Popish Feltry rightly serbed
THE powers of sarcasm, ridicule, and contempt, are never more fittingly exercised than upon the follies and blasphemies of idolatry. Elijah is gloriously scornful as he bids Baal's worshippers "Cry aloud, for he is a god;" and the psalmist is nobly contemptuous as he sings of the idols, "Noses have they, but they smell not, neither speak they through their throat." The godly Israelite never called the ox of Isis by any other name than a calf, and Beelzebul, the god of flies, was to him Beelzebub, the god of dung. Jehu's zeal against Baal found a most fitting form for its display when "they brought forth the images out of the house of Baal, and burned them. And they bruke down the image of Baal, and brake down the house of Baal, and made it a draught-house unto this day." (2 Kings x. 26, 27.) On this account it was that "the Lord said unto Jehu, Because thou hast done well in executing that which is right in mine eyes, and hast done unto the house of Ahab according to all that was in mine heart, thy children of the fourth generation shall sit on the throne of Israel." (2 Kings x. 30.) This also was a statute and ordinance in Israel: "But thus shall ye deal with them; ye shall destroy their altars, and break down their images, and cut down their groves, and burn their graven images with fire." (Deut. vii. 5.)
Mindful of such venerable precedents, and moved by honest indignation, our forefathers, at the time of the Reformation and in succeeding years, poured abundant scorn upon the abominations of Romish idolatry. They were not content to remove the images of jealousy, they destroyed them; and not even satisfied with this, they put the fragments as far as possible to the most ignoble uses, thus showing the thoroughness of their abhorrence of the detestable Antichrist. In these days when superstition is threatening to renovate the shrines of Popish heathenism, it may be well for those who are on the Lord's side to refresh their memories with the records of the brave days of old, hopeful that the like horror of idolatry may yet again seize upon the people, and that the national edifices may be once more thoroughly purged. We at one time shared in the regret that so much architectural ruin was wrought in this kingdom by iconoclastic zeal, but in the light of Puseyism we see far differently, and are sorry that one stone was left upon another, even so much as to commemorate the defiling of this land by the harlot of Babylon. Let the nests come down by all means, and the trees too, rather than invite the unclean birds to return. Better to make antiquaries weep than to cause souls to be lost, better grind into the finest dust every specimen of emblematic tracery and superstitious imagery, however high their art, than leave them as a ladder by which error may again climb into the church of God. It is better when the plague is in a house to burn the most valuable garments than let them remain as a nest for the disease; and who that knows our poor humanity does not see with half an eye that the very beauty and taste displayed in superstitious emblems make them all the more dangerous as temptations to entice men to their use. It would be a good day for England if, with full allowance of the law, chisel and hammer could go to work once more in certain High-church haunts. Any lawless riot we should as much deprecate as
2 K
any one, but if our legislators who dictate the fashion of the national religion would but decree its purification from idolatry, every right-minded man would rejoice.
