "select preacher" on Sunday morning would be a Tractarian, the "select preacher" on Sunday afternoon would probably be a Neologist. Few of us at our tender age could have kept the faith like that old Bedell at Cambridge, who exclaimed on his death-bed, "Well, I have heard every university sermon for the last five and thirty years, and thank God I still die a Christian." As it was, we were a law unto ourselves, and indulged everything not contrary to our own canons of taste and our own code of honour.

Such was my training for the ministry. I was ordained first deacon, and then priest, by the Right Rev. Dr. Silvertongue, Bishop of Snorem. His Lordship, as is well known, is a High Churchman—quite as "high" as it is "safe" for a bishop to be. As one of the candidates kindly warned me, "Mind you stick up for Baptismal Regeneration, and quote old Snorem's book on it if you can." Fortunately I had read that work, and had the satisfaction of coming in third out of eighteen. But I fancy I hear some one say, "What a scapegrace you must have been to profess and preach what you did not believe!" Verily I was—but let those who know the world decide whether I am a solitary example.

"My dear Mr. Smith," said the Bishop of Snorem to a curate of the "muscular Christianity" school, whose licence he had revoked, "I am

so shocked to hear that you question the doctrine of the apostolic succession. I cannot tell you, my dear sir, what pain this has given me. I never doubted it myself, never."

"Your Lordship must remember," said Mr. Smith, who meant to give up the Church and go to the bar, "your Lordship must remember that you believe at the rate of £10,000 a-year. I only believe at the rate of £80."

The truth is, you may bring up a child to profess anything, and as a man he will continue to profess it, if it be his interest to do so, so long as self-interest is dearer to him than truth. Men are not all impostors who do this—some are no doubt; but to most men self-interest blinds the eyes, and they mistake their own party and their own principles for divine truth. Orthodoxy is their doxy, heterodoxy is other people's doxy. I am not excusing myself: I was a sceptic in the proper sense of the word, as I fancy are most of the men (I mean the laymen) of this age. They do not deny or deride, they simply, and with all respect, doubt whether this or that is true or false. "What is truth?" is emphatically the motto of the nineteenth century.

Veiling then my scepticism in surplice, hood and stole, I entered on my duties as curate of the parish of Puddletown. My rector, the Rev. Ambrose Pyx was a Tractarian, or as he was pleased to say a "Catholic." He used to wear a crucifix round his neck, and go about the parish in a long black cloth cassock, and a college cap or a priest's beretta. I need not say that there were daily "Matins and Evensong," "early and mid-day celebrations of the Holy Sacrifice" every Sunday, "candles on the altar," and a "surpliced choir." The Rev. Ambrose was the squire's eldest son, and had held the living ten years. The population was agricultural, and hated the new-fangled ritual from their souls. But they dared not avow such treason. The farmers put in an appearance on Sunday morning, having an eye to business with the future squire, and the poor came just as often as was absolutely necessary to get their share of the "sacrament money" and the Christmas dole. But when the rector was sitting over his port after dinner, the whole parish might have been seen on the road to Hopetown, flocking to hear the gospel preached in the Baptist Chapel. He never knew it. All he knew was, that he was making no way himself. He told me candidly he did not believe that in all those ten years he had made one genuine convert. By this time I doubt not the Rev. Ambrose Pyx has bloomed into cope and anice, dalmatica and chasuble, amid clouds of incense. Or perhaps he too has crossed the Rubicon, if the £1,800 a-year has not proved too heavy a weight for so long a journey. "Linquenda tellus et domus*" is a hard necessity, and if he became a priest, 'twere harder still to bid his "placens uxor†" get her to a nunnery.

At Puddletown, I tried to cure myself of my scepticism. Phrenologists tell me there is a hollow in my head where the bump of veneration ought to be. I took to reading the Fathers. Many a dreary tome of bad Latin and worse Greek has it been my lot to wade through. Next I came to the schoolmen, and speculated with Thomas Aquinas

* "To have to leave glebe and rectory."

† "Charming wife."

71

how many angels could balance themselves on the point of a needle. Then I came to Bossuet and the Gallican writers, and last to the modern Romanists with their all-explaining theory of papal infallibility. And all this long array told me I was out of the true Church, not in communion with Peter, and consequently out of the pale of salvation.

