The Case of Mr. Robertson
WE have been astounded at the misrepresentations given in our English papers of the case of Mr. Robertson, the compositor, who was denied communion with the Free-Church on account of his following his usual avocations on the Sabbath. It has been described as a case of Sabbatarianism akin to the famous fable of the man who threw away the yeast for working on Sunday, and killed his hens for laying eggs on the same holy day. The poor man, it is said, did a little necessary work on the Sabbath evening in order to produce the Monday's newspaper, and was at once hunted down by the advocates for the bitter observance of the Sabbath. As we sat in the Assembly hall during the trial, we had a presentiment that certain of the secular papers would be sure thus to state the case, and probably had leaders already set up depicting the horrible Sabbatarianism of the Scotch; but we hardly thought that professedly religious papers would fall into the same glaring error. It is due to those who have been slandered to state one or two matters, which quite change the aspect of the case.
1. The case was not one desired by the Assembly as matter of judgment, but its appearance was the source of deep, and almost universal regret, not because the Free Church has not its own opinion as to the Sabbath, but because the intelligence of its ministers revolts at the idea of making the Assembly a tribunal to settle minor details of Sabbath observance which are best left to individual consciences.
2. The case of Mr. Robertson was not sought out by the Free Church, but was mentioned by the man's own wife to the minister, and pressed upon his consideration at Mr. Robertson's own request. The minister at the Assembly declared, in reference to another alleged case of Sabbath-breaking, that he did not think it his duty to pry into persons' private actions; and that in this instance the subject was directly and distinctly brought under his notice by the party's own act and deed.
3. Mr. Robertson did not work a few hours on Sunday evening at, setting up necessary telegrams, but he went to work at half-past one or just after noon of the Lord's-day, and worked on throughout the day at the usual work of a newspaper, which might for the most part be done on the Saturday, and is so done in certain other printing offices. He obtained by this Sunday labour a holiday on Saturdays, and thus.
I
gives up his Sabbath privileges in exchange for a Saturday's holiday. If this be tolerated in the Christian Church, the first day of the week would be no longer the day of hallowed rest and worship.
4. Other work was open to him, and offered to him, but he voluntarily elected to work at the particular office which had chosen to make the Sunday its day of work, and the Saturday its day of rest. Evidence was given to this fact, and it was not denied by the compositor himself.
5. He had no doubts as to the binding character of the Decalogue, but declared his belief that it stood in all its force, and therefore he could not claim to be treated as one who raised the question as to the duty of resting on the seventh day.
6. No decision was given or intended to be given as to many other instances of labour about the necessity of which questions have been raised, but all such points were in Dr. Candlish's most masterly speech very properly left to individuals, or reserved for separate consideration as they arose; but this one case was so clear that there was not a word of dissent from any one present, although the assembly was as intelligent a gathering as could have been mustered in her Majesty's dominions.
Upon the whole Mr. Robertson was dealt with in a manner to be censured only for its leniency. Had he been a member of a Baptist Church, he would have had no opportunity of boarding a session, a presbytery, a synod, and an assembly, but would have been disposed of at the next church-meeting. It was the general opinion that the case was got up to cause embarrassment to the Free Church, and that the person appearing in it was only the cat's paw. If it were so, the concocters signally failed to raise the main question, for the case was adjudged by itself alone, and was so clear as to need no discussion, so weak as to admit of no defence. The cry of persecution has been raised, but of all cant, irreligious cant is the most canting; an ordinary club has a right to expel a man who breaks its rules, and surely a church is to be allowed to do the same. It is idle to talk of conscience; surely the consciences of thousands are not to be forced to succumb to the pretended conscience of a man who accepts the decalogue, and then does a day's work needlessly on the Sabbath.