The destruction of the cross in Cheapside is a fair illustration of righteous iconoclastic energy; we doubt not that Heaven approved the deed, and the motives which suggested it. We have been reading with very considerable satisfaction the records of the destruction of superstitious monuments and church furniture in the parish churches of Lincolnshire, exactly three hundred years ago, and as a small tricentenary commemoration we shall give a few selections. We have first, however, a few words to offer. The High-church party shudder at these "works of impiety," but to us they appear to be fruits meet for repentance, the genuine results of loyal attachment
to the spiritual worship of the only true God. When the worthy Dean of Durham made the coffins of the priors into swine troughs, and the stoups for holy water into vessels for ignoble kitchen uses, he was far more reverent and Godfearing than when modern ritualists profane the simple breaking of bread in memory of our blessed Lord into a sacrifice for the propitiation of sin. It is true reverence to God to be irreverent towards that which insults him, and a man can scarcely love the Lord Jesus Christ at all who does not hate the mass with all his heart, and soul, and strength. Martin Luther said, "There are many that think I am too fierce against Popedom; on the contrary, I complain that I am, alas! too mild; I wish I could breathe out lightning against Pope and Popedom, and that every word were a thunderbolt." To him it was sufficient recommendation of a caricature to say, "It will vex the Pope horribly and touch the consciences of Papists." Let no man in dealing with the modern revival of Popery be such a simpleton as to dream that moderation and soft speaking are possible, or if possible desirable. It has come to this, that to be loyal to the Lord Jesus we must constantly resent the usurpations of Antichrist. Ritualism is very bold, and so must we be. It does not attempt to conceal its hatred of Protestantism, and we must not compromise matters and prophesy smooth things concerning it. Tracts and volumes are scattered on all hands which teach undisguised Popery, and confidently declare that the Church of England is not and
499
never has been a Protestant church. For this we do not blame those who so think; on the contrary, we commend their zeal for what they believe; but that which they teach is so execrable, that it is a marvel that a still greater zeal to counteract their teaching is not evinced by all evangelical Christians. From a tract before us issued by the Ritualists as one of a series, entitled, "Tracts on the Doctrine and Discipline of the Church of England," we cull the following specimen extract concerning the celebration of that Tractarian hocus-poens which they profanely call the Holy Eucharist:—
"First of all, there is required an Altar of wood or stone, which represents the Cross on which Jesus Christ offered himself as a propitiation for the sins of the whole world. This is raised on steps to represent how Jesus suffered on a mountain—the hill of Calvary. On the Altar the Church appoints two lights to be kept burning during the Liturgy, by which are set forth the two natures—His Godhead and Manhood, which are both shewn forth in this great and mysterious sacrifice, in which His Body and Blood, together with His Human Soul and His Sacred Divinity become present in sacramental mystery, and are offered to the Father on behalf of His Church. Between the lights there is usually a cross, to remind us still further that in this mystery the Passion and Death of Christ are set forth in an especial manner. All the ceremonies of the Priest are full of meaning—When he goes to the south side of the Altar to recite the Collect and Epistle, and passes to the north side to read the Gospel, and returns to the middle to repeat the Creed and so on. The carrying of the elements from the credence to the Altar, shews forth how Jesus was led as a lamb to the slaughter. The mixing of the cup of wine and water shews the mysterious union between Christ and His Church, and also represents the blood and water, which flowed from the wounded side of our Lord on the cross. These elements are properly prepared and are then offered on the Altar, not then as a proper sacrifice, but as a kind of first-fruits of our substance; but at the Prayer of Consecration—in which the sacrifice proper consists—a great change takes place. The Priest lifts the paten to commemorate the lifting up of Christ on the cross; he breaks the bread to signify the breaking of that Holy Body: he lays his hand upon it to transfer the sins of the people to the victim, and as he pronounces the words of consecration 'THIS IS MY BODY'—'THIS IS MY BLOOD' the great action is accomplished, the Christian Sacrifice is completed. The sacred Humanity and Divinity of Christ have come into the elements: by the separate consecration of His Body and of His Blood, He has undergone not a real (that He did once only on the Cross), but a mystical death, corresponding to the slaying of the victim in the Jewish sacrifice, and He lies on the Altar concealed under the lowly form of bread and wine, ready, like the victim of old, to be consumed by the Priest and the people. This then, Jacob, is the most important and holy rite of the Christian Church, the rite which alone constitutes Church worship, and to which all other acts of prayer and service—whether of the Church, or families, or of individuals—are but subordinate and dependent parts. And the essence of the Sacrifice consists in the consecration of the bread and wine, to be the Body and Blood of Christ."