I began to think it must be so. That would be a satisfactory solution of all my difficulties. That would explain why I had never felt saving grace. Perhaps I had not been baptized properly. Perhaps the officiating minister had only favoured me with aspersion, only sprinkled my forehead instead of washing it, or used his forefinger when he should have used his thumb. You smile, reader; so do I now, but at the time I can tell you it was no smiling matter. Anyhow I could not long have continued to minister in the Church of England. I have said I was a sceptic, and no man can go on preaching and officiating as a clergyman unless he is either a believer in his Church or an infidel. He must face questions which never occur to a layman, or which, if they do occur, a layman can put aside.

I went abroad to Belgium to see the Roman Catholic system under its most favourable aspect. I had already seen it in Spain, the most Catholic country in Europe, under an aspect very unfavourable, but at a time when I cared for none of these things. It was a case of "advise me to marry Tam Glen." I was "received" at Brussels by the "Apostolic Nuncio."

Full soon the disenchantment began. I found that the practical system of the Roman Catholic Church and the theoretical Catholicism of Bossuet's "Exposition" were widely different. I found a religion nominally Christian, really Marian. I distinctly assert that the charge of idolatry which Protestants impute to the Roman Catholic Church, however it may have been at times illogically or extravagantly urged, is well founded. Catholic controversialists define latria to be the supreme worship due to God alone, dulia to be the inferior worship due to saints, and hyperdulia to be the worship due to the blessed Virgin Mary. It is also held that relative worship may be offered to a sensible object, e.g., a crucifix or a chemise, of the same kind as that offered to the person whom it represents. Thus in the office for Good Friday, the priest holding up the wood of the "True Cross," says, "Ecco lignum crucis!" And the choir respond "Venite adoremus." Such, I presume, was the worship of the brazen serpent and the golden calf.

Now I maintain first, that in practice even learned men cannot distinguish between the three, and that ignorant people, i. e., the majority of mankind cannot distinguish them even in theory. I have known many Roman Catholics whose only daily prayer was the Litany of Loretto, and seen many reciting the "chaplet," even during Mass. I have heard the late Father Faber call Mary our "Co-Redemptress," and inform his hearers, that "it was revealed to St. Ignatius (Loyola), at Mass, what part of the Host belonged to Mary and what part to Christ." It would be a nice question whether the segment of the consecrated wafer which belonged to Mary should receive latria or hyperdulia.

I should fatigue the reader's patience if I were to multiply evidence of the fact that the devout Roman Catholic trusts mainly, if not solely,

in her, to whom he often dedicates his children, and whom he always invokes with his last breath as his saviour in the hour of death, and in the day of judgment. One such book as the "Glories of Mary," or, "Buonaventura's Psalter," stamped with the imprimatur of authority, affords evidence more valuable than aught which I can allege. Nor shall I dwell upon the worship offered to Mary's images: the image itself must be the object of worship where, as in the case of the Vierges Miraculeuses of Belgium, our Lady of Antwerp has one prerogative, and our Black Lady of Liège another. Every Christian who is not cursed with a "strong delusion so as to believe a lie," must surely feel that if St. Peter or St. Paul were to rise from the dead, and enter a Church where a crowd of people were kneeling before a doll in crinoline and coronation robes, the first impulse of the apostle would be to break the idol in pieces before the Lord, and his next to preach Christ to the congregation.

I restrict myself to the statement that the Roman Catholic Church practises and patronises what the Bible forbids, the worship of the creature. Worship is the exclusive prerogative of Almighty God. This can never be too often repeated or too strongly affirmed. "Let no man beguile you of your reward in a voluntary humility and worshipping of angels, intruding into those things which he has not seen, vainly puffed up by his fleshly mind, and not holding the Head." All secondary worship is forbidden. Moreover if we accept the Roman Catholic definition of idolatry, i. e. offering to a creature the worship due to the Creator, where, I would ask, has idolatry ever prevailed? Not even the Fetish-worshipper of Africa confounds his Fetish with the Maker and Preserver of all things. Some races have thought the Great Spirit too far above them, and afar from them, to hear their prayer, and have worshipped creatures as his symbols or vicegerents, or as inferior deities more immediately concerned with the affairs of men. But none ever offered latria to an idol. Still less were the civilized nations of antiquity in this sense idolaters. It is supposed that the unity and some of the attributes of God were the secret revealed to the initiated in the Mysteries; and the "God-fearing" Athenians whom St. Paul addressed on the Areopagus certainly distinguished the altar of the "Unknown God" from that of the Olympian Zeus or the Athene of the Acropolis; for it was the inscription on that altar which the apostle took as the text of his sermon. The essence of idolatry consists not in offering Divine worship to a creature, but in worshipping the Creator in a mode not acceptable to him, or in worshipping the creature in any mode whatever. It is not ignorance of which St. Paul accuses the heathen world (Rom. i. 19—25); it is "that, when they knew God, they glorified him not as God, . . . . . (but) changed the truth of God into a lie, and worshipped and served the creature more than the Creator." When St. John in the vision was shown the holy city, "I fell down," he says, "to worship before the feet of the angel which shewed me these things. Then saith he unto me, See thou do it not; for I am thy fellow-servant: worship God." Roman Catholic commentators tell us that John mistook the angel for the Son of Man, and would have offered him latria. But observe, John himself calls the angel "One of the seven angels which had the