After this, let the reader's patience submit to the perusal of a direction for obtaining pardon of sin offered in "The Little Primer," another precious production of the Anglican clergy. "If you find the burden very heavy, and if you wish to be entirely washed of the sins, go to a priest and ask him to give you absolution. Tell him what is on your mind, and ask his advice; but the advice alone will do no good, the thing you must have is absolution. That is the way appointed by Christ for blotting out sin." As we are not every day personally pestered with such silly pretences we can think of them with some patience, but if they were now, as they soon will be, thrust constantly in our way, would it be at all wonderful if the coarser spirits even exceeded the bounds of propriety and manifested their justifiable indignation in ways to be regretted. Certain violent persons in the Reforming days hanged a cat on a gallows beside the cross in Cheapside, arrayed in a chasuble, with its head shaved to imitate the priestly tonsure, and a representation of the wafer between its paws. Those whose errors provoked such mockery were vastly more to be blamed than those who perpetrated it, but this form of ridicule was too weak to answer any desirable end. It would be perfectly legitimate for the sellers of dolls to dress them after the fashion of the clergy, and so allow the children in the nursery to participate in the sports practised by infantile minds in the churches, but the sorrowful side of the business forbids that our ridicule should be mere frivolity. Our contempt for sacramentarianism should be deep and solemn, and our words of ridicule must be dictated by an overwhelming sense of indignation at the insults offered to the majesty of Heaven by the system of which the ceremonial and the ritual are but an outgrowth. When Bonner had forcibly dressed Rowland Taylor in priestly robes, that brave servant of God set his hands to his sides, and walking up and down said, "How say you, my lord, am I not a goodly fool? How say you, my masters, if I were in Cheapside, should I not have boys to laugh at these apish tricks and trumpery?" Such ridicule which came from a heart prepared to endure the flaming faggot is such as the noblest instincts of nature will not only excuse but commend. If my neighbour's idols are not matters of horror to me, it is indecorous that they should excite my scorn, but if I feel in my heart's core that they insult my God, I shall from purest love to God and my neighbour pour contempt upon his fond delusions.
We must, however, carefully guard against bearing the slightest illwill towards those who so grievously provoke us by provoking our God. Former ages have been unable to distinguish between hatred of error and hatred of men holding the error; but now we have learned the lesson we must not forget it. Evil and especially the evil of idolatry is to be loathed and denounced, but no weapon is to be used in its extermination but that which is spiritual; carnal force may be left to our opponents if they are witless enough to use it, but let the spiritual be ours. One reservation however we do make, we would not touch a hair of any man's head, but we would not spare his idols if we had a right to break them. To religious associations which sustain themselves and make no demand upon any but their voluntary votaries our laws allow a toleration which is their right before the secular tribunal; but when a sect accepts the pay of the state in the form of tithes, and puts itself under national jurisdiction, it has of its own accord become amenable
501
to human law, and every means should be used to prevent its violating the national will. It has appealed unto Caesar, and unto Caesar it should go. If we were churchwardens we would remove every rag, candle, flowerpot, vestment and instrument of Popery from the national edifices over which we had charge, and if we were in any degree connected with the Anglican establishment and held evangelical views, we would in a quiet, orderly, but very decided way purge and cleanse the parish churches, and if the law punished us for so doing, we would have done with a community oppressed by such a law. If the Evangelicals had possessed the courage of mice they would have organized societies in all the parishes, and would have appointed discreet and respectable persons in each town to cleanse out all trumpery as soon as it was introduced into the churches, and they would have raised a national fund to defend all such appointed persons in case of their being prosecuted. If the Evangelicals had been as they should be, they would have had their heroes by this time, who would have run risks in resisting innovations, and have gloried in being martyrs in such a cause, but we fear that we must look in vain to that quarter. We turn from the churchwardens of the present to their predecessors in better days, and note with pleasure how they brake in pieces the images and defiled the altars. We give the items in the original spelling.
Sometimes the superstitious matters were put to serviceable purposes in connection with the church.
Itin one cope whearof is made a clothe for the coion (communion) table.
Itin a hollie water fatt erwete and suche like—was the said fyrst year meltid and occupied aboute the mending of o' church.
Itin iij altar stones—Brokne in peces and Laid with in the porch one of theim and thother ij wee have made stepping stones of at o' church yard stile.
Itin the roode lofte taken downe anno 1562 and was burnte sens christmas last by a plumer that we hired to amend o' leades.
At other times the instruments of idolatry were utterly destroyed.
Itin the mass bookes the processioners the manuell and all such peltrei of the popes sinfull service—was made away torne and defacid in the second or third yeare of the Reigne of o' soueraigne Ladie that now is.
Imp'mis the Image of the Rood mary and Johan and an other ymage of papistry was burnt by Thoms pank in the p'sens (presence) of Symond doddes & m' Elizabeth Lynne Thoms panke & John normanton churchwardens then.
Itin a sepulker wth litle Jack*—broken in peces one year ago but litle Jack was broken in peces this yeare by the said churchwardens.
Itin one sacring bell†—willin Eland had and hong it by his horse care a long tyme but nowe yt is broken.
Itin a messe boke a graile a portess and a manuell cutt in peces
* It was a common thing among the Reformed to call the wafer by the name of Jack-in-the-box, Little Jack, Round Robin, the Sacrament of the Halter, and such like terms. They did not treat tenderly this detestable mockery of our incarnate God.
† A bell rung during mass.
before my lord of Lincoln iij yeres sens when he was there and preaching.
Itin the Rood marve and John and all other Idoles and pyetours mass bookes legend bookes and all other papisticall bookes and serymonyes was openlye burned at the Crosse called the markett Crosse in the seid yeare Master willm Porter then beyng alderman.
Itin the Rood with Marie and John with the rest of the Idolatrous Imageis belonging to th'abom'iable mass—was brent (burnt) iij yeares ago in or market place in the puce (presence) of the pishners (parishioners) Thomas Rawlinson and Richard Cater being churchwardens.
Frequently the matters were sold and put to excellent use by the purchasers, or sent home to those who had formerly lent or given them.
Itin the Sensors crwetes and such like trash—was sold by the said churchward and defacid.
Itin all the mas bookes and all bookes of papistrie—were torne in peces in a° pino Eliz and sold to pedlers to lap spice in.
Itin one crewett cruste in peces and sold to a plu2mer (plumber) for sawdar.
Itin one hallywater fatt of lead sold to george verna? 1565 and he haith melted yt and made (sic) mylke vessell thereof.
Itin a rood loft—sold to Richard Langlandes of the said pishe (parish) sence Mr Archdeacon his visitacon Anno Dni 1565 by Willm walton and Richard floorman and is by the said Longlandes broken in peces who haithe nowe made a bridge for his sheep to go over into his pasture.
Itin one candlestick and one hallywater fatt sold to willm Brinckill sens the last visitaco.
Itin a towell sold to Laurene Pane sens the last visitaçon And he occupieth yt on his table.
Itin to Robert Bellamee ij corporax? sold this yere wherof his wief made of one a stomacher for her wench and of thother being ript she will make a purse.
Rood loft was take? down parte of it ij yeres agoe & part at Christems last and it is sold to Mr. John Sheffield to mak sealing.
Itin one vestint one alb flanell stools with such like linnen appertaininge to the popishe preist a mass book and a pax with such trifling tromprie belonging to the sinfull service of the popish preist—was delicuerid to Sr James Bancroft A° pino Elicabih of whome wee had ye same the fyrst yeare of Quene Marie the said preston and Skipworth being churchwardens.
Itin ij altar stones—which is defacid and Laid in high waies and serveth as bridges for sheepe and cattall to go on so that their nowe remaineth no trashe nor tromprie of popish peltrie in or said church of Keilbie. (Churchwardens of Keilbie, how is it now?)
Itin one holly water fatt of stone wch or said vicare haith made a swines troughe of.
Itin one sacringe bell wch Thomas Carter had and he haith made a horse bell therof to hange at a horses eare.
Itin a sacringe bell—sold to Austen Earle to put about a calues neck.