73

seven vials." It must therefore have been *dalia* which the angel declined, *i.e.* the worship which every Roman Catholic offers to his guardian angel.

I adduced this example from the Bible in arguing recently with a Roman Catholic friend of mine. The substance of his answer was, "So much the worse for the Bible," for that "saint-worship was a necessary corollary of the New Law." So it is—but what then? As another Catholic friend of mine, also a convert, remarked, "We don't care a fig for the Bible; we could do just as well without it. For my part, I'd sooner believe Pius than Paul"—on the principle, I presume, that a living dog is better than a dead lion.

I have presented one feature, and only one of the religion of Rome. I will add one feature of its morality. And here let it be understood, I censure not individuals but the system with which they unhappily are *solidaires*. Four years' residence as a Catholic in Catholic countries abroad and in Ireland, has taught me how impossible it is to conjecture what a man's conduct will be from the principles which he professes; how often the man is superior to the system. Nor had anyone ever better cause to speak well of Roman Catholics individually. I experienced nothing but kindness and hospitality, both here and abroad, at the hands of Roman Catholics, especially of that illustrious prelate who though vested in the Roman purple, won admiration and almost popularity for a Prince of the Roman Church, amidst a Protestant and at first hostile nation. I say then, that the Roman system not only paralyses the intellect but corrupts conscience, which is the guide of life, by substituting for the eternal morality, which is a reflection of the Divine nature, a false code of ethics which expands or contracts, as best suits the interests of the Church. The ἀρχή πεπήρωται, the current of action is vitiated at the fountain-head. Men, as I have said, are often better than the systems which they support. But I believe that in proportion as men have imbibed the spirit of Rome, exactly in that proportion does their moral sense become blunted to the discernment of right and wrong, truth and falsehood. Those who have read such works as the writings of Dens, and Alphonsus di Liguori, or the Monita Secreta of the Jesuit order, will best apprehend what I mean. Perinde ac cadaver* is not peculiar to the Jesuit order or to the duty of obedience. Confession would never have become so popular had it not responded to a want in the human heart; that want is the desire to rid oneself of personal moral responsibility, and to shift it on to the shoulders of another. Men (not converts) rarely submit to the discipline of the confessional, "the Sacrament of Penance;" but women in all countries throng to it in crowds, and the corpse on a dissecting table is not more at the mercy of the operating surgeon than is the female penitent at the mercy of the confessor, especially if, as is often the case, he is also her spiritual director. Gifted with less reasoning power than men, and with an organization in which devotion and sensuousness are highly developed and strangely mingled, women are peculiarly susceptible of moral influence. I say nothing of the scandals which have resulted from the abuse of the confessional, and which have made the "prétraille," as Frenchmen call them, the bye-word of Europe; but let any man

* "Like a corpse."

read the manuals for the use of confessors, and say whether even a good man could apply them in practice without moral contamination, probably to himself and certainly to the penitent. It must be remembered too that faith and obedience are not inseparable. "I believe but I do not practise" is a very common case. It is the old story. Human nature in every age has always tried to make a compromise with God, offering him sacrifice instead of obedience. "Il y a des accommodements avec le ciel," as Voltaire said with his withering sneer.

But this is a collateral question. The point on which I now lay stress is that the moral sense even of religious men, men aspiring to holiness, is so corrupted by a false standard of right and wrong, that they will themselves commit, and sanction in others, actions plainly unjustifiable.