* A linen cloth used in the mass.
503
Itin the roode loft was sold by the said John Somercote & John flowers
unto the said John Audeleye who made a bedde of yt.
Itin one old awble geven awaic to poor folkes in the towne in a' primo
Eliz and the haue made clowtes for their childerne ther of.
Itin one pillowe wèh laie on thaltare (the altar) geven to a maide to
make her a stomacher of.
Itin one annysse* geven a waic to a poore woman wèh she made her
child a sherte of.
Itin iij altare stones—lynge in oë churche at this pn'te vnpavid two
of them wèh shalbe broken and one lieth at M'. Harr'g't'ns fier back
(the back of the fire-place).
Itin the roode loft—taken downe and sold to Johnne Templeina* who
haith defaced the same and made a hovell therof.
It may be long before a reformation so godly and thorough shall again
be made, but there is need of it, and it ought to be attempted by every
legal process known. Perhaps the statutes which purified the churches
so long ago may still remain unrepealed; if so, let them be enforced.
The sooner we have no national church the better for all concerned, but
if we must have such an incubus, at any rate let it be kept commonly
sweet and decent. When our law cannot remove a nuisance, it restrains
it within limits, and if no act of Parliament can at present be passed
ridding us of state-patronage, at least let it not patronise what many
believe to be quite as gross an evil as the Pope of Rome and his
detestable enormities.
Across the Irish channel, where as yet ritualism has done but little in the
Establishment, there comes a voice which perhaps may stir to action some
sluggish Anglican who would sneer at our cries of alarm. Bishop Gregg
of Cork gave the following manly utterance in his late charge. Episco-
palians hear it and act upon it. "What claims, then, those persons can
have to the title of true ministers, or sound members of our Church, who
call the holy table 'altar' and the consecrated bread 'sacrifice,' it is not
easy for us to say. Their attachment to Protestantism, and their loyalty
to their Prayer-book, seem, to say the least, doubtful, and their inclina-
tion to a kind of Romanism and to a kind of mass is, I fear, undoubted.
We see men in these degenerate days, ministers and pastors of our
Church, as they are called, perverting, not preaching the Gospel; sub-
verting, not building up souls; making very little of Christ and his work,
and very much of themselves and their own. They turn away the minds
of men immortal, so far as they can, from the fulness and all-sufficiency
of Christ and the gracious work of the Spirit to beggarly elements of
human device unknown to pure and early time, and endeavour to fix
them on sights and shows, or dresses of clergy, on colours and forms
and figures on turning now to this side and this thing, and again
bending and bowing to that side and that thing; one time they gabble
in one part of the service and again they mutter in another, as if clergy-
men were showmen or necromancers, and the laity were only babies to
be amused, and fools to trifle with, not to teach. Frivolities and
fantasies are such things; they act only on the senses, or perhaps at best
engage the imagination, but satisfy not in any degree the deep require-
* A linen vestment worn by the priest at mass.
ments and longings and yearnings of the soul. Such trifling and puerility the people could have equally well, and with as much benefit, in theatres, or even in heathen temples, with an idolatrous service, and from pagan priests. Such teachers wrong the laity, and rob them of their rights. I wonder the laity can submit to it. The laity constitute the largest portion of the church by many degrees; for them are the clergy maintained, and for them are the fabric of the church and its system upheld, and yet they allow a state of things to go on in the service of the church which pains every pious mind while it starves the soul, and from which the manly mind recoils—a state that is an insult to the understanding, a perversion and misrepresentation of the Christian religion, and a degradation of the church. Ritualism, as it is called, is childish—not bad enough of itself to do us harm, but as symbolizing corrupt doctrines it bodes us no good, but is ominous of evil. It pretends, indeed, religion and promises peace, but it is an engine of war—a device of the foe. It menaces our safety, and a breach has been made for it in our walls; but draw it not in, allow it not to enter; 'Equo ne credite Teucri.'