I will give one instance out of many. Some time ago Lord Blacklegge, who has since gone through the Bankruptcy Court, and who was then correspondent in a notorious divorce case, joined the Church of Rome; and it was hinted in some of the newspapers, that a connexion of his, a Roman Catholic lady, had paid the heavy damages to which he was condemned on condition that he became a dutiful son of Holy Church. I congratulated a priest whom I happened to meet on their noble convert; but the reverend father seemed not to think it a subject of congratulation.

"Lord Blacklegge," said he, "was received by Father —, at — Street, on the — day of —, but I always deny it."

"How do you mean?" I asked.

"You know it's a fact as well as I do," he replied; "but if anybody asks me about it, I always say it's not true."

Yet this priest was a man who had given up a rich living for conscience' sake, who gave all his private fortune to the poor, and who would, I doubt not, have given his body to be burned. At the same time I know, if he had had the power, he would quite as cheerfully have burned others, for he has told me so, while defending the Act De Heretico comburendo; nor did he scruple, in the instance mentioned, to tell a downright lie in order to avert some possible discredit from his Church.

I am not writing controversy, I am simply serving up one or two scraps of personal experience, if haply they may lead others to profitable study and reflection. Idolatry is ever assuming new forms. The spirit of idolatry impregnates the very air. Saint-worship and king-worship, and hero-worship, and parson-worship,—anything, everything, but God's worship. Even things harmless in themselves often lead to harm: the old serpent has left his trail over the evergreens of Christmas. More than half the churches are idol-temples. "When ye come to appear before me," saith the Lord, "who hath required this at your hand, to tread my courts? Bring no more vain oblations; incense is an abomination unto me; the new moons and Sabbaths, the calling of assemblies, I cannot away with; it is iniquity, even the solemn meeting." All these holy rituals and holy places, holy festivals and holy vigils, holy fathers and holy mothers, holy vestments and holy vessels, holy oil and holy water, holy crosses and holy candles, holy incense and holy altars, are idolatrons in origin and in nature, and therefore far more acceptable to humanity than that worship in spirit and in truth, and that spiritual body built up of living stones, which alone is acceptable to God.

75

One word, dear reader, in conclusion: you and I shall never meet most likely in this world, but we shall hereafter if we are faithful unto death. Heaven is our home. Are we going Homewards? Can we say with the poet—

"Nightly I pitch my moving tent

A day's march nearer home"?

Are we like the patriarchs, dwellers in tents, always on the move? Do we feel like strangers and pilgrims on the earth? Or are we trying to build stone cities here, forgetful of the Better Land and of Him who shall lead us thither? Are we journeying Romewards in search of some perfect Church which exists not upon earth? Are we looking for the Most High in temples made with hands, in minsters and meeting-houses, in gorgeous ceremonial, or in golden eloquence?

Some of these things may be useful, but all may be pernicious. Examine yourself, I entreat you, whether you be in the Faith, prove your own self. Keep yourself from idols. Anything may become an idol if it lead you to forget God. Fling away the accursed thing if it is in your hand; if it is in your heart, tear it up by the roots. Never mind the world's dread laugh, the sneer of society. Let those laugh that win. There will be plenty of the very best society in hell, kings and kaisers, popes and prelates, and all sorts of noble and royal, and serene and illustrious personages. Better to crawl into life on crutches with Lazarus, than to drive to hell with Dives in a coach and six, with outriders and running footmen.

Only look to Jesus and you are saved. He is the author and finisher of your faith. He is always ready, always waiting for you. "Behold, I stand at the door, and knock: if any man hear my voice and open the door, I will come in to him and will sup with him, and he with me. To him that overcometh will I grant to sit with me in my throne."

And "who is he that overcometh the world but he that believeth that Jesus is the Son of God? This is the victory that overcometh the world, even our faith." Say to him, "Lord, I believe: help thou mine unbelief."

"Rock of ages, cleft for me,

Let me hide myself in thee."

Yet a little while and the dark night of sin and sorrow, the hour of defeat and doubt and despondency will be past: the dark valley of the shadow of death will have been crossed, and morn will break on the everlasting hills.

Farewell, dear reader, and pray for me, that I too may see the rising of the Sun of righteousness.

PHILALETHES.

Everything we make is available for free because of a generous community of supporters.

Donate